Pyrimidine-Dependent UV-Mediated Cross-Linking Magnifies Minor Genetic or Epigenetic Changes in Clinical Samples.

BACKGROUND: Detection of minor DNA allele alterations is becoming increasingly important for early detection and monitoring of cancer. We describe a new method that uses ultraviolet light to eliminate wild-type DNA alleles and enables improved detection of minor genetic or epigenetic changes. METHODS: Pyrimidine-dependent UV-based minor-allele enrichment (PD-UVME) employed oligonucleotide probes that incorporated a UVA-sensitive 3-cyanovinylcarbazole (CNVK), placed directly opposite interrogated pyrimidines, such as thymine (T) or cytosine (C) in wild-type (WT) DNA. Upon UVA-illumination, CNVK cross-linked with T/C, preventing subsequent amplification. Mutations that removed the T/C escaped cross-linking and were amplified and detected. Similarly, CNVK discriminated between methylated and unmethylated cytosine in CpG dinucleotides, enabling direct enrichment of unmethylated DNA targets. PD-UVME was combined with digital droplet PCR (ddPCR) to detect serine/threonine-protein kinase B-Raf (BRAF) V600E mutations in model systems, thyroid patient cancer tissue samples, and circulating DNA of tumor origin (ctDNA) from melanoma patients. RESULTS: One thyroid cancer sample out of 9, and 6 circulating-DNA samples out of 7 were found to be BRAF V600E-positive via PD-UVME while classified as negative by conventional ddPCR. Positive samples via conventional ddPCR were also found positive via PD-UVME. All 10 circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA) samples obtained from normal volunteers were negative via both approaches. Furthermore, preferential enrichment of unmethylated alleles in MAGEA1 promoters using PD-UVME was demonstrated. CONCLUSIONS: PD-UVME mutation/methylation enrichment performed prior to ddPCR magnifies low-level mutations or epigenetic changes and increases sensitivity and confidence in the results. It can assist with clinical decisions that hinge on the presence of trace alterations like BRAF V600E.

Mutation enrichment in human DNA samples via UV-mediated cross-linking.

Detection of low-level DNA mutations can reveal recurrent, hotspot genetic changes of clinical relevance to cancer, prenatal diagnostics, organ transplantation or infectious diseases. However, the high excess of wild-type (WT) alleles, which are concurrently present, often hinders identification of salient genetic changes. Here, we introduce UV-mediated cross-linking minor allele enrichment (UVME), a novel approach that incorporates ultraviolet irradiation (∼365 nm UV) DNA cross-linking either before or during PCR amplification. Oligonucleotide probes matching the WT target sequence and incorporating a UV-sensitive 3-cyanovinylcarbazole nucleoside modification are employed for cross-linking WT DNA. Mismatches formed with mutated alleles reduce DNA binding and UV-mediated cross-linking and favor mutated DNA amplification. UV can be applied before PCR and/or at any stage during PCR to selectively block WT DNA amplification and enable identification of traces of mutated alleles. This enables a single-tube PCR reaction directly from genomic DNA combining optimal pre-amplification of mutated alleles, which then switches to UV-mediated mutation enrichment-based DNA target amplification. UVME cross-linking enables enrichment of mutated KRAS and p53 alleles, which can be screened directly via Sanger sequencing, high-resolution melting, TaqMan genotyping or digital PCR, resulting in the detection of mutation allelic frequencies of 0.001-0.1% depending on the endpoint detection method. UV-mediated mutation enrichment provides new potential for mutation enrichment in diverse clinical samples.

Duplex-Repair enables highly accurate sequencing, despite DNA damage.

Accurate DNA sequencing is crucial in biomedicine. Underlying the most accurate methods is the assumption that a mutation is true if altered bases are present on both strands of the DNA duplex. We now show that this assumption can be wrong. We establish that current methods to prepare DNA for sequencing, via 'End Repair/dA-Tailing,' may substantially resynthesize strands, leading amplifiable lesions or alterations on one strand to become indiscernible from true mutations on both strands. Indeed, we discovered that 7-17% and 32-57% of interior 'duplex base pairs' from cell-free DNA and formalin-fixed tumor biopsies, respectively, could be resynthesized in vitro and potentially introduce false mutations. To address this, we present Duplex-Repair, and show that it limits interior duplex base pair resynthesis by 8- to 464-fold, rescues the impact of induced DNA damage, and affords up to 8.9-fold more accurate duplex sequencing. Our study uncovers a major Achilles' heel in sequencing and offers a solution to restore high accuracy.

