A comparison of asbestos fiber potency and elongate mineral particle (EMP) potency for mesothelioma in humans.

Dr. Garabrant presented a paper concerning a comparison of asbestos fiber potency and elongate mineral particle (EMP) potency for mesothelioma in humans at the Elongate Mineral Particles Conference in Charlottesville, Virginia in 2017. I was a participant at the Conference. Following Dr. Garabrant's talk, I rose in question period to point out that he had not considered information about the occurrence of mesothelioma in several cohorts that was published after the studies that he cited. These additional data were still not addressed in the paper published in your Journal. I believe that your readers would be interested in these, so this letter is written to draw the additional data to their attention.

Comments on "Dimensions of elongated mineral particles with implications for pathogenicity and classification as asbestiform versus cleavage fragments".

Roggli and Green have reported their study of the dimensions of fibers extracted from the tissues of cases examined in their laboratory, and have drawn conclusions about the pathogenicity of Elongated Mineral Particles and their classification as asbestiform versus cleavage fragments. There are aspects of their methodology and discussion that would benefit from examination. Roggli and Green have relied upon a paper by Harper et al. for their definitions of asbestiform and cleavage fragments. Unfortunately, they have misinterpreted the work of those authors who have concluded that the best criterion is a particle width <1µm. Roggli and Green conclude that 'Our findings demonstrate the lack of pathogenicity of fibers less than 10 µm long or likelihood of cleavage fragments for fibers less than 10µm long and greater than 1.0µm in diameter has little or no effect on the classification of commercial amphibole fibers using our analytical methodology. On the other hand, both lack of pathogenicity and likelihood of cleavage fragments apply to a significant proportion of noncommercial amphiboles identified using our counting scheme.' This is not true. The study of Roggli and Green was a simple fiber counting study with no control population. The design of such a study does not allow the investigator to draw any conclusions about pathogenicity, or lack thereof.

Cyclophosphamide versus etoposide in combination with total body irradiation as conditioning regimen for adult patients with Ph-negative acute lymphoblastic leukemia undergoing allogeneic stem cell transplant: On behalf of the ALWP of the European Society for Blood and Marrow Transplantation.

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (alloHCT) with myeloablative conditioning based on total body irradiation (TBI) is widely used for the treatment of adults with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). TBI is most frequently administered in combination with either cyclophosphamide (Cy/TBI) or etoposide (Vp/TBI). The goal of this study was to retrospectively compare these two regimens. Adult patients with Ph-negative ALL treated with alloHCT in first or second complete remission who received Cy/TBI (n = 1346) or Vp/TBI (n = 152) conditioning were included in the analysis. In a univariate analysis, as compared to Cy/TBI, the use of Vp/TBI was associated with reduced incidence of relapse (17% vs. 30% at 5 years, P = .007), increased rate of leukemia-free survival (60% vs. 50%, P = .04), and improved "graft versus host disease (GVHD) and relapse-free survival" (GRFS, 43% vs. 33%, P = .04). No significant effect could be observed in terms of the incidence of nonrelapse mortality or acute or chronic GVHD. In a multivariate model, the use of Vp/TBI was associated with reduced risk of relapse (HR = 0.62, P = .04) while the effect on other study end-points was not significant. In conclusion, conditioning regimen based on Vp combined with TBI appears more effective for disease control than the combination of Cy with TBI for adult patients with Ph-negative ALL treated with alloHCT.

Competition between polymers for adsorption on silica: a solvent relaxation NMR and small-angle neutron scattering study.

The competition between poly(vinylpyrrolidone) and poly(ethylene oxide) for adsorption at the silica surface was studied by solvent relaxation nuclear magnetic resonance and small-angle neutron scattering. The additive nature of the NMR relaxation rate enhancement was used to observe changes in the train layer when the two polymers were in direct competition for an increasing weight percentage of silica. PVP is shown to displace preadsorbed PEO from the particle surface, and this was observed for a range of PVP molecular weights. SANS measurements were found to give detailed information on the adsorption of the polymers in the separate systems; however, only qualitative information on the adsorption of the polymers could be obtained from the mixed samples. At a total polymer concentration of 0.4% w/v with 1.1% w/v silica, the SANS data were consistent with PVP adsorbing at the surface and dPEO remaining in solution, in agreement with the NMR data.

