Glu289 residue in the pore-forming motif of Vibrio cholerae cytolysin is important for efficient ß-barrel pore formation.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a potent membrane-damaging ß-barrel pore-forming toxin. Upon binding to the target membranes, VCC monomers first assemble into oligomeric prepore intermediates and subsequently transform into transmembrane ß-barrel pores. VCC harbors a designated pore-forming motif, which, during oligomeric pore formation, inserts into the membrane and generates a transmembrane ß-barrel scaffold. It remains an enigma how the molecular architecture of the pore-forming motif regulates the VCC pore-formation mechanism. Here, we show that a specific pore-forming motif residue, E289, plays crucial regulatory roles in the pore-formation mechanism of VCC. We find that the mutation of E289A drastically compromises pore-forming activity, without affecting the structural integrity and membrane-binding potential of the toxin monomers. Although our single-particle cryo-EM analysis reveals WT-like oligomeric ß-barrel pore formation by E289A-VCC in the membrane, we demonstrate that the mutant shows severely delayed kinetics in terms of pore-forming ability that can be rescued with elevated temperature conditions. We find that the pore-formation efficacy of E289A-VCC appears to be more profoundly dependent on temperature than that of the WT toxin. Our results suggest that the E289A mutation traps membrane-bound toxin molecules in the prepore-like intermediate state that is hindered from converting into the functional ß-barrel pores by a large energy barrier, thus highlighting the importance of this residue for the pore-formation mechanism of VCC.

Pore formation-independent cell death induced by a ß-barrel pore-forming toxin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a ß-barrel pore-forming toxin (ß-PFT). It exhibits potent hemolytic activity against erythrocytes that appears to be a direct outcome of its pore-forming functionality. However, VCC-mediated cell-killing mechanism is more complicated in the case of nucleated mammalian cells. It induces apoptosis in the target nucleated cells, mechanistic details of which are still unclear. Furthermore, it has never been explored whether the ability of VCC to trigger programmed cell death is stringently dependent on its pore-forming activity. Here, we show that VCC can evoke hallmark features of the caspase-dependent apoptotic cell death even in the absence of the pore-forming ability. Our study demonstrates that VCC mutants with abortive pore-forming hemolytic activity can trigger apoptotic cell death responses and cytotoxicity, similar to those elicited by the wild-type toxin. VCC as well as its pore formation-deficient mutants display prominent propensity to translocate to the target cell mitochondria and cause mitochondrial membrane damage. Therefore, our results for the first time reveal that VCC, despite being an archetypical ß-PFT, can kill target nucleated cells independent of its pore-forming functionality. These findings are intriguing for a ß-PFT, whose destination is generally expected to remain limited on the target cell membranes, and whose mode of action is commonly attributed to the membrane-damaging pore-forming ability. Taken together, our study provides critical new insights regarding distinct implications of the two important virulence functionalities of VCC for the V. cholerae pathogenesis process: hemolytic activity for iron acquisition and cytotoxicity for tissue damage by the bacteria.

Tyrosine in the hinge region of the pore-forming motif regulates oligomeric ß-barrel pore formation by Vibrio cholerae cytolysin.

ß-barrel pore-forming toxins perforate cell membranes by forming oligomeric ß-barrel pores. The most crucial step is the membrane-insertion of the pore-forming motifs that create the transmembrane ß-barrel scaffold. Molecular mechanism that regulates structural reorganization of these pore-forming motifs during ß-barrel pore-formation still remains elusive. Using Vibrio cholerae cytolysin as an archetypical example of the ß-barrel pore-forming toxin, we show that a key tyrosine residue (Y321) in the hinge region of the pore-forming motif plays crucial role in this process. Mutation of Y321 abrogates oligomerization of the membrane-bound toxin protomers, and blocks subsequent steps of pore-formation. Our study suggests that the presence of Y321 in the hinge region of the pore-forming motif is crucial for the toxin molecule to sense membrane-binding, and to trigger essential structural rearrangements required for the subsequent oligomerization and pore-formation process. Such a regulatory mechanism of pore-formation by V. cholerae cytolysin has not been documented earlier in the structurally related ß-barrel pore-forming toxins.