NGS-based identification and tracing of microsatellite instability from minute amounts DNA using inter-Alu-PCR.

Sensitive detection of microsatellite instability (MSI) in tissue or liquid biopsies using next generation sequencing (NGS) has growing prognostic and predictive applications in cancer. However, the complexities of NGS make it cumbersome as compared to established multiplex-PCR detection of MSI. We present a new approach to detect MSI using inter-Alu-PCR followed by targeted NGS, that combines the practical advantages of multiplexed-PCR with the breadth of information provided by NGS. Inter-Alu-PCR employs poly-adenine repeats of variable length present in every Alu element and provides a massively-parallel, rapid approach to capture poly-A-rich genomic fractions within short 80-150bp amplicons generated from adjacent Alu-sequences. A custom-made software analysis tool, MSI-tracer, enables Alu-associated MSI detection from tissue biopsies or MSI-tracing at low-levels in circulating-DNA. MSI-associated indels at somatic-indel frequencies of 0.05-1.5% can be detected depending on the availability of matching normal tissue and the extent of instability. Due to the high Alu copy-number in human genomes, a single inter-Alu-PCR retrieves enough information for identification of MSI-associated-indels from ∼100 pg circulating-DNA, reducing current limits by ∼2-orders of magnitude and equivalent to circulating-DNA obtained from finger-sticks. The combined practical and informational advantages of inter-Alu-PCR make it a powerful tool for identifying tissue-MSI-status or tracing MSI-associated-indels in liquid biopsies.

Combined clinical and research training in medical physics in a multi-institutional setting: 13-year experience of Harvard Medical Physics Residency Program.

PURPOSE: This manuscript describes the structure, management and outcomes of a multi-institutional clinical and research medical physics residency program (Harvard Medical Physics Residency Program, or HMPRP) to provide potentially useful information to the centers considering a multi-institutional approach for their training programs. METHODS: Data from the program documents and public records was used to describe HMPRP and obtain statistics about participating faculty, enrolled residents, and graduates. Challenges associated with forming and managing a multi-institutional program and developed solutions for effective coordination between several clinical centers are described. RESULTS: HMPRP was formed in 2009 and was accredited by the Commission on Accreditation of Medical Physics Education Programs (CAMPEP) in 2011. It is a 3-year therapy program, with a dedicated year of research and the 2 years of clinical training at three academic hospitals. A CAMPEP-accredited Certificate Program is embedded in HMPRP to allow enrolled residents to complete a formal didactic training in medical physics if necessary. The clinical training covers the material required by CAMPEP. In addition, training in protons, CyberKnife, MR-linac, and at network locations is included. The clinical training and academic record of the residents is outstanding. All graduates have found employment within clinical medical physics, mostly at large academic centers and graduates had a 100% pass rate at the oral American Board of Radiology exams. On average, three manuscripts per resident are published during residency, and multiple abstracts are presented at conferences. CONCLUSIONS: A multi-institutional medical physics residency program can be successfully formed and managed. With a collaborative administrative structure, the program creates an environment for high-quality clinical training of the residents and high productivity in research. The main advantage of such program is access to a wide variety of resources. The main challenge is creating a structure for efficient management of multiple resources at different locations. This report may provide valuable information to centers considering starting a multi-institutional residency program.

Enzymatic Methods for Mutation Detection in Cancer Samples and Liquid Biopsies.

Low-level tumor somatic DNA mutations in tissue and liquid biopsies obtained from cancer patients can have profound implications for development of metastasis, prognosis, choice of treatment, follow-up, or early cancer detection. Unless detected, such low-frequency DNA alterations can misinform patient management decisions or become missed opportunities for personalized medicine. Next-generation sequencing technologies and digital-PCR can resolve low-level mutations but require access to specialized instrumentation, time, and resources. Enzymatic-based approaches to detection of low-level mutations provide a simple, straightforward, and affordable alternative to enrich and detect such alterations and is broadly available to low-resource laboratory settings. This review summarizes the traditional uses of enzymatic mutation detection and describes the latest exciting developments, potential, and applications with specific reference to the field of liquid biopsy in cancer.

