Controlling excited-state dynamics via protonation of naphthalene-based azo dyes.

Azo dyes are a class of photoactive dyes that constitute a major focus of chemical research due to their applications in numerous industrial functions. This work explores the impact of protonation on the photophysics of four naphthalene-based azo dyes. The pKa value of the dyes increases proportionally with decreasing Hammett parameter of p-phenyl substituents from 8.1 (R = -H, σ = 0) to 10.6 (R = -NMe2, σ = -0.83) in acetonitrile. Protonation of the dyes shuts down the steady-state photoisomerization observed in the unprotonated moieties. Fluorescence measurements reveal a lower quantum yield with more electron-donating p-phenyl substituents, with overall lower fluorescence quantum yields than the unprotonated dyes. Transient absorption spectroscopy reveals four excited-state lifetimes (<1 ps, ∼3 ps, ∼13 ps, and ∼200 ps) exhibiting faster excited-state dynamics than observed in the unprotonated forms (for 1-3: 0.7-1.5 ps, ∼3-4 ps, 20-40 ps, 20-300 min; for 4: 0.7 ps, 4.8 ps, 17.8 ps, 40 ps, 8 min). Time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) elucidates the reason for the loss of isomerization in the protonated dyes, revealing a significant change in the lowest excited state potential energy nature and landscape upon protonation. Protonation impedes relaxation along the typical rotational and inversion isomerization axes, locking the dyes into a trans-configuration that rapidly decays back to the ground state.

Acid Violet 3: A Base-Activated Water-Soluble Photoswitch.

Acidic azo dyes are widely used for their vibrant colors. However, if their photophysics were better understood and controllable, they could be integrated into many more applications such as photosensing, photomedicine, and nonlinear optics. Here, the proton-controlled photophysics of a widely used acid, hydrazo dye, acid violet 3 (AV3) is explored. Density functional theory is used to predict the ground- and excited-state potential energy surfaces, and the proposed photoisomerization mechanism is confirmed with spectroscopic experiments. The ground-state and first two excited-state surfaces of the three readily accessible protonation states, AV3-H, AV3, and AV3+H, are investigated along both the dihedral rotation and inversion coordinates. The deprotonated AV3-H undergoes photoisomerization with blue light (λex = 453 nm) through a dihedral rotation mechanism. Upon the formation of the cis-isomer, the reversion of AV3-H is predicted to occur through a mixed rotational and inversion mechanism. In contrast, AV3 and its protonated form, AV3+H, do not undergo photoisomerization because there is no driving force for either the rotation or inversion of the azo bond in the excited state. In addition, when the azo bond is acidic, the ground-state dihedral rotation reversion mechanism barrier is lower. The mechanistic insights gained here through the combination of theory and experiment provide a roadmap to control the reactivity of AV3 across 11 orders of magnitude of proton concentration, making them interesting candidates for a range of pharmaceuticals.

Ultra-fast excited-state dynamics of substituted trans-naphthalene azo moieties.

In this work we untangle the ultrafast deactivation of high-energy excited states in four naphthalene-based azo dyes. Through systematic photophysical and computational study, we observed a structure-property relationship in which increasing the electron donating strength of the substituent leads to longer lived excited states in these organic dyes and faster thermal reversion from the cis to trans configuration. In particular, azo dyes 1-3 containing less electron donating substituents show three distinct excited-state lifetimes of ∼0.7-1.5 ps, ∼3-4 ps, and 20-40 ps whereas the most electron donating dimethyl amino substituted azo 4 shows excited-state lifetimes of 0.7 ps, 4.8 ps, 17.8 ps and 40 ps. While bulk photoisomerization of all four moieties is rapid, the cis to trans reversion lifetimes vary by a factor of 30 with τreversion decreasing from 276 min to 8 min with increasing electron donating strength of the substituent. In order to rationalize this change in photophysical behavior, we explored the excited-state potential energy surfaces and spin-orbit coupling constants for azo 1-4 through density functional theory. The increase in excited-state lifetime for 4 can be attributed to geometric and electronic degrees of freedom of the lowest energy singlet excited-state potential energy surface.