Piercing the lipid raft: the case of Vibrio cholerae cytolysin.

In a recent issue of Biochemical Journal, Kathuria et al. [Biochem. J. (2018) 475, 3039-3055] report that membrane binding of the pore-forming toxin Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is facilitated by the presence of cholesterol, and the presence of this sterol within the lipid bilayer is key for the formation of a functional pore. Yet, in the presence of accessory non-lipid components, VCC retains its membrane-binding capability likely through membrane lipid raft structures. In light of their results, the authors provide new insights into the roles of cholesterol and of membrane microstructures in the binding, the oligomeric assembly and the cytolytic pore formation of VCC which all take place following infection by V. cholerae.

Revisiting the role of cholesterol in regulating the pore-formation mechanism of Vibrio cholerae cytolysin, a membrane-damaging ß-barrel pore-forming toxin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a ß-barrel pore-forming toxin with potent membrane-damaging cell-killing activity. Previous studies employing the model membranes of lipid vesicles (liposomes) have shown that pore formation by VCC requires the presence of cholesterol in the liposome membranes. However, the exact role of cholesterol in the mode of action of VCC still remains unclear. Most importantly, implication of cholesterol, if any, in regulating the pore-formation mechanism of VCC in the biomembranes of eukaryotic cells remains unexplored. Here, we show that the presence of cholesterol promotes the interaction of VCC with the membrane lipid bilayer, when non-lipid-dependent interactions are absent. However, in the case of biomembranes of human erythrocytes, where accessory interactions are available, cholesterol appears to play a less critical role in the binding step. Nevertheless, in the absence of an optimal level of membrane cholesterol in the human erythrocytes, membrane-bound fraction of the toxin remains trapped in the form of abortive oligomeric assembly, devoid of functional pore-forming activity. Our study also shows that VCC exhibits a prominent propensity to associate with the cholesterol-rich membrane micro-domains of human erythrocytes. Interestingly, mutation of the cholesterol-binding ability of VCC does not block association with the cholesterol-rich membrane micro-domains on human erythrocytes. Based on these results, we propose that the specific cholesterol-binding ability of VCC does not appear to dictate its association with the cholesterol-rich micro-domains on human erythrocytes. Rather, targeting of VCC toward the membrane micro-domains of human erythrocytes possibly acts to facilitate the cholesterol-dependent pore-formation mechanism of the toxin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin: Multiple facets of the membrane interaction mechanism of a ß-barrel pore-forming toxin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a membrane-damaging protein toxin with potent cytolytic/cytotoxic activity against wide range of eukaryotic cells. VCC is a ß-barrel pore-forming toxin (ß-PFT), and it inflicts damage to the target cell membranes by forming transmembrane heptameric ß-barrel pores. To exert pore-forming activity, VCC must bind to the cell membranes in an efficient manner. Efficient interaction with the cell membranes is an essential pre-requisite to trigger subsequent structural/conformational and organizational changes in the toxin molecules leading toward formation of the transmembrane oligomeric ß-barrel pores. Based on the large numbers of studies investigating the mode of action of VCC, it is now evident that VCC is capable of using multiple distinct mechanisms to recognize and bind to the membrane components and cell surface molecules. In this review article, we present an overview of our current understanding regarding the membrane interaction mechanisms of VCC, and their functional implications for the pore-forming activity of the toxin. © 2018 IUBMB Life, 70(4):260-266, 2018.