Recent Developments in Mutation Enrichment and Detection Technologies.

BACKGROUND: Presence of excess unaltered, wild-type DNA (wtDNA) providing information of little clinical value may often mask low-level mutations containing important diagnostic or therapeutic clues. This is a recurring hurdle in biotechnology and medicine, including cancer, prenatal diagnosis, infectious diseases, and organ transplantation. Mutation enrichment techniques that allow reduction of unwanted DNA to enable the detection of low-level mutations have emerged since the early 1990s. They are continuously being refined and updated with new technologies. The burgeoning interest in liquid biopsies for residual cancer monitoring, detection of resistance to therapy, and early cancer detection has driven an expanded interest in new and improved methodologies for practical and effective mutation enrichment and detection of low-level mutations of clinical relevance. CONTENT: Newly developed mutation enrichment technologies are described and grouped according to the main principle of operation, PCR-blocking technologies, enzymatic methods, and physicochemical approaches. Special emphasis is given to technologies enabling pre-PCR blockage of wtDNA to bypass PCR errors [nuclease-assisted minor-allele enrichment assay with overlapping probes (NaME-PrO) and UV-mediated cross-linking minor allele enrichment (UVME)] or providing high multiplexity followed by next-generation sequencing [Minor allele enriched sequencing through recognition oligonucleotides (MAESTRO)]. SUMMARY: This review summarizes technological developments in rare mutation enrichment over the last 12 years, complementing pre-2010 reviews on this topic. The expanding field of liquid biopsy calls for improved limits of detection (LOD) and highly parallel applications, along with the traditional requirements for accuracy, speed, and cost-effectiveness. The current technologies are reviewed with regards to these new requirements.

Enhanced detection of microsatellite instability using pre-PCR elimination of wild-type DNA homo-polymers in tissue and liquid biopsies.

Detection of microsatellite-instability in colonoscopy-obtained polyps, as well as in plasma-circulating DNA, is frequently confounded by sensitivity issues due to co-existing excessive amounts of wild-type DNA. While also an issue for point mutations, this is particularly problematic for microsatellite changes, due to the high false-positive artifacts generated by polymerase slippage (stutter-bands). Here, we describe a nuclease-based approach, NaME-PrO, that uses overlapping oligonucleotides to eliminate unaltered micro-satellites at the genomic DNA level, prior to PCR. By appropriate design of the overlapping oligonucleotides, NaME-PrO eliminates WT alleles in long single-base homopolymers ranging from 10 to 27 nucleotides in length, while sparing targets containing variable-length indels at any position within the homopolymer. We evaluated 5 MSI targets individually or simultaneously, NR27, NR21, NR24, BAT25 and BAT26 using DNA from cell-lines, biopsies and circulating-DNA from colorectal cancer patients. NaME-PrO enriched altered microsatellites and detected alterations down to 0.01% allelic-frequency using high-resolution-melting, improving detection sensitivity by 500-1000-fold relative to current HRM approaches. Capillary-electrophoresis also demonstrated enhanced sensitivity and enrichment of indels 1-16 bases long. We anticipate application of this highly-multiplex-able method either with standard 5-plex reactions in conjunction with HRM/capillary electrophoresis or massively-parallel-sequencing-based detection of MSI on numerous targets for sensitive MSI-detection.

Nuclease-Assisted Minor Allele Enrichment Using Overlapping Probes-Assisted Amplification-Refractory Mutation System: An Approach for the Improvement of Amplification-Refractory Mutation System-Polymerase Chain Reaction Specificity in Liquid Biopsies.

