Molecular Machines that Facilitate Bacterial Outer Membrane Protein Biogenesis.

Almost all outer membrane proteins (OMPs) in Gram-negative bacteria contain a ß-barrel domain that spans the outer membrane (OM). To reach the OM, OMPs must be translocated across the inner membrane by the Sec machinery, transported across the crowded periplasmic space through the assistance of molecular chaperones, and finally assembled (folded and inserted into the OM) by the ß-barrel assembly machine. In this review, we discuss how considerable new insights into the contributions of these factors to OMP biogenesis have emerged in recent years through the development of novel experimental, computational, and predictive methods. In addition, we describe recent evidence that molecular machines that were thought to function independently might interact to form dynamic intermembrane supercomplexes. Finally, we discuss new results that suggest that OMPs are inserted primarily near the middle of the cell and packed into supramolecular structures (OMP islands) that are distributed throughout the OM.

Cryo-EM structures reveal multiple stages of bacterial outer membrane protein folding.

Transmembrane ß barrel proteins are folded into the outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative bacteria by the ß barrel assembly machinery (BAM) via a poorly understood process that occurs without known external energy sources. Here, we used single-particle cryo-EM to visualize the folding dynamics of a model ß barrel protein (EspP) by BAM. We found that BAM binds the highly conserved "ß signal" motif of EspP to correctly orient ß strands in the OM during folding. We also found that the folding of EspP proceeds via "hybrid-barrel" intermediates in which membrane integrated ß sheets are attached to the essential BAM subunit, BamA. The structures show an unprecedented deflection of the membrane surrounding the EspP intermediates and suggest that ß sheets progressively fold toward BamA to form a ß barrel. Along with in vivo experiments that tracked ß barrel folding while the OM tension was modified, our results support a model in which BAM harnesses OM elasticity to accelerate ß barrel folding.

Function of the Omp85 Superfamily of Outer Membrane Protein Assembly Factors and Polypeptide Transporters.

The Omp85 protein superfamily is found in the outer membrane (OM) of all gram-negative bacteria and eukaryotic organelles of bacterial origin. Members of the family catalyze both the membrane insertion of ß-barrel proteins and the translocation of proteins across the OM. Although the mechanism(s) by which these proteins function is unclear, striking new insights have emerged from recent biochemical and structural studies. In this review we discuss the entire Omp85 superfamily but focus on the function of the best-studied member, BamA, which is an essential and highly conserved component of the bacterial barrel assembly machinery (BAM). Because BamA has multiple functions that overlap with those of other Omp85 proteins, it is likely the prototypical member of the Omp85 superfamily. Furthermore, BamA has become a protein of great interest because of the recent discovery of small-molecule inhibitors that potentially represent an important new class of antibiotics.

The Escherichia coli outer membrane protein OmpA acquires secondary structure prior to its integration into the membrane.

Almost all proteins that reside in the outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative bacteria contain a membrane-spanning segment that folds into a unique ß barrel structure and inserts into the membrane by an unknown mechanism. To obtain further insight into outer membrane protein (OMP) biogenesis, we revisited the surprising observation reported over 20 years ago that the Escherichia coli OmpA ß barrel can be assembled into a native structure in vivo when it is expressed as two noncovalently linked fragments. Here, we show that disulfide bonds between ß strand 4 in the N-terminal fragment and ß strand 5 in the C-terminal fragment can form in the periplasmic space and greatly increase the efficiency of assembly of "split" OmpA, but only if the cysteine residues are engineered in perfect register (i.e., they are aligned in the fully folded ß barrel). In contrast, we observed only weak disulfide bonding between ß strand 1 in the N-terminal fragment and ß strand 8 in the C-terminal fragment that would form a closed or circularly permutated ß barrel. Our results not only demonstrate that ß barrels begin to fold into a ß-sheet-like structure before they are integrated into the OM but also help to discriminate among the different models of OMP biogenesis that have been proposed.

A clostripain-like protease plays a major role in generating the secretome of enterotoxigenic Bacteroides fragilis.

