Limitations in membrane protein structure determination by lipid nanodiscs.

Lipid nanodiscs are popular mimetics of biological membranes for determining membrane protein structures. However, a recent study revealed that the choice of nanodisc scaffold directly influenced the structure of an ion channel. This finding prompts us to be cautious and calls for improved membrane mimetics for structure determination.

Cryo-EM Structures and Regulation of Arabinofuranosyltransferase AftD from Mycobacteria.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis causes tuberculosis, a disease that kills over 1 million people each year. Its cell envelope is a common antibiotic target and has a unique structure due, in part, to two lipidated polysaccharides-arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan. Arabinofuranosyltransferase D (AftD) is an essential enzyme involved in assembling these glycolipids. We present the 2.9-Å resolution structure of M. abscessus AftD, determined by single-particle cryo-electron microscopy. AftD has a conserved GT-C glycosyltransferase fold and three carbohydrate-binding modules. Glycan array analysis shows that AftD binds complex arabinose glycans. Additionally, AftD is non-covalently complexed with an acyl carrier protein (ACP). 3.4- and 3.5-Å structures of a mutant with impaired ACP binding reveal a conformational change, suggesting that ACP may regulate AftD function. Mutagenesis experiments using a conditional knockout constructed in M. smegmatis confirm the essentiality of the putative active site and the ACP binding for AftD function.

The 3.5-Å CryoEM Structure of Nanodisc-Reconstituted Yeast Vacuolar ATPase Vo Proton Channel.

The molecular mechanism of transmembrane proton translocation in rotary motor ATPases is not fully understood. Here, we report the 3.5-Å resolution cryoEM structure of the lipid nanodisc-reconstituted Vo proton channel of the yeast vacuolar H+-ATPase, captured in a physiologically relevant, autoinhibited state. The resulting atomic model provides structural detail for the amino acids that constitute the proton pathway at the interface of the proteolipid ring and subunit a. Based on the structure and previous mutagenesis studies, we propose the chemical basis of transmembrane proton transport. Moreover, we discovered that the C terminus of the assembly factor Voa1 is an integral component of mature Vo. Voa1's C-terminal transmembrane α helix is bound inside the proteolipid ring, where it contributes to the stability of the complex. Our structure rationalizes possible mechanisms by which mutations in human Vo can result in disease phenotypes and may thus provide new avenues for therapeutic interventions.

Threonine phosphorylation regulates the molecular assembly and signaling of EGFR in cooperation with membrane lipids.

The cytoplasmic domain of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) plays roles as a kinase and a protein scaffold; however, the allocation of these two functions is not fully understood. Here, we analyzed the assembly of the transmembrane (TM)-juxtamembrane (JM) region of EGFR, one of the best studied members of RTKs, by combining single-pair fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) imaging and a nanodisc technique. The JM domain of EGFR contains a threonine residue (T654) that is phosphorylated after ligand association. We observed that the TM-JM peptides of EGFR form anionic lipid-induced dimers and cholesterol-induced oligomers. The two forms involve distinct molecular interactions, with a bias toward oligomer formation upon threonine phosphorylation. We further analyzed the functions and oligomerization of whole EGFR molecules, with or without a substitution of T654 to alanine, in living cells. The results suggested an autoregulatory mechanism in which T654 phosphorylation causes a switch of the major function of EGFR from kinase-activating dimers to scaffolding oligomers.

Phospholipid Type Regulates Protein Corona Composition and In Vivo Performance of Lipid Nanodiscs.

