Assessing symptom improvement after elective prostatectomy for benign prostatic hypertrophy.

BACKGROUND: Elective surgery for benign prostatic hypertrophy requires estimates of likely improvement. METHODS: Data are from a prospective study of all patients without cancer who underwent transurethral prostatectomy. After eliminating patients for whom surgery was not elective, we examined symptom improvement. RESULTS: Surgery was effective in reducing symptoms for all but those with very mild preoperative symptoms. For the remainder, the average level of postoperative outcomes achieved was independent of the initial symptom severity. CONCLUSIONS: Elective prostatectomy is effectiveness for improving symptoms. The improvement is typically sustained, and for some symptoms improvement continues during the first year after surgery. Patients with severe symptoms were as likely to achieve the same level of postoperative improvement as were patients with less severe problems initially. However, patients with very mild symptoms benefited little or none from surgery.

Guns and suicide: possible effects of some specific legislation.

The authors describe suicide rates in Toronto and Ontario and methods used for suicide in Toronto for 5 years before and after enactment of Canadian gun control legislation in 1978. They also present data from San Diego, Calif., where state laws attempt to limit access to guns by certain psychiatric patients. Both sets of data indicate that gun control legislation may have led to decreased use of guns by suicidal men, but the difference was apparently offset by an increase in suicide by leaping. In the case of men using guns for suicide, these data support a hypothesis of substitution of suicide method.

A protocol-based treatment for intradialytic hypotension in hospitalized hemodialysis patients.

Human serum albumin is used in hemodialysis (HD) units as treatment for hypotension despite its high cost and undetermined efficacy. During a 4-month period in 1995, albumin was used in 22% of 1,296 consecutive HD treatments in the HD unit or intensive care units (ICUs) at our tertiary-care hospital. We evaluated the safety and efficacy of a protocol designed to minimize albumin use for treating HD-associated hypotension (HDAH). The protocol consisted of the stepwise use of saline, mannitol, and albumin for the purpose of achieving physician-determined ultrafiltration goals. Patients were exempted from receiving the protocol for age younger than 18 years, freshly declotted angioaccess, or cardiovascular instability. The protocol was evaluated prospectively in 2,559 consecutive dialysis sessions (15% in ICUs) in 442 patients. Hypotension occurred during 608 sessions (24%), and attending nephrologists elected to initiate the protocol in 71% of these cases. Of the 433 instances in which the protocol was begun, reversal of hypotension was achieved without the need for albumin in 91% and with the addition of albumin in an additional 2%. Protocol treatment was not completed because of nursing error in 1% or clotting of filter or angioaccess in 4%. Use of the protocol failed to reverse hypotension in only 2% of the cases in which it was completed. Albumin was administered in only 6% of the 2,559 HD treatments. In summary, our protocol-based approach to HDAH was effective, easy for nurses to use, albumin sparing, and cost reducing.

Research priorities in critical care medicine in the UK.

OBJECTIVES: To establish priorities for research in critical care medicine in the UK using survey and nominal group (NG) techniques. DESIGN: The senior doctor and nurse from 325 intensive care units (ICUs) in the UK were invited to contribute up to ten research questions relevant to intensive care organisation, practice or outcomes. These were then ranked twice using a Likert scale by a panel (nominal group) consisting of ten doctors (two trainees) and two nurses from university teaching and district general (community) hospitals. The first ratings were performed privately, and the second after group discussion. Thirty questions, ten each with strong, moderate or weak support, were then returned for rating by the originating ICU staff and the results compared with those of the NG. RESULTS: One hundred eighty-five respondents (35.6 % university teaching, 62.1% district general, 2.3 % not stated) provided 811 questions of which 722 were research hypotheses. The most frequently identified topics were the evaluation of high dependency care, ICU characteristics, treatments for acute lung injury and acute renal failure, nurse:patient ratios, pulmonary artery catheterisation, aspects of medical and nursing practice, protocol evaluation, and interhospital transfers. These were condensed into 100 topics for consideration by the NG. Discussion and re-rating by the group resulted in strong support being offered for 37 topics, moderate support for 48, and weak support for 21. Following circulation of ten questions from each category, nine questions achieved strong support from both ICU staff and the NG. These were the effect on outcomes from critical illness of early intervention, high dependency care, nurse:patient ratios, interhospital transfers, early enteral feeding, optimisation of perioperative care, hospital type, regionalisation of paediatric intensive care and the use of pulmonary artery catheters. The absence of any questions relating to interventions targetting mediators of the immuno-inflammatory response could be a consequence of the failure of recent studies in sepsis to demonstrate benefits in outcome. CONCLUSIONS: The intensive care community in the UK appears to prioritise research into organisational aspects of clinical practice and practical aspects of organ-system support. Health services research and the biological sciences need to develop collaborative methods for evaluating interventions and outcomes.

