Electrophysiology of bacteria.

Bacteria secrete and harbor in their membranes a number of pore-forming proteins. Some of these are bona fide ion channels that may respond to changes in membrane tension, voltage, or pH. Others may be large translocons used for the secretion of folded or unfolded polypeptide substrates. Additionally, many secreted toxins insert into target cell membranes and form pores that either collapse membrane electrochemical gradients or provide conduits for the delivery of virulence factors. In all cases, electrophysiological approaches have yielded much progress in past decades in understanding the functional mechanisms of these pores. By monitoring the changes in current due to ion flow through the pores, these techniques are used as high-resolution tools to gather detailed information on the kinetic and permeation properties of these proteins, including those whose physiological role is not ion flux. This review highlights some of the electrophysiological studies that have advanced the field of transport by pore-forming proteins of bacterial origin.

Molecular basis of usher pore gating in Escherichia coli pilus biogenesis.

Extracellular fibers called chaperone-usher pathway pili are critical virulence factors in a wide range of Gram-negative pathogenic bacteria that facilitate binding and invasion into host tissues and mediate biofilm formation. Chaperone-usher pathway ushers, which catalyze pilus assembly, contain five functional domains: a 24-stranded transmembrane ß-barrel translocation domain (TD), a ß-sandwich plug domain (PLUG), an N-terminal periplasmic domain, and two C-terminal periplasmic domains (CTD1 and 2). Pore gating occurs by a mechanism whereby the PLUG resides stably within the TD pore when the usher is inactive and then upon activation is translocated into the periplasmic space, where it functions in pilus assembly. Using antibiotic sensitivity and electrophysiology experiments, a single salt bridge was shown to function in maintaining the PLUG in the TD channel of the P pilus usher PapC, and a loop between the 12th and 13th beta strands of the TD (ß12-13 loop) was found to facilitate pore opening. Mutation of the ß12-13 loop resulted in a closed PapC pore, which was unable to efficiently mediate pilus assembly. Deletion of the PapH terminator/anchor resulted in increased OM permeability, suggesting a role for the proper anchoring of pili in retaining OM integrity. Further, we introduced cysteine residues in the PLUG and N-terminal periplasmic domains that resulted in a FimD usher with a greater propensity to exist in an open conformation, resulting in increased OM permeability but no loss in type 1 pilus assembly. These studies provide insights into the molecular basis of usher pore gating and its roles in pilus biogenesis and OM permeability.

Electrostatic networks control plug stabilization in the PapC usher.

The PapC usher, a ß-barrel pore in the outer membrane of uropathogenic Escherichia coli, is used for assembly of the P pilus, a key virulence factor in bacterial colonization of human kidney cells. Each PapC protein is composed of a 24-stranded ß-barrel channel, flanked by N- and C-terminal globular domains protruding into the periplasm, and occluded by a plug domain (PD). The PD is displaced from the channel towards the periplasm during pilus biogenesis, but the molecular mechanism for PD displacement remains unclear. Two structural features within the ß-barrel, an α-helix and ß5-6 hairpin loop, may play roles in controlling plug stabilization. Here we have tested clusters of residues at the interface of the plug, barrel, α-helix and hairpin, which participate in electrostatic networks. To assess the roles of these residues in plug stabilization, we used patch-clamp electrophysiology to compare the activity of wild-type and mutant PapC channels containing alanine substitutions at these sites. Mutations interrupting each of two salt bridge networks were relatively ineffective in disrupting plug stabilization. However, mutation of two pairs of arginines located at the inner and the outer surfaces of the PD resulted in an enhanced propensity for plug displacement. One arginine pair involved in a repulsive interaction between the linkers that tether the plug to the ß-barrel was particularly sensitive to mutation. These results suggest that plug displacement, which is necessary for pilus assembly and translocation, may require a weakening of key electrostatic interactions between the plug linkers, and the plug and the α-helix.