Over the years, there has been significant interest in PEGylated lipid-based nanocarriers within the drug delivery field. The inevitable interplay between the nanocarriers and plasma protein plays a pivotal role in their in vivo biological fate. Understanding the factors influencing lipid-based nanocarrier and protein corona interactions is of paramount importance in the design and clinical translation of these nanocarriers. Herein, discoid-shaped lipid nanodiscs (sNDs) composed of different phospholipids with varied lipid tails and head groups were fabricated. We investigated the impact of phospholipid components on the interaction between sNDs and serum proteins, particle stability, and biodistribution. The results showed that all of these lipid nanodiscs remained stable over a 15 day storage period, while their stability in the blood serum demonstrated significant differences. The sND composed of POPG exhibited the least stability due to its potent complement activation capability, resulting in rapid blood clearance. Furthermore, a negative correlation between the complement activation capability and serum stability was identified. Pharmacokinetic and biodistribution experiments indicated that phospholipid composition did not influence the capability of sNDs to evade the accelerated blood clearance phenomenon. Complement deposition on the sND was inversely associated with the area under the curve. Additionally, all lipid nanodiscs exhibited dominant adsorption of apolipoprotein. Remarkably, the POPC-based lipid nanodisc displayed a significantly higher deposition of apolipoprotein E, contributing to an obvious brain distribution, which provides a promising tool for brain-targeted drug delivery.

Cancer Cell Membrane Nanodiscs for Antitumor Vaccination.

Cell membrane-based nanovaccines have demonstrated attractive features due to their inherently multiantigenic nature and ability to be formulated with adjuvants. Here, we report on cellular nanodiscs fabricated from cancer cell membranes and incorporated with a lipid-based adjuvant for antitumor vaccination. The cellular nanodiscs, with their small size and discoidal shape, are readily taken up by antigen-presenting cells and drain efficiently to the lymph nodes. Due to its highly immunostimulatory properties, the nanodisc vaccine effectively stimulates the immune system and promotes tumor-specific immunity. Using a murine colorectal cancer model, strong control of tumor growth is achieved in both prophylactic and therapeutic settings, particularly in combination with checkpoint blockades. Considerable therapeutic efficacy is also observed in treating a weakly immunogenic metastatic melanoma model. This work presents a new paradigm for the design of multiantigenic nanovaccines that can effectively activate antitumor immune responses and may be applicable to a wide range of cancers.

Membrane-Driven Dimerization of the Peripheral Membrane Protein KRAS: Implications for Downstream Signaling.

Transient homo-dimerization of the RAS GTPase at the plasma membrane has been shown to promote the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling pathway essential for cell proliferation and oncogenesis. To date, numerous crystallographic studies have focused on the well-defined GTPase domains of RAS isoforms, which lack the disordered C-terminal membrane anchor, thus providing limited structural insight into membrane-bound RAS molecules. Recently, lipid-bilayer nanodisc platforms and paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) analyses have revealed several distinct structures of the membrane-anchored homodimers of KRAS, an isoform that is most frequently mutated in human cancers. The KRAS dimerization interface is highly plastic and altered by biologically relevant conditions, including oncogenic mutations, the nucleotide states of the protein, and the lipid composition. Notably, PRE-derived structures of KRAS homodimers on the membrane substantially differ in terms of the relative orientation of the protomers at an "α-α" dimer interface comprising two α4-α5 regions. This interface plasticity along with the altered orientations of KRAS on the membrane impact the accessibility of KRAS to downstream effectors and regulatory proteins. Further, nanodisc platforms used to drive KRAS dimerization can be used to screen potential anticancer drugs that target membrane-bound RAS dimers and probe their structural mechanism of action.

Conditional Cooperativity in RAS Assembly Pathways on Nanodiscs and Altered GTPase Cycling.