Bacteroides fragilis toxin (BFT) is a protein secreted by enterotoxigenic (ETBF) strains of B. fragilis. BFT is synthesized as a proprotein (proBFT) that is predicted to be a lipoprotein and that is cleaved into two discrete fragments by a clostripain-like protease called fragipain (Fpn). In this study, we obtained evidence that Fpn cleaves proBFT following its transport across the outer membrane. Remarkably, we also found that the disruption of the fpn gene led to a strong reduction in the level of >100 other proteins, many of which are predicted to be lipoproteins, in the culture medium of an ETBF strain. Experiments performed with purified Fpn provided direct evidence that the protease releases at least some of these proteins from the cell surface. The observation that wild-type cells outcompeted an fpn- strain in co-cultivation assays also supported the notion that Fpn plays an important role in cell physiology and is not simply dedicated to toxin biogenesis. Finally, we found that purified Fpn altered the adhesive properties of HT29 intestinal epithelial cells. Our results suggest that Fpn is a broad-spectrum protease that not only catalyzes the protein secretion on a wide scale but that also potentially cleaves host cell proteins during colonization.

Chaperone OsmY facilitates the biogenesis of a major family of autotransporters.

OsmY is a widely conserved but poorly understood 20 kDa periplasmic protein. Using a folding biosensor, we previously obtained evidence that OsmY has molecular chaperone activity. To discover natural OsmY substrates, we screened for proteins that are destabilized and thus present at lower steady-state levels in an osmY-null strain. The abundance of an outer membrane protein called antigen 43 was substantially decreased and its ß-barrel domain was undetectable in the outer membrane of an osmY-null strain. Antigen 43 is a member of the diffuse adherence family of autotransporters. Like strains that are defective in antigen 43 production, osmY-null mutants failed to undergo cellular autoaggregation. In vitro, OsmY assisted in the refolding of the antigen 43 ß-barrel domain and protected it from added protease. Finally, an osmY-null strain that expressed two members of the diffuse adherence family of autotransporters that are distantly related to antigen 43, EhaA and TibA, contained reduced levels of the proteins and failed to undergo cellular autoaggregation. Taken together, our results indicate that OsmY is involved in the biogenesis of a major subset of autotransporters, a group of proteins that play key roles in bacterial pathogenesis.

The Bam complex catalyzes efficient insertion of bacterial outer membrane proteins into membrane vesicles of variable lipid composition.

Most proteins that reside in the bacterial outer membrane (OM) have a distinctive "ß-barrel" architecture, but the assembly of these proteins is poorly understood. The spontaneous assembly of OM proteins (OMPs) into pure lipid vesicles has been studied extensively but often requires non-physiological conditions and time scales and is strongly influenced by properties of the lipid bilayer, including surface charge, thickness, and fluidity. Furthermore, the membrane insertion of OMPs in vivo is catalyzed by a heterooligomer called the ß-barrel assembly machinery (Bam) complex. To determine the role of lipids in the assembly of OMPs under more physiological conditions, we exploited an assay in which the Bam complex mediates their insertion into membrane vesicles. After reconstituting the Bam complex into vesicles that contain a variety of different synthetic lipids, we found that two model OMPs, EspP and OmpA, folded efficiently regardless of the lipid composition. Most notably, both proteins folded into membranes composed of a gel-phase lipid that mimics the rigid bacterial OM. Interestingly, we found that EspP, OmpA, and another model protein (OmpG) folded at significantly different rates and that an α-helix embedded inside the EspP ß-barrel accelerates folding. Our results show that the Bam complex largely overcomes effects that lipids exert on OMP assembly and suggest that specific interactions between the Bam complex and an OMP influence its rate of folding.

Identification of a novel post-insertion step in the assembly of a bacterial outer membrane protein.

Although the barrel assembly machinery (Bam) complex has been shown to facilitate the insertion of ß barrel proteins into the bacterial outer membrane (OM), the stage at which ß barrels fold is unknown. Here, we describe insights into ß barrel assembly that emerged from an analysis of a member of the autotransporter family of OM proteins (EspP) in Escherichia coli. EspP contains an extracellular 'passenger' domain that is translocated across the OM and then released from the covalently linked ß barrel domain in an intra-barrel cleavage reaction. We found that the mutation of an unusual lipid-exposed lysine residue impairs a previously unidentified late folding step that follows both the membrane insertion of the ß barrel domain and the secretion of the passenger domain but that precedes proteolytic maturation. Our results demonstrate that ß barrel assembly can be completed at a post-insertion stage and raise the possibility that interactions with membrane lipids can promote folding in vivo. Furthermore, by showing that the passenger domain is secreted before the ß barrel domain is fully assembled, our results also provide evidence against the long-standing hypothesis that autotransporters are autonomous protein secretion systems.

