Recent advances in Si-rhodamine-based fluorescent probes for live-cell imaging.

Fluorescence imaging is a powerful technique for visualizing biological events in living samples with high temporal and spatial resolution. Fluorescent probes emitting far-red to near infrared (NIR) fluorescence are particularly advantageous for in vivo imaging due to their high tissue permeability and low autofluorescence, as well as their suitability for multicolor imaging. Among the far-red to NIR fluorophores, Si-rhodamine is one of the most practical fluorophores for the development of tailor-made NIR fluorescent probes because of the relative ease of synthesis of various derivatives, the unique intramolecular spirocyclization behavior, and the relatively high water solubility and high photostability of the probes. This review summarizes these features of Si-rhodamines and presents recent advances in the synthesis and applications of far-red to NIR fluorescent probes based on Si-rhodamines, focusing on live-cell imaging applications such as fluorogenic probes, super-resolution imaging and dye-protein hybrid-based indicators.

Development of a Fluorescence Probe for Detecting Nitroreductase Activity Based on Steric Repulsion-Induced Twisted Intramolecular Charge Transfer (sr-TICT).

Twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) is a phenomenon involving intramolecular charge transfer together with intramolecular rotation upon photoexcitation, and in general this excited state of fluorescent dyes undergoes non-radiative decay (producing no fluorescence). We recently discovered that the magnitude of TICT in rhodamine derivatives could be regulated by altering the size of the substituents on the xanthene moiety, generating differing degrees of intramolecular steric repulsion. To further illustrate the usefulness and generality of this strategy, we describe here an application of quinone methide chemistry, which is widely used as a fluorescence off/on switching reaction for fluorescence probes detecting enzymatic activity, to construct a steric repulsion-induced (sr)-TICT-based fluorescence probe targeting nitroreductase (NTR) activity. The developed probe was almost non-fluorescent in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) due to strong induction of the TICT state. On the other hand, when the probe was incubated with NTR and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH), a large fluorescence increase was observed over time. We confirmed that the enzymatic reaction proceeded as expected, i.e., the nitro group of the probe was reduced to the corresponding amino group, followed by spontaneous elimination of iminoquinone methide. These results suggest that our simple design strategy based on the sr-TICT mechanism, i.e., controlling intramolecular steric repulsion, would be applicable to the development of fluorescence probes for a variety of enzymes.

Nasal alum-adjuvanted vaccine promotes IL-33 release from alveolar epithelial cells that elicits IgA production via type 2 immune responses.

Aluminum hydroxide salts (alum) have been added to inactivated vaccines as safe and effective adjuvants to increase the effectiveness of vaccination. However, the exact cell types and immunological factors that initiate mucosal immune responses to alum adjuvants are unclear. In this study, the mechanism of action of alum adjuvant in nasal vaccination was investigated. Alum has been shown to act as a powerful and unique adjuvant when added to a nasal influenza split vaccine in mice. Alum is cytotoxic in the alveoli and stimulates the release of damage-associated molecular patterns, such as dsDNA, interleukin (IL)-1α, and IL-33. We found that Ag-specific IgA antibody (Ab) production was markedly reduced in IL-33-deficient mice. However, no decrease was observed in Ag-specific IgA Ab production with DNase I treatment, and no decrease was observed in IL-1α/ß or IL-6 production in IL-33-deficient mice. From the experimental results of primary cultured cells and immunofluorescence staining, although IL-1α was secreted by alveolar macrophage necroptosis, IL-33 release was observed in alveolar epithelial cell necroptosis but not in alveolar macrophages. Alum- or IL-33-dependent Ag uptake enhancement and elevation of OX40L expression were not observed. By stimulating the release of IL-33, alum induced Th2 immunity via IL-5 and IL-13 production in group 2 innate lymphoid cells (ILC2s) and increased MHC class II expression in antigen-presenting cells (APCs) in the lung. Our results suggest that IL-33 secretion by epithelial cell necroptosis initiates APC- and ILC2-mediated T cell activation, which is important for the enhancement of Ag-specific IgA Ab production by alum.

Studies of lincosamide formation complete the biosynthetic pathway for lincomycin A.