Elucidation of complex triplet excited state dynamics in Pd(II) biladiene tetrapyrroles.

Pd(II) biladienes have been developed over the last five years as non-aromatic oligotetrapyrrole complexes that support a rich triplet photochemistry. In this work, we have undertaken the first detailed photophysical interrogation of three homologous Pd(II) biladienes bearing different combinations of methyl- and phenyl-substituents on the frameworks' sp3-hybridized meso-carbon (i.e., the 10-position of the biladiene framework). These experiments have revealed unexpected excited-state dynamics that are dependent on the wavelength of light used to excite the biladiene. More specifically, transient absorption spectroscopy revealed that higher-energy excitation (λexc ∼ 350-500 nm) led to an additional lifetime (i.e., an extra photophysical process) compared to experiments carried out following excitation into the lowest-energy excited states (λexc = 550 nm). Each Pd(II) biladiene complex displayed an intersystem crossing lifetime on the order of tens of ps and a triplet lifetime of ∼20 µs, regardless of the excitation wavelength. However, when higher-energy light is used to excite the complexes, a new lifetime on the order of hundreds of ps is observed. The origin of the 'extra' lifetime observed upon higher energy excitation was revealed using density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TDDFT). These efforts demonstrated that excitation into higher-energy metal-mixed-charge-transfer excited states with high spin-orbit coupling to higher energy metal-mixed-charge-transfer triplet states leads to the additional excitation deactivation pathway. The results of this work demonstrate that Pd(II) biladienes support a unique triplet photochemistry that may be exploited for development of new photochemical schemes and applications.

Synthesis, Electrochemistry, and Photophysics of Pd(II) Biladiene Complexes Bearing Varied Substituents at the sp3-Hybridized 10-Position.

A set of Pd(II) biladiene complexes bearing different combinations of methyl- and phenyl-substituents on the sp3-hybridized meso-carbon (the 10-position of the biladiene framework) was prepared and studied. In addition to a previously described Pd(II) biladiene complex bearing geminal dimethyl substituents a the 10-position (Pd[DMBil]), homologous Pd(II) biladienes bearing geminal methyl and phenyl substituents (Pd[MPBil1]) and geminal diphenyl groups(Pd[DPBil1]) were prepared and structurally characterized. Detailed electrochemical as well as steady-state and time-resolved spectroscopic experiments were undertaken to evaluate the influence of the substituents on the biladiene's tetrahedral meso-carbon. Although all three biladiene homologues are isostructural, Pd[MPBil1] and Pd[DPBil1] display more intense absorption profiles that shift slightly toward lower energies as geminal methyl groups are replaced by phenyl rings. All three biladiene homologues support a triplet photochemistry, and replacement of the geminal dimethyl substituents of Pd[DMBil1] (ΦΔ = 54%) with phenyl groups improves the ability of Pd[MPBil1] (ΦΔ = 76%) and Pd[DPBil1] (ΦΔ = 66%) to sensitize 1O2. Analysis of the excited-state dynamics of the Pd(II) biladienes by transient absorption spectroscopy shows that each complex supports a long-lived triplet excited-state (i.e., τ > 15 µs for each homologue) but that the ISC quantum yields (ΦT) varied as a function of biladiene substitution. The observed trend in ISC efficiency matches that for singlet oxygen sensitization quantum yields (ΦΔ) across the biladiene series considered in this work. The results of this study provide new insights to guide future development of biladiene based agents for PDT and other photochemical applications.

Role of Electrostatics in Influencing the Pathway by Which the Excited State of [Ru(bpy)3]2+ Is Deactivated by Ferrocene Derivatives.