Self-assemblies (i.e., nanoclusters) of the RAS GTPase on the membrane act as scaffolds that activate downstream RAF kinases and drive MAPK signaling for cell proliferation and tumorigenesis. However, the mechanistic details of nanoclustering remain largely unknown. Here, size-tunable nanodisc platforms and paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) analyses revealed the structural basis of the cooperative assembly processes of fully processed KRAS, mutated in a quarter of human cancers. The cooperativity is modulated by the mutation and nucleotide states of KRAS and the lipid composition of the membrane. Notably, the oncogenic mutants assemble in nonsequential pathways with two mutually cooperative 'α/α' and 'α/ß' interfaces, while α/α dimerization of wild-type KRAS promotes the secondary α/ß interaction sequentially. Mutation-based interface engineering was used to selectively trap the oligomeric intermediates of KRAS and probe their favorable interface interactions. Transiently exposed interfaces were available for the assembly. Real-time NMR demonstrated that higher-order oligomers retain higher numbers of active GTP-bound protomers in KRAS GTPase cycling. These data provide a deeper understanding of the nanocluster-enhanced signaling in response to the environment. Furthermore, our methodology is applicable to assemblies of many other membrane GTPases and lipid nanoparticle-based formulations of stable protein oligomers with enhanced cooperativity.

A new algorithm for particle weighted subtraction to decrease signals from unwanted components in single particle analysis.

Single particle analysis (SPA) in cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is highly used to obtain the near-atomic structure of biological macromolecules. The current methods allow users to produce high-resolution maps from many samples. However, there are still challenging cases that require extra processing to obtain high resolution. This is the case when the macromolecule of the sample is composed of different components and we want to focus just on one of them. For example, if the macromolecule is composed of several flexible subunits and we are interested in a specific one, if it is embedded in a viral capsid environment, or if it has additional components to stabilize it, such as nanodiscs. The signal from these components, which in principle we are not interested in, can be removed from the particles using a projection subtraction method. Currently, there are two projection subtraction methods used in practice and both have some limitations. In fact, after evaluating their results, we consider that the problem is still open to new solutions, as they do not fully remove the signal of the components that are not of interest. Our aim is to develop a new and more precise projection subtraction method, improving the performance of state-of-the-art methods. We tested our algorithm with data from public databases and an in-house data set. In this work, we show that the performance of our algorithm improves the results obtained by others, including the localization of small ligands, such as drugs, whose binding location is unknown a priori.

Cryo-EM of the ATP11C flippase reconstituted in Nanodiscs shows a distended phospholipid bilayer inner membrane around transmembrane helix 2.

ATP11C is a member of the P4-ATPase flippase family that mediates translocation of phosphatidylserine (PtdSer) across the lipid bilayer. In order to characterize the structure and function of ATP11C in a model natural lipid environment, we revisited and optimized a quick procedure for reconstituting ATP11C into Nanodiscs using methyl-ß-cyclodextrin as a reagent for the detergent removal. ATP11C was efficiently reconstituted with the endogenous lipid, or the mixture of endogenous lipid and synthetic dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC)/dioleoylphosphatidylserine (DOPS), all of which retained the ATPase activity. We obtained 3.4 Å and 3.9 Å structures using single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) of AlF- and BeF-stabilized ATP11C transport intermediates, respectively, in a bilayer containing DOPS. We show that the latter exhibited a distended inner membrane around ATP11C transmembrane helix 2, possibly reflecting the perturbation needed for phospholipid release to the lipid bilayer. Our structures of ATP11C in the lipid membrane indicate that the membrane boundary varies upon conformational changes of the enzyme and is no longer flat around the protein, a change that likely contributes to phospholipid translocation across the membrane leaflets.

Reconstitution of purified membrane protein dimers in lipid nanodiscs with defined stoichiometry and orientation using a split GFP tether.

Many membrane proteins function as dimers or larger oligomers, including transporters, channels, certain signaling receptors, and adhesion molecules. In some cases, the interactions between individual proteins may be weak and/or dependent on specific lipids, such that detergent solubilization used for biochemical and structural studies disrupts functional oligomerization. Solubilized membrane protein oligomers can be captured in lipid nanodiscs, but this is an inefficient process that can produce stoichiometrically and topologically heterogeneous preparations. Here, we describe a technique to obtain purified homogeneous membrane protein dimers in nanodiscs using a split GFP (sGFP) tether. Complementary sGFP tags associate to tether the coexpressed dimers and control both stoichiometry and orientation within the nanodiscs, as assessed by quantitative Western blotting and negative-stain EM. The sGFP tether confers several advantages over other methods: it is highly stable in solution and in SDS-PAGE, which facilitates screening of dimer expression and purification by fluorescence, and also provides a dimer-specific purification handle for use with GFP nanobody-conjugated resin. We used this method to purify a Frizzled-4 homodimer and a Frizzled-4/low-density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 6 heterodimer in nanodiscs. These examples demonstrate the utility and flexibility of this method, which enables subsequent mechanistic molecular and structural studies of membrane protein pairs.