Current fluctuation analysis of the PopB and PopD translocon components of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa type III secretion system.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is a major agent of hospital-acquired infections, and a pathogen of immunocompromised, cystic fibrosis and burn patients. It uses a type III secretion system for the injection of toxins directly into host cells, through a translocon assembled in the host cell membrane. The hydrophobic translocator subunits of this system, PopB and PopD, have membrane permeabilizing activity based on previous dye leakage experiments, but little is known about the mechanism of assembly and the pore properties of this translocon. Using electrophysiology, we have observed that an equimolar mixture of PopB and PopD induces current fluctuations in planar lipid bilayers, with a unitary conductance of 57 pS in 1 M KCl and numerous larger conductance levels. The activity depends on voltage magnitude and polarity, and increases with protein concentration and the duration of the voltage step. PopB alone is sufficient for producing current fluctuations. PopD rarely displays any transitions, but accelerates PopB onset of activity. The effects of pH, ionic strength, and lipid composition have also been explored. Our data provide new, to our knowledge, insights into the behavior of PopB and PopD by highlighting similarities with secreted pore-forming peptides, and by suggesting that PopB/PopD may form channels via the toroidal pore model. We believe that the events we report here represent the initial steps of insertion and assembly of these translocators in the membrane.

Effects of conjugated and unconjugated bile acids on the activity of the Vibrio cholerae porin OmpT.

During infection, the enteric pathogen Vibrio cholerae encounters a bile-containing environment. Previous studies have shown that bile and/or bile acids exert several effects on the virulence and physiology of the bacterial cells. These observations have led to the suggestion that bile acids may play a signaling role in infection. We have previously reported that the bile component deoxycholic acid blocks the general diffusion porin OmpT in a dose-dependent manner, presumably as it transits through the pore. V. cholerae colonizes the distal jejunum and ileum, where a mixture of various conjugated and unconjugated bile acids are found. In this work, we have used patch clamp electrophysiology to investigate the effects of six bile acids on OmpT. Two bile acids (deoxycholic and chenodeoxycholic acids) were found to block OmpT at physiological concentrations below 1 mM, while glycodeoxycholic acid was mildly effective and cholic, lithocholic and taurodeoxycholic acids were ineffective in this range. The block was also voltage-dependent. These observations suggest the presence of a specific binding site inside the OmpT pore. Since deconjugation is due to the activity of the endogenous flora, the preferential uptake of some unconjugated bile acids by OmpT may signal the presence of a hospitable environment. The results are also discussed in terms of the possible molecular interactions between the penetrating bile acid molecule and the channel wall.

Size and dynamics of the Vibrio cholerae porins OmpU and OmpT probed by polymer exclusion.

The trimeric OmpU and OmpT porins form large, triple-barrel hydrophilic channels in the outer membrane of the pathogen Vibrio cholerae. They have distinct pore properties, such as conductance, block by deoxycholic acid, and sensitivity to acidic pH. Their three-dimensional structures are unknown, but they share significant sequence homologies. To gain insight into the molecular basis for the distinct functional properties of these two similar porins, we carried out polymer exclusion experiments using planar lipid bilayer and patch-clamp electrophysiology. By studying the partitioning of polyethylene glycols (PEGs) of different molecular weights into each porin, we determined an effective radius of 0.55 nm and 0.43 nm for OmpU and OmpT respectively, and found an increased OmpU effective radius at acidic pH. PEGs or high buffer ionic strength promotes the appearance of single step closures in OmpU similar to the acidic-pH induced closures we documented previously. In addition, these closing events can be triggered by nonpenetrating PEGs applied asymmetrically. We believe our results support a model whereby acidic pH, high ionic strength, or exposure to PEGs stabilizes a less conductive state that corresponds to the appearance of an additional resistive element on one side of the OmpU protein and common to the three monomers.

Modulating effects of the plug, helix, and N- and C-terminal domains on channel properties of the PapC usher.

The chaperone/usher system is one of the best characterized pathways for protein secretion and assembly of cell surface appendages in Gram-negative bacteria. In particular, this pathway is used for biogenesis of the P pilus, a key virulence factor used by uropathogenic Escherichia coli to adhere to the host urinary tract. The P pilus individual subunits bound to the periplasmic chaperone PapD are delivered to the outer membrane PapC usher, which serves as an assembly platform for subunit incorporation into the pilus and secretion of the pilus fiber to the cell surface. PapC forms a dimeric, twin pore complex, with each monomer composed of a 24-stranded transmembrane beta-barrel channel, an internal plug domain that occludes the channel, and globular N- and C-terminal domains that are located in the periplasm. Here we have used planar lipid bilayer electrophysiology to characterize the pore properties of wild type PapC and domain deletion mutants for the first time. The wild type pore is closed most of the time but displays frequent short-lived transitions to various open states. In comparison, PapC mutants containing deletions of the plug domain, an alpha-helix that caps the plug domain, or the N- and C-terminal domains form channels with higher open probability but still exhibiting dynamic behavior. Removal of the plug domain results in a channel with extremely large conductance. These observations suggest that the plug gates the usher channel closed and that the periplasmic domains and alpha-helix function to modulate the gating activity of the PapC twin pore.