Excited states of tris(2,2'-bipyridine)ruthenium(II), [Ru(bpy)3]2+, can be deactivated by a wide range of ferrocene derivatives. The pathway by which deactivation takes place, either energy transfer (EnT) or electron transfer (ET), depends on several factors inherent to each specific donor-acceptor (D···A) system. In this work, we provide mechanistic insight into bimolecular quenching between [Ru(bpy)3]2+* and several ferrocene (Fc) derivatives in a variety of solvents. By introducing various functional groups onto the cyclopentadienyl ring of ferrocene, the chemical properties of the organometallic complexes were altered by tuning the oxidation potentials and charge of the iron complexes, and the manner in which the [Ru(bpy)3]2+ excited state is quenched by each ferrocene complex in solvents of various dielectric constants, including anhydrous acetonitrile (ACN), dimethylformamide (DMF), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), and water (pH 10), was assessed. Through the use of transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy, the mechanism of [Ru(bpy)3]2+* quenching by each of five ferrocene derivatives (i.e., either EnT or ET) in the aforementioned solvents was evaluated. On the basis of these studies, electrostatic factors relating to the charge on the ferrocene moiety were found to influence the quenching pathway(s) for the [Ru(bpy)3]2+···Fc systems under interrogation. When the ferrocene moiety is positively charged, the [Ru(bpy)3]2+ excited state is quenched by EnT to Fc, while when the ferrocene moiety is neutral or negatively charged, the [Ru(bpy)3]2+ excited state is quenched via reductive ET.

Excited State Characterization of Carborane-Containing Poly(dihexyl fluorene)s.

Carborane-containing poly(dihexylfluorene)s experience drastic solvatochromism in both the solution and solid states, a characteristic that is advantageous for use in environmental and biological sensing applications. Understanding the intrinsic decay mechanisms that give rise to such sensitive emission properties is important for designing responsive sensors. The solution-state photophysical properties of homopolymer, poly(9,9-dihexyl(bisfluorenyl)carborane) (PFCY), and alternating copolymer, poly(9,9-dihexyl-2,7-fluorene- alt-9,9-dihexyl(bisfluorenyl)carborane) (PFCS), were deciphered using steady-state, electrochemical, spectroelectrochemical, and time-resolved spectroscopic methods. From these techniques, it was discovered that following excitation the conjugated fluorene local excited state (LES) donates an electron to the carborane molecule, forming an intramolecular charge transfer (ICT) state between a radical cation on the fluorene moiety and a radical anion on the carborane moiety. From the global analysis of transient absorption data, it was discovered that the rate of electron transfer from the fluorene to the carborane is heavily influenced by solvent polarity and is significantly faster in more polar solvents. Once formed, the ICT state can decay through radiative or nonradiative mechanisms and is more likely to undergo radiative decay in nonpolar solvents, due to an intramolecular restriction of the polar ICT state. This study elucidates the effects that polarity has on the excited-state formation and subsequent decay mechanisms of fluorene-carborane systems, conclusively explaining the solvatochromism and steady-state emission properties exhibited by this system.

Short Excited-State Lifetimes Enable Photo-Oxidatively Stable Rubrene Derivatives.

A series of rubrene derivatives were synthesized and the influence of the side group in enhancing photo-oxidative stability was evaluated. Photo-oxidation half-lives were determined via UV-vis absorption spectroscopy, which revealed thiophene containing derivatives to be the most stable species. The electron affinity of the compounds did not correlate with stability as previously reported in literature. Our work shows that shorter excited-state lifetimes result in increased photo-oxidative stability in these rubrene derivatives. These results confirm that faster relaxation kinetics out-compete the formation of reactive oxygen species that ultimately degrade linear oligoacenes. This report highlights the importance of using molecular design to tune excited-state lifetimes in order to generate more stable oligoacenes.

pH-Driven Mechanistic Switching from Electron Transfer to Energy Transfer between [Ru(bpy)3]2+ and Ferrocene Derivatives.