Revisiting the oligomerization mechanism of Vibrio cholerae cytolysin, a beta-barrel pore-forming toxin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a membrane-damaging beta-barrel pore-forming toxin (beta-PFT). VCC causes permeabilization of the target membranes by forming transmembrane oligomeric beta-barrel pores. Oligomerization is a key step in the mode of action of any beta-PFT, including that of VCC. Earlier studies have identified some of the key residues in VCC that are directly involved in the generation of the inter-protomer contacts, thus playing critical roles in the oligomerization of the membrane-bound toxin. Analysis of the VCC oligomeric pore structure reveals a potential hydrogen-bond network that appears to connect the sidechain of an asparagine residue (Asn582; located within an inter-domain linker sequence) from one protomer to the backbone CO- and NH-groups of the neighbouring protomer, indirectly through water molecules at most of the inter-protomer interfaces. In the present study, we show that the mutation of Asn582Ala affects the oligomerization and the pore-forming activity of VCC in the membrane lipid bilayer of the synthetic lipid vesicles, while the replacement of Asn582Gln results into the restoration of the oligomeric pore-forming ability of the toxin. Using a number of truncated variants of VCC, having deletion in the C-terminal region of the toxin starting from the Asn582 residue or beyond, we also show that the presence of Asn582 is critically required for the oligomerization of the truncated form of the protein.

Trapping of Vibrio cholerae cytolysin in the membrane-bound monomeric state blocks membrane insertion and functional pore formation by the toxin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a potent membrane-damaging cytolytic toxin that belongs to the family of ß barrel pore-forming protein toxins. VCC induces lysis of its target eukaryotic cells by forming transmembrane oligomeric ß barrel pores. The mechanism of membrane pore formation by VCC follows the overall scheme of the archetypical ß barrel pore-forming protein toxin mode of action, in which the water-soluble monomeric form of the toxin first binds to the target cell membrane, then assembles into a prepore oligomeric intermediate, and finally converts into the functional transmembrane oligomeric ß barrel pore. However, there exists a vast knowledge gap in our understanding regarding the intricate details of the membrane pore formation process employed by VCC. In particular, the membrane oligomerization and membrane insertion steps of the process have only been described to a limited extent. In this study, we determined the key residues in VCC that are critical to trigger membrane oligomerization of the toxin. Alteration of such key residues traps the toxin in its membrane-bound monomeric state and abrogates subsequent oligomerization, membrane insertion, and functional transmembrane pore-formation events. The results obtained from our study also suggest that the membrane insertion of VCC depends critically on the oligomerization process and that it cannot be initiated in the membrane-bound monomeric form of the toxin. In sum, our study, for the first time, dissects membrane binding from the subsequent oligomerization and membrane insertion steps and, thus, defines the exact sequence of events in the membrane pore formation process by VCC.

Physicochemical constraints of elevated pH affect efficient membrane interaction and arrest an abortive membrane-bound oligomeric intermediate of the beta-barrel pore-forming toxin Vibrio cholerae cytolysin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a potent membrane-damaging cytotoxic protein. VCC causes permeabilization of the target cell membranes by forming transmembrane oligomeric beta-barrel pores. Membrane pore formation by VCC involves following key steps: (i) membrane binding, (ii) formation of a pre-pore oligomeric intermediate, (iii) membrane insertion of the pore-forming motifs, and (iv) formation of the functional transmembrane pore. Membrane binding, oligomerization, and subsequent pore-formation process of VCC appear to be facilitated by multiple regulatory mechanisms that are only partly understood. Here, we have explored the role(s) of the physicochemical constraints, specifically imposed by the elevated pH conditions, on the membrane pore-formation mechanism of VCC. Elevated pH abrogates efficient interaction of VCC with the target membranes, and blocks its pore-forming activity. Under the elevated pH conditions, membrane-bound fractions of VCC remain trapped in the form of abortive oligomeric species that fail to generate the functional transmembrane pores. Such an abortive oligomeric assembly appears to represent a distinct, more advanced intermediate state than the pre-pore state. The present study offers critical insights regarding the implications of the physicochemical constraints for regulating the efficient membrane interaction and pore formation by VCC.

