Circulating cell-free DNA: a novel biomarker for response to therapy in ovarian carcinoma.

INTRODUCTION: Cell-free DNA (CFDNA) is a reflection of both normal and tumor-derived DNA released into the circulation through cellular necrosis and apoptosis. We sought to determine whether tumor-specific plasma DNA could be used as a biomarker for tumor burden and response to therapy in an orthotopic ovarian cancer model. METHODS: Female nude mice injected intraperitoneally with HeyA8 ovarian cancer cells were treated with either docetaxel alone or in combination with anti-angiogenic agents (AEE788-dual VEGFR and EGFR antagonist or EA5-monoclonal antibody against ephrin A2). Following DNA extraction from plasma, quantification of tumor-specific DNA was performed by real-time PCR using human specific beta-actin primers. The number of genome equivalents (GE/ml) were determined from a standard curve. Apoptosis was assessed by TUNEL staining of treated tumors. RESULTS: The levels of tumor-specific DNA in plasma increased progressively with increasing tumor burden (R2=0.8, p<0.01). Additionally, tumor-specific plasma DNA levels varied following treatment with chemotherapy. In mice with established tumors (19 days following tumor injection), tumor-specific plasma DNA levels increased by 63% at 24 hours following a single dose of docetaxel (15 mg/kg), and then declined to 20% below baseline at 72 hours and were 83% lower than baseline 10 days following therapy. In addition, docetaxel treatment resulted in a significant increase in the apoptotic index at 24 hours (p<0.01). Moreover, in two separate therapy experiments using a combination of cytotoxic chemotherapy with anti-angiogenic agents, tumor-specific plasma DNA levels were significantly higher in mice treated with vehicle compared to the treatment groups. The correlation between tumor weight and tumor-specific DNA in these experiments was 0.71-0.76 (p<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that tumor-specific CFDNA levels correlate with increasing tumor burden and decline following therapy. Thus, tumor-specific DNA may be a useful surrogate biomarker of therapeutic response and should be evaluated in future clinical trials.

Quantification of total plasma cell-free DNA in ovarian cancer using real-time PCR.

Our objective was to compare the levels of total circulating plasma cell-free DNA (CfDNA) using real-time PCR in patients with late-stage ovarian cancer with those in unaffected controls. Following IRB consent, DNA was extracted from archived frozen plasma of 19 patients with primary ovarian carcinoma and 12 age-matched controls using Qiagen DNA Isolation Kits. Quantification of total CfDNA was performed using real-time PCR with the TaqMan Assay for GAPDH, beta-actin and beta-globin and the number of genome equivalents (GE/mL) were determined from a standard curve. CfDNA levels of these loci were compared between the groups with Student's t-test, with P < 0.05 being statistically significant. The mean age of the patients was 61.6 years (+/-9.6) and of the controls was 54 years (+/-12.2). All patients had high-grade, advanced stage (III or IV) serous ovarian carcinomas. Preoperative CA-125 levels ranged from 43 to 15,626 IU/mL (mean 2487.2 +/- 3686 IU/mL). Total CfDNA in ovarian cancer was higher among patients with ovarian cancer as compared to controls at all three loci: GAPDH (P = 0.022), beta-actin (P = 0.025), and beta-globin (P = 0.0089). CfDNA is elevated in advanced stage disease compared to controls. These preliminary results suggest that total CfDNA in the plasma of patients with ovarian cancer may be useful for noninvasive screening and disease surveillance.

Elevated levels of total (maternal and fetal) beta-globin DNA in maternal blood from first trimester pregnancies with trisomy 21.