The metal-to-ligand charge transfer excited states of [Ru(bpy)3]2+ (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) may be deactivated via energy transfer or electron transfer with ferrocene derivatives in aqueous conditions. Stern-Volmer quenching analysis revealed that the rate constant for [Ru(bpy)3]2+ excited-state quenching depends on solution pH when a ferrocenyl-amidinium derivative (Fc-am) containing a proton-responsive functionality tethered to the ferrocene center was present. By contrast, the rate constant with which the [Ru(bpy)3]2+ excited state is quenched by an analogous ferrocene derivative (ferrocenyl-trimethylammonium, Fc-mam) that lacks a protonic group does not depend on pH. These results show that the presence (or absence) of a readily transferrable proton modulates quenching rate constants in bimolecular events involving [Ru(bpy)3]2+ and ferrocene. More surprisingly, transient absorption spectroscopy reveals that the mechanism by which the [Ru(bpy)3]2+ excited state is quenched by Fc-am appears to be modulated by solution proton availability, switching from energy transfer at low pH when Fc-am is protonated, to electron transfer at high pH when Fc-am is deprotonated. The mechanistic switching that is observed for this system cannot be aptly explained using a simple driving force dependence argument, suggesting that more subtle factors dictate the pathway by which the [Ru(bpy)3]2+ excited state is deactivated by ferrocene in aqueous solutions.

Photophysical and Electrochemical Characterization of BODIPY-Containing Dyads Comparing the Influence of an A-D-A versus D-A Motif on Excited-State Photophysics.

A complete photophysical characterization of organic molecules designed for use as molecular materials is critical in the design and construction of devices such as organic photovoltaics (OPV). The nature of a molecule's excited state will be altered in molecules employing the same chromophoric units but possessing different molecular architectures. For this reason, we examine the photophysical reactions of two BODIPY-based D-A and A-D-A molecules, where D is the donor and A is the acceptor. A BODIPY (4,4'-difluoro-4-bora-3a,4a-diaza-s-indacene) moiety serves as the A component and is connected through the meso position using a 3-hexylthiophene linker to a N-(2-ethylhexyl)dithieno[3,2-b:2',3'-d]pyrrole (DTP), which serves as the D component. An A-D-A motif is compared to its corresponding D-A dyad counterpart. We show a potential advantage to the A-D-A motif over the D-A motif in creating longer-lived excited states. Transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy is used to characterize the photophysical evolution of each molecule's excited state. Global analysis of TA data using singular value decomposition and target analysis is performed to identify decay-associated difference spectra (DADS). The DADS reveal the spectral features associated with charge-transfer excited states that evolve with different dynamics. A-D-A possess slightly longer excited-state lifetimes, 42 ps nonradiative decay, and 4.64 ns radiative decay compared to those of D-A, 24 ps nonradiative decay, and 3.95 ns radiative decay. A longer lived A-D-A component is observed with microsecond lifetimes, representing a small fraction of the total photophyscial product. Steady-state and time-resolved photoluminescence augment the insights from TA, while electrochemistry and spectroelectrochemistry are employed to identify the nature of the excited state. Density functional theory supports the observed electronic and electrochemical properties of the D-A and A-D-A molecules. These results form a complete picture of the electronic and photophysical properties of D-A and A-D-A and provide contextualization for structure-function relationships between molecules and OPV devices.

An Introduction to Processing, Fitting, and Interpreting Transient Absorption Data.

Transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy is a powerful time-resolved spectroscopic method used to track the evolution of excited-state processes through changes in the system's absorption spectrum. Early implementations of TA were confined to specialized laboratories, but the evolution of commercial turn-key systems has made the technique increasingly available to research groups across the world. Modern TA systems are capable of producing large datasets with high energetic and temporal resolution that are rich in photophysical information. However, processing, fitting, and interpreting TA spectra can be challenging due to the large number of excited-state features and instrumental artifacts. Many factors must be carefully considered when collecting, processing, and fitting TA data in order to reduce uncertainty over which model or set of fitting parameters best describes the data. The goal of data preparation and fitting is to reduce as many of these extraneous factors while preserving the data for analysis. In this method, beginners are provided with a protocol for processing and preparing TA data as well as a brief introduction to selected fitting procedures and models, specifically single wavelength fitting and global lifetime analysis. Commentary on a number of commonly encountered data preparation challenges and methods of addressing them is provided, followed by a discussion of the challenges and limitations of these simple fitting methods.

Lasing through a strongly-coupled mode by intra-cavity pumping.