The structure of lincomycin A consists of the unusual eight-carbon thiosugar core methyllincosamide (MTL) decorated with a pendent N-methylprolinyl moiety. Previous studies on MTL biosynthesis have suggested GDP-ᴅ-erythro-α-ᴅ-gluco-octose and GDP-ᴅ-α-ᴅ-lincosamide as key intermediates in the pathway. However, the enzyme-catalyzed reactions resulting in the conversion of GDP-ᴅ-erythro-α-ᴅ-gluco-octose to GDP-ᴅ-α-ᴅ-lincosamide have not yet been elucidated. Herein, a biosynthetic subpathway involving the activities of four enzymes-LmbM, LmbL, CcbZ, and CcbS (the LmbZ and LmbS equivalents in the closely related celesticetin pathway)-is reported. These enzymes catalyze the previously unknown biosynthetic steps including 6-epimerization, 6,8-dehydration, 4-epimerization, and 6-transamination that convert GDP-ᴅ-erythro-α-ᴅ-gluco-octose to GDP-ᴅ-α-ᴅ-lincosamide. Identification of these reactions completes the description of the entire lincomycin biosynthetic pathway. This work is significant since it not only resolves the missing link in octose core assembly of a thiosugar-containing natural product but also showcases the sophistication in catalytic logic of enzymes involved in carbohydrate transformations.

General Design Strategy to Precisely Control the Emission of Fluorophores via a Twisted Intramolecular Charge Transfer (TICT) Process.

Fluorogenic probes for bioimaging have become essential tools for life science and medicine, and the key to their development is a precise understanding of the mechanisms available for fluorescence off/on control, such as photoinduced electron transfer (PeT) and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). Here we establish a new molecular design strategy to rationally develop activatable fluorescent probes, which exhibit a fluorescence off/on change in response to target biomolecules, by controlling the twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) process. This approach was developed on the basis of a thorough investigation of the fluorescence quenching mechanism of N-phenyl rhodamine dyes (commercially available as the QSY series) by means of time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations and photophysical evaluation of their derivatives. To illustrate and validate this TICT-based design strategy, we employed it to develop practical fluorogenic probes for HaloTag and SNAP-tag. We further show that the TICT-controlled fluorescence off/on mechanism is generalizable by synthesizing a Si-rhodamine-based fluorogenic probe for HaloTag, thus providing a palette of chemical dyes that spans the visible and near-infrared range.

Self-Assembly of Proteinaceous Shells around Positively Charged Gold Nanomaterials Enhances Colloidal Stability in High-Ionic-Strength Buffers.

The enzyme lumazine synthase (LS) has been engineered to self-assemble into hollow-shell structures that encapsulate unnatural cargo proteins through complementary electrostatic interactions. Herein, we show that a negatively supercharged LS variant can also form organic-inorganic hybrids with gold nanomaterials. Simple mixing of LS pentamers with positively charged gold nanocrystals in aqueous buffer spontaneously affords protein-shelled gold cores. The procedure works well with differently sized and shaped gold nanocrystals, and the resulting shelled complexes exhibit dramatically enhanced colloidal stability over a wide range of pH (4.0-10.0) and at high ionic strength (up to 1 m NaCl). They are even stable over days upon dilution in buffer. Self-assembly of engineered LS shells in this way offers an easy and attractive alternative to commonly used ligand-exchange methods for stabilizing inorganic nanomaterials.

Co-opting sulphur-carrier proteins from primary metabolic pathways for 2-thiosugar biosynthesis.