Colloidal particles in competition for stabilizer: a solvent relaxation NMR study of polymer adsorption and desorption.

The competitive adsorption of poly(vinylpyrrolidone) onto silica and alumina-modified silica particles was studied using solvent relaxation nuclear magnetic resonance. The additive nature of the measured relaxation rate enabled predictions to be made of the relaxation rate in different polymer adsorption scenarios. Preferential adsorption of the poly(vinylpyrrolidone) onto the unmodified silica particles occurred when there was insufficient polymer in the system to coat the entire available surface area. Desorption was also found to occur when the polymer was initially adsorbed upon the alumina-modified particle and silica particles were added.

Solution and Solid-State Behavior of Amphiphilic ABA Triblock Copolymers of Poly(acrylic acid-stat-styrene)-block-poly(butyl acrylate)-block-poly(acrylic acid-stat-styrene).

A combination of statistical and triblock copolymer properties is explored to produce stable aqueous polymer dispersions suitable for the film formation. In order to perform an extensive structural characterization of the products in the dissolved, dispersed, and solid states, a wide range of symmetrical poly(acrylic acid-stat-styrene) x -block-poly(butyl acrylate) y -block-poly(acrylic acid-stat-styrene) x , poly(AA-st-St) x -b-PBA y -b-poly(AA-st-St) x , (x = 56, 108 and 140, y = 100-750; the AA:St molar ratio is 42:58) triblock copolymers were synthesized by reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) solution polymerization using a bifunctional symmetrical RAFT agent. It is demonstrated that the amphiphilic statistical outer blocks can provide sufficient stabilization to largely hydrophobic particles in aqueous dispersions. Such a molecular design provides an advantage over copolymers composed only of homoblocks, as a simple variation of the statistical block component ratio provides an efficient way to control the hydrophilicity of the stabilizer block, which ultimately affects the copolymer morphology in solutions and solid films. It was found by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) that the copolymers behaved as dissolved chains in methylethylketone (MEK) but self-assembled in water into stable and well-defined spherical particles that increased in size with the length of the hydrophobic PBA block. These particles possessed an additional particulate surface structure formed by the statistical copolymer stabilizer block, which self-folded through the hydrophobic interactions between the styrene units. SAXS and atomic force microscopy showed that the copolymer films cast from the MEK solutions formed structures predicted by self-consistent field theory for symmetrical triblock copolymers, while the aqueous dispersions formed structural morphologies similar to a close-packed spheres, as would be expected for copolymer particles trapped kinetically due to the restricted movement of the blocks in the initial aqueous dispersion. A strong correlation between the structural morphology and mechanical properties of the films was observed. It was found that the properties of the solvent cast films were highly dependent on the ratios of the hard [poly(AA-st-St)] and soft (PBA) blocks, while the aqueous cast films did not show such a dependence. The continuous phase of hard blocks, always formed in the case of the aqueous cast films, produced films with a higher elastic modulus and a lower extension-to-break in a comparison with the solvent-cast films.

Time-resolved small-angle X-ray scattering studies of polymer-silica nanocomposite particles: initial formation and subsequent silica redistribution.

Small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) is a powerful characterization technique for the analysis of polymer-silica nanocomposite particles due to their relatively narrow particle size distributions and high electron density contrast between the polymer core and the silica shell. Time-resolved SAXS is used to follow the kinetics of both nanocomposite particle formation (via silica nanoparticle adsorption onto sterically stabilized poly(2-vinylpyridine) (P2VP) latex in dilute aqueous solution) and also the spontaneous redistribution of silica that occurs when such P2VP-silica nanocomposite particles are challenged by the addition of sterically stabilized P2VP latex. Silica adsorption is complete within a few seconds at 20 °C and the rate of adsorption strongly dependent on the extent of silica surface coverage. Similar very short time scales for silica redistribution are consistent with facile silica exchange occurring as a result of rapid interparticle collisions due to Brownian motion; this interpretation is consistent with a zeroth-order Smoluchowski-type calculation.