Revealing KRas4b topology on the membrane surface.

KRas4b is a membrane-bound regulatory protein belonging to the family of small GTPases that function as a molecular switch, facilitating signal transduction from activated membrane receptors to intracellular pathways controlling cell growth and proliferation. Oncogenic mutations locking KRas4b in the active GTP state are responsible for nearly 85% of all Ras-driven cancers. Understanding the membrane-bound state of KRas4b is crucial for designing new therapeutic approaches targeting oncogenic KRas-driven signaling pathways. Extensive research demonstrates the significant involvement of the membrane bilayer in Ras-effector interactions, with anionic lipids playing a critical role in determining protein conformations The preferred topology of KRas4b for interacting with signaling partners has been a long-time question. Computational studies suggest a membrane-proximal conformation, while other biophysical methods like neutron reflectivity propose a membrane-distal conformation. To address these gaps, we employed FRET measurements to investigate the conformation of KRas4b. Using fully post-translationally modified KRas4b, we designed a Nanodisc based FRET assay to study KRas4b-membrane interactions. We suggest an extended conformation of KRas4b relative to the membrane surface. Measurement of FRET donor - acceptor distances reveal that a negatively charged membrane surface weakly favors closer association with the membrane surface. Our findings provide insights into the role of anionic lipids in determining the dynamic conformations of KRas4b and shed light on the predominant conformation of its topology on lipid headgroups.

Platelet Membrane-Derived Nanodiscs for Neutralization of Endogenous Autoantibodies and Exogenous Virulence Factors.

The multifaceted functions of platelets in various physiological processes have long inspired the development of therapeutic nanoparticles that mimic specific platelet features for disease treatment. Here, the development and characterization of platelet membrane-derived nanodiscs (PLT-NDs) as platelet decoys for biological neutralization is reported. In one application, PLT-NDs effectively bind with anti-platelet autoantibodies, thus blocking them from interacting with platelets. In a mouse model of thrombocytopenia, PLT-NDs successfully neutralize pathological anti-platelet antibodies, preventing platelet depletion and maintaining hemostasis. In another application, PLT-NDs effectively neutralize the cytotoxicity of bacterial virulence factors secreted by methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). In a mouse model of MRSA infection, treatment with PLT-NDs leads to significant survival benefits for the infected mice. Additionally, PLT-NDs show good biocompatibility and biosafety, as demonstrated in acute toxicity studies conducted in mice. These findings underscore the potential of PLT-NDs as a promising platelet mimicry for neutralizing various biological agents that target platelets. Overall, this work expands the repertoire of platelet-mimicking nanomedicine by creating a unique disc-like nanostructure made of natural platelet membranes.

Isolation of recombinant apolipoprotein E4 N-terminal domain by foam fractionation.