BACKGROUND: Elevated levels of circulating fetal DNA have been observed in maternal plasma when a trisomy 21 fetus is confirmed. However, these studies have been limited to pregnancies carrying a male fetus. We sought to quantify total (fetal and maternal) DNA from dried blood spots (DBS) for use as an additional factor in multi-parameter prenatal screening for aneuploidy. METHODS: Maternal DBS were obtained from the NICHD-sponsored multi-center cohort (BUN) study. Seventeen confirmed trisomy 21 (mean gestational age 12.23 +/- 0.77 weeks) cases were each matched by gestational age to euploid controls (n = 30). DNA was extracted and quantitative PCR was performed to measure four non-chromosome 21 loci, including glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) (12p13), beta-globin (11p15.5), beta-actin (7p15-12) and p53 (17p13.1). RESULTS: Beta-globin DNA levels were significantly elevated (P = 0.003) in 13 of 17 trisomy 21 cases (4.08 +/- 1.78 Geq/ml x 10(5)) compared with matched controls (2.35 +/- 1.84 Geq/ml x 10(5)). Following conversion of beta-globin concentrations into multiples of the median (MoM), MoM for trisomy 21 cases was 2.8 compared with 1.0 in euploid cases. No significant differences in levels of circulating GAPDH, beta-actin and p53 sequences were detected. CONCLUSIONS: This work demonstrates differential levels of circulating beta-globin DNA in maternal blood of euploid and trisomy 21 cases. Sequence-specific quantification could provide an additional measure to improve non-invasive methods of prenatal screening to detect trisomy 21 using dried blood. Beta-globin in particular is an attractive biomarker that could contribute to enhance multiple serum parameter testing in the first trimester.

Quantity versus quality: optimal methods for cell-free DNA isolation from plasma of pregnant women.

PURPOSE: Methods to isolate cell-free fetal DNA from maternal plasma are critical in developing noninvasive fetal DNA testing strategies. Given that plasma consists of heterogeneous DNA-size fragments in a complex mix of proteins, recovery and analysis of this DNA are understandably inefficient. To facilitate recovery, we performed qualitative and quantitative analysis of DNA isolated from maternal plasma. METHODS: DNA isolated from maternal blood (n = 15) was compared using five different DNA isolation protocols: two conventional, two column-based, and one magnetic-bead based. Purity and concentration of DNA recovered were determined with a NanoDrop spectrophotometer. Real-time polymerase chain reaction quantification of the beta-globin and DYS1 loci was performed to determine total and fetal-specific genome equivalents, respectively. RESULTS: DNA quality and quantity were different among the five methods tested. Although purity and concentration of total DNA were greatest with the conventional boiling-lysis approach, correct detection of a male fetus was achieved in only 62.5% of cases. DNA isolation using the magnetic beads yielded the highest quantity of total DNA (2018.83 +/- 4.09 GEq/mL), with 100% fetal DNA detection. CONCLUSIONS: Optimal plasma DNA recovery protocols must take into account DNA purity and concentration. We confirm that the magnetic-beads method provides a fast, simple, sensitive, and specific approach to purify plasma DNA. The resulting high-quality DNA facilitates efficient examination of fetal DNA sequences.

Quantitative DNA perturbations of p53 in endometriosis: analysis of American and Icelandic cases.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate quantitative aberrations involving p53 copy numbers in eutopic endometrial and endometriotic tissue from two populations. DESIGN: Comparative analysis of normal and diseased tissue. SETTING: Tissue specimens collected in Iceland and USA. PATIENT(S): Subjects with moderate/severe endometriosis (Iceland, n = 26; USA, n = 45). Paraffin-embedded tissue from 19 matched Icelandic cases and seven unaffected controls. American cases were fresh surgical tissue from 17 matched cases and 28 unaffected controls. DNA isolation and real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) with TaqMan assay were performed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): The frequency of p53 loss and/or gain based on quantitative differences for copy numbers of p53 located on chromosome (17p) and GAPDH on a control locus (chromosome 12p). RESULT(S): Among American cases, significant p53 gain (n = 13) or loss (n = 4) was observed in 17 of 21 cases. In Icelandic cases this was not seen to the same degree. Mean normalized p53 values were 3.46 and 1.16 copies per reaction, respectively. Significant differences were observed between normalized p53 in the control blood and affected tissue for the American and Icelandic cases compared to standard GAPDH control but not in normal Icelandic and American endometrium. CONCLUSION(S): The results continue to support a role for nonrandom somatic p53 locus alterations in the pathogenesis of late or severe-stage endometriosis. Differences between Icelandic and American subjects have implications for generalization of genome-wide approaches.