Outer membrane permeability and antibiotic resistance.

To date most antibiotics are targeted at intracellular processes, and must be able to penetrate the bacterial cell envelope. In particular, the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria provides a formidable barrier that must be overcome. There are essentially two pathways that antibiotics can take through the outer membrane: a lipid-mediated pathway for hydrophobic antibiotics, and general diffusion porins for hydrophilic antibiotics. The lipid and protein compositions of the outer membrane have a strong impact on the sensitivity of bacteria to many types of antibiotics, and drug resistance involving modifications of these macromolecules is common. This review will describe the molecular mechanisms for permeation of antibiotics through the outer membrane, and the strategies that bacteria have deployed to resist antibiotics by modifications of these pathways.

Disulfide bond tethering of extracellular loops does not affect the closure of OmpF porin at acidic pH.

The permeability of the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria is essentially controlled by pore-forming proteins of the porin family. The trimeric E. coli porin OmpF is assembled as a triple ß-barrel, where each monomer contains a central pore and extracellular loops. Electrophysiological analysis of the behavior of OmpF at acidic pH reveals that the protein undergoes a conformational change leading to the sequential step-wise closure of the three monomers. A previous atomic force microscopy study suggested that the conformational change might be due to a bending of extracellular loops over the pore opening, and loop deletion experiments suggested that loops L1, L7, and L8 are involved. In order to test the hypothesis for loop movement, we engineered a series of double cysteine mutants in loops L1, L6, L7 and L8 in order to create disulfide bonds linking two loops to each other, or the two branches of a loop, or a loop to the ß-barrel. Five out of the six mutants showed the formation of the disulfide bond. However, none of these had an altered response to acidic pH relative to the wildtype channel. Although we cannot dismiss the possibility that the mobility restriction introduced by each disulfide bond was too localized to impact a more global conformational change of the three loops, the fact that all of the different types of disulfide bond tethering were similarly ineffective suggests that the extracellular loops L1, L7, and L8 may not undergo a major acidic-pH induced conformational change leading to channel closure.

Altered pore properties and kinetic changes in mutants of the Vibrio cholerae porin OmpU.

The electrophysiological technique of patch-clamp was used to characterize the pore properties of site-directed mutants in the Vibrio cholerae general diffusion porin OmpU. Changes in conductance and selectivity were observed, thus confirming the predicted pore location of these residues, based on homology with the Escherichia coli porins OmpF and OmpC. Some mutants acquire a weak selectivity for cations, which mirrors the properties of the homologous, deoxycholic acid sensitive, OmpT porin of V. cholerae. However, the mutants remain insensitive to deoxycholic acid, like wildtype OmpU. This result suggests that channel selectivity is not an important determinant in the sensitivity to this drug, and is in agreement with our finding that the neutral deoxycholic acid, and not deoxycholate, is the actual active form in channel block. Modifications in the kinetics of spontaneous closures were also noted, and are similar to those found for the E. coli channels. In addition, mutants at the D116 residue on the L3 loop display marked transitions to sub-conductance states. The results reported here are compared to a phenotypical characterization of the mutants in terms of permeability to maltodextrins and beta-lactam antibiotic sensitivity. No strict correlations are observed, suggesting that distinct, but somewhat overlapping, molecular determinants control electrophysiological properties and substrate permeability.

Phenotypic characterization of pore mutants of the Vibrio cholerae porin OmpU.

General-diffusion porins form large beta-barrel channels that control the permeability of the outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria to nutrients, some antibiotics, and external signals. Here, we have analyzed the effects of mutations in the OmpU porin of Vibrio cholerae at conserved residues that are known to affect pore properties in the Escherichia coli porins OmpF and OmpC. Various phenotypes were investigated, including sensitivity to beta-lactam antibiotics, growth on large sugars, and sensitivity to and biofilm induction by sodium deoxycholate, a major bile component that acts as an external signal for multiple cellular responses of this intestinal pathogen. Overall, our results indicate that specific residues play different roles in controlling the passage of various compounds. Mutations of barrel wall arginine residues that protrude in the pore affect pore size and growth in the presence of large sugars or sodium deoxycholate. Sensitivity to large cephalosporins is mostly affected by D116, located on the L3 loop, whose homolog in E. coli, OmpF, is a known binding determinant for these drugs. L3 loop residues also affect biofilm induction. The results are interpreted in terms of a homology model based on the structures of E. coli porins.