Pre-pore oligomer formation by Vibrio cholerae cytolysin: insights from a truncated variant lacking the pore-forming pre-stem loop.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC), a ß-barrel pore-forming toxin (ß-PFT), induces killing of the target eukaryotic cells by forming heptameric transmembrane ß-barrel pores. Consistent with the ß-PFT mode of action, binding of the VCC toxin monomers with the target cell membrane triggers formation of pre-pore oligomeric intermediates, followed by membrane insertion of the ß-strands contributed by the pre-stem motif within the central cytolysin domain of each protomer. It has been shown previously that blocking of membrane insertion of the VCC pre-stem motif arrests conversion of the pre-pore state to the functional transmembrane pore. Consistent with the generalized ß-PFT mechanism, it therefore appears that the VCC pre-stem motif plays a critical role toward forming the structural scaffold of the transmembrane ß-barrel pore. It is, however, still not known whether the pre-stem motif plays any role in the membrane interaction process, and subsequent pre-pore structure formation by VCC. In this direction, we have constructed a recombinant variant of VCC deleting the pre-stem region, and have characterized the effect(s) of physical absence of the pre-stem motif on the distinct steps of the membrane pore-formation process. Our results show that the deletion of the pre-stem segment does not affect membrane binding and pre-pore oligomer formation by the toxin, but it critically abrogates the functional pore-forming activity of VCC. Present study extends our insights regarding the structure-function mechanism associated with the membrane pore formation by VCC, in the context of the ß-PFT mode of action.

Curcumin Inhibits Membrane-Damaging Pore-Forming Function of the ß-Barrel Pore-Forming Toxin Vibrio cholerae Cytolysin.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a ß-barrel pore-forming toxin (ß-PFT). Upon encountering the target cells, VCC forms heptameric ß-barrel pores and permeabilizes the cell membranes. Structure-function mechanisms of VCC have been extensively studied in the past. However, the existence of any natural inhibitor for VCC has not been reported yet. In the present study, we show that curcumin can compromise the membrane-damaging activity of VCC. Curcumin is known to modulate a wide variety of biological processes and functions. However, the application of curcumin in the physiological scenario often gets limited due to its extremely poor solubility in the aqueous environment. Interestingly, we find that VCC can associate with the insoluble fraction of curcumin in the aqueous medium and thus gets separated from the solution phase. This, in turn, reduces the availability of VCC to attack the target membranes and thus blocks the membrane-damaging action of the toxin. We also observe that the soluble aqueous extract of curcumin, generated by the heat treatment, compromises the pore-forming activity of VCC. Interestingly, in the presence of such soluble extract of curcumin, VCC binds to the target membranes and forms the oligomeric assembly. However, such oligomers appear to be non-functional, devoid of the pore-forming activity. The ability of curcumin to bind to VCC and neutralize its membrane-damaging activity suggests that curcumin has the potential to act as an inhibitor of this potent bacterial ß-PFT.

Signaling beyond Punching Holes: Modulation of Cellular Responses by Vibrio cholerae Cytolysin.

Pore-forming toxins (PFTs) are a distinct class of membrane-damaging cytolytic proteins that contribute significantly towards the virulence processes employed by various pathogenic bacteria. Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a prominent member of the beta-barrel PFT (beta-PFT) family. It is secreted by most of the pathogenic strains of the intestinal pathogen V. cholerae. Owing to its potent membrane-damaging cell-killing activity, VCC is believed to play critical roles in V. cholerae pathogenesis, particularly in those strains that lack the cholera toxin. Large numbers of studies have explored the mechanistic basis of the cell-killing activity of VCC. Consistent with the beta-PFT mode of action, VCC has been shown to act on the target cells by forming transmembrane oligomeric beta-barrel pores, thereby leading to permeabilization of the target cell membranes. Apart from the pore-formation-induced direct cell-killing action, VCC exhibits the potential to initiate a plethora of signal transduction pathways that may lead to apoptosis, or may act to enhance the cell survival/activation responses, depending on the type of target cells. In this review, we will present a concise view of our current understanding regarding the multiple aspects of these cellular responses, and their underlying signaling mechanisms, evoked by VCC.