Sulphur is an essential element for life and is ubiquitous in living systems. Yet how the sulphur atom is incorporated into many sulphur-containing secondary metabolites is poorly understood. For bond formation between carbon and sulphur in primary metabolites, the major ionic sulphur sources are the persulphide and thiocarboxylate groups on sulphur-carrier (donor) proteins. Each group is post-translationally generated through the action of a specific activating enzyme. In all reported bacterial cases, the gene encoding the enzyme that catalyses the carbon-sulphur bond formation reaction and that encoding the cognate sulphur-carrier protein exist in the same gene cluster. To study the production of the 2-thiosugar moiety in BE-7585A, an antibiotic from Amycolatopsis orientalis, we identified a putative 2-thioglucose synthase, BexX, whose protein sequence and mode of action seem similar to those of ThiG, the enzyme that catalyses thiazole formation in thiamine biosynthesis. However, no gene encoding a sulphur-carrier protein could be located in the BE-7585A cluster. Subsequent genome sequencing uncovered a few genes encoding sulphur-carrier proteins that are probably involved in the biosynthesis of primary metabolites but only one activating enzyme gene in the A. orientalis genome. Further experiments showed that this activating enzyme can adenylate each of these sulphur-carrier proteins and probably also catalyses the subsequent thiolation, through its rhodanese domain. A proper combination of these sulphur-delivery systems is effective for BexX-catalysed 2-thioglucose production. The ability of BexX to selectively distinguish sulphur-carrier proteins is given a structural basis using X-ray crystallography. This study is, to our knowledge, the first complete characterization of thiosugar formation in nature and also demonstrates the receptor promiscuity of the A. orientalis sulphur-delivery system. Our results also show that co-opting the sulphur-delivery machinery of primary metabolism for the biosynthesis of sulphur-containing natural products is probably a general strategy found in nature.

Development of screening method for intranasal influenza vaccine and adjuvant safety in preclinical study.

Recently, many vaccine adjuvants have been developed; however, most of the newly developed adjuvants have been dropped out of preclinical and clinical trials owing to their unexpected toxicity. Thus, the development of highly quantitative and comparable screening methods for evaluating adjuvant safety is needed. In a previous study, we identified specific biomarkers for evaluating the safety of an intranasal influenza vaccine with CpG K3 adjuvant by comparing biomarker expression. We hypothesized that these biomarkers might be useful for screening newly developed adjuvant safety. We compared the expression of biomarkers in mouse lungs by the intranasal administration of 4 types of adjuvants: Alum, Pam3CSK4, NanoSiO2, and DMXAA with subvirion influenza vaccine. The control adjuvant alum did not show any significant increase in biomarker expression or preclinical parameters; however, NanoSiO2 and Pam3CSK4 increased the expression of biomarkers, such as Timp1 and Csf1. DMXAA at 300 µg induced the expression of over 80% of biomarkers. Hierarchical clustering analysis showed that 300 µg DMXAA was classified in the toxicity reference whole-particle influenza vaccine cluster. FACS analysis to confirm specific phenotypes that the number of T cells decreased in DMXAA-treated mouse lungs. Thus, our biomarkers are useful for initial adjuvant safety and toxicity screening.

Structural and functional analysis of two di-domain aromatase/cyclases from type II polyketide synthases.

Aromatic polyketides make up a large class of natural products with diverse bioactivity. During biosynthesis, linear poly-ß-ketone intermediates are regiospecifically cyclized, yielding molecules with defined cyclization patterns that are crucial for polyketide bioactivity. The aromatase/cyclases (ARO/CYCs) are responsible for regiospecific cyclization of bacterial polyketides. The two most common cyclization patterns are C7-C12 and C9-C14 cyclizations. We have previously characterized three monodomain ARO/CYCs: ZhuI, TcmN, and WhiE. The last remaining uncharacterized class of ARO/CYCs is the di-domain ARO/CYCs, which catalyze C7-C12 cyclization and/or aromatization. Di-domain ARO/CYCs can further be separated into two subclasses: "nonreducing" ARO/CYCs, which act on nonreduced poly-ß-ketones, and "reducing" ARO/CYCs, which act on cyclized C9 reduced poly-ß-ketones. For years, the functional role of each domain in cyclization and aromatization for di-domain ARO/CYCs has remained a mystery. Here we present what is to our knowledge the first structural and functional analysis, along with an in-depth comparison, of the nonreducing (StfQ) and reducing (BexL) di-domain ARO/CYCs. This work completes the structural and functional characterization of mono- and di-domain ARO/CYCs in bacterial type II polyketide synthases and lays the groundwork for engineered biosynthesis of new bioactive polyketides.

Expanding the structural analysis capabilities on an Orbitrap-based mass spectrometer for large macromolecular complexes.

Native mass spectrometry can provide insight into the structure of macromolecular biological systems. As analytes under investigation get larger and more complex, instrument capabilities need to be advanced. Herein, modifications to an Orbitrap Q Exactive Plus mass spectrometer that increase signal intensity, mass resolution, and maximum m/z measurable are described.