Health status and quality of life of British men with lower urinary tract symptoms: results from the SF-36.

OBJECTIVES: To determine the extent to which urinary symptoms, and resulting bothersomeness interfere with daily activities and affect health status, as measured using the Medical Outcomes Study 36-item short form health survey (SF-36). METHODS: Postal population survey in a British health region of 217 men aged 55 years and over known to have reported mild, moderate, or severe lower urinary tract symptoms. Outcome measures are self-reported urinary symptoms, their bothersomeness, general health status, and quality of life (measured using the SF-36). RESULTS: Response rate among eligible subjects was 84%. Depending on the activity, between 9% and 49% of men with moderate or severe urinary symptoms reported interference with some of their daily activities. Increasing symptom severity was associated with worsening physical role, social functioning, vitality, mental health, and perception of general health, and increasing bothersomeness was associated with worsening of all dimensions of general health status and quality of life. The association between these measures and bothersomeness was stronger than with symptom score. Compared with the general population, men bothered by their symptoms to the extent that they were a medium or a large problem have worse health status for all dimensions except physical functioning. CONCLUSIONS: The SF-36 demonstrates a deterioration in general health status and quality of life with increasing lower urinary tract symptoms and the extent to which those symptoms are bothersome. As such, it provides a generic measure of the burden of ill health arising from these symptoms at a population level. There is, however, considerable individual variation in the way that men respond to their symptoms.

Outcome measures for adult critical care: a systematic review.

OBJECTIVES: 1. To identify generic and disease specific measures of impairment, functional status and health-related quality of life that have been used in adult critical care (intensive and high-dependency care) survivors. 2. To review the validity, reliability and responsiveness of the measures in adult critical care survivors. 3. To consider the implications for future policy and to make recommendations for further methodological research. 4. To review what is currently known of the outcome of adult critical care. DATA SOURCES: Searches of electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, PsycLIT, The Cochrane Library and SIGLE) from 1970 to August 1998. Manual searches of five journals (1985-98) not indexed in electronic databases and relevant conference proceedings (1993-98). Reference lists of six existing reviews, plus snowballing from reference lists of all relevant articles identified. STUDY SELECTION: Randomised trials, non-randomised trials (cohort studies) and case series that included data on outcomes after discharge from adult (16 years and over) critical care. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: If reported, the following data were extracted from each paper: patient characteristics (age, gender, severity of illness, diagnostic category) number of patients eligible for study, follow-up period, number of deaths before follow-up, number and proportion of survivors included in follow-up method of presentation of outcome data - proportion normal as defined by reference values, or aggregate value (e.g. mean or median), or aggregate values plus an indication of variance (e.g. standard deviation or inter-quartile range). Evidence for three measurement properties was sought for each outcome measure that had been used in at least two studies - their validity, reliability and responsiveness in adult critical care. If the authors did not report these aspects explicitly, an attempt was made to use the data provided to provide these measurement properties. For measures that were used in at least ten studies, information on actual reported outcomes were also extracted. RESULTS: MEASURES USED IN CRITICAL CARE: Measures of impairment were largely confined to the respiratory system so are almost certainly not appropriate for many critical care survivors. They can be categorised as respiratory volumes (e.g. vital capacity), gas flow within the respiratory system (e.g. forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1)), pulmonary diffusing capacity (e.g. carbon monoxide diffusing capacity) and visualisation of the upper airway (e.g. bronchoscopy). Multiple tests are often performed. Eight measures of physical functional status were used, five generic and three disease-specific. The most frequently used generic measures were multi-item scales. Two single-item global measures attempted to capture a person's overall activity level or functional status. Five multi-item measures of mental functional status were used, four generic and one specific to trauma patients. The generic measures were either confined to assessing depressive symptoms or also encompassed a measure of anxiety. Measures of neuropsychological functioning relate to a person's cognition, attention, ability to process information and memory. Apart from one single-item measure, which focused on communication level, six multi-item measures were used with critical care survivors. Such measures are particularly appropriate for use with survivors of head injury or other neurological insult and, in that sense, they are disease-specific rather than generic measures. Single item measures of recovery were frequently used but researchers often invented their own, so there was little consistency in the wording. These measures had five principal foci - return to work, return to own home, degree of recovery, productivity and chronic health status. One multi-item scale was also used. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)

