Alternative proteoforms and proteoform-dependent assemblies in humans and plants.

The variability of proteins at the sequence level creates an enormous potential for proteome complexity. Exploring the depths and limits of this complexity is an ongoing goal in biology. Here, we systematically survey human and plant high-throughput bottom-up native proteomics data for protein truncation variants, where substantial regions of the full-length protein are missing from an observed protein product. In humans, Arabidopsis, and the green alga Chlamydomonas, approximately one percent of observed proteins show a short form, which we can assign by comparison to RNA isoforms as either likely deriving from transcript-directed processes or limited proteolysis. While some detected protein fragments align with known splice forms and protein cleavage events, multiple examples are previously undescribed, such as our observation of fibrocystin proteolysis and nuclear translocation in a green alga. We find that truncations occur almost entirely between structured protein domains, even when short forms are derived from transcript variants. Intriguingly, multiple endogenous protein truncations of phase-separating translational proteins resemble cleaved proteoforms produced by enteroviruses during infection. Some truncated proteins are also observed in both humans and plants, suggesting that they date to the last eukaryotic common ancestor. Finally, we describe novel proteoform-specific protein complexes, where the loss of a domain may accompany complex formation.

Separating distinct structures of multiple macromolecular assemblies from cryo-EM projections.

Single particle analysis for structure determination in cryo-electron microscopy is traditionally applied to samples purified to near homogeneity as current reconstruction algorithms are not designed to handle heterogeneous mixtures of structures from many distinct macromolecular complexes. We extend on long established methods and demonstrate that relating two-dimensional projection images by their common lines in a graphical framework is sufficient for partitioning distinct protein and multiprotein complexes within the same data set. The feasibility of this approach is first demonstrated on a large set of synthetic reprojections from 35 unique macromolecular structures spanning a mass range of hundreds to thousands of kilodaltons. We then apply our algorithm on cryo-EM data collected from a mixture of five protein complexes and use existing methods to solve multiple three-dimensional structures ab initio. Incorporating methods to sort single particle cryo-EM data from extremely heterogeneous mixtures will alleviate the need for stringent purification and pave the way toward investigation of samples containing many unique structures.

Structural basis for RNA-duplex recognition and unwinding by the DEAD-box helicase Mss116p.

DEAD-box proteins are the largest family of nucleic acid helicases, and are crucial to RNA metabolism throughout all domains of life. They contain a conserved 'helicase core' of two RecA-like domains (domains (D)1 and D2), which uses ATP to catalyse the unwinding of short RNA duplexes by non-processive, local strand separation. This mode of action differs from that of translocating helicases and allows DEAD-box proteins to remodel large RNAs and RNA-protein complexes without globally disrupting RNA structure. However, the structural basis for this distinctive mode of RNA unwinding remains unclear. Here, structural, biochemical and genetic analyses of the yeast DEAD-box protein Mss116p indicate that the helicase core domains have modular functions that enable a novel mechanism for RNA-duplex recognition and unwinding. By investigating D1 and D2 individually and together, we find that D1 acts as an ATP-binding domain and D2 functions as an RNA-duplex recognition domain. D2 contains a nucleic-acid-binding pocket that is formed by conserved DEAD-box protein sequence motifs and accommodates A-form but not B-form duplexes, providing a basis for RNA substrate specificity. Upon a conformational change in which the two core domains join to form a 'closed state' with an ATPase active site, conserved motifs in D1 promote the unwinding of duplex substrates bound to D2 by excluding one RNA strand and bending the other. Our results provide a comprehensive structural model for how DEAD-box proteins recognize and unwind RNA duplexes. This model explains key features of DEAD-box protein function and affords a new perspective on how the evolutionarily related cores of other RNA and DNA helicases diverged to use different mechanisms.

Evolution of RNA-protein interactions: non-specific binding led to RNA splicing activity of fungal mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases.