Evaluation of marker gene expression as a potential predictive marker of leukopenic toxicity for inactivated influenza vaccines.

The leukopenic toxicity test (LTT) is used to evaluate the safety and lot-to-lot consistency of influenza hemagglutinin split vaccine (HAv) and is included in the Japanese Minimum Requirements for Biological Products. LTT assesses the reduced leukocyte levels in murine peripheral blood after HAv administration. However, they require large numbers of animals, and therefore it would be beneficial to develop a more accurate and sensitive alternative method. In this study, we selected biomarkers of leukocyte reduction from 18 previously identified marker genes that were associated with an abnormal toxicity test (ATT). Among these 18 genes, the expressions of 15 marker genes were strongly associated with leukocyte reduction levels. A stepwise single addition multiple regression analysis was used to further extract the genes responsible for leukocyte reduction, with significant (p < 0.25) regression coefficients. The expression of 7 genes significantly predicted the leukocyte reduction. The prediction accuracy of this approach was approximately >90% (mean) for the direct measurement of leukocyte numbers. These results indicate that the expression of these 18 previously identified genes can provide information for both ATT and LTT.

Characterization of Enzymes Catalyzing Transformations of Cysteine S-Conjugated Intermediates in the Lincosamide Biosynthetic Pathway.

Lincosamides such as lincomycin A, celesticetin, and Bu-2545, constitute an important group of antibiotics. These natural products are characterized by a thiooctose linked to a l-proline residue, but they differ with regards to modifications of the thioacetal moiety, the pyrrolidine ring, and the octose core. Here we report that the pyridoxal 5'-phosphate-dependent enzyme CcbF (celesticetin biosynthetic pathway) is a decarboxylating deaminase that converts a cysteine S-conjugated intermediate into an aldehyde. In contrast, the homologous enzyme LmbF (lincomycin biosynthetic pathway) catalyzes C-S bond cleavage of the same intermediate to afford a thioglycoside. We show that Ccb4 and LmbG (downstream methyltransferases) convert the aldehyde and thiol intermediates into a variety of methylated lincosamide compounds including Bu-2545. The substrates used in these studies are the ß-anomers of the natural substrates. The findings not only provide insight into how the biosynthetic pathway of lincosamide antibiotics can bifurcate to generate different lincosamides, but also reveal the promiscuity of the enzymes involved.

Carbamazepine-Induced Liver Injury Requires CYP3A-Mediated Metabolism and Glutathione Depletion in Rats.

Carbamazepine (CBZ) is widely used as an antiepileptic agent and causes rare but severe liver injury in humans. It has been generally recognized that reactive metabolites formed via the metabolic activation reaction contribute to the onset of liver injuries by several drugs. However, the role of CBZ metabolism in the development of liver injury is not fully understood. In this study, we developed a novel rat model of CBZ-induced liver injury and attempted to elucidate the associated mechanisms by focusing on the metabolism of CBZ. The repeated administration of CBZ for 5 days in combination with l-buthionine sulfoximine (BSO), a glutathione (GSH) synthesis inhibitor, resulted in increases in the plasma alanine aminotransferase (ALT) levels and centrilobular necrosis in the liver that were observed in various degrees. The CBZ and 2-hydroxy-CBZ concentrations in the plasma after the last CBZ administration were lower in the rats with high plasma ALT levels compared with those with normal plasma ALT levels, showing the possibility that the further metabolism of CBZ and/or 2-hydroxy-CBZ is associated with the liver injury. Although a single administration of CBZ did not affect the plasma ALT levels, even when cotreated with BSO, pretreatment with dexamethasone, a CYP3A inducer, increased the plasma ALT levels. In addition, the rats cotreated with troleandomycin or ketoconazole, CYP3A inhibitors, suppressed the increased plasma ALT levels. In conclusion, reactive metabolite(s) of CBZ produced by CYP3A under the GSH-depleted condition might be involved in the development of liver injury in rats.

In vitro characterization of LmbK and LmbO: identification of GDP-D-erythro-α-D-gluco-octose as a key intermediate in lincomycin A biosynthesis.