Selective pressure for rapid membrane integration constrains the sequence of bacterial outer membrane proteins.

Almost all bacterial outer membrane proteins (OMPs) contain a ß barrel domain that serves as a membrane anchor, but the assembly and quality control of these proteins are poorly understood. Here, we show that the introduction of a single lipid-facing arginine residue near the middle of the ß barrel of the Escherichia coli OMPs OmpLA and EspP creates an energy barrier that impedes membrane insertion. Although several unintegrated OmpLA mutants remained insertion-competent, they were slowly degraded by the periplasmic protease DegP. Two EspP mutants were also gradually degraded by DegP but were toxic because they first bound to the Bam complex, an essential heteroligomer that catalyzes the membrane insertion of OMPs. Interestingly, another EspP mutant likewise formed a prolonged, deleterious interaction with the Bam complex but was protected from degradation and eventually inserted into the membrane in a native conformation. The different types of interactions between the EspP mutants and the Bam complex that we observed may correspond to distinct stages in OMP assembly. Our results show that sequences that significantly delay assembly are disfavored not only because unintegrated OMPs are subjected to degradation, but also because OMPs that assemble slowly can form dominant-negative interactions with the Bam complex.

The plasticity of a translation arrest motif yields insights into nascent polypeptide recognition inside the ribosome tunnel.

The recognition of a C-terminal motif in E. coli SecM ((150)FXXXXWIXXXXGIRAGP(166)) inside the ribosome tunnel causes translation arrest, but the mechanism of recognition is unknown. Whereas single mutations in this motif impair recognition, we demonstrate that new arrest-inducing peptides can be created through remodeling of the SecM C terminus. We found that R163 is indispensable but that flanking residues that vary in number and position play an important secondary role in translation arrest. The observation that individual SecM variants showed a distinct pattern of crosslinking to ribosomal proteins suggests that each peptide adopts a unique conformation inside the tunnel. Based on the results, we propose that translation arrest occurs when the peptide conformation specified by flanking residues moves R163 into a precise intratunnel location. Our data indicate that translation arrest results from extensive communication between SecM and the tunnel and help to explain the striking diversity of arrest-inducing peptides found throughout nature.

Looks can be deceiving: recent insights into the mechanism of protein secretion by the autotransporter pathway.

Autotransporters are a large superfamily of cell surface proteins produced by Gram-negative bacteria that consist of an N-terminal extracellular domain ('passenger domain') and a C-terminal ß-barrel domain that resides in the outer membrane (OM). Although it was originally proposed that the passenger domain is translocated across the OM through a channel formed exclusively by the covalently linked ß-barrel domain, this idea has been strongly challenged by a variety of observations. Recent experimental results have suggested a new model in which both the translocation of the passenger domain and the membrane integration of the ß-barrel domain are facilitated by the Bam complex, a highly conserved heteroligomer that plays a general role in OM protein assembly. Other factors, including periplasmic chaperones and inner membrane proteins, have also recently been implicated in the biogenesis of at least some members of the autotransporter superfamily. New results have raised intriguing questions about the energetics of the secretion reaction and the relationship between the assembly of autotransporters and the assembly of other classes of OM proteins. Concomitantly, new mechanistic and structural insights have expanded the utility of the autotransporter pathway for the surface display of heterologous peptides and proteins of interest.

Of linkers and autochaperones: an unambiguous nomenclature to identify common and uncommon themes for autotransporter secretion.

Autotransporter (AT) proteins provide a diverse array of important virulence functions to Gram-negative bacterial pathogens, and have also been adapted for protein surface display applications. The 'autotransporter' moniker refers to early models that depicted these proteins facilitating their own translocation across the bacterial outer membrane. Although translocation is less autonomous than originally proposed, AT protein segments upstream of the C-terminal transmembrane ß-barrel have nevertheless consistently been found to contribute to efficient translocation and/or folding of the N-terminal virulence region (the 'passenger'). However, defining the precise secretion functions of these AT regions has been complicated by the use of multiple overlapping and ambiguous terms to define AT sequence, structural, and functional features, including 'autochaperone', 'linker' and 'junction'. Moreover, the precise definitions and boundaries of these features vary among ATs and even among research groups, leading to an overall murky picture of the contributions of specific features to translocation. Here we propose a unified, unambiguous nomenclature for AT structural, functional and conserved sequence features, based on explicit criteria. Applied to 16 well-studied AT proteins, this nomenclature reveals new commonalities for translocation but also highlights that the autochaperone function is less closely associated with a conserved sequence element than previously believed.