Gender differences in the management and outcome of patients with acute coronary artery disease.

STUDY OBJECTIVE: s: To compare the clinical management and health outcomes of men and women after admission with acute coronary syndromes, after adjusting for disease severity, sociodemographic, and cardiac risk factors. DESIGN: Prospective national survey of acute cardiac admissions followed up by mailed patient questionnaire two to three years after initial admission. SETTING: Random sample of 94 district general hospitals in the UK. PATIENTS: 1064 patients under 70 years old recruited between April 1995 and November 1996. MAIN RESULTS: Of the 1064 patients recruited, 126 (11.8%) died before follow up. Of the 938 survivors, 719 (76.7%) completed a follow up questionnaire. There were no gender differences in the use of cardiac investigations during the index admission or follow up period. However, male patients with hypertension were more likely to undergo rehabilitation compared with female hypertensive patients (OR 2.01, 95% CI 0.85 to 4.72). Men were also more likely to undergo coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) than women (OR 1.90, 95%CI 1.21 to 3.00), but there was no gender difference in the use of revascularisation overall (p=0.14). An indirect indication that the gender differences in CABG were not attributable to bias was provided by the lack of gender differences in health outcomes, which implies that patients received the care they needed. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the extensive international literature referring to a gender bias in favour of men with coronary heart disease, this national survey found no gender differences in the use of investigations or in revascularisation overall. However, the criteria used for selecting percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty compared with CABG requires further investigation as does the use of rehabilitation. It is unclear whether the clinical decisions to provide these procedures are made solely on the basis of clinical need.

Urinary symptoms: prevalence and severity in British men aged 55 and over.

OBJECTIVE: To measure the prevalence and severity of urinary symptoms among men aged 55 and over in the British population. DESIGN: Cross sectional population survey using a postal questionnaire. SETTING: North West Thames health region. SUBJECTS: 1480 men aged 55 years and over randomly selected from 8 general practices. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Self reported frequency and severity of urinary symptoms, their bothersomeness and previous prostate surgery. RESULTS: The response rate among eligible subjects was 78%. The prevalence of moderate and severe symptoms was 204 per 1000, rising from 160 per 1000 in the 55-59 age group to 259 per 1000 in the 70-74 age group and declining after the age of 80 to 119 per thousand in the 85+ age group. Twelve per cent of men reported previous prostate surgery, and the probability of having had surgery increases steadily with age. About a third of those undergoing surgery have recurrence or persistence of symptoms after surgery. Of men with moderate and severe symptoms, 27.9% reported that their symptoms were a medium or big problem, 36.9% reported that their symptoms interfered with their daily activities at least some of the time, and 43.1% were unhappy or 'felt terrible' about the prospect of a future with their current symptoms. CONCLUSION: The prevalence of urinary symptoms in men is lower than previously reported, although there is a substantial number of men who are bothered by, or who find their lives adversely effected by them.