Allele-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) (amplification-refractory mutation system, ARMS) is one of the most commonly used methods for mutation detection. However, a main limitation of ARMS-PCR is the false positive results obtained due to nonspecific priming that can take place with wild-type (WT) DNA, which often precludes detection of low-level mutations. To improve the analytical specificity of ARMS, we present here a new technology, NAPA: NaME-PrO-assisted ARMS, that overcomes the ARMS deficiency by adding a brief enzymatic step that reduces wild-type alleles just prior to ARMS. We performed this technology for the simultaneous detection of two hot-spot PIK3CA mutations (E545 K and H1047R) in circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and cell free DNA (cfDNA). The developed protocol could simultaneously detect mutation-allelic-frequency of 0.5% for PIK3CA exon 9 (E545 K) and 0.1% for PIK3CA exon 20 (H1047R) with high specificity. We further compared the developed NAPA assay with (a) ddPCR considered as the gold standard and (b) our previous assay based on the combination of allele-specific, asymmetric rapid PCR, and melting analysis. Our data show that the newly developed NAPA assay gives consistent results with both these assays (p = 0.001). The developed assay resolves the false positive signals issue derived through classic ARMS-PCR and provides an ideal combination of speed, accuracy, and versatility and should be easily applicable in routine diagnostic laboratories.

Methylation-sensitive enrichment of minor DNA alleles using a double-strand DNA-specific nuclease.

Aberrant methylation changes, often present in a minor allelic fraction in clinical samples such as plasma-circulating DNA (cfDNA), are potentially powerful prognostic and predictive biomarkers in human disease including cancer. We report on a novel, highly-multiplexed approach to facilitate analysis of clinically useful methylation changes in minor DNA populations. Methylation Specific Nuclease-assisted Minor-allele Enrichment (MS-NaME) employs a double-strand-specific DNA nuclease (DSN) to remove excess DNA with normal methylation patterns. The technique utilizes oligonucleotide-probes that direct DSN activity to multiple targets in bisulfite-treated DNA, simultaneously. Oligonucleotide probes targeting unmethylated sequences generate local double stranded regions resulting to digestion of unmethylated targets, and leaving methylated targets intact; and vice versa. Subsequent amplification of the targeted regions results in enrichment of the targeted methylated or unmethylated minority-epigenetic-alleles. We validate MS-NaME by demonstrating enrichment of RARb2, ATM, MGMT and GSTP1 promoters in multiplexed MS-NaME reactions (177-plex) using dilutions of methylated/unmethylated DNA and in DNA from clinical lung cancer samples and matched normal tissue. MS-NaME is a highly scalable single-step approach performed at the genomic DNA level in solution that combines with most downstream detection technologies including Sanger sequencing, methylation-sensitive-high-resolution melting (MS-HRM) and methylation-specific-Taqman-based-digital-PCR (digital Methylight) to boost detection of low-level aberrant methylation-changes.

Denaturation-Enhanced Droplet Digital PCR for Liquid Biopsies.

BACKGROUND: Although interest in droplet-digital PCR technology (ddPCR) for cell-free circulating DNA (cfDNA) analysis is burgeoning, the technology is compromised by subsampling errors and the few clinical targets that can be analyzed from limited input DNA. The paucity of starting material acts as a "glass ceiling" in liquid biopsies because, irrespective how analytically sensitive ddPCR techniques are, detection limits cannot be improved past DNA input limitations. METHODS: We applied denaturation-enhanced ddPCR (dddPCR) using fragmented genomic DNA (gDNA) with defined mutations. We then tested dddPCR on cfDNA from volunteers and patients with cancer for commonly-used mutations. gDNA and cfDNA were tested with and without end repair before denaturation and digital PCR. RESULTS: By applying complete denaturation of double-stranded DNA before ddPCR droplet formation the number of positive droplets increased. dddPCR using gDNA resulted in a 1.9-2.0-fold increase in data-positive droplets, whereas dddPCR applied on highly-fragmented cfDNA resulted in a 1.6-1.7-fold increase. End repair of cfDNA before denaturation enabled cfDNA to display a 1.9-2.0-fold increase in data-positive signals, similar to gDNA. Doubling of data-positive droplets doubled the number of potential ddPCR assays that could be conducted from a given DNA input and improved ddPCR precision for cfDNA mutation detection. CONCLUSIONS: dddPCR is a simple and useful modification in ddPCR that enables extraction of more information from low-input clinical samples with minor change in protocols. It should be applicable to all ddPCR platforms for mutation detection and, potentially, for gene copy-number analysis in cancer and prenatal screening.

Elimination of unaltered DNA in mixed clinical samples via nuclease-assisted minor-allele enrichment.