Apolipoprotein (apo) E functions in lipoprotein metabolism as a low density lipoprotein receptor ligand. ApoE is comprised of two structural domains, a 22 kDa N-terminal (NT) domain that adopts a helix bundle conformation and a 10 kDa C-terminal domain with strong lipid binding affinity. The NT domain is capable of transforming aqueous phospholipid dispersions into discoidal reconstituted high density lipoprotein (rHDL) particles. Given the utility of apoE-NT as a structural component of rHDL, expression studies were conducted. A plasmid construct encoding a pelB leader sequence fused to the N-terminus of human apoE4 (residues 1-183) was transformed into Escherichia coli. Upon expression, the fusion protein is directed to the periplasmic space where leader peptidase cleaves the pelB sequence, generating mature apoE4-NT. In shaker flask expression cultures, apoE4-NT escapes the bacteria and accumulates in the medium. In a bioreactor setting, however, apoE4-NT was found to combine with gas and liquid components in the culture medium to generate large quantities of foam. When this foam was collected in an external vessel and collapsed into a liquid foamate, analysis revealed that apoE4-NT was the sole major protein present. The product protein was further isolated by heparin affinity chromatography (60-80 mg/liter bacterial culture), shown to be active in rHDL formulation, and documented to serve as an acceptor of effluxed cellular cholesterol. Thus, foam fractionation provides a streamlined process to produce recombinant apoE4-NT for biotechnology applications.

Structure and regulation of the BsYetJ calcium channel in lipid nanodiscs.

BsYetJ is a bacterial homolog of transmembrane BAX inhibitor-1 motif-containing 6 (TMBIM6) membrane protein that plays a key role in the control of calcium homeostasis. However, the BsYetJ (or TMBIM6) structure embedded in a lipid bilayer is uncharacterized, let alone the molecular mechanism of the calcium transport activity. Herein, we report structures of BsYetJ in lipid nanodiscs identified by double electron-electron resonance spectroscopy. Our results reveal that BsYetJ in lipid nanodiscs is structurally different from those crystallized in detergents. We show that BsYetJ conformation is pH-sensitive in apo state (lacking calcium), whereas in a calcium-containing solution it is stuck in an intermediate, inert to pH changes. Only when the transmembrane calcium gradient is established can the calcium-release activity of holo-BsYetJ occur and be mediated by pH-dependent conformational changes, suggesting a dual gating mechanism. Conformational substates involved in the process and a key residue D171 relevant to the gating of calcium are identified. Our study suggests that BsYetJ/TMBIM6 is a pH-dependent, voltage-gated calcium channel.

Employing NaChBac for cryo-EM analysis of toxin action on voltage-gated Na+ channels in nanodisc.

NaChBac, the first bacterial voltage-gated Na+ (Nav) channel to be characterized, has been the prokaryotic prototype for studying the structure-function relationship of Nav channels. Discovered nearly two decades ago, the structure of NaChBac has not been determined. Here we present the single particle electron cryomicroscopy (cryo-EM) analysis of NaChBac in both detergent micelles and nanodiscs. Under both conditions, the conformation of NaChBac is nearly identical to that of the potentially inactivated NavAb. Determining the structure of NaChBac in nanodiscs enabled us to examine gating modifier toxins (GMTs) of Nav channels in lipid bilayers. To study GMTs in mammalian Nav channels, we generated a chimera in which the extracellular fragment of the S3 and S4 segments in the second voltage-sensing domain from Nav1.7 replaced the corresponding sequence in NaChBac. Cryo-EM structures of the nanodisc-embedded chimera alone and in complex with HuwenToxin IV (HWTX-IV) were determined to 3.5 and 3.2 Å resolutions, respectively. Compared to the structure of HWTX-IV-bound human Nav1.7, which was obtained at an overall resolution of 3.2 Å, the local resolution of the toxin has been improved from ∼6 to ∼4 Å. This resolution enabled visualization of toxin docking. NaChBac can thus serve as a convenient surrogate for structural studies of the interactions between GMTs and Nav channels in a membrane environment.

Photosensitive Nanodiscs Composed of Human Photoreceptors for Refractive Index Modulation at Selective Wavelengths.

A photoreceptor on the retina acts as an optical waveguide to transfer an individual photonic signal to the cell inside, which is determined by the refractive index of internal materials. Under the photoactivation of photoreceptors making conformational and chemical variation in a visual cell, the optical signal modulation is demonstrated using an artificial photoreceptor-based waveguide with a controlling beam refraction. Two types of nanodiscs are made of human photoreceptor proteins, short-wavelength-sensitive opsin and rhodopsin, with spectral sensitivity. The refractive index and nonlinear features of those two photosensitive nanodiscs are investigated as fundamental properties. The photonanodiscs are photoactivated in such a way that allow refractive index tuning over 0.18 according to the biological function of the respective proteins with color-dependent response.