Appropriate indications for prostatectomy in the UK--results of a consensus panel.

STUDY OBJECTIVE: The use of formal consensus development to determine appropriate indications for prostatectomy and to identify factors underlying clinical decisions about appropriateness is described. DESIGN: A nominal group technique was used. SETTINGS: The study took place in an academic research institution. PARTICIPANTS: The panel consisted of six urologists and three general practitioners. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The panel identified agreed indications for prostatectomy, expressed in terms of different combinations of type of retention, type and severity of symptoms, and level of comorbidity. Agreement was reached for 67% of the indications considered. For acute on chronic retention, surgery is indicated, regardless of symptom severity, if life expectancy is greater than one year. For acute or chronic retention, surgery is generally indicated if symptoms are severe, or if symptoms are moderate and life expectancy is greater than five years. For patients with neither acute nor chronic retention, surgery is indicated if symptoms are severe, or if these are moderate and life expectancy is greater than five years. For chronic or acute retention surgery is inappropriate if symptoms are mild and life expectancy is less than one year, or if there is no retention and only mild symptoms. An "appropriateness score" was developed. This confirmed that in general the ratings were internally consistent, that the panel attached little weight to mild symptoms, that a combination of irritative and obstructive symptoms was no more indicative of surgery than obstructive symptoms alone, and that the type of symptom was less important than the other factors considered. CONCLUSIONS: The results provide a basis for population based surveys of the need for prostatectomy.

Criterion validation of the Nottingham Health Profile: patient views of surgery for benign prostatic hypertrophy.

As part of a prospective cohort study of 388 men undergoing TURP for benign prostatic hypertrophy, the Nottingham Health Profile (NHP) was self-administered before and at 3, 6 and 12 months after surgery. By comparison of pre- and post-operative NHP scores with other patient-reported health measures the criterion validity of the Profile was examined. Before surgery, statistically significant linear trends were observed for increasing NHP score (i.e. having more health problems) with both worsening self-rated general health and increasing severity of prostatic symptoms. One year after surgery, the extent of reduction in NHP score was significantly linearly associated with a perceived favourable outcome of surgery and to a lesser extent with a reduction in prostatic symptoms. In addition, changes in NHP scores during follow-up were associated with perceived changes in operative outcome during the same period, patients with the greatest reduction in NHP score tending to report more successful surgery at 12 months than at the 3 month assessment.

The efficiency of ECT: II. Correlation of specific treatment variables to response rate in unilateral ECT.

Determining the most efficient use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) for treating depression hinges on defining the crucial variable(s) related to the maximal efficacy of an individual seizure. In this study, we examined the relationships of several treatment variables to antidepressant effect of 109 individual unilaterally induced seizures. The seizures occurred during the maximal response phase of 39 courses of ECT judged to have been effective. The patients were divided according to whether or not they were receiving antidepressants during ECT. The variables were treatment number, seizure length, and type of seizure end point. In the total group, earlier treatments were significantly related to antidepressant effect. Seizure length and type of seizure end point appeared to be of little consequence. Further studies of ECT should focus particularly on the effects of the first treatment in order to define optimal ECT efficiency.

The efficiency of ECT: I. Response rate in depressive episodes.

A great deal of variation in opinion and practice remains regarding the most efficient use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in treating depression. In this study we used an estimate of maximal improvement point to look at the rate of response to conventional ECT (one seizure per session, three times per week) in 66 patients with depressive episodes. Of the variables examined, increasing age was found to be significantly associated with slower response rate. Comparison of our results with studies of the multiple seizure technique suggests that giving multiple seizures per session does not speed response rate. We therefore conclude that within the limits of current clinical practice age is probably more important than number of frequency of seizures in determining the rate at which depression responds to ECT.

Health care sought and received by men with urinary symptoms, and their views on prostatectomy.

