Clinical Safety Recommendations for Testicular Torsion: Analysis of 101 Claims Settled with Compensation in Spain and France.

INTRODUCTION: The study aimed to analyze testicular torsion (TT) claims settled with compensation to have data available as the basis for making recommendations to decrease clinical risk and prevent claims. TT is a urological emergency with a high rate of orchiectomy, representing one of the main reasons for urological claims. METHODS: Data were analyzed from personal majority policy and from the public sector of Catalonia (Spain), as well as data from the main medical civil liability insurance firm at healthcare centers in France in the period from January 1, 2000 to December 31, 2018. RESULTS: Fifty Spanish and 51 French cases were analyzed. Statistical differences were logged in the two settings analyzed in performing ultrasounds, in the area where primary care was provided and with regard to settlement amounts. Diagnosis was late in 76.2% of cases. DISCUSSION: The medical action time from the onset of symptoms and Doppler testicular ultrasound in cases of questionable differential diagnoses is key to prognoses to save the testicles. Properly filling out the emergency report and the rest of medical records are essential for receiving correct medical care and defending possible claims.

Professional liability claims in vascular surgery practice.

BACKGROUND: Patient safety is a major concern worldwide, but particularly high rates of adverse events are reported in the surgery setting. Angiology and vascular surgery is of special interest due to the complexity of the pathologies involved and the esthetic component of some of its procedures. In this study we identified the most frequent factors that apply to vascular surgery claims to determine areas of special risk in vascular surgery, with an aim to improve patient safety. METHODS: We performed a retrospective and descriptive study of the claims pertaining to vascular surgery from the database of the Service of Professional Liability (SRP) of the Official College of Physicians of Barcelona. The time frame of data collection was from 1986 to 2009. We analyzed both the clinical and legal characteristics of the cases. RESULTS: Of the total of 6952 registered claims during the 23-year period, 91 (1.3%) were related to the practice of vascular surgery. Of these, 53.8% were related to venous pathology and 46.1% to arterial pathology. Neurologic damage was the main motive for claims (15.3%), followed by thromboembolic disease (14.2%), burns as a result of cosmetic treatment (12%), and amputation (10.9%). The neurologic damage in relation to vein pathology registered the greatest proportion of cases with professional liability (30.8%), followed by burns (19.2%), forgotten gauze (11.5%), and amputations (11.5%). CONCLUSIONS: Angiology and vascular surgery does not seem to be a specialty with a high risk for claims, but complications, such as thromboembolic disease and neurologic damage after varicose vein intervention, do occur and deserve special attention so improvements can be made to patient safety.

Professional Liability in Plastic Surgery: A Change of Scenario in Medical Professional Liability in Spain.

The epidemic of complaints and/or litigation, both in and out of court, for cases of alleged malpractice has increased dramatically. In Spain, claims related to plastic surgery are gaining more and more interest. Methods: The Council of Medical Associations of Catalonia database was used to analyze claims related to plastic surgery from 1986 to 2021. Results: 1039 claims (9.8% over 10,567 total claims) were studied. Both the total number of claims (P = 0.016; R2=0.16) and the number of claims for plastic surgery (P < 0.0005; R2=0.732) showed an upward trend during the period of study. In the period from 2000 to 2021, the behavior was different; while the number of total claims stabilized (P = 0.352; R2 = 0.043), plastic surgery claims continued to show a time-related tendency to increase (P < 0.0005; R2=0.484). The distribution was 50.12% out of court. Ten unique procedures accounted for 84.5% of the total number of claims. Liability was observed in 21.46% of the closed claims, with differences between civil (20.34%), criminal (6.89%), and out-of-court (25.53%) procedures. Regarding compensation amounts, out-of-court cases had an average of 33,169.44 euros paid; civil cases, 29,153.37 euros; and criminal cases, 37,186.88 euros. Conclusions: The increase in the number of cases can only be related to an increase in the activity carried out by plastic surgeons. There has been a change in Spain in terms of the most sought-after medical specialty, with plastic surgery having displaced the perennially most sought-after specialty, orthopedic surgery and traumatology.

Twenty four years of oral and maxillofacial surgery malpractice claims in Spain: patient safety lessons to learn.

PURPOSE: Oral and maxillofacial surgery (OMS) malpractice risk is of special interest due to both the aesthetic component of some procedures and the complexity of the pathologies involved. This study aims to identify relevant factors involved in OMS professional liability (PL) claims to help achive better management of risks and improve patient safety. METHODS: We performed a retrospective analysis of 315 OMS claims opened between 1990 and 2014 from the database of the PL Department of the Catalonian Council of Medical Colleges, and identified their clinical, economical and juridical characteristics. RESULTS: OMS showed a high rate of compensation (33.8%). Dental implant surgery, third molar surgery and rhinoplasty presented the greatest exposure to claims, and in these cases, lack of osteointegration of dental implants, neurologic injury of inferior dentoalveolar/lingual nerves and a poor aesthetic result were the most frequently compensated sequelae. Statistically, significant association was found between this perioperative complications group and the presence of PL. Poorly documented patient information (informed consent document) was also significantly related with PL outcome. CONCLUSIONS: OMS is a specialty of medium risk for claims, especially oral surgery cases. Surgical complications, such as neurologic damage after oral/head and neck procedures and poor aesthetic results, do occur and deserve special attention to improve patient safety, as well as patient-information procedure.

Analysis of obstetrics and gynecology professional liability claims in Catalonia, Spain (1986-2010).

OBJECTIVE: To identify relevant factors involved in obstetrics and gynecology (OG) professional liability claims to help archive better management of risks. STUDY DESIGN: Analysis of 885 OG claims opened between 1986 and 2010, with the identification of the most common events leading to a claim, the economical and juridical characteristics of the claims, as well as the relevant trends over the study period. RESULTS: Most claims related to obstetrics. Labor, delivery and its complications accounted for 33.1% of the claims; 12.77% related specifically to cesarean. Oncological diseases, fetus death during labor and delivery, neurologically impaired infant and histerectomy-related problems were the most frequently claimed events. Most cases ended up without an indemnity payment and 37.7% of closed files were solved by an out-of-court procedure. Average payment was higher for the obstetric procedures than for those concerning gynecology cases. The proportion of claims relating to obstetrics increased during the study period, as well as the average payment. CONCLUSION: OG is at high-risk for malpractice claims, but compensation awards are not frequent. However, particular events, such as retained foreign objects, tubal ligation, ultrasound diagnosis or neurologically impaired newborns, deserve special attention regarding medico-legal issues.