Split tolerance induced by the intrathymic adoptive transfer of thymocyte stem cells.

The intrathymic transfer of semiallogeneic CD4/CD8 double-negative (DN) thymocyte stem cells into irradiated host mice resulted in a transient state of chimerism in adoptive host thymus, spleen, and lymph nodes. Host-derived T cells, isolated from the thymus and periphery of the chimeric mice, were found to be specifically nonresponsive to the MHC antigens of the semiallogeneic DN donor in cytotoxicity assays. This nonresponsiveness was not permanent, but persisted as long as appreciable numbers of Thy-1 alloantigen-positive progeny of the DN donor cells could be detected in the spleen and lymph nodes of adoptive host mice. FACS sorting of DN donor cells before intrathymic transfer indicated that nonresponsiveness could be induced by Thy-1+ cells and was therefore not attributable to contaminating thymic macrophages, dendritic cells, or B cells. When FACS-sorted Thy-1+ (bm5 x bm12)F1 DN cells were transferred intrathymically into C57BL/6 hosts, nonresponsiveness to DN donor MHC class I but not class II alloantigen (split tolerance) was observed. These experiments were repeated using FACS-sorted Thy-1+ DN donor cells that were semiallogeneic to the irradiated adoptive host at either MHC class I or class II locus with similar results. Limiting dilution analysis showed that host-derived CTL precursors were tolerant of DN donor MHC class I alloantigen and no evidence for the involvement of suppressor T cells was found. The data indicate that murine thymocytes themselves are capable of tolerizing to MHC class I but not class II alloantigen after intrathymic transfer. The implications for intrathymic T cell differentiation and maintenance of self tolerance are discussed.

Thymocyte subpopulations during early fetal development in the BALB/c mouse.

Phenotypic analysis of thymocytes during murine fetal development may be of use in determining the pathways of thymocyte differentiation. The expression of the functionally significant molecules Lyt-2 (CD8), L3T4 (CD4), and the TCR has already been described. However, mAb specific for several other murine lymphocyte surface markers are now available and, although these have been used to characterize adult thymocytes, a detailed analysis of fetal thymocytes with these antibodies has not previously been undertaken. In this study, we have used mAb specific for Thy-1, J11d, Pgp-1, and the IL-2R, in addition to those for Lyt-2 and L3T4, to identify subpopulations of early fetal thymocytes. By using two-color flow cytometric analysis of cells obtained from fetal thymuses on sequential days of gestation, we have been able to follow the development of various subpopulations through early fetal ontogeny. Our data indicate that the earlier thymocytes are found in the J11d+/Pgp-1+ subset which is abundant at fetal day 14 but constitute a numerical minority by day 16.

Transient expression of IL-2 receptor precedes the differentiation of immature thymocytes.

The growth of mature T lymphocytes after activation by antigen is regulated by the binding and endocytosis of interleukin-2 (IL-2). In the thymus, approximately 50% of adult thymocytes that carry neither the CD4 nor the CD8 antigen and day 14-15 fetal CD4-8- thymocytes express receptors for IL-2(IL-2R). The CD4-8- (double-negative) subpopulation of thymocytes contains the precursors of cells that can differentiate along an unknown pathway into thymocytes bearing either CD8 or CD4, with the characteristics of mature T lymphocytes. The basis for IL-2R expression by double-negative thymocytes is unclear as they appear to lack a functional T-cell receptor/CD3 complex through which activation of peripheral T cells is mediated. The argument for a role for IL-2 in thymocyte differentiation has also been complicated by conflicting reports on the inability or capability of double-negative thymocytes to respond to IL-2 in vitro. At present, both the nature of the stimuli within the thymic micro-environment which induce IL-2R expression and its relevance to thymocyte differentiation are not known. We show here that the IL-2R-bearing subset has a greater potential to differentiate into phenotypically mature T lymphocytes than do IL-2R-negative thymocytes. In addition, progeny of IL-2R-negative donor cells transiently express IL-2R in the thymuses of adoptive hosts before generating CD8 and/or CD4-positive thymocytes. These results identify the IL-2R-positive cells as a more differentiated double-negative thymocyte subset on the pathway to mature T lymphocytes.