BACKGROUND: Urinary symptoms are common among middle aged and elderly men. AIM: A study was undertaken to describe the health care sought by men aged 55 years and over with urinary symptoms, the action taken by general practitioners and urologists, and the men's views on prostatectomy. METHOD: A postal questionnaire was sent to 516 men aged 55 years and over in the North West Thames Regional Health Authority, with previously identified mild, moderate or severe urinary symptoms. RESULTS: The response rate among eligible subjects was 83%. Of 420 respondents 45% had seen their general practitioner for their symptoms. General practitioners had referred 62% of these men to a urologist, reassured 21% and prescribed medication to 17%. The probability of a man seeking medical advice increased with increasing symptom severity. In contrast, the decision to refer was independent of symptom severity. Of the men referred to a urologist, the majority (71%) were offered and accepted surgery. The remainder were reassured (17%), or received a prescription (4%). Eight per cent were offered surgery but declined. When presented with details and information on the risks and benefits of prostatectomy, 22% of men with symptoms would probably or definitely refuse treatment, while a further 47% of men were unsure. CONCLUSION: There are many men who do not seek treatment for urinary symptoms and, of those who do, subsequent referral is not associated with symptom severity. There is scope for improving the referral process through the shared development of guidelines between general practitioners, hospitals and commissioning agencies.

Why is evaluation of the cost effectiveness of audit so difficult? The example of thrombolysis for suspected acute myocardial infarction.

BACKGROUND: Cost effectiveness analysis is an established technique for evaluation of delivery of health care, but its use to evaluate clinical audit is rarely reported. Thrombolysis for suspected acute myocardial infarction is a commonly used therapy of established effectiveness and an appropriate subject for audit in many healthcare settings. OBJECTIVE: To measure the cost effectiveness of audit of thrombolysis in some district general hospitals. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Cost of audit per extra patient treated with thrombolysis (incremental cost effectiveness ratio). DESIGN: Prospective agreement with physicians to undertake repeated audits of a specific aspect of the management of patients with acute myocardial infarction. Baseline measurement of the proportion of these patients given thrombolysis in each hospital were made, as were three subsequent retrospective audits, giving time series of measurements. Costs were estimated from records of staff time and other resources used in each hospital; effectiveness was estimated by fitting the results to a model which assumed a uniform rate of increase over time in the proportion of eligible patients given thrombolysis which might be accelerated by regular audit. Upper and lower limits for main outcome measure were derived from sensitivity analysis of costs and logistic regression of time series data. SETTING: Five district general hospitals in North West Thames Regional Health Authority including one control hospital were used, starting in April 1991 when widespread medical audit was first introduced. RESULTS: Between the first and last audits, the proportion of patients with suspected acute myocardial infarctions receiving thrombolysis rose in three of the hospitals undertaking audit by 20% to 37% and fell by 6% in the fourth (although this hospital started with a rate in excess of 90%). The corresponding change in the control hospital was an increase of 15%. The differences between each of the auditing hospitals and control hospital were not significant, except in one case, where 51 extra treatments per year were attributable to audit (95% confidence intervals (95% CIs) 0.5 to 61 cases per year). Estimated overall costs in each hospital ranged from 3700 Pounds to 5200 Pounds for data collection, a series of four audit meetings, and subsequent actions. The central estimate of cost effectiveness in the three responsive hospitals ranged from 101 Pounds to 392 Pounds per extra case given thrombolysis, with very wide 95% CIs. In the fourth hospital audit had zero effectiveness as defined in this study. CONCLUSIONS: Methodological difficulties were encountered which need to be considered in future economic evaluations of clinical audit and related activities. These were: (a) adequate control for other factors influencing clinical behaviour; (b) uncertainties about the sustainability of changes in behaviour associated with audit; and (c) the relative infrequency in a single hospital of specific clinical events leading to small numbers for analysis. These difficulties constitute major challenges for the economic evaluation of clinical audit. They are most likely to be overcome in a large study which compares clinical audit with other interventions aiming for the same quality improvement, such as patient specific reminders or educational programmes.