We demonstrate room temperature lasing through the polaritonic mode of a J-aggregate microcavity in which losses from exciton-exciton annihilation and slow polariton relaxation typical of direct J-aggregate excitation are circumvented via intra-cavity pumping. The pumping scheme utilizes an organic dye layer (DCM) within the cavity with an emission band overlapping the entire lower J-aggregate polariton branch spectrum, hence forcing DCM lasing to occur through the strongly-coupled mode. This cavity architecture, which separates strong coupling and gain into two materials, presents a general and flexible design for polariton devices and allows for the use of a wide range of materials, organic and inorganic, to be integrated into the cavity.

Proton-controlled non-exponential photoluminescence in a pyridylamidine-substituted Re(I) complex.

Chemical intuition and well-known design principles can typically be used to create ligand environments in transition metal complexes to deliberately tune reactivity for desired applications. However, intelligent ligand design does not always result in the expected outcomes. Herein we report the synthesis and characterization of a tricarbonyl rhenium (2,2'-bipyridine) 4-pyridylamidine, Re(4-Pam), complex with unexpected photophysical properties. Photoluminescence kinetics of Re(4-Pam) undergoes non-exponential decay, which can be deconvolved into two emission lifetimes. However, upon protonation of the amidine functionality of the 4-pyridylamidine to form Re(4-PamH), a single exponential decay is observed. To understand and rationalize these experimental observations, density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) are employed. The symmetry or asymmetry of the protonated or deprotonated 4-pyridylamidine ligand, respectively, is the key factor in switching between one and two photoluminescence lifetimes. Specifically, rotation of the dihedral angle formed between the bipyridine and 4-Pam ligand leads to two rotamers of Re(4-Pam) with degenerate triplet- to ground-state transitions.

ZnS Ultrathin Interfacial Layers for Optimizing Carrier Management in Sb2S3-based Photovoltaics.

Antimony chalcogenides represent a family of materials of low toxicity and relative abundance, with a high potential for future sustainable solar energy conversion technology. However, solar cells based on antimony chalcogenides present open-circuit voltage losses that limit their efficiencies. These losses are attributed to several recombination mechanisms, with interfacial recombination being considered as one of the dominant processes. In this work, we exploit atomic layer deposition (ALD) to grow a series of ultrathin ZnS interfacial layers at the TiO2/Sb2S3 interface to mitigate interfacial recombination and to increase the carrier lifetime. ALD allows for very accurate control over the ZnS interlayer thickness on the ångström scale (0-1.5 nm) and to deposit highly pure Sb2S3. Our systematic study of the photovoltaic and optoelectronic properties of these devices by impedance spectroscopy and transient absorption concludes that the optimum ZnS interlayer thickness of 1.0 nm achieves the best balance between the beneficial effect of an increased recombination resistance at the interface and the deleterious barrier behavior of the wide-bandgap semiconductor ZnS. This optimization allows us to reach an overall power conversion efficiency of 5.09% in planar configuration.

Electrochemical proton-coupled electron transfer of an anthracene-based azo dye.

Herein, we report the thermodynamics, kinetics, and mechanism for electrochemical proton-coupled electron transfer involving the anthracene-based azo dye azo-OMe. The peak reduction potential of azo-OMe with organic acids spanning the pK a range of 2.6-23.51 shows a dependence upon the pK a of the acid when the acid pK a falls between 8 and 20 (in acetonitrile). A potential-pK a diagram is constructed and used to estimate the pK a of the azo-OMe species. Heterogeneous electron-transfer rate constants are obtained using rotating disk electrode voltammetry in combination with Koutecký-Levich and Tafel analysis. Electrochemical analysis shows that the reactions are diffusion limited and are kinetically controlled by the electron-transfer step. Kinetic isotope studies indicate a concerted proton, electron transfer event occurs in the pK a-dependent range when using trifluoroacetic acid.

Spin multiplicity effects in doublet versus singlet emission: the photophysical consequences of a single electron.