The Rotavirus NSP4 Viroporin Domain is a Calcium-conducting Ion Channel.

Viroporins are small virus-encoded ion channel proteins. Most viroporins are monovalent selective cation channels, with few showing the ability to conduct divalent cations, like calcium (Ca2+). Nevertheless, some viroporins are known to disrupt host cell Ca2+ homeostasis, which is critical for virus replication and pathogenesis. Rotavirus nonstructural protein 4 (NSP4) is an endoplasmic reticulum transmembrane glycoprotein that has a viroporin domain (VPD), and NSP4 viroporin activity elevates cytosolic Ca2+ in mammalian cells. The goal of this study was to demonstrate that the NSP4 VPD forms an ion channel and determine whether the channel can conduct Ca2+. Using planar lipid bilayer and liposome patch clamp electrophysiology, we show that a synthetic peptide of the NSP4 VPD has ion channel activity. The NSP4 VPD was selective for cations over anions and channel activity was observed to have both well-defined "square top" openings as well as fast current fluctuations, similar to other viroporins. Importantly, the NSP4 VPD showed similar conductance of divalent cations (Ca2+ and Ba2+) as monovalent cations (K+), but a viroporin defective mutant lacked Ca2+ conductivity. These data demonstrate that the NSP4 VPD is a Ca2+-conducting viroporin and establish the mechanism by which NSP4 disturbs host cell Ca2+ homeostasis.

Effect of chaperone-adhesin complex on plug release by the PapC usher.

The P pilus of uropathogenic Escherichia coli is a multisubunit fiber assembled at the outer membrane in a defined sequence by a chaperone/usher secretion system, comprising a periplasmic chaperone and a beta-barrel outer membrane protein, the PapC usher. To gain insight into the pilus biogenesis mechanism, we used patch clamp electrophysiology to investigate the effect of the initiating adhesin subunit, as it is delivered to PapC in a complex with the chaperone. We show that the chaperone-adhesin complex facilitates opening of the PapC pore and appears to engage within the PapC lumen, in agreement with prior biochemical and structural data.

Subconductance states in OmpF gating.

Discrepancies were noted in the published conductance of the Escherichia coli porin OmpF. Results from various papers are hard to compare because of the use of different channel preparations, salt types and concentrations, and electrophysiological techniques (black lipid membrane (BLM) vs. patch clamp). To reconcile these data, we present a side-by-side comparison of OmpF activity studied with the two techniques on the same preparation of pure protein, and in the same low salt concentrations (150 mM KCl). The novel aspect of OmpF porin behavior revealed by this comparison is the ubiquitous existence of states of smaller conductance than the monomeric conductance (subconductance states), regardless of the techniques or experimental conditions used, and the drastic enhancement of subconductance gating by polyamines. Transitions to subconductance states have received little attention in previous publications, in particular when BLM electrophysiology was used. Monomeric closures are rare in recordings at clamped potentials, at least at voltages lower than approximately 100-120 mV. Most closing activity is in the form of subconductance gating, which becomes more dominant in the presence of spermine, with a more frequent and prolonged occupation of these substates. A discussion of the molecular basis for this hallmark behavior of porin is presented.

Colicins, spermine and cephalosporins: a competitive interaction with the OmpF eyelet.

The L3 loop is an important feature of the OmpF porin structure, contributing to both channel size and electrostatic properties. Colicins A and N, spermine, and antibiotics that use OmpF to penetrate the cell, were used to investigate the structure-function relationships of L3. Spermine was found to protect efficiently cells expressing wild-type OmpF from colicin action. Among other solutes, sugars had minor effects on colicin A activity, whereas competitions between colicin A and antibiotic fluxes were observed. Among the antibiotics tested, cefepime appeared the most efficient. Escherichia coli cells expressing various OmpF proteins mutated in the eyelet were tested for their susceptibility to colicin A, and resistant strains were found only among L3 mutants. Mutations at residues 119 and 120 were the most effective at conferring resistance to colicin A, probably due to epitope structure alteration, as revealed by a specific antipeptide. More detailed information was obtained on mutants D113A and D121A, by focusing on the kinetics of colicin A and colicin N activities through measurements of potassium efflux. D113 appeared to play an essential role for colicin A activity, whereas colicin N activity was more dependent on D121 than on D113.

