Stacked conservation practices reduce nitrogen loss: A paired watershed study.

Combinations of best management practices (BMPs) are needed to achieve nutrient reduction goals in the Mississippi/Atchafalaya River Basin (MARB), but field results are crucial to encourage stacked adoption of BMPs. A paired catchment-scale study (2015-18) was done to assess the impact of (i) BMPs, (ii) precipitation patterns, and (iii) seasonality on nitrogen (N) export. Flow-weighted samples were collected and analyzed for total ammonia nitrogen (TAN), nitrate (NO3-N), and total nitrogen (TN). Catchments Low-BMP 11 and High-BMP 12 had 27.6% and 87.6% areal coverage of BMPs, respectively. No significant difference (p > 0.05) in TAN concentrations was found between Low-BMP 11 (0.023 mg L-1) and High-BMP 12 (0.020 mg L-1). However, NO3-N and TN concentrations were significantly higher (p < 0.05) at Low-BMP 11 (NO3-N: 26.0 mg L-1, TN: 28.7 mg L-1) than at High-BMP 12 (NO3-N: 8.8 mg L-1, TN: 9.2 mg L-1). Two precipitation factors that affected N export patterns were observed. First, N flushing could continue for several years after a drought as elevated NO3-N concentrations were observed in 2015 (i.e., two years after the 2011-2013 drought). Second, higher annual N export was observed when more precipitation occurred during the pre-planting or early-growing season versus later periods. For both catchments, the highest 50% of flows were responsible for majority of the NO3-N export. We estimated that 33-37%, 61-62%, and 82-85% of the NO3-N loads occurred in the 90th, 75th, and 50th flow percentiles, respectively. As demonstrated in High-BMP 12, stacked BMP application effectively lowered NO3-N and TN loads by 60.3% and 59.1%, respectively, relative to Low-BMP 11. Although 27.6% BMP coverage area in Low-BMP 11 was considered low for this study, this coverage area is higher than many other parts of the MARB. This research highlights the importance of joint efforts between landowners in a watershed to meet downstream water quality goals.

Catchment-scale Phosphorus Export through Surface and Drainage Pathways.

The site-specific nature of P fate and transport in drained areas exemplifies the need for additional data to guide implementation of conservation practices at the catchment scale. Total P (TP), dissolved reactive P (DRP), and total suspended solids (TSS) were monitored at five sites-two streams, two tile outlets, and a grassed waterway-in three agricultural subwatersheds (221.2-822.5 ha) draining to Black Hawk Lake in western Iowa. Median TP concentrations ranged from 0.034 to 1.490 and 0.008 to 0.055 mg P L for event and baseflow samples, respectively. The majority of P and TSS export occurred during precipitation events and high-flow conditions with greater than 75% of DRP, 66% of TP, and 59% of TSS export occurring during the top 25% of flows from all sites. In one subwatershed, a single event (annual recurrence interval < 1 yr) was responsible for 46.6, 84.0, and 81.0% of the annual export of TP, DRP, and TSS, respectively, indicating that frequent, small storms have the potential to result in extreme losses. Isolated monitoring of surface and drainage transport pathways indicated significant P and TSS losses occurring through drainage; over the 2-yr study period, the drainage pathway was responsible for 69.8, 59.2, and 82.6% of the cumulative TP, DRP, and TSS export, respectively. Finally, the results provided evidence that particulate P losses in drainage were greater than dissolved P losses. Understanding relationships between flow, precipitation, transport pathway, and P fraction at the catchment scale is needed for effective conservation practice implementation.

Impact of stacked conservation practices on phosphorus and sediment export at the catchment scale.

Best management practices (BMPs) are effective in reducing nutrient and sediment export, but further understanding of the benefits of the stacked BMPs is needed. This catchment-scale study was established to evaluate the impact of hydrology and BMPs on phosphorus (P) and sediment losses. Two adjacent catchments, one with a lower level of BMP adoption (Low-BMP #11) and one with a higher level (High-BMP #12), were compared for total P (TP) and total suspended solids (TSS) export. The BMPs include nutrient management plans, reduced tillage, grassed waterways, terraces, and perennial vegetation. The TP event-flow-weighted (EFW) concentration was significantly higher at Low-BMP #11 (0.293 mg L-1) than at High-BMP #12 (0.069 mg L-1). There was no significant difference in TP base-flow-weighted (BFW) concentrations between Low-BMP #11 (0.035 mg L-1) and High-BMP #12 (0.037 mg L-1). The TSS-EFW (148.0 vs. 18.6 mg L-1) and TSS-BFW (13.3 vs. 6.9 mg L-1) concentrations were also higher at Low-BMP #11 than at High-BMP #12. High-BMP #12 had lower TP (0.36 vs. 0.59 kg ha-1 yr-1) and TSS (253 vs. 1,961 kg ha-1 yr-1) loading than Low-BMP #11. The lower TP export at High-BMP #12 was likely attributed to the effectiveness of stacked erosion control BMPs and nutrient management plans. Overall, lower P and sediment loading was observed when a greater areal extent of stacked practices was implemented at the catchment level. This finding provides vital information to encourage wider BMP adoption at the watershed scale.