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (mtTyrRS; CYT-18 protein) evolved a new function as a group I intron splicing factor by acquiring the ability to bind group I intron RNAs and stabilize their catalytically active RNA structure. Previous studies showed: (i) CYT-18 binds group I introns by using both its N-terminal catalytic domain and flexibly attached C-terminal anticodon-binding domain (CTD); and (ii) the catalytic domain binds group I introns specifically via multiple structural adaptations that occurred during or after the divergence of Peziomycotina and Saccharomycotina. However, the function of the CTD and how it contributed to the evolution of splicing activity have been unclear. Here, small angle X-ray scattering analysis of CYT-18 shows that both CTDs of the homodimeric protein extend outward from the catalytic domain, but move inward to bind opposite ends of a group I intron RNA. Biochemical assays show that the isolated CTD of CYT-18 binds RNAs non-specifically, possibly contributing to its interaction with the structurally different ends of the intron RNA. Finally, we find that the yeast mtTyrRS, which diverged from Pezizomycotina fungal mtTyrRSs prior to the evolution of splicing activity, binds group I intron and other RNAs non-specifically via its CTD, but lacks further adaptations needed for group I intron splicing. Our results suggest a scenario of constructive neutral (i.e., pre-adaptive) evolution in which an initial non-specific interaction between the CTD of an ancestral fungal mtTyrRS and a self-splicing group I intron was "fixed" by an intron RNA mutation that resulted in protein-dependent splicing. Once fixed, this interaction could be elaborated by further adaptive mutations in both the catalytic domain and CTD that enabled specific binding of group I introns. Our results highlight a role for non-specific RNA binding in the evolution of RNA-binding proteins.

Knotted fusion proteins reveal unexpected possibilities in protein folding.

Proteins that contain a distinct knot in their native structure are impressive examples of biological self-organization. Although this topological complexity does not appear to cause a folding problem, the mechanisms by which such knotted proteins form are unknown. We found that the fusion of an additional protein domain to either the amino terminus, the carboxy terminus, or to both termini of two small knotted proteins did not affect their ability to knot. The multidomain constructs remained able to fold to structures previously thought unfeasible, some representing the deepest protein knots known. By examining the folding kinetics of these fusion proteins, we found evidence to suggest that knotting is not rate limiting during folding, but instead occurs in a denatured-like state. These studies offer experimental insights into when knot formation occurs in natural proteins and demonstrate that early folding events can lead to diverse and sometimes unexpected protein topologies.

Solution structures of DEAD-box RNA chaperones reveal conformational changes and nucleic acid tethering by a basic tail.

The mitochondrial DEAD-box proteins Mss116p of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and CYT-19 of Neurospora crassa are ATP-dependent helicases that function as general RNA chaperones. The helicase core of each protein precedes a C-terminal extension and a basic tail, whose structural role is unclear. Here we used small-angle X-ray scattering to obtain solution structures of the full-length proteins and a series of deletion mutants. We find that the two core domains have a preferred relative orientation in the open state without substrates, and we visualize the transition to a compact closed state upon binding RNA and adenosine nucleotide. An analysis of complexes with large chimeric oligonucleotides shows that the basic tails of both proteins are attached flexibly, enabling them to bind rigid duplex DNA segments extending from the core in different directions. Our results indicate that the basic tails of DEAD-box proteins contribute to RNA-chaperone activity by binding nonspecifically to large RNA substrates and flexibly tethering the core for the unwinding of neighboring duplexes.

Knot formation in newly translated proteins is spontaneous and accelerated by chaperonins.

Topological knots are found in a considerable number of protein structures, but it is not clear how they knot and fold within the cellular environment. We investigated the behavior of knotted protein molecules as they are first synthesized by the ribosome using a cell-free translation system. We found that newly translated knotted proteins can spontaneously self-tie and do not require the assistance of molecular chaperones to fold correctly to their trefoil-knotted structures. This process is slow but efficient, and we found no evidence of misfolded species. A kinetic analysis indicates that the knotting process is rate limiting, occurs post-translationally, and is specifically and significantly (P < 0.001) accelerated by the GroEL-GroES chaperonin complex. This demonstrates a new active mechanism for this molecular chaperone and suggests that chaperonin-catalyzed knotting probably dominates in vivo. These results explain how knotted protein structures have withstood evolutionary pressures despite their topological complexity.

Experimental detection of knotted conformations in denatured proteins.

