Electronic prescribing systems as tools to improve patient care: a learning health systems approach to increase guideline concordant prescribing for venous thromboembolism prevention.

BACKGROUND: Venous thromboembolism (VTE) causes significant mortality and morbidity in hospitalised patients. Risk factors for VTE are well known and there are validated risk assessment tools to support the use of prophylactic therapies. In England, reporting the percentage of patients with a completed VTE risk assessment is mandated, but this does not include whether that risk assessment resulted in appropriate prescribing. Full guideline compliance, defined as an assessment which led to an appropriate action-here prescribing prophylactic low molecular weight heparin where indicated, is rarely reported. Education, audit and feedback enhance guideline compliance but electronic prescribing systems (EPS) can mandate guideline-compliant actions. We hypothesised that a systems-based EPS intervention (prescribing rules which mandate approval or rejection of a proposed prescription of prophylactic low molecular weight heparin based on the mandated VTE assessment) would increase full VTE guideline compliance more than interventions which focused on targeting individual prescribers. METHODS: All admitted patients within University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust were included for analysis between 2011 and 2020. The proportion of patients who received a fully compliant risk assessment and action was assessed over time. Interventions included teaching sessions and face-to-face feedback based on measured performance (an approach targeting individual prescribers) and mandatory risk assessment and prescribing rules into an EPS (a systems approach). RESULTS: Data from all 235,005 admissions and all 5503 prescribers were included in the analysis. Risk assessments were completed in > 90-95% of all patients at all times, but full guideline compliance was lower (70% at the start of this study). Face-to-face feedback improved full VTE guideline compliance from 70 to 77% (p ≤ 0.001). Changes to the EPS to mandate assessment with prescribing rules increased full VTE compliance to 95% (p ≤ 0.001). Further amendments to the EPS system to reduce erroneous VTE assessments slightly reduced full compliance to 92% (p < 0.001), but this was then maintained including during changes to the low molecular weight heparin used for VTE prophylaxis. DISCUSSION: An EPS-systems approach was more effective in improving sustained guideline-compliant VTE prevention over time. Non-compliance remained at 8-5% despite this mandated system. Further research is needed to assess the potential reasons for this.

Variation in lung cancer resources and workload: results from the first national lung cancer organisational audit.

We report the findings of the first national lung cancer organisational audit. The results demonstrate marked variation in service provision and workload of some lung cancer specialists. For example, over half of the clinical nurse specialists report case volumes over recommended numbers. Some trusts have no access to key treatments such as video assisted thoracoscopy (VAT) lobectomy and stereotactic radiotherapy. Multivariate regression analysis demonstrated an association between higher surgical resection rates and the on-site availability of advanced staging and therapeutic modalities, for example, PET scan and VAT lobectomy. We conclude by making a number of recommendations to address the variation in lung cancer care.

A multicentre randomised controlled trial of reciprocal lung cancer peer review and supported quality improvement: results from the improving lung cancer outcomes project.

BACKGROUND: Results from the National Lung Cancer Audit demonstrate unexplained variation in outcomes. Peer review with supported quality improvement has been shown to reduce variation in other areas of health care but has not been formally tested in cancer multidisciplinary teams. The aim of the current study is to assess the impact of reciprocal peer-to-peer review visits with supported quality improvement and collaborative working on lung cancer process and outcome measures. METHODS: English lung cancer teams were randomised to usual care or facilitated reciprocal peer review visits followed by 12 months of supported quality improvement. The primary outcome was change in the following national audit indicators; mulitdisciplinary team discussion, histological confirmation, active treatment, surgical resection, small-cell chemotherapy and specialist nurse review. Patient experience was measured using a new lung cancer patient questionnaire in the intervention group. RESULTS: Thirty teams (31 trusts) entered the intervention group and 29 of these submitted a total of 67 quality improvement plans. Active treatment increased in the intervention group (n=31) by 5.2% compared with 1.2% in the control group (n=48, mean difference 4.1%, 95% CI -0.1 to 8.2%, P=0.055). The remaining audit indicators improved similarly in all groups. Mean patient experience scores in the intervention group did not change significantly during the study but a significant improvement was seen in the scores for the five teams with the worst baseline scores (0.86 to 0.22, P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Reciprocal peer review with supported quality improvement was feasible and effective in stimulating quality improvement activity but resulted in only modest improvements in lung cancer treatment rates and patient experience.

