A primer on standards setting as it applies to surgical education and credentialing.

BACKGROUND: Surgical technological advances in the past three decades have led to dramatic reductions in the morbidity associated with abdominal procedures and permanently altered the surgical practice landscape. Significant changes continue apace including surgical robotics, natural orifice-based surgery, and single-incision approaches. These disruptive technologies have on occasion been injurious to patients, and high-stakes assessment before adoption of new technologies would be reasonable. METHODS: We reviewed the drivers for well-established psychometric techniques available for the standards-setting process. RESULTS: We present a series of examples that are relevant in the surgical domain including standards setting for knowledge and skills assessments. CONCLUSIONS: Defensible standards for knowledge and procedural skills will likely become part of surgical clinical practice. Understanding the methodology for determining standards should position the surgical community to assist in the process and lead within their clinical settings as standards are considered that may affect patient safety and physician credentialing.

Normokinetic biliary dyskinesia: a novel diagnosis.

BACKGROUND: Biliary dyskinesia diagnosed with CCK-HIDA scan and ejection fraction less than 35 % has been successfully treated by laparoscopic cholecystectomy. However, a population of patients with symptomatic biliary pain and a normal CCK-HIDA scan never receive a diagnosis, and thus no definitive treatment. Some of these patients report a reproducible pain during their CCK-HIDA scan. It is hypothesized that these patients have a novel diagnosis, normokinetic biliary dyskinesia, and may have resolution of pain when treated with cholecystectomy. METHODS: A retrospective chart review was completed looking for patients with biliary pain in accordance with the ROME III criteria. Additional inclusion criteria were (1) greater than age 18 years, (2) reproducible biliary symptoms during the CCK-HIDA scan, and (3) an ejection fraction greater than 35 %. Treatment modality was laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Descriptive statistics were preformed, and data were reported as mean ± standard deviation and range. RESULTS: Nineteen patients met the inclusion criteria for this study from August 2008 to July 2011. There were 15 women and 4 men with a mean age of 48.4 ± 13.0 years. The mean ejection fraction was 75.1 ± 19.4 %. The average duration of preoperative symptoms was 6.8 ± 5.9 months and postoperative follow-up was 21.8 ± 10.6 months. Seventeen patients had complete resolution of symptoms, one had partial resolution, and one had no change. There was a complete resolution rate of 89.5 % and an improvement rate of 94.7 %. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest that patients who present with biliary pain, a normal CCK-HIDA scan with an ejection fraction greater than 35 %, and with reproducible symptoms on infusion of CCK could have a novel diagnosis: normokinetic biliary dyskinesia. Currently, these patients are excluded from the diagnosis of biliary dyskinesia and thus treatment. We hypothesize a potential new diagnosis, suggest cholecystectomy as treatment, and recommend a prospective study design for further evaluation.