The Patient Outcomes of Surgery-Hand/Arm (POS-Hand/Arm): a new patient-based outcome measure.

The purpose of this study was to develop and validate a new patient-based outcome measure for hand/arm disorders for use in audit, clinical trials and effectiveness studies. There were three stages. First, we carried out interviews with 40 patients with hand/arm disorders to develop and pilot questionnaire content. Second, in a postal survey with 165 pre- and 181 post-surgery patients, we reduced the number of items and identified scales. Third, in a postal survey with 132 pre- and 204 post-surgery patients we evaluated the psychometric properties of the measure. Findings confirmed the acceptability, reliability, validity and responsiveness to clinical change of the questionnaire. The Patient Outcomes of Surgery-Hand/Arm (POS-Hand/Arm) is a new surgical outcome measure that can be used before and after surgery (29 and 33 items, respectively) to evaluate and compare new techniques, surgical teams and units.

Groin hernia surgery: a systematic review.

BACKGROUND: An extensive volume of clinical research has been undertaken on the use of surgery for groin hernias. For many years there has been a large number of different methods of repairing hernias and, with the introduction of laparoscopic surgery, this has increased further. It is uncertain which method is the best in terms of safety and effectiveness. OBJECTIVES: This review was undertaken to compare the outcomes following different surgical procedures to treat groin hernias in adults. It sought answers to six questions: 1)Which method of surgery (including open procedures and laparoscopic surgery) is the safest and most effective for inguinal hernia repair? 2) Is local anaesthesia a safe and effective alternative to general anaesthesia? 3) Is there a difference in outcome between specialist and non-specialist surgeons? 4) Is day-case as safe and effective as inpatient surgery? 5) Is synchronous bilateral hernia repair as safe and effective as delayed repair? 6) Which method of surgery is the safest and most effective for femoral hernia repair? METHODS: The primary measure of effectiveness used was the proportion of hernia repairs in which there was a recurrence. Secondary outcome measures included complications, post-operative pain, wound infection, time to return to normal activities and/or return to work. A systematic search of the literature (up to February 1996) was undertaken using a variety of approaches. the methodological quality of all prospective comparative studies (45 randomised trials and 26 non-randomised trials/prospective cohort studies) was assessed using a standard checklist. RESULTS: Some of the variation in findings from different studies is likely to be due to methodological differences rather than differences in the effectiveness of the surgical procedures. The main methodological shortcomings of the studies that have been performed are: lack of agreed method for assessing severity of hernias; failure to take confounding into account in non-randomised studies; variation in length of follow-up; poor external validity; lack of objective measures of outcome; and inadequate statistical power. These problems severely limit the conclusions that can be drawn from the literature.

A randomised controlled trial of surgery for glue ear.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the effect of five different surgical treatments for glue ear (secretory otitis media) on improvement in hearing and, assuming one or more treatments to be effective, to identify the appropriate indications for surgery. DESIGN: Randomised controlled trial of children receiving (a) adenoidectomy, bilateral myringotomy, and insertion of a unilateral grommet; (b) adenoidectomy, unilateral myringotomy, and insertion of a unilateral grommet; (c) bilateral myringotomy and insertion of a unilateral grommet; and (d) unilateral myringotomy and insertion of a grommet. Children were followed up at seven weeks, six months, 12 months, and 24 months by symptom history and clinical investigations. SETTING: Otolaryngology department in an urban hospital. PATIENTS: 149 Children aged 4-9 years who were admitted for surgery for glue ear and who had no history of previous operations on tonsils, adenoids, or ears and no evidence of sensorineural deafness. Inadequate follow up information on levels of hearing and on middle ear function was obtained from 22. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Mean hearing loss (dB) of the three worst heard frequencies between 250 and 4000 Hz, results of impedance tympanometry, and parental views on their child's progress. RESULTS: In the 127 children for whom adequate information was available ears in which a grommet had been inserted performed better in the short term (for at least six months) than those in which no grommet had been inserted, irrespective of any accompanying procedure. Most of the benefit had disappeared by 12 months. Adenoidectomy produced a slight improvement that was not significant, though was sustained for at least two years. The ears of children who had had an adenoidectomy with myringotomy and grommet insertion, however, continued to improve so that two years after surgery about 50% had abnormal tympanometry compared with 83% of those who had had only myringotomy and grommet insertion, and 93% of the group that had had no treatment. Logistic regression analyses identified preoperative hearing level as the single best predictor of good outcome from surgery. Other variables contributed little additional predictive power. CONCLUSIONS: If the principal objective of surgery for glue ear is to restore hearing then our study shows that insertion of grommets is the treatment of choice. The addition of an adenoidectomy will increase the likelihood of restoration of normal function of the middle ear but will not improve hearing. When deciding appropriate indications for surgery, a balance has to be made between performing unnecessary operations and failing to treat patients who might benefit from surgical intervention. Preoperative audiometry scores might be the best predictor in helping to make this decision.