Presence of excess unaltered, wild-type (WT) DNA providing no information of biological or clinical value often masks rare alterations containing diagnostic or therapeutic clues in cancer, prenatal diagnosis, infectious diseases or organ transplantation. With the surge of high-throughput technologies there is a growing demand for removing unaltered DNA over large pools-of-sequences. Here we present nuclease-assisted minor-allele enrichment with probe-overlap (NaME-PrO), a single-step approach with broad genome coverage that can remove WT-DNA from numerous sequences simultaneously, prior to genomic analysis. NaME-PrO employs a double-strand-DNA-specific nuclease and overlapping oligonucleotide-probes interrogating WT-DNA targets and guiding nuclease digestion to these sites. Mutation-containing DNA creates probe-DNA mismatches that inhibit digestion, thus subsequent DNA-amplification magnifies DNA-alterations at all selected targets. We demonstrate several-hundred-fold mutation enrichment in diverse human samples on multiple clinically relevant targets including tumor samples and circulating DNA in 50-plex reactions. Enrichment enables routine mutation detection at 0.01% abundance while by adjusting conditions it is possible to sequence mutations down to 0.00003% abundance, or to scan tumor-suppressor genes for rare mutations. NaME-PrO introduces a simple and highly parallel process to remove un-informative DNA sequences and unmask clinically and biologically useful alterations.

Multiplexed Elimination of Wild-Type DNA and High-Resolution Melting Prior to Targeted Resequencing of Liquid Biopsies.

BACKGROUND: The use of clinical samples and circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA) collected from liquid biopsies for diagnostic and prognostic applications in cancer is burgeoning, and improved methods that reduce the influence of excess wild-type (WT) portion of the sample are desirable. Here we present enrichment of mutation-containing sequences using enzymatic degradation of WT DNA. Mutation enrichment is combined with high-resolution melting (HRM) performed in multiplexed closed-tube reactions as a rapid, cost-effective screening tool before targeted resequencing. METHODS: We developed a homogeneous, closed-tube approach to use a double-stranded DNA-specific nuclease for degradation of WT DNA at multiple targets simultaneously. The No Denaturation Nuclease-assisted Minor Allele Enrichment with Probe Overlap (ND-NaME-PrO) uses WT oligonucleotides overlapping both strands on putative DNA targets. Under conditions of partial denaturation (DNA breathing), the oligonucleotide probes enhance double-stranded DNA-specific nuclease digestion at the selected targets, with high preference toward WT over mutant DNA. To validate ND-NaME-PrO, we used multiplexed HRM, digital PCR, and MiSeq targeted resequencing of mutated genomic DNA and cfDNA. RESULTS: Serial dilution of KRAS mutation-containing DNA shows mutation enrichment by 10- to 120-fold and detection of allelic fractions down to 0.01%. Multiplexed ND-NaME-PrO combined with multiplexed PCR-HRM showed mutation scanning of 10-20 DNA amplicons simultaneously. ND-NaME-PrO applied on cfDNA from clinical samples enables mutation enrichment and HRM scanning over 10 DNA targets. cfDNA mutations were enriched up to approximately 100-fold (average approximately 25-fold) and identified via targeted resequencing. CONCLUSIONS: Closed-tube homogeneous ND-NaME-PrO combined with multiplexed HRM is a convenient approach to efficiently enrich for mutations on multiple DNA targets and to enable prescreening before targeted resequencing.

Nanoparticle Mediated Tumor Vascular Disruption: A Novel Strategy in Radiation Therapy.

More than 50% of all cancer patients receive radiation therapy. The clinical delivery of curative radiation dose is strictly restricted by the proximal healthy tissues. We propose a dual-targeting strategy using vessel-targeted-radiosensitizing gold nanoparticles and conformal-image guided radiation therapy to specifically amplify damage in the tumor neoendothelium. The resulting tumor vascular disruption substantially improved the therapeutic outcome and subsidized the radiation/nanoparticle toxicity, extending its utility to intransigent or nonresectable tumors that barely respond to standard therapies.

DMSO Increases Mutation Scanning Detection Sensitivity of High-Resolution Melting in Clinical Samples.