Resolving the film-formation dilemma with infrared radiation-assisted sintering.

The film formation of an acrylate latex with a glass-transition temperature of 38 °C has been achieved through the use of near-infrared (NIR) radiative heating. A hard, crack-free coating was obtained without the addition of plasticizers. Sintering of acrylate particles was confirmed through measurements using atomic force microscopy. The addition of an NIR-absorbing polymer increased the rate of particle deformation such that it was significantly greater than obtained in a convection oven at 60 °C. The results are consistent with a lower polymer viscosity under infrared radiation, according to a simple analysis using a standard model of sintering.

Control of Particle Size in the Self-Assembly of Amphiphilic Statistical Copolymers.

A range of amphiphilic statistical copolymers is synthesized where the hydrophilic component is either methacrylic acid (MAA) or 2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate (DMAEMA) and the hydrophobic component comprises methyl, ethyl, butyl, hexyl, or 2-ethylhexyl methacrylate, which provide a broad range of partition coefficients (log P). Small-angle X-ray scattering studies confirm that these amphiphilic copolymers self-assemble to form well-defined spherical nanoparticles in an aqueous solution, with more hydrophobic copolymers forming larger nanoparticles. Varying the nature of the alkyl substituent also influenced self-assembly with more hydrophobic comonomers producing larger nanoparticles at a given copolymer composition. A model based on particle surface charge density (PSC model) is used to describe the relationship between copolymer composition and nanoparticle size. This model assumes that the hydrophilic monomer is preferentially located at the particle surface and provides a good fit to all of the experimental data. More specifically, a linear relationship is observed between the surface area fraction covered by the hydrophilic comonomer required to achieve stabilization and the log P value for the hydrophobic comonomer. Contrast variation small-angle neutron scattering is used to study the internal structure of these nanoparticles. This technique indicates partial phase separation within the nanoparticles, with about half of the available hydrophilic comonomer repeat units being located at the surface and hydrophobic comonomer-rich cores. This information enables a refined PSC model to be developed, which indicates the same relationship between the surface area fraction of the hydrophilic comonomer and the log P of the hydrophobic comonomer repeat units for the anionic (MAA) and cationic (DMAEMA) comonomer systems. This study demonstrates how nanoparticle size can be readily controlled and predicted using relatively ill-defined statistical copolymers, making such systems a viable attractive alternative to diblock copolymer nanoparticles for a range of industrial applications.

Unexpected facile redistribution of adsorbed silica nanoparticles between latexes.

Addition of excess sterically stabilized P2VP latex to a colloidal dispersion of P2VP-silica nanocomposite particles (with silica shells at full monolayer coverage) leads to the facile redistribution of the silica nanoparticles such that partial coverage of all the P2VP latex particles is achieved. This silica exchange, which is complete within 1 h at 20 degrees C as judged by small-angle x-ray scattering, is observed for nanocomposite particles prepared by heteroflocculation, but not for nanocomposite particles prepared by in situ copolymerization. These observations are expected to have important implications for the optimization of nanocomposite formulations in the coatings industry.

Cracking of drying latex films: an ESEM experiment.

In this study environmental scanning electron microscopy was used to observe the cracking of drying latex films below their glass-transition temperature. By controlling the relative humidity so that it decreases linearly with time, a critical level of humidity at which cracking occurs can be determined and this is measured as a function of film thickness. It was found that the cracking humidity decreases with increases in film thickness for thicknesses in the range of 30 to 100 mum and then remains almost unchanged. A scaling argument can be used to fit the data very well and indicates that cracking occurs as soon as the entire film is consolidated into close packing.