Structures that contain a knot formed by the path of the polypeptide backbone represent some of the most complex topologies observed in proteins. How or why these topological knots arise remains unclear. By developing a method to experimentally trap and detect knots in nonnative polypeptide chains, we find that two knotted methyltransferases, YibK and YbeA, can exist in a trefoil-knot conformation even in their chemically unfolded states. The unique denatured-state topology of these molecules explains their ability to efficiently fold to their native knotted structures in vitro and offers insights into the potential role of knots in proteins. Furthermore, the high prevalence of the denatured-state knots identified here suggests that they are either difficult to untie or that threading of any untied molecules is rapid and spontaneous. The occurrence of such knotted topologies in unfolded polypeptide chains raises the possibility that they could play an important, and as yet unexplored, role in folding and misfolding processes in vivo.

Exploring knotting mechanisms in protein folding.

One of the most striking topological features to be found in a protein is that of a distinct knot formed by the path of the polypeptide backbone. Such knotted structures represent some of the smallest "self-tying" knots observed in Nature. Proteins containing a knot deep within their structure add an extra complication to the already challenging protein-folding problem; it is not obvious how, during the process of folding, a substantial length of polypeptide chain manages to spontaneously thread itself through a loop. Here, we probe the folding mechanism of YibK, a homodimeric alpha/beta-knot protein containing a deep trefoil knot at its carboxy terminus. By analyzing the effect of mutations made in the knotted region of the protein we show that the native structure in this area remains undeveloped until very late in the folding reaction. Single-site destabilizing mutations made in the knot structure significantly affect only the folding kinetics of a late-forming intermediate and the slow dimerization step. Furthermore, we find evidence to suggest that the heterogeneity observed in the denatured state is not caused by isomerization of the single cis proline bond as previously thought, but instead could be a result of the knotting mechanism. These results allow us to propose a folding model for YibK where the threading of the polypeptide chain and the formation of native structure in the knotted region of the protein occur independently as successive events.

The dimerization of an alpha/beta-knotted protein is essential for structure and function.

alpha/beta-Knotted proteins are an extraordinary example of biological self-assembly; they contain a deep topological trefoil knot formed by the backbone polypeptide chain. Evidence suggests that all are dimeric and function as methyltransferases, and the deep knot forms part of the active site. We investigated the significance of the dimeric structure of the alpha/beta-knot protein, YibK, from Haemophilus influenzae by the design and engineering of monomeric versions of the protein, followed by examination of their structural, functional, stability, and kinetic folding properties. Monomeric forms of YibK display similar characteristics to an intermediate species populated during the formation of the wild-type dimer. However, a notable loss in structure involving disruption to the active site, rendering it incapable of cofactor binding, is observed in monomeric YibK. Thus, dimerization is vital for preservation of the native structure and, therefore, activity of the protein.

Systematic Discovery of Endogenous Human Ribonucleoprotein Complexes.

RNA-binding proteins (RBPs) play essential roles in biology and are frequently associated with human disease. Although recent studies have systematically identified individual RNA-binding proteins, their higher-order assembly into ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complexes has not been systematically investigated. Here, we describe a proteomics method for systematic identification of RNP complexes in human cells. We identify 1,428 protein complexes that associate with RNA, indicating that more than 20% of known human protein complexes contain RNA. To explore the role of RNA in the assembly of each complex, we identify complexes that dissociate, change composition, or form stable protein-only complexes in the absence of RNA. We use our method to systematically identify cell-type-specific RNA-associated proteins in mouse embryonic stem cells and finally, distribute our resource, rna.MAP, in an easy-to-use online interface (rna.proteincomplexes.org). Our system thus provides a methodology for explorations across human tissues, disease states, and throughout all domains of life.

A comparison of the folding of two knotted proteins: YbeA and YibK.

The extraordinary topology of proteins belonging to the alpha/beta-knot superfamily of proteins is unexpected, due to the apparent complexities involved in the formation of a deep trefoil knot in a polypeptide backbone. Despite this, an increasing number of knotted structures are being identified; how such proteins fold remains a mystery. Studies on the dimeric protein YibK from Haemophilus influenzae have led to the characterisation of its folding pathway in some detail. To complement research into the folding of YibK, and to address whether folding pathways are conserved for members of the alpha/beta-knot superfamily, the structurally similar knotted protein YbeA from Escherichia coli has been studied. A comprehensive thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of the folding of YbeA is presented here, and compared to that of YibK. Both fold via an intermediate state populated under equilibrium conditions that is monomeric and considerably structured. The unfolding/refolding kinetics of YbeA are simpler than those found for YibK and involve two phases attributed to the formation of a monomeric intermediate state and a dimerisation step. In contrast to YibK, a change in the rate-determining step on the unfolding pathway for YbeA is observed with a changing concentration of urea. Despite this difference, both proteins fold by a mechanism involving at least one sequential monomeric intermediate that has properties similar to that observed during the equilibrium unfolding. The rate of dimerisation observed for YbeA and YibK is very similar, as is the rate constant for formation of the kinetic monomeric intermediate that precedes dimerisation. The findings suggest that relatively slow folding and dimerisation may be common attributes of knotted proteins.