Exploring variations in lung cancer care across the UK--the 'story so far' for the National Lung Cancer Audit.

The National Lung Cancer Audit was developed to improve the quality and outcomes of services for patients with lung cancer, knowing that outcomes vary widely across the UK and are poor compared to other western countries. After five years the audit is capturing approximately 100% of the expected number of incident cases across hospitals in England, Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Jersey. Measures of process and outcome have improved over the audit period, such as the histological confirmation rate (64-76%), the proportion of patients discussed in a multidisciplinary team meeting (78-94%), and the proportion of patients having anti-cancer treatment (43-59%), surgical resection (9-14%) and small cell lung cancer chemotherapy (58-66%). These national averages hide wide variations between hospitals providing lung cancer care which cannot be accounted for by differences in casemix. This paper describes the evolution of the audit, and describes the ways in which it may have improved clinical practice.

Stage III Non-small Cell Lung Cancer Management in England.

AIMS: We present the first analysis of the management and outcomes of stage III non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) conducted in England using National Lung Cancer Audit data. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patients diagnosed with stage III NSCLC in 2016 were identified. Linked datasets (including Hospital Episode Statistics, the National Radiotherapy Dataset, the Systemic Anti-Cancer Dataset, pathology reports and death certificate data) were used to categorise the treatment received. Kaplan-Meier survival curves were obtained, with survival defined from the date of diagnosis to the date of death. RESULTS: In total, 6276 cases of stage III NSCLC were analysed: 3827 stage IIIA and 2449 stage IIIB; 1047 (17%) patients were treated with radical radiotherapy with 676 (11%) of these also receiving chemotherapy. Twenty per cent of patients with stage IIIA disease underwent surgery, with half of these also receiving chemotherapy, predominantly delivered in the adjuvant setting. Of note, 2148 (34%) patients received palliative-intent treatment and 2265 (36%) received no active anti-cancer treatment. The 1-year survival was 32.9% (37.4% for stage IIIA), with the highest survival seen for those patients receiving chemotherapy and surgery. CONCLUSIONS: We highlight important gaps in the optimal care of patients with stage III NSCLC in England. Multimodality treatment with either surgery or radical radiotherapy combined with chemotherapy was delivered to less than one-fifth of patients, even though these regimens are considered optimal. Timely access to specialist resources and staff, the practice of effective shared decision making and challenging preconceptions have the potential to optimise management.

Demographics, management and survival of patients with malignant pleural mesothelioma in the National Lung Cancer Audit in England and Wales.

INTRODUCTION AND METHODS: Malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) is an uncommon cancer with poor survival. We have used data collected for the UK National Lung Cancer Audit to assess current practice and to highlight regional variation in the management of mesothelioma patients, as well as to describe survival patterns in subgroups. RESULTS: Our data on 8740 cases seen in hospitals in England and Wales is the largest cohort of MPM in the literature and represents approximately 80% of the total incident cases. 83% are male and median age is 73 years. Performance status is recorded in 81% and of these approximately 70% are PS 0-2. Stage is poorly recorded and unreliable in this dataset. The patient pathway is similar to lung cancer with approximately one-fifth having a non-elective referral to secondary care. A histo-cytological diagnosis is made in 87% and varies across organisations. Only 67% have anti-cancer treatment, and this also varies across organisations, but there has been an annual increase in the proportion receiving chemotherapy. Overall median survival was 9.5 months, with a 1YS of 41.4% and 3YS of 12.0%, but was strongly linked to performance status and histological subtype. Median survival also varied by cancer network from 209 days to 349 days, but appeared to increase from of 9.2 months in 2008 to 10.5 months in 2012. CONCLUSION: Our data provide a large scale, detailed assessment of MPM epidemiology, treatment choices and outcomes. Incidence is increasing in line with predictions and uptake of treatments has generally mirrored publication of key MPM treatment trials, in particular increasing use of chemotherapy but low uptake of radical surgery. However, there is significant variation in care patterns and outcomes that may reflect limited expertise in area with low incidence. Initiatives to improve outcomes should include improved recording of clinical stage.