Lincomycin A is a clinically useful antibiotic isolated from Streptomyces lincolnensis. It contains an unusual methylmercapto-substituted octose, methylthiolincosamide (MTL). While it has been demonstrated that the C8 backbone of MTL moiety is derived from D-fructose 6-phosphate and D-ribose 5-phosphate via a transaldol reaction catalyzed by LmbR, the subsequent enzymatic transformations leading to the MTL moiety remain elusive. Here, we report the identification of GDP-D-erythro-α-D-gluco-octose (GDP-D-α-D-octose) as a key intermediate in the MTL biosynthetic pathway. Our data show that the octose 1,8-bisphosphate intermediate is first converted to octose 1-phosphate by a phosphatase, LmbK. The subsequent conversion of the octose 1-phosphate to GDP-D-α-D-octose is catalyzed by the octose 1-phosphate guanylyltransferase, LmbO. These results provide significant insight into the lincomycin biosynthetic pathway, because the activated octose likely serves as the acceptor for the installation of the C1 sulfur appendage of MTL.

A general fluorescence off/on strategy for fluorogenic probes: Steric repulsion-induced twisted intramolecular charge transfer (sr-TICT).

Various control strategies are available for building fluorogenic probes to visualize biological events in terms of a fluorescence change. Here, we performed the time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) computational analysis of the twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) process in rhodamine dyes. On the basis of the results, we designed and synthesized a series of rhodamine dyes and established a fluorescence quenching strategy that we call steric repulsion-induced TICT (sr-TICT), in which the fluorescence quenching process is greatly accelerated by simple intramolecular twisting. As proof of concept of this design strategy, we used it to develop a fluorogenic probe, 2-Me PeER (pentyloxyethylrhodamine), for the N-dealkylation activity of CYP3A4. We applied 2-Me PeER for CYP3A4 activity-based fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS), providing access to homogeneous, highly functional human-induced pluripotent stem cell (hiPSC)-derived hepatocytes and intestinal epithelial cells. Our results suggest that sr-TICT represents a general fluorescence control method for fluorogenic probes.

Repeated Omicron exposures redirect SARS-CoV-2-specific memory B cell evolution toward the latest variants.

Immunological imprinting by ancestral SARS-CoV-2 strains is thought to impede the robust induction of Omicron-specific humoral responses by Omicron-based booster vaccines. Here, we analyzed the specificity and neutralization activity of memory B (Bmem) cells after repeated BA.5 exposure in individuals previously imprinted by ancestral strain-based mRNA vaccines. After a second BA.5 exposure, Bmem cells with BA.5 spike protein-skewed reactivity were promptly elicited, correlating with preexisting antibody titers. Clonal lineage analysis identified BA.5-skewed Bmem cells that had redirected their specificity from the ancestral strain to BA.5 through somatic hypermutations. Moreover, Bmem cells with redirected BA.5 specificity exhibited accelerated development compared with de novo Bmem cells derived from naïve repertoires. This redirected BA.5 specificity demonstrated greater resilience to viral point mutation and adaptation to recent Omicron variants HK.3 and JN.1, months after the second BA.5 exposure, suggesting that existing Bmem cells elicited by older vaccines can redirect their specificity toward newly evolving variants.

Systemically inoculated adjuvants stimulate pDC-dependent IgA response in local site.

The stimulation of local immunity by vaccination is desirable for controlling virus replication in the respiratory tract. However, the local immune stimulatory effects of adjuvanted vaccines administered through the non-mucosal route are poorly understood. Here, we clarify the mechanisms by which non-mucosal inoculation of adjuvants stimulates the plasmacytoid dendritic cell (pDC)-dependent immunoglobulin (Ig)A response in the lungs. After systemic inoculation with type 1 interferon (IFN)-inducing adjuvants, type 1 IFN promotes CXCL9/10/11 release from alveolar endothelial and epithelial cells and recruits CXCR3-expressing pDCs into the lungs. Because adjuvant-activated pulmonary pDCs highly express major histocompatibility complex II, cluster of differentiation 80, and cluster of differentiation 86, transplantation of such cells into the lungs successfully enhances antigen-specific IgA production by the intranasally sensitized vaccine. In contrast, pDC accumulation in the lungs and subsequent IgA production are impaired in pDC-depleted mice and Ifnar1-/- mice. Notably, the combination of systemic inoculation with type 1 IFN-inducing adjuvants and intranasal antigen sensitization protects mice against influenza virus infection due to the pDC-dependent IgA response and type I IFN response. Our results provide insights into the novel mucosal vaccine strategies using non-mucosal inoculated adjuvants.