Charge-dependent secretion of an intrinsically disordered protein via the autotransporter pathway.

Autotransporters are a large class of virulence proteins produced by Gram-negative bacteria. They contain an N-terminal extracellular ("passenger") domain that folds into a ß-helical structure and a C-terminal ß-barrel ("ß") domain that anchors the protein to the outer membrane. Because the periplasm lacks ATP, the source of energy that drives passenger domain secretion is unknown. The prevailing model postulates that vectorial folding of the ß-helix in the extracellular space facilitates unidirectional secretion of the passenger domain. In this study we used a chimeric protein composed of the 675-residue receptor-binding domain (RD) of the Bordetella pertussis adenylate cyclase toxin CyaA fused to the C terminus of the Escherichia coli O157:H7 autotransporter EspP to test this hypothesis. The RD is a highly acidic, repetitive polypeptide that is intrinsically disordered in the absence of calcium. Surprisingly, we found that the RD moiety was efficiently secreted when it remained in an unfolded conformation. Furthermore, we found that neutralizing or reversing the charge of acidic amino acid clusters stalled translocation in the vicinity of the altered residues. These results challenge the vectorial folding model and, together with the finding that naturally occurring passenger domains are predominantly acidic, provide evidence that a net negative charge plays a significant role in driving the translocation reaction.

Mechanistic link between ß barrel assembly and the initiation of autotransporter secretion.

Autotransporters are bacterial virulence factors that contain an N-terminal extracellular ("passenger") domain and a C-terminal ß barrel ("ß") domain that anchors the protein to the outer membrane. The ß domain is required for passenger domain secretion, but its exact role in autotransporter biogenesis is unclear. Here we describe insights into the function of the ß domain that emerged from an analysis of mutations in the Escherichia coli O157:H7 autotransporter EspP. We found that the G1066A and G1081D mutations slightly distort the structure of the ß domain and delay the initiation of passenger domain translocation. Site-specific photocrosslinking experiments revealed that the mutations slow the insertion of the ß domain into the outer membrane, but do not delay the binding of the ß domain to the factor that mediates the insertion reaction (the Bam complex). Our results demonstrate that the ß domain does not simply target the passenger domain to the outer membrane, but promotes translocation when it reaches a specific stage of assembly. Furthermore, our results provide evidence that the Bam complex catalyzes the membrane integration of ß barrel proteins in a multistep process that can be perturbed by minor structural defects in client proteins.

Stepwise folding of an autotransporter passenger domain is not essential for its secretion.

Autotransporters are a superfamily of virulence proteins produced by Gram-negative bacteria. They consist of an N-terminal ß-helical domain ("passenger domain") that is secreted into the extracellular space and a C-terminal ß-barrel domain ("ß-domain") that anchors the protein to the outer membrane. Because the periplasm lacks ATP, vectorial folding of the passenger domain in a C-to-N-terminal direction has been proposed to drive the secretion reaction. Consistent with this hypothesis, mutations that disrupt the folding of the C terminus of the passenger domain of the Escherichia coli O157:H7 autotransporter EspP have been shown to cause strong secretion defects. Here, we show that point mutations introduced at specific locations near the middle or N terminus of the EspP ß-helix that perturb folding also impair secretion, but to a lesser degree. Surprisingly, we found that even multiple mutations that potentially abolish the stability of several consecutive rungs of the ß-helix only moderately reduce secretion efficiency. Although these results provide evidence that the free energy derived from passenger domain folding contributes to secretion efficiency, they also suggest that a significant fraction of the energy required for secretion is derived from another source.

Sequential and spatially restricted interactions of assembly factors with an autotransporter beta domain.