When does silica exchange occur between vinyl polymer-silica nanocomposite particles and sterically stabilized latexes?

The redistribution of silica nanoparticles between "core-shell" polymer-silica nanocomposites and sterically stabilized latexes is investigated using a combination of electron microscopy, disk centrifuge photosedimentometry (DCP), and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Facile exchange of silica nanoparticles occurs on addition of sterically-stabilized polystyrene (or poly(2-vinylpyridine)) latex to polystyrene-silica (or poly(2-vinylpyridine)-silica) nanocomposite particles previously prepared by heteroflocculation. In contrast, no silica exchange occurs after such a latex "challenge" if similar polymer/silica nanocomposite particles are prepared via in situ polymerization. Silica redistribution can be confirmed by post mortem electron microscopy studies, which are facilitated if the original nanocomposite and latex particles differ sufficiently in their mean diameters. Ideally, XPS requires a unique elemental marker for the nanocomposite particle cores, which become progressively more exposed if silica exchange occurs. DCP is a particularly convenient in situ technique for assessing whether or not silica exchange has occurred. If no silica exchange occurs, there is little or no change in the nanocomposite and latex size distributions. On the other hand, silica redistribution always results in a larger mean particle diameter for the (partially) silica-coated latex particles relative to the original bare latex. In addition, incipient flocculation is typically observed after silica exchange. Like electron microscopy, DCP studies are aided if there is a significant difference in particle diameter between the original polymer-silica nanocomposite particles and the added latex. Moreover, silica redistribution can be prevented for heteroflocculated polymer-silica nanocomposite particles under certain conditions. For example, although silica exchange is observed at pH 10 when adding sterically-stabilized polystyrene (or poly(2-vinylpyridine)) latex to heteroflocculated poly(2-vinylpyridine)-silica particles, it does not occur at pH 5. Presumably, this is due to greater electrostatic attraction between the cationic P2VP cores and the anionic silica nanoparticles at this lower pH.

Probing the mechanism of the PCl5-initiated living cationic polymerization of the phosphoranimine Cl3P=NSiMe3 using model compound chemistry.

New insight into the mechanism of the ambient temperature PCl5-initiated living cationic chain growth polycondensation of the N-silylphosphoranimine Cl3P=NSiMe3 (1) to give poly(dichlorophosphazene), [N=PCl2]n, has been provided by studies of model compound chemistry. Investigations of the reactivity of Cl- salts of the proposed cationic intermediates [Cl3P=N=PCl3]+ ([2]+) and [Cl3P=N-PCl2=N=PCl3]+ ([6]+) toward Ph3P=NSiMe3 (3a) provided evidence that under the usual polymerization conditions that involve a high monomer to initiator ratio, propagation occurs at both chain ends. However, analogous studies of near stoichiometric processes suggested that propagation is faster at one chain end, particularly when the chains are short. In addition, experiments involving [Ph3P=N=PPh3][PCl6] ([9][PCl6]) and the N-silylphosphoranimines R3P=NSiMe3 3a (R = Ph) and 3b (R = p-CF3C6H4), showed that the [PCl6]- anion, which is formed in the early stages of the polymerization and has hitherto been assumed to be an innocent spectator counteranion, is actually reactive under the reaction conditions and can initiate oligomerization and polymerization. Finally, the absence of reactions between phosphoranimines 3b or 1 with the Cl- salts of the cations [Ph3P=N-PCl2=N=PPh3]+ ([10a]+), [Ph3P=N-(PCl2=N)2=PPh3]+ ([5]+), and [Ph3P=N-(PCl2=N)3=PPh3]+ ([8]+) with P-Cl bonds located internally but not at the chain ends have shown that chain branching reactions are unlikely to be significant during the polymerization. These results identify key factors that complicate the living PCl5-initiated chain growth polycondensation of 1 and potentially lead to a loss of control over molecular weight and broaden the molecular weight distributions, but also indicate that the polymer formed is essentially linear rather than branched.