Classification of Single Particles from Human Cell Extract Reveals Distinct Structures.

Multi-protein complexes are necessary for nearly all cellular processes, and understanding their structure is required for elucidating their function. Current high-resolution strategies in structural biology are effective but lag behind other fields (e.g., genomics and proteomics) due to their reliance on purified samples rather than heterogeneous mixtures. Here, we present a method combining single-particle analysis by electron microscopy with protein identification by mass spectrometry to structurally characterize macromolecular complexes from human cell extract. We identify HSP60 through two-dimensional classification and obtain three-dimensional structures of native proteasomes directly from ab initio classification of a heterogeneous mixture of protein complexes. In addition, we reveal an ∼1-MDa-size structure of unknown composition and reference our proteomics data to suggest possible identities. Our study shows the power of using a shotgun approach to electron microscopy (shotgun EM) when coupled with mass spectrometry as a tool to uncover the structures of macromolecular machines.

Probing nature's knots: the folding pathway of a knotted homodimeric protein.

The homodimeric protein YibK from Haemophilus influenzae belongs to a recently discovered superfamily of knotted proteins that has brought about a new protein-folding conundrum. Members of the alpha/beta-knot clan form deep trefoil knots in their native backbone structure, a topological feature that is currently unexplained in the protein-folding field. To help solve the puzzle of how a polypeptide chain can efficiently knot itself, the folding kinetics of YibK have been studied extensively and the results are reported here. Folding was monitored using probes for changes in both secondary and tertiary structure, and the monomer-dimer equilibrium was perturbed with a variety of solution conditions to allow characterisation of otherwise inaccessible states. Multiphasic kinetics were observed in the unfolding and refolding reactions of YibK, and under conditions where the dimer is favoured, dissociation and association were rate-limiting, respectively. A folding model consistent with all kinetic data is proposed: YibK appears to fold via two parallel pathways, partitioned by proline isomerisation events, to two distinct monomeric intermediates. These form a common third intermediate that is able to fold to native dimer. Kinetic simulations suggest that all intermediates are on-pathway. These results provide the valuable groundwork required to further understand how Nature codes for knot formation.

Systems-wide Studies Uncover Commander, a Multiprotein Complex Essential to Human Development.

Recent mass spectrometry maps of the human interactome independently support the existence of a large multiprotein complex, dubbed "Commander." Broadly conserved across animals and ubiquitously expressed in nearly every human cell type examined thus far, Commander likely plays a fundamental cellular function, akin to other ubiquitous machines involved in expression, proteostasis, and trafficking. Experiments on individual subunits support roles in endosomal protein sorting, including the trafficking of Notch proteins, copper transporters, and lipoprotein receptors. Commander is critical for vertebrate embryogenesis, and defects in the complex and its interaction partners disrupt craniofacial, brain, and heart development. Here, we review the synergy between large-scale proteomic efforts and focused studies in the discovery of Commander, describe its composition, structure, and function, and discuss how it illustrates the power of systems biology. Based on 3D modeling and biochemical data, we draw strong parallels between Commander and the retromer cargo-recognition complex, laying a foundation for future research into Commander's role in human developmental disorders.

Folding studies on a knotted protein.

