The recipient metabolome explains the asymmetric ovarian impact on fetal sex development after embryo transfer in cattle.

ABSTRACT

In cattle, lateral asymmetry affects ovarian function and embryonic sex, but the underlying molecular mechanisms remain unknown. The plasma metabolome of recipients serves to predict pregnancy after embryo transfer (ET). Thus, the aim of this study was to investigate whether the plasma metabolome exhibits distinct lateral patterns according to the sex of the fetus carried by the recipient and the active ovary side (AOS), i.e., the right ovary (RO) or the left ovary (LO). We analyzed the plasma of synchronized recipients by 1H+NMR on day 0 (estrus, n = 366) and day 7 (hours prior to ET; n = 367). Thereafter, a subset of samples from recipients that calved female (n = 50) or male (n = 69) was used to test the effects of embryonic sex and laterality on pregnancy establishment. Within the RO, the sex ratio of pregnancies carried was biased toward males. Significant differences (P < 0.05) in metabolite levels were evaluated based on the day of blood sample collection (days 0, 7 and day 7/day 0 ratio) using mixed generalized models for metabolite concentration. The most striking differences in metabolite concentrations were associated with the RO, both obtained by multivariate (OPLS-DA) and univariate (mixed generalized) analyses, mainly with metabolites measured on day 0. The metabolites consistently identified through the OPLS-DA with a higher variable importance in projection score, which allowed for discrimination between male fetus- and female fetus-carrying recipients, were hippuric acid, l-phenylalanine, and propionic acid. The concentrations of hydroxyisobutyric acid, propionic acid, l-lysine, methylhistidine, and hippuric acid were lowest when male fetuses were carried, in particular when the RO acted as AOS. No pathways were significantly regulated according to the AOS. In contrast, six pathways were found enriched for calf sex in the day 0 dataset, three for day 7, and nine for day 7/day 0 ratio. However, when the AOS was the right, 20 pathways were regulated on day 0, 8 on day 7, and 13 within the day 7/day 0 ratio, most of which were related to amino acid metabolism, with phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan biosynthesis and phenylalanine metabolism pathways being identified throughout. Our study shows that certain metabolites in the recipient plasma are influenced by the AOS and can predict the likelihood of carrying male or female embryos to term, suggesting that maternal metabolism prior to or at the time of ET could favor the implantation and/or development of either male or female embryos.

This study explored how the active ovary side (AOS, i.e., left or right) and the sex of the calf carried by the recipient relate to the plasma metabolome in blood. For this purpose, we analyzed blood samples from heifers at two specific times the day of the estrus and the day of the embryo transfer. We found significant differences in the sex ratio of pregnancies carried in the right ovary, and in the levels of certain metabolites depending on whether the active ovary was on the right or left and whether the calf was male or female. As examples, the concentrations of hydroxyisobutyric acid, propionic acid, l-lysine, methylhistidine, and hippuric acid were lowest when male calves were carried, in particular when the right ovary was active. Interestingly, the calf sex also influenced certain metabolic pathways, especially in the right AOS, several of them related to amino acid metabolism. However, no significant metabolic pathway changes were observed based solely on which ovary was active. Overall, the study suggests that the metabolism of the recipient, influenced by the AOS, might play a role in the successful implantation and development of embryos of a certain sex. This insight could potentially help to predict and improve pregnancy outcomes in cattle through embryo transfer techniques.