Deletions of single extracellular loops affect pH sensitivity, but not voltage dependence, of the Escherichia coli porin OmpF.

The molecular basis for the voltage and pH dependence of the Escherichia coli OmpF porin activity remains unknown. The L3 loop was previously shown not be involved in voltage dependence. Here we used seven OmpF mutants where single extracellular loops, except L3, were deleted one at a time. The proteins are expressed at levels comparable to wild-type and purified as trimers. Wild-type and mutant proteins were inserted into planar lipid bilayers for electrophysiological measurement of their activity. Current-voltage relationships show the typical porin channel closure at voltages greater than the critical voltage. Measurements of critical voltages for the seven deletion mutants showed no significant differences relative to wild-type, hence eliminating the role of single loops in voltage sensitivity. However, deletions of loops L1, L7 or L8 affected the tendency of channels to close at acidic pH. Wild-type channels close more readily at acidic pH and their open probability is decreased by approximately 60% at pH 4.0 relative to pH 7.0. For mutants lacking loop L1, L7 or L8, the channel open probability was found not to be significantly different at pH 4.0 than at pH 7.0. The other deletion mutants retained a pH sensitivity similar to the wild-type channel. Possible mechanistic scenarios for the voltage- and pH dependence of E.coli OmpF porin are discussed based on these results.

Solute uptake through general porins.

General diffusion porins are among the few membrane proteins that have been thoroughly investigated by many techniques, including X-ray crystallography, AFM microscopy, computer modeling, electrophysiology and biochemistry. This had led to a good understanding of the process of solute transport per se. However, other aspects of porin function remain enigmatic, such as the molecular basis and physiological relevance of many regulatory processes. After summarizing the most salient structural features, the review provides a description of the techniques used for the functional study of porins. The process of solute transport is presented on the basis of structure-function relationship and modeling studies. Three aspects of regulation are discussed: voltage-dependence, pH sensitivity and modulation by polycations and polyanions. The review ends with a perspective on future porin research, to be targeted at a molecular understanding of the regulatory processes, the deciphering of the physiological context in which these processes take place, and rational drug design.

Allosteric signalling in the outer membrane translocation domain of PapC usher.

PapC ushers are outer-membrane proteins enabling assembly and secretion of P pili in uropathogenic E. coli. Their translocation domain is a large ß-barrel occluded by a plug domain, which is displaced to allow the translocation of pilus subunits across the membrane. Previous studies suggested that this gating mechanism is controlled by a ß-hairpin and an α-helix. To investigate the role of these elements in allosteric signal communication, we developed a method combining evolutionary and molecular dynamics studies of the native translocation domain and mutants lacking the ß-hairpin and/or the α-helix. Analysis of a hybrid residue interaction network suggests distinct regions (residue 'communities') within the translocation domain (especially around ß12-ß14) linking these elements, thereby modulating PapC gating. Antibiotic sensitivity and electrophysiology experiments on a set of alanine-substitution mutants confirmed functional roles for four of these communities. This study illuminates the gating mechanism of PapC ushers and its importance in maintaining outer-membrane permeability.

Electrophysiological characterization of bacterial pore-forming proteins in planar lipid bilayers.

Together with patch-clamp, the planar lipid bilayer technique is one of the electrophysiological approaches used to study the biophysical properties of bacterial pore-forming proteins. Electrophysiological studies have provided important insight into the mechanistic details underlying the function of this class of proteins. Although there are different apparatus designs and variations to the process of obtaining channel recordings, the general architecture of a planar lipid bilayer setup involves two compartments filled with an ionic solution and separated by a septum with a micro-aperture, where a phospholipid bilayer is formed, and an amplifier used to clamp the membrane potential and record currents. Bacterial outer membrane porins and translocons, among others, can be reconstituted in this bilayer and their electrophysiology probed in different physicochemical conditions or through functional assays with substrates or potential modulators. This chapter describes specifically the reconstitution of detergent purified outer membrane pore-forming proteins into artificial lipid membranes using a laboratory customized planar lipid bilayer apparatus and the subsequent recording of channel activity under voltage clamp.