Ambient-stable fluorescent radicals have recently emerged as promising luminescent materials; however, tailoring their properties has been difficult due to the limited photophysical understanding of open-shell organic systems. Here we report the experimental and computational analysis of a redox pair of π-conjugated fluorescent molecules that differ by one electron. A π-dication (DC) and π-radical cation (RC) demonstrate different absorption spectra, but similar red emission (λ emiss,max = ∼630 nm), excitation maxima (λ exc,max = ∼530 nm), fluorescence lifetimes (1-10 ns), and even excited-state (non-emissive) lifetimes when measured by transient absorption spectroscopy. Despite their experimental similarities, time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) studies reveal that DC and RC emission mechanisms are distinct and rely on different electronic transitions. Excited-state reorganization occurs by hole relaxation in singlet DC, while doublet RC undergoes a Jahn-Teller distortion by bending its π-backbone in order to facilitate spin-pairing between singly occupied molecular orbitals. This relationship between the excited-state dynamics of RC and its π-backbone geometry illustrates a potential strategy for developing π-conjugated radicals with new emission properties. Additionally, by comparing TDDFT and CIS (configuration interaction singles) excitations, we show that unrestricted TDDFT accurately reproduces experimental absorption spectra and provides an opportunity to examine the relaxed excited-state properties of large open-shell molecules like RC.

Comparative PCET study of a donor-acceptor pair linked by ionized and nonionized asymmetric hydrogen-bonded interfaces.

A Zn(II) amidinium porphyrin is the excited-state electron donor (D) to a naphthalene diimide acceptor (A) appended with either a carboxylate or sulfonate functionality. The two-point hydrogen bond (...[H(+)]...) formed between the amidinium and carboxylate or sulfonate functionalities establishes a proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) pathway for charge transfer. The two D...[H(+)]...A assemblies differ only by the proton configuration within the hydrogen-bonding interface. Specifically, the amidinium ion transfers a proton to the carboxylate to form a nonionized amidine-carboxylic acid two-point hydrogen network, whereas the amidinium retains both protons when bound to the sulfonate functionality, forming an ionized amidinium-sulfonate two-point hydrogen bond network. These two interface configurations within the dyads thus allow for a direct comparison of the PCET kinetics for the same donor and acceptor juxtaposed by ionized and nonionized hydrogen-bonded interfaces. Analysis of the PCET kinetics ascertained from transient absorption and transient emission spectroscopy reveals that the ionized interface is more strongly impacted by the local solvent environment, thus establishing that the initial static configuration of the proton interface is a critical determinant in the kinetics of PCET.

Anthracene-based azo dyes for photo-induced proton-coupled electron transfer.

Herein, we report a new donor-acceptor system for photo-induced proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) that leverages an azo linkage as the proton-sensitive component and anthracene as a photo-trigger. Electrochemistry shows a change in the reduction potential with addition of acid. However, photochemistry is invariant to the absence or presence of acid. The anthracene and phenol/4-methoxyphenyl moieties of the azo dyes are highly conjugated, likely mitigating photo-induced charge transfer, despite sufficient driving force.

Adjusting Interfacial Chemistry and Electronic Properties of Photovoltaics Based on a Highly Pure Sb2S3 Absorber by Atomic Layer Deposition.

The combination of oxide and heavier chalcogenide layers in thin film photovoltaics suffers limitations associated with oxygen incorporation and sulfur deficiency in the chalcogenide layer or with a chemical incompatibility which results in dewetting issues and defect states at the interface. Here, we establish atomic layer deposition (ALD) as a tool to overcome these limitations. ALD allows one to obtain highly pure Sb2S3 light absorber layers, and we exploit this technique to generate an additional interfacial layer consisting of 1.5 nm ZnS. This ultrathin layer simultaneously resolves dewetting and passivates defect states at the interface. We demonstrate via transient absorption spectroscopy that interfacial electron recombination is one order of magnitude slower at the ZnS-engineered interface than hole recombination at the Sb2S3/P3HT interface. The comparison of solar cells with and without oxide incorporation in Sb2S3, with and without the ultrathin ZnS interlayer, and with systematically varied Sb2S3 thickness provides a complete picture of the physical processes at work in the devices.