BACKGROUND: Mutation scanning provides the simplest, lowest-cost method for identifying DNA variations on single PCR amplicons, and it may be performed before sequencing to avoid screening of noninformative wild-type samples. High-resolution melting (HRM) is the most commonly used method for mutation scanning. With PCR-HRM, however, mutations less abundant than approximately 3%-10% that can still be clinically significant may often be missed. Therefore, enhancing HRM detection sensitivity is important for mutation scanning and its clinical application. METHODS: We used serial dilution of cell lines containing the TP53 exon 8 mutation to demonstrate the improvement in detection sensitivity for conventional-PCR-HRM in the presence of DMSO. We also conducted coamplification at lower denaturation temperature (COLD)-PCR with an extra step for cross-hybridization, followed by preferential denaturation and amplification at optimized critical temperature (full-COLD-PCR), to further enrich low-level mutations before HRM with or without DMSO, and we used droplet-digital PCR to derive the optimal conditions for mutation enrichment. Both conventional PCR-HRM and full-COLD-PCR-HRM with and without DMSO were used for mutation scanning of TP53 exon 8 in cancer samples containing known mutations and myelodysplastic syndrome samples with unknown mutations. Mutations in other genes were also examined. RESULTS: The detection sensitivity of PCR-HRM scanning increases 2- to 5-fold in the presence of DMSO, depending on mutation type and sequence context, and can typically detect mutation abundance of approximately 1%. When mutation enrichment is applied during amplification with full-COLD-PCR followed by HRM in the presence of DMSO, mutations with 0.2%-0.3% abundance in TP53 exon 8 can be detected. CONCLUSIONS: DMSO improves HRM mutation scanning sensitivity with saturating dyes. When full-COLD-PCR is used, followed by DMSO-HRM, the overall improvement is about 20-fold compared with conventional PCR-HRM.

Differential strand separation at critical temperature: a minimally disruptive enrichment method for low-abundance unknown DNA mutations.

Detection of low-level DNA variations in the presence of wild-type DNA is important in several fields of medicine, including cancer, prenatal diagnosis and infectious diseases. PCR-based methods to enrich mutations during amplification have limited multiplexing capability, are mostly restricted to known mutations and are prone to polymerase or mis-priming errors. Here, we present Differential Strand Separation at Critical Temperature (DISSECT), a method that enriches unknown mutations of targeted DNA sequences purely based on thermal denaturation of DNA heteroduplexes without the need for enzymatic reactions. Target DNA is pre-amplified in a multiplex reaction and hybridized onto complementary probes immobilized on magnetic beads that correspond to wild-type DNA sequences. Presence of any mutation on the target DNA forms heteroduplexes that are subsequently denatured from the beads at a critical temperature and selectively separated from wild-type DNA. We demonstrate multiplexed enrichment by 100- to 400-fold for KRAS and TP53 mutations at multiple positions of the targeted sequence using two to four successive cycles of DISSECT. Cancer and plasma-circulating DNA samples containing traces of mutations undergo mutation enrichment allowing detection via Sanger sequencing or high-resolution melting. The simplicity, scalability and reliability of DISSECT make it a powerful method for mutation enrichment that integrates well with existing downstream detection methods.

Ice-COLD-PCR enables rapid amplification and robust enrichment for low-abundance unknown DNA mutations.

Identifying low-abundance mutations within wild-type DNA is important in several fields of medicine, including cancer, prenatal diagnosis and infectious diseases. However, utilizing the clinical and diagnostic potential of rare mutations is limited by sensitivity of the molecular techniques employed, especially when the type and position of mutations are unknown. We have developed a novel platform that incorporates a synthetic reference sequence within a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) reaction, designed to enhance amplification of unknown mutant sequences during COLD-PCR (CO-amplification at Lower Denaturation temperature). This new platform enables an Improved and Complete Enrichment (ice-COLD-PCR) for all mutation types and eliminates shortcomings of previous formats of COLD-PCR. We evaluated ice-COLD-PCR enrichment in regions of TP53 in serially diluted mutant and wild-type DNA mixtures. Conventional-PCR, COLD-PCR and ice-COLD-PCR amplicons were run in parallel and sequenced to determine final mutation abundance for a range of mutations representing all possible single base changes. Amplification by ice-COLD-PCR enriched all mutation types and allowed identification of mutation abundances down to 1%, and 0.1% by Sanger sequencing or pyrosequencing, respectively, surpassing the capabilities of other forms of PCR. Ice-COLD-PCR will help elucidate the clinical significance of low-abundance mutations and our understanding of cancer origin, evolution, recurrence-risk and treatment diagnostics.