Detecting fetal DNA from dried maternal blood spots: another step towards broad scale non-invasive prenatal genetic screening and feasible testing.

Both intact fetal cells and cell-free fetal DNA are present in the maternal circulation and have been used for non-invasive prenatal genetic diagnosis. However, broad clinical application awaits development of robust methods for collecting, transporting and enriching maternal blood samples to recover rare fetal cells. To circumvent this impediment, we have devised a reliable method of fetal DNA detection using dried maternal blood spots and real-time polymerase chain reaction. Fetal Y-specific (DYS1) sequences were detected in all 19 (100%) maternal blood specimens from women carrying male fetuses, in genome equivalents of 4.20-24.68 per ml of blood; the ubiquitous glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) gene, reflecting both maternal and fetal DNA, concurrently showed 43,684 to 680,357 genome equivalents per ml of blood. The results demonstrate that fetal DNA detection using dried maternal blood spots is highly feasible and easily adaptable for population screening.

Cell-free fetal DNA and intact fetal cells in maternal blood circulation: implications for first and second trimester non-invasive prenatal diagnosis.

Both intact fetal cells as well as cell-free fetal DNA are present in the maternal circulation and can be recovered for non-invasive prenatal genetic diagnosis. Although methods for enrichment and isolation of rare intact fetal cells have been challenging, diagnosis of fetal chromosomal aneuploidy including trisomy 21 in first- and second-trimester pregnancies has been achieved with a 50-75% detection rate. Similarly, cell-free fetal DNA can be reliably recovered from maternal plasma and assessed by quantitative PCR to detect fetal trisomy 21 and paternally derived single gene mutations. Real-time PCR assays are robust in detecting low-level fetal DNA concentrations, with sensitivity of approximately 95-100% and specificity near 100%. Comparing intact fetal cell versus cell-free fetal DNA methods for non-invasive prenatal screening for fetal chromosomal aneuploidy reveals that the latter is at least four times more sensitive. These preliminary results do not support a relationship between frequency of intact fetal cells and concentration of cell-free fetal DNA. The above results imply that the concentration of fetal DNA in maternal plasma may not be dependent on circulating intact fetal cells but rather be a product of growth and cellular turnover during embryonic or fetal development.

Interlaboratory comparison of fetal male DNA detection from common maternal plasma samples by real-time PCR.

BACKGROUND: Analysis of fetal DNA from maternal plasma by PCR offers great potential for noninvasive prenatal genetic diagnosis. To further evaluate this potential, we developed and validated a standard protocol to determine whether fetal DNA sequences could be reproducibly amplified and measured across multiple laboratories in a common set of specimens. METHODS: Each of five participating centers in a National Institute of Child Health and Human Development consortium collected 20 mL of peripheral blood from 20 pregnant women between 10 and 20 weeks of gestation. The plasma fraction was separated according to a common protocol, divided, and frozen in five aliquots. One aliquot was shipped to each participating laboratory, where DNA was extracted according to a standard protocol. All plasma samples (n = 100) were then analyzed blindly for the presence and quantity of total DNA (GAPDH) and male fetal DNA (SRY) by real-time PCR. Genomic DNA was isolated from female and male cells at one center, quantified, and shipped to the others to serve as calibrators for GAPDH and SRY, respectively. RESULTS: The amplification of known quantities of DNA was consistent among all centers. The mean quantity of male DNA amplified from maternal plasma when the fetus was male ranged from 51 to 228 genome equivalents (GE)/mL. Qualitative concordance was found overall among centers. The sensitivity of the assay for detection of male DNA when the fetus was male varied from 31% to 97% among centers. Specificity was more consistent (93-100%) with only four false-positive results obtained across the entire study. CONCLUSIONS: All centers were able to consistently amplify frozen and shipped DNA. The PCR procedure used here is reliable and reproducible. Centers that extracted and amplified more DNA per milliliter of maternal plasma had superior sensitivities of Y chromosome sequence detection. The specificity of the assay was more consistent among centers. A robust and thoroughly optimized protocol for the extraction of DNA from maternal plasma is needed to make testing of fetal DNA in maternal plasma a clinically relevant analytical tool.