YibK is a 160 residue homodimeric protein belonging to the SPOUT class of methyltransferases. Proteins in this group all display a unique topological feature; the backbone polypeptide chain folds to form a deep trefoil knot. Such knotted structures were completely unpredicted, it being thought impossible for a protein to fold efficiently in this way. However, they are becoming more common and there are now a growing number of examples in the Protein Data Bank. These intriguing knotted structures represent a new and significant challenge in the field of protein folding. Here, we present an initial characterisation of the folding of YibK, one of the smallest knotted proteins to be identified. This is the first detailed folding study on a knotted protein to be reported. We have established conditions under which the protein can be denatured reversibly in vitro using urea, thereby showing that molecular chaperones are not required for the efficient folding of this protein. A series of equilibrium unfolding experiments were performed over a 400-fold range of protein concentration. Both secondary and tertiary structural probes show a single, protein concentration-dependent unfolding transition, and data are most consistent with a three-state equilibrium denaturation model involving a monomeric intermediate. Thermodynamic parameters obtained from the fit of the data to this model indicate that the intermediate is a stable species with appreciable secondary and tertiary structure; whether the topological knot remains in the intermediate state is still to be shown. Together, these results demonstrate that, despite its complex knotted structure, YibK is able to fold efficiently and behaves remarkably similarly to other dimeric proteins under equilibrium conditions.

Molecular insights into RNA and DNA helicase evolution from the determinants of specificity for a DEAD-box RNA helicase.

How different helicase families with a conserved catalytic 'helicase core' evolved to function on varied RNA and DNA substrates by diverse mechanisms remains unclear. In this study, we used Mss116, a yeast DEAD-box protein that utilizes ATP to locally unwind dsRNA, to investigate helicase specificity and mechanism. Our results define the molecular basis for the substrate specificity of a DEAD-box protein. Additionally, they show that Mss116 has ambiguous substrate-binding properties and interacts with all four NTPs and both RNA and DNA. The efficiency of unwinding correlates with the stability of the 'closed-state' helicase core, a complex with nucleotide and nucleic acid that forms as duplexes are unwound. Crystal structures reveal that core stability is modulated by family-specific interactions that favor certain substrates. This suggests how present-day helicases diversified from an ancestral core with broad specificity by retaining core closure as a common catalytic mechanism while optimizing substrate-binding interactions for different cellular functions.

Backbone NMR assignments of a topologically knotted protein in urea-denatured state.

YbeA is a 3-methylpseudoridine methyltransferase from Escherichia coli that forms a stable homodimer in solution. It is one of the deeply trefoil 31 knotted proteins, of which the knot encompasses the C-terminal helix that threads through a long loop. Recent studies on the knotted protein folding pathways using YbeA have suggested that the protein knot remains present under chemically denaturing conditions. Here, we report (1)H, (13)C and (15)N chemical shift assignments for urea-denatured YbeA, which will serve as the basis for further structural characterisations using solution state NMR spectroscopy with paramagnetic spin labeled and partial alignment media.

Backbone 1H, 13C and 15N assignments of YibK and avariant containing a unique cysteine residue at C-terminus in 8 M urea-denatured states [corrected].

YibK is a tRNA methyltransferase from Haemophilus influenzae, which forms a stable homodimer in solution and contains a deep trefoil 31 knot encompassing the C-terminal helix that threads through a long loop. It has been a model system for investigating knotted protein folding pathways. Recent data have shown that the polypeptide chain of YibK remains loosely knotted under highly denaturing conditions. Here, we report (1)H, (13)C and (15)N chemical shift assignments for YibK and its variant in the presence of 8 M urea. This work forms the basis for further analysis using NMR techniques such as paramagnetic relaxation enhancement, residual dipolar couplings and spin-relaxation dynamics analysis.

How does a knotted protein fold?

The issue of how a newly synthesized polypeptide chain folds to form a protein with a unique three-dimensional structure, otherwise known as the 'protein-folding problem', remains a fundamental question in the life sciences. Over the last few decades, much information has been gathered about the mechanisms by which proteins fold. However, despite the vast topological diversity observed in biological structures, it was thought improbable, if not impossible, that a polypeptide chain could 'knot' itself to form a functional protein. Nevertheless, such knotted structures have since been identified, raising questions about how such complex topologies can arise during folding. Their formation does not fit any current folding models or mechanisms, and therefore represents an important piece of the protein-folding puzzle. This article reviews the progress made towards discovering how nature codes for, and contends with, knots during protein folding, and examines the insights gained from both experimental and computational studies. Mechanisms to account for the formation of knotted structures that were previously thought unfeasible, and their implications for protein folding, are also discussed.