Comparative audit between hospitals: the example of appendectomy.

How useful are routine, comparative audit systems? To attempt to answer this question, data from a system in North West Thames were used. A common procedure was selected (appendectomy) and data supplied by 17 surgeons between January and June 1990 were analysed. Aspects of the case-mix, clinical management, diagnostic accuracy and patient outcomes for the surgeons were compared. A total of 401 patients had been treated. All aspects of care varied between surgeons: mean age of patients (19-36 years), proportion of female patients (30-75 per cent), mean length of stay (2.1-7.1 days), prophylactic antibiotic use (0-85 per cent), diagnostic accuracy (40-100 per cent) and incidence of wound infections (0-4 per cent). As a result of the small sample sizes (mean number of cases per surgeon was 23.6) few of these differences were statistically significant. In addition, there were some doubts about the accuracy of some of the data. If such methodological difficulties can be overcome, comparative audit systems offer a practical and useful way of uncovering unusual clinical practices and generating hypotheses for evaluative research.

Dissecting a waiting list.

This study examines a list of 1,283 patients waiting for general and orthopaedic surgery in an outer London borough. In general surgery varicose vein and hernia surgery accounted for 60% of those waiting more than one year. Of those who had waited more than a year on the orthopaedic list 25% were waiting for knee replacement surgery. The average length of time spent waiting was 10 months, with some people waiting over 5 years. The impact of the numbers waiting a long time on aggregate waiting time was highlighted by weighting the numbers waiting by the months spent waiting. Analysis of urgency codes indicates that although there was a statistically significant relationship between urgency and the length of waiting time there were some anomalies. There was considerable inter-consultant variation in list size, waiting times and the case mix. Analysis of the flows onto the list and work done in one month showed that it would take a considerable time to clear some lists at present rates of activity. Disaggregated information such as this which explores the flows of patients on to and off of the lists is essential for the management of waiting lists and will become increasingly important as waiting lists become a feature of--'contracts'--service agreements, in the reformed NHS.

Response to rubella immunisation education in health authority family planning clinics: a controlled clinical trial.

The response of women attending family planning clinics run by the Area Health Authority providing health education on protection against rubella (cases), was compared with those attending clinics with no specific educational provision (controls). The effectiveness of the intervention was determined by studying the number of women approaching their General Practitioner in the ensuing four months for serological testing to determine their immune-status. Of 174 cases and 170 controls registered with a General Practitioner, follow-up information was obtained on 164 (94%) cases and 155 (91%) controls. General Practitioners' records revealed pre-existing knowledge of serologically confirmed immunity or previous rubella immunisation in only 35 (21%) cases and 29 (19%) controls. In response to health education, 12 (7%) cases approached their GP on the subject compared with 3 (2%) controls - a small but significant difference (P less than 0.05) which was confined to women aged 25-29 years. This suggests that such a programme would fail to make a significant contribution to the prevention of congenital rubella.