Endothelial interactions of neutrophils under flow in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

It is generally accepted that the neutrophil is central to the pathogenesis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Enhanced endothelial interactions of this cell may contribute to the susceptibility of smokers who develop the disease; however, these interactions have not previously been studied in COPD. The aim of the current study was to determine whether enhanced endothelial interactions of neutrophils from smokers are a predisposing factor for the development of COPD. Endothelial interactions under flow and adhesion molecule expression of peripheral blood neutrophils were compared between seven never-smokers (NS), seven healthy smokers (HS), 11 COPD patients with severe alpha1-antitrypsin deficiency (PiZ) and neutrophils from 11 COPD patients without the deficiency (PiM). Total adhesive and migratory responses (per mm2 endothelium per 10(6) neutrophils) were significantly greater in the PiM group (mean+/-se 704.2+/-57.9 versus 509.3+/-48.8 in the PiZ group, 499.3+/-40.1 in the HS and 491.2+/-33.7 in the NS). This corresponded with increased macrophage antigen-1 (CD11b) expression on stimulated neutrophils in the PiM group compared with the PiZ group (mean+/-se relative fluorescence intensity 1.4+/-0.1 versus 1.1+/-0.1). In conclusion, the enhanced endothelial interaction of neutrophils from smokers who have developed chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in the presence of normal levels of alpha1-antitrypsin deficiency, but not in those with severe alpha(1)-antitrypsin deficiency, suggests that this is a predisposing factor for the development of the disease, and upregulation of macrophage antigen-1 may be responsible.

Effect of sputum processing with dithiothreitol on the detection of inflammatory mediators in chronic bronchitis and bronchiectasis.

BACKGROUND: Sputum analysis is used increasingly to assess airway inflammation in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, including those with chronic bronchitis and bronchiectasis. However, it is not known whether dithiothreitol (DTT), a reducing mucolytic agent regularly used to homogenise sputum, affects the detection of inflammatory mediators in the sputum soluble phase from such patients. METHODS: Thirty two spontaneous sputum samples were collected from 13 patients with chronic bronchitis and 17 with bronchiectasis. An aliquot from each sample was treated with either freshly prepared 0.1% DTT plus normal saline (NaCl) or NaCl alone, then ultracentrifuged to obtain the sputum sol phase. Interleukin (IL)-1beta, IL-6, IL-8, leukotriene B(4) (LTB(4)), secretory leukoprotease inhibitor (SLPI), alpha-1-antitrypsin (alpha(1)-AT), and tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNFalpha) were measured by ELISA, and neutrophil elastase (NE) and myeloperoxidase (MPO) by chromogenic substrate assay. The effect of DTT on the detection of assay standards was also determined. RESULTS: Median levels of IL-1beta, IL-6, IL-8, SLPI, and NE were similar in the DTT and NaCl treated samples. There was a significant reduction in median (IQR) levels of detectable TNFalpha (0.07 (0.00-0.47) pM v 0.90 (0.06-6.98) pM, p<0.001), LTB(4) (1.67 (1.31-2.64) nM v 2.29 (0.95-4.22) nM, p<0.05) and MPO (0.00 (0.00-0.00) mg/l v 4.48 (0.00-33.66) mg/l, p<0.001) and a small increase in the median alpha(1)-AT concentration (0.05 (0.03-0.08) nM v 0.03 (0.02-0.08) nM, p<0.01) in the DTT treated samples. DTT had no effect on the assay standards for IL-1beta, IL-8 or TNFalpha, but at higher concentrations it did affect IL-6, SLPI, NE, and LTB(4) standards (43%, 70%, 76% and 643% of control value for top standard, respectively) and at all concentrations DTT completely abolished MPO activity. CONCLUSIONS: Sputum processing with DTT significantly reduces the detectable concentration of TNFalpha, LTB(4) and MPO, and produces a small but significant increase in median alpha(1)-AT levels. To avoid this problem we recommend that an untreated aliquot of sputum be retained for cytokine analysis, unless the assay has been specifically validated.

Sputum chemotactic activity in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: effect of alpha(1)-antitrypsin deficiency and the role of leukotriene B(4) and interleukin 8.