Expression of T cell antigen receptor beta-chains on subsets of mouse thymocytes. Analysis by three-color flow cytometry.

The expression on adult mouse thymocytes of a T cell antigen receptor beta-chain epitope, recognized by the antibody F23.1, has been studied by three-color flow cytometry. Low density F23.1 staining was found mainly on CD4+8+ thymocytes. High density staining was mainly on CD4+8- and CD4-8+ cells. Variable proportions of CD4-8- cells were also F23.1+. Among CD4-8+ cells, F23.1 was expressed only on the J11d- subset with mature T cell function. We conclude that many subpopulations of thymocytes express antigen receptors and are candidates for the population subject to thymic selection, but at present no single subpopulation makes a convincing claim.

Characterization of the gamma-interferon-mediated induction of antigen-presenting ability in P388D1 cells.

We characterized an assay system to study the lymphokine-mediated induction of antigen-presenting ability in P388D1 cells. The ability of lymphokine-induced P388D1 macrophages to present antigen plus Id was measured by their ability to induce interleukin 2 production by antigen-specific, Id-restricted T cell hybridomas in the presence of the appropriate antigen. The production of IL 2 by the T cell hybridomas is known to be dependent on the expression of Ia antigens by the antigen-presenting cells. The results obtained suggest that a factor present in the supernatant of the T cell hybridoma FS7-20.6.18 is responsible for inducing the appearance of I-Ad and I-Ed on P388D1, measured by immunofluorescence, and the ability of the cell to present antigen in association with I-Ad or I-Ed. The factor mediating the induction of antigen-presenting ability is thought to be gamma-interferon, because the hybridoma FS7-20.6.18 is known to produce this lymphokine and the factor is sensitive to pH 2 incubation. gamma-Interferon produced by recombinant DNA technology was found to induce antigen-presenting ability in this assay; however, alpha- and beta-interferon were inactive. This observation suggests a unique immunoregulatory role for gamma-interferon. Using many T cell hybridomas in the assay, we were able to distinguish three groups: a) high avidity hybridomas that respond to antigen presented by uninduced P388D1 but show an enhanced response to antigen plus induced P388D1; b) medium avidity hybridomas that do not respond to antigen presented by uninduced P388D1; and c) low avidity hybridomas that show a limited response to antigen presented by induced P388D1, but the response of which increases if the P388D1 cells are induced for longer periods of time. These different patterns of response are believed to be dependent on the Ia antigen density expressed by the gamma-interferon-induced presenting cells, and suggest that the T cell receptors for Ag/Id display marked heterogeneity in their avidities for Ag/Id.

Differentiation potential of subsets of CD4-8- thymocytes.

Precursor T cells in the thymus are contained within a subpopulation of thymocytes that lack the markers CD4 and CD8. We have examined the heterogeneity of these cells by flow cytometric analysis, and defined four subpopulations using the cell surface markers Thy-1, J11d and the IL-2 receptor (IL-2R). The J11d+ subset of CD4-8- cells all bear the antigen Thy-1, and some express the IL-2R. Staining and RNA analysis of J11d+ cells suggest that some express receptors of the CD3 gamma delta type, but none express CD3 alpha beta receptors. In fetal thymus organ culture, the J11d+ cells diversify to form 'cortical type' CD4+8+ cells and 'medullary type' cells expressing either CD4 or CD8; in vivo they repopulate the thymus of an irradiated host and seed the periphery with T cells. In contrast, the J11d- subset of CD4-8- thymocytes do not all bear Thy-1 and none express the IL-2R, but some express antigen receptors of the CD3 alpha beta type. They have more limited diversification potential in organ culture, and in vivo fail to recolonize the irradiated host in a homing-independent assay. We conclude that they are not precursor T cells, but rather a side-branch from the main line of T cell differentiation.