An evaluation of physical and augmented patient-specific intracranial aneurysm simulators on microsurgical clipping performance and skills: a randomized controlled study.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE: In the era of flow diversion, there is an increasing demand to train neurosurgeons outside the operating room in safely performing clipping of unruptured intracranial aneurysms. This study introduces a clip training simulation platform for residents and aspiring cerebrovascular neurosurgeons, with the aim to visualize peri-aneurysm anatomy and train virtual clipping applications on the matching physical aneurysm cases. METHODS: Novel, cost-efficient techniques allow the fabrication of realistic aneurysm phantom models and the additional integration of holographic augmented reality (AR) simulations. Specialists preselected suitable and unsuitable clips for each of the 5 patient-specific models, which were then used in a standardized protocol involving 9 resident participants. Participants underwent four sessions of clip applications on the models, receiving no interim training (control), a video review session (video), or a video review session and holographic clip simulation training (video + AR) between sessions 2 and 3. The study evaluated objective microsurgical skills, which included clip selection, number of clip applications, active simulation time, wrist tremor analysis during simulations, and occlusion efficacy. Aneurysm occlusions of the reference sessions were assessed by indocyanine green videoangiography, as well as conventional and photon-counting CT scans. RESULTS: A total of 180 clipping procedures were performed without technical complications. The measurements of the active simulation times showed a 39% improvement for all participants. A median of 2 clip application attempts per case was required during the final session, with significant improvement observed in experienced residents (postgraduate year 5 or 6). Wrist tremor improved by 29% overall. The objectively assessed aneurysm occlusion rate (Raymond-Roy class 1) improved from 76% to 80% overall, even reaching 93% in the extensively trained cohort (video + AR) (p = 0.046). CONCLUSIONS: The authors introduce a newly developed simulator training platform combining physical and holographic aneurysm clipping simulators. The development of exchangeable, aneurysm-comprising housings allows objective radio-anatomical evaluation through conventional and photon-counting CT scans. Measurable performance metrics serve to objectively document improvements in microsurgical skills and surgical confidence. Moreover, the different training levels enable a training program tailored to the cerebrovascular trainees' levels of experience and needs.