BACKGROUND: Neutrophil recruitment to the airway is thought to be an important component of continuing inflammation and progression of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), particularly in the presence of severe alpha(1)-antitrypsin (alpha(1)-AT) deficiency. However, the chemoattractant nature of secretions from these patients has yet to be clarified. METHODS: The chemotactic activity of spontaneous sputum from patients with stable COPD, with (n=11) and without (n=11) alpha(1)-AT deficiency (PiZ), was assessed using the under-agarose assay. The contribution of leukotriene B(4) (LTB(4)) and interleukin 8 (IL-8) to the chemotactic activity was examined using an LTB(4) receptor antagonist (BIIL 315 ZW) and an IL-8 monoclonal antibody, respectively. RESULTS: Sputum neutrophil chemotactic activity (expressed as % n-formylmethionyl leucylphenylalanine (fMLP) control) was significantly higher in patients with alpha(1)-AT deficiency (mean (SE) 63.4 (8.9)% v 36.7 (5.5)%; mean difference 26.7% (95% CI 4.9 to 48.4), p<0.05). The mean (SE) contribution of both LTB(4) and IL-8 (expressed as % fMLP control) was also significantly higher in alpha(1)-AT deficient patients than in patients with COPD with normal levels of alpha(1)-AT (LTB(4): 31.9 (6.3)% v 18.0 (3.7)%; mean difference 13.9% (95% CI -1.4 to 29.1), p<0.05; IL-8: 24.1 (5.2)% v 8.1 (1.2)%; mean difference 15.9% (95% CI 4.7 to 27.2), p<0.05). When all the subjects were considered together the mean (SE) contribution of LTB(4) (expressed as % total chemotactic activity) was significantly higher than IL-8 (46.8 (3.5)% v 30.8 (4.6)%; mean difference 16.0% (95% CI 2.9 to 29.2), p<0.05). This difference was not significantly influenced by alpha(1)-AT phenotype (p=0.606). CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that the bronchial secretions of COPD patients with alpha(1)-AT deficiency have increased neutrophil chemotactic activity. This relates to the increased levels of IL-8 and, in particular LTB(4), which accounted most of the sputum chemotactic activity in the patients with COPD as a whole. Increased chemotactic activity, together with inhibitor deficiency, may contribute to the more rapid disease progression seen in alpha(1)-AT deficiency via increased neutrophil recruitment and release of neutrophil elastase.

Symptom resolution assessed using a patient directed diary card during treatment of acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis.

BACKGROUND: Acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis are common and the presenting symptoms vary, although it is not clear how this should influence management. From a health care perspective, an understanding of the speed of symptom resolution is of importance to determine the success of treatment or when a change is indicated because of treatment failure. METHODS: The response of 63 patients treated at home for exacerbations of chronic bronchitis was assessed using a patient directed diary card incorporating sputum characteristics and symptoms. Treatment was given according to the nature of the sputum at presentation; patients with purulent sputum received an antibiotic for 5 or 10 days (randomised, double blind) whereas patients with mucoid sputum received high dose inhaled steroid or placebo for 14 days (randomised, double blind). RESULTS: The mean (SE) total diary card score at presentation was significantly higher in the purulent group than in the mucoid group (19.7 (0.9) v 16.3 (0.9); mean difference -3.4 (95% CI -6.1 to -0.7), p<0.05). In the purulent group sputum colour and volume improved rapidly and in both groups the mean (SE) total diary card score had improved by the fifth day of treatment to 13.0 (0.7) in the purulent group (mean difference -6.6 (95% CI -8.8 to -4.4), p<0.001) and 14.6 (0.8) in the mucoid group (mean difference -1.7 (95% CI -4.0 to 0.8), p<0.05), which was no longer significantly different from the stable state. Diary card scores did not differ significantly between patients who received antibiotics for 5 or 10 days in the purulent group or between patients who received inhaled fluticasone or placebo in the mucoid group. CONCLUSIONS: Exacerbations of chronic bronchitis associated with purulent sputum have significantly worse symptoms at presentation than those with mucoid sputum. In both groups these symptoms resolve rapidly so that by the fifth day of treatment they are no different from the stable state. No significant effect was found on symptom resolution of antibiotic duration (5 v 10 days) in the purulent group or of inhaled fluticasone in the mucoid group, which resolved without antibiotics. Larger numbers may be required to demonstrate a statistically (if not clinically) significant difference.