Understanding Glass through Differential Scanning Calorimetry.

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) is a powerful tool to address some of the most challenging issues in glass science and technology, such as the nonequilibrium nature of the glassy state and the detailed thermodynamics and kinetics of glass-forming systems during glass transition, relaxation, rejuvenation, polyamorphic transition, and crystallization. The utility of the DSC technique spans across all glass-forming chemistries, including oxide, chalcogenide, metallic, and organic systems, as well as recently discovered metal-organic framework glass-forming systems. Here we present a comprehensive review of the many applications of DSC in glass science with focus on glass transition, relaxation, polyamorphism, and crystallization phenomena. We also emphasize recent advances in DSC characterization technology, including flash DSC and temperature-modulated DSC. This review demonstrates how DSC studies have led to a multitude of relevant advances in the understanding of glass physics, chemistry, and even technology.

Why does B2O3 suppress nepheline (NaAlSiO4) crystallization in sodium aluminosilicate glasses?

The uncontrolled growth of nepheline (NaAlSiO4) crystals during the manufacturing of sodium aluminosilicate glasses via the fusion draw or float techniques and during the vitrification of some of the sodium- and alumina-rich nuclear waste glasses is a well-known problem. The addition of B2O3 to suppress the crystallization in these glasses is well documented in the literature. Another advantage of B2O3 is that it lowers the viscosity of the glass melt and, if incorporated in its trigonal coordination state, will improve the intrinsic damage resistance of the final glass product. Hence, B2O3 has been an integral component of glass compositions for advanced industrial applications and for nuclear waste vitrification. However, one major disadvantage of adding B2O3 to alkali aluminosilicate based glasses is its adverse impact on their chemical durability due to the rapid hydrolysis of B[3,4]-O-B[3,4] bonds in comparison to (Si, Al)-O-(Si, Al) bonds. Therefore, designing a boron-containing alkali aluminosilicate based functional glass with minimal tendency towards crystallization and high chemical durability requires an in-depth fundamental understanding of the mechanism through which B2O3 tends to suppress crystallization in these glasses. There is no current consensus on the fundamental mechanism through which B2O3 tends to suppress nepheline crystallization in these glasses. Based on the mechanisms described and the questions raised in the preceding literature, the present study focuses on addressing the ongoing debate through a detailed structural and thermo-kinetic investigation of glasses designed in the Na2O-Al2O3-B2O3-SiO2 based quaternary system over a broad composition space. Using a combination of Raman and (1D and 2D) nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopies along with equilibrium and non-equilibrium viscosity, and liquidus temperature measurements, it has been shown that the substitution of Si-O-Al by Si-O-B linkages in the glass structure results in a significant increase in the glass forming ability as well as an increase in the liquidus viscosity (slower diffusivity), thereby suppressing the nepheline crystallization.

Isotropic rotation vs. shear relaxation in supercooled liquids with globular cage molecules.

The temperature dependence of the rotational dynamics of P4Se3 molecules in the glass-forming molecular liquid P5Se3 is studied using two-dimensional (31)P nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Unlike typical molecular glass-forming liquids, the constituent molecules in the P5Se3 liquid perform rapid isotropic rotation without significant translational diffusion in the supercooled regime and this rotational process shows a decoupling in time scale from shear relaxation by nearly six orders of magnitude at the glass transition. This dynamical behavior of liquid-like rotation and localized translation appears to be universal to glass-forming liquids with high-symmetry globular molecules that are characterized by an underlying thermodynamically stable plastic crystal phase.

Relaxation of enthalpy fluctuations during sub-T(g) annealing of glassy selenium.

The relaxation behavior of glass is influenced by the presence of dynamical heterogeneities, which lead to an intrinsically non-monotonic decay of fluctuations in density and enthalpy during isothermal annealing. This is apparently a universal feature of fragile glass forming systems associated with localized spatial variations in relaxation time. Here we present direct experimental observation of the nonmonotonic evolution of enthalpy fluctuations in glassy selenium annealed near room temperature. The nonmonotonic change in the distribution of enthalpy fluctuations measured by heat capacity spectroscopy offers direct evidence for the presence of dynamical heterogeneity in this glass. An enthalpy landscape model of selenium is then used to simulate annealing under identical conditions. The simulation results closely follow the evolution of enthalpy fluctuations observed experimentally. The close match between model and experiment demonstrate that enthalpy and density fluctuations are sources of dynamical heterogeneities in glassy materials.