Discovery of a cystathionine γ-lyase (CSE) selective inhibitor targeting active-site pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) via Schiff base formation.

D,L-Propargylglycine (PAG) has been widely used as a selective inhibitor to investigate the biological functions of cystathionine γ-lyase (CSE), which catalyzes the formation of reactive sulfur species (RSS). However, PAG also inhibits other PLP (pyridoxal-5'-phosphate)-dependent enzymes such as methionine γ-lyase (MGL) and L-alanine transaminase (ALT), so highly selective CSE inhibitors are still required. Here, we performed high-throughput screening (HTS) of a large chemical library and identified oxamic hydrazide 1 as a potent inhibitor of CSE (IC50 = 13 ± 1 µM (mean ± S.E.)) with high selectivity over other PLP-dependent enzymes and RSS-generating enzymes. Inhibitor 1 inhibited the enzymatic activity of human CSE in living cells, indicating that it is sufficiently membrane-permeable. X-Ray crystal structure analysis of the complex of rat CSE (rCSE) with 1 revealed that 1 forms a Schiff base linkage with the cofactor PLP in the active site of rCSE. PLP in the active site may be a promising target for development of selective inhibitors of PLP-dependent enzymes, including RSS-generating enzymes such as cystathionine ß-synthase (CBS) and cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase 2 (CARS2), which have unique substrate binding pocket structures.

Construction of the octose 8-phosphate intermediate in lincomycin A biosynthesis: characterization of the reactions catalyzed by LmbR and LmbN.

Lincomycin A is a potent antimicrobial agent noted for its unusual C1 methylmercapto-substituted 8-carbon sugar. Despite its long clinical history for the treatment of Gram-positive infections, the biosynthesis of the C(8)-sugar, methylthiolincosamide (MTL), is poorly understood. Here, we report our studies of the two initial enzymatic steps in the MTL biosynthetic pathway leading to the identification of D-erythro-D-gluco-octose 8-phosphate as a key intermediate. Our experiments demonstrate that this intermediate is formed via a transaldol reaction catalyzed by LmbR using D-fructose 6-phosphate or D-sedoheptulose 7-phosphate as the C(3) donor and D-ribose 5-phosphate as the C(5) acceptor. Subsequent 1,2-isomerization catalyzed by LmbN converts the resulting 2-keto C(8)-sugar (octulose 8-phosphate) to octose 8-phosphate. These results provide, for the first time, in vitro evidence for the biosynthetic origin of the C(8) backbone of MTL.

An investigation and assessment of the muscle damage and inflammation at injection site of aluminum-adjuvanted vaccines in guinea pigs.

Aluminum salt adjuvants (Als) have been the most widely used adjuvants in vaccines and known to be effective in intramuscular inoculation. However, in rare cases, some Al containing vaccines caused serious adverse events such as chronic pain at the site of the injection. The Als cause mild tissue damage at the inoculation site, allowing the antigen to be locally retained at the inoculation site and thus potentiate innate immunity. This is required to elicit effectiveness of vaccination. However, there is concern that chronic muscle damage might potentially lead to serious adverse events, such as autoimmune disease and movement disorders. In this study, muscle damage caused by several Al containing vaccines were examined in guinea pigs. Mild and moderate inflammation were observed following Al containing split influenza virus vaccine, formalin-inactivated diphtheria-pertussis-tetanus and Salk polio vaccine. While massive inflammation and muscle damage were observed in Al-containing human papillomavirus vaccine-inoculated animals. However, the severities of damage were not associated with their Al contents. Masson's trichrome staining and immunostaining revealed that injured muscle at the inoculated site recovered within one month of vaccination, whereas inflammatory nodules remained. Flow cytometric analyses of the infiltrating cells revealed that the number of CD45+ lymphocytes and potential granulocytes were increased following vaccination. The number of infiltrated cells seemed to be associated with severity of muscle damages. These observations revealed that Al containing vaccine-induced muscle damage is reparable, and severity of transient muscle damages seemed to be determined by type of antigen or types of Al salts rather than Al content.