Autotransporters are bacterial virulence factors that consist of an N-terminal extracellular ("passenger") domain and a C-terminal ß barrel domain ("ß domain") that resides in the outer membrane. Here we used an in vivo site-specific photocrosslinking approach to gain insight into the mechanism by which the ß domain is integrated into the outer membrane and the relationship between ß domain assembly and passenger domain secretion. We found that periplasmic chaperones and specific components of the ß barrel assembly machinery (Bam) complex interact with the ß domain of the Escherichia coli O157:H7 autotransporter extracellular serine protease P (EspP) in a temporally and spatially regulated fashion. Although the chaperone Skp initially interacted with the entire ß domain, BamA, BamB, and BamD subsequently interacted with discrete ß domain regions. BamB and BamD remained bound to the ß domain longer than BamA and therefore appeared to function at a later stage of assembly. Interestingly, we obtained evidence that the completion of ß domain assembly is regulated by an intrinsic checkpoint mechanism that requires the completion of passenger domain secretion. In addition to leading to a detailed model of autotransporter biogenesis, our results suggest that the lipoprotein components of the Bam complex play a direct role in the membrane integration of ß barrel proteins.

The patatin-like protein PlpD forms structurally dynamic homodimers in the Pseudomonas aeruginosa outer membrane.

Members of the Omp85 superfamily of outer membrane proteins (OMPs) found in Gram-negative bacteria, mitochondria and chloroplasts are characterized by a distinctive 16-stranded ß-barrel transmembrane domain and at least one periplasmic POTRA domain. All previously studied Omp85 proteins promote critical OMP assembly and/or protein translocation reactions. Pseudomonas aeruginosa PlpD is the prototype of an Omp85 protein family that contains an N-terminal patatin-like (PL) domain that is thought to be translocated across the OM by a C-terminal ß-barrel domain. Challenging the current dogma, we find that the PlpD PL-domain resides exclusively in the periplasm and, unlike previously studied Omp85 proteins, PlpD forms a homodimer. Remarkably, the PL-domain contains a segment that exhibits unprecedented dynamicity by undergoing transient strand-swapping with the neighboring ß-barrel domain. Our results show that the Omp85 superfamily is more structurally diverse than currently believed and suggest that the Omp85 scaffold was utilized during evolution to generate novel functions.

Mutations in the Escherichia coli ribosomal protein L22 selectively suppress the expression of a secreted bacterial virulence factor.

Mutations in the ribosomal protein L22 that impair peptide-mediated translation arrest in Escherichia coli have been shown to reduce the expression of several genes, including secA, which encodes an ATPase that drives protein export via the Sec pathway. Here, we used a comparative proteomic approach to obtain insight into the global effects of the L22(Δ82-84) mutation on gene expression and protein synthesis. While the mutation did not affect or modestly affected the level of most soluble proteins, it dramatically reduced the level of antigen 43 (Ag43), a secreted virulence factor that promotes autoaggregation. The reduced protein concentration correlated with a sharp decrease in the abundance and stability of Ag43 mRNA. We found that the overexpression of secA or the inactivation of genes that encode presecretory and membrane proteins restored Ag43 production in the L22 mutant strain. Furthermore, impairment of the Sec pathway in a wild-type strain reduced Ag43 production but did not significantly affect the synthesis of other presecretory proteins. Taken together, these results indicate that Ag43 gene expression is exquisitely sensitive to the status of the Sec machinery and strongly suggest that the L22 mutation decreases the Ag43 concentration indirectly by reducing secA expression. Our results imply the existence of a novel regulatory mechanism in which the efficiency of protein export is coupled to gene expression and help to explain the modulation of SecA synthesis that has been observed in response to secretion stress.

Secretion of a bacterial virulence factor is driven by the folding of a C-terminal segment.

Autotransporters are bacterial virulence factors consisting of an N-terminal "passenger domain" that is secreted in a C- to-N-terminal direction and a C-terminal "ß domain" that resides in the outer membrane (OM). Although passenger domain secretion does not appear to use ATP, the energy source for this reaction is unknown. Here, we show that efficient secretion of the passenger domain of the Escherichia coli O157:H7 autotransporter EspP requires the stable folding of a C-terminal ≈17-kDa passenger domain segment. We found that mutations that perturb the folding of this segment do not affect its translocation across the OM but impair the secretion of the remainder of the passenger domain. Interestingly, an examination of kinetic folding mutants strongly suggested that the ≈17-kDa segment folds in the extracellular space. By mutagenizing the ≈17-kDa segment, we also fortuitously isolated a unique translocation intermediate. Analysis of this intermediate suggests that a heterooligomer that facilitates the membrane integration of OM proteins (the Bam complex) also promotes the surface exposure of the ≈17-kDa segment. Our results provide direct evidence that protein folding can drive translocation and help to clarify the mechanism of autotransporter secretion.