Facade-Based Bicelles as a New Tool for Production of Active Membrane Proteins in a Cell-Free System.

Integral membrane proteins are important components of a cell. Their structural and functional studies require production of milligram amounts of proteins, which nowadays is not a routine process. Cell-free protein synthesis is a prospective approach to resolve this task. However, there are few known membrane mimetics that can be used to synthesize active membrane proteins in high amounts. Here, we present the application of commercially available "Facade" detergents for the production of active rhodopsin. We show that the yield of active protein in lipid bicelles containing Facade-EM, Facade-TEM, and Facade-EPC is several times higher than in the case of conventional bicelles with CHAPS and DHPC and is comparable to the yield in the presence of lipid-protein nanodiscs. Moreover, the effects of the lipid-to-detergent ratio, concentration of detergent in the feeding mixture, and lipid composition of the bicelles on the total, soluble, and active protein yields are discussed. We show that Facade-based bicelles represent a prospective membrane mimetic, available for the production of membrane proteins in a cell-free system.

Synthesis of Erythrocyte Nanodiscs for Bacterial Toxin Neutralization.

Nanodiscs are a compelling nanomedicine platform due to their ultrasmall size and distinct disc shape. Current nanodisc formulations are made primarily with synthetic lipid bilayers and proteins. Here, we report a cellular nanodisc made with human red blood cell (RBC) membrane (denoted "RBC-ND") and show its effective neutralization against bacterial toxins. In vitro, RBC-ND neutralizes the hemolytic activity and cytotoxicity caused by purified α-toxin or complex whole secreted proteins (wSP) from methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus bacteria. In vivo, RBC-ND confers significant survival benefits for mice intoxicated with α-toxin or wSP in both therapeutic and prevention regimens. Moreover, RBC-ND shows good biocompatibility and biosafety in vivo. Overall, RBC-ND distinguishes itself by inheriting the biological functions of the source cell membrane for bioactivity. The design strategy of RBC-ND can be generalized to other types of cell membranes for broad applications.

Purification of active human vacuolar H+-ATPase in native lipid-containing nanodiscs.

Vacuolar H+-ATPases (V-ATPases) are large, multisubunit proton pumps that acidify the lumen of organelles in virtually every eukaryotic cell and in specialized acid-secreting animal cells, the enzyme pumps protons into the extracellular space. In higher organisms, most of the subunits are expressed as multiple isoforms, with some enriched in specific compartments or tissues and others expressed ubiquitously. In mammals, subunit a is expressed as four isoforms (a1-4) that target the enzyme to distinct biological membranes. Mutations in a isoforms are known to give rise to tissue-specific disease, and some a isoforms are upregulated and mislocalized to the plasma membrane in invasive cancers. However, isoform complexity and low abundance greatly complicate purification of active human V-ATPase, a prerequisite for developing isoform-specific therapeutics. Here, we report the purification of an active human V-ATPase in native lipid nanodiscs from a cell line stably expressing affinity-tagged a isoform 4 (a4). We find that exogenous expression of this single subunit in HEK293F cells permits assembly of a functional V-ATPase by incorporation of endogenous subunits. The ATPase activity of the preparation is >95% sensitive to concanamycin A, indicating that the lipid nanodisc-reconstituted enzyme is functionally coupled. Moreover, this strategy permits purification of the enzyme's isolated membrane subcomplex together with biosynthetic assembly factors coiled-coil domain-containing protein 115, transmembrane protein 199, and vacuolar H+-ATPase assembly integral membrane protein 21. Our work thus lays the groundwork for biochemical characterization of active human V-ATPase in an a subunit isoform-specific manner and establishes a platform for the study of the assembly and regulation of the human holoenzyme.