Revealing the relationship between liquid fragility and medium-range order in silicate glasses.

Despite decades of studies, the nature of the glass transition remains elusive. In particular, the sharpness of the dynamical arrest of a melt at the glass transition is captured by its fragility. Here, we reveal that fragility is governed by the medium-range order structure. Based on neutron-diffraction data for a series of aluminosilicate glasses, we propose a measurable structural parameter that features a strong inverse correlation with fragility, namely, the average medium-range distance (MRD). We use in-situ high-temperature neutron-scattering data to discuss the physical origin of this correlation. We argue that glasses exhibiting low MRD values present an excess of small network rings. Such rings are unstable and deform more readily with changes in temperature, which tends to increase fragility. These results reveal that the sharpness of the dynamical arrest experienced by a silicate glass at the glass transition is surprisingly encoded into the stability of rings in its network.

Kinetic and Calorimetric Fragility of Chalcogenide Glass-Forming Liquids: Role of Shear vs Enthalpy Relaxation.

The kinetic and calorimetric fragility indices m of binary As-Se and Se-Te chalcogenide liquids with a wide range of fragility are determined using a combination of parallel plate rheometry, beam bending viscometry, and conventional differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). It is shown that both sets of measurements lead to consistent m values only if the validity of the assumptions often implicit in the methodology for the estimation of m are considered. These assumptions are (i) the glass transition temperature Tg corresponds to a viscosity of ∼1012 Pa s and (ii) enthalpy and shear relaxation time scales τen and τshear are comparable near Tg. Both assumptions are shown to be untenable for highly fragile liquids, for which modulated DSC studies demonstrate that τen ≫ τshear near Tg. In these cases, the above-mentioned assumptions are shown to lead to consistently higher values for the kinetic fragility compared to its calorimetric counterpart.

Understanding the structural drivers governing glass-water interactions in borosilicate based model bioactive glasses.

The past decade has witnessed a significant upsurge in the development of borate and borosilicate based resorbable bioactive glasses owing to their faster degradation rate in comparison to their silicate counterparts. However, due to our lack of understanding about the fundamental science governing the aqueous corrosion of these glasses, most of the borate/borosilicate based bioactive glasses reported in the literature have been designed by "trial-and-error" approach. With an ever-increasing demand for their application in treating a broad spectrum of non-skeletal health problems, it is becoming increasingly difficult to design advanced glass formulations using the same conventional approach. Therefore, a paradigm shift from the "trial-and-error" approach to "materials-by-design" approach is required to develop new-generations of bioactive glasses with controlled release of functional ions tailored for specific patients and disease states, whereby material functions and properties can be predicted from first principles. Realizing this goal, however, requires a thorough understanding of the complex sequence of reactions that control the dissolution kinetics of bioactive glasses and the structural drivers that govern them. While there is a considerable amount of literature published on chemical dissolution behavior and apatite-forming ability of potentially bioactive glasses, the majority of this literature has been produced on silicate glass chemistries using different experimental and measurement protocols. It follows that inter-comparison of different datasets reveals inconsistencies between experimental groups. There are also some major experimental challenges or choices that need to be carefully navigated to unearth the mechanisms governing the chemical degradation behavior and kinetics of boron-containing bioactive glasses, and to accurately determine the composition-structure-property relationships. In order to address these challenges, a simplified borosilicate based model melt-quenched bioactive glass system has been studied to depict the impact of thermal history on its molecular structure and dissolution behavior in water. It has been shown that the methodology of quenching of the glass melt impacts the dissolution rate of the studied glasses by 1.5×-3× depending on the changes induced in their molecular structure due to variation in thermal history. Further, a recommendation has been made to study dissolution behavior of bioactive glasses using surface area of the sample - to - volume of solution (SA/V) approach instead of the currently followed mass of sample - to - volume of solution approach. The structural and chemical dissolution data obtained from bioactive glasses following the approach presented in this paper can be used to develop the structural descriptors and potential energy functions over a broad range of bioactive glass compositions. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Realizing the goal of designing third generation bioactive glasses requires a thorough understanding of the complex sequence of reactions that control their rate of degradation (in physiological fluids) and the structural drivers that control them. In this article, we have highlighted some major experimental challenges and choices that need to be carefully navigated in order to unearth the mechanisms governing the chemical dissolution behavior of borosilicate based bioactive glasses. The proposed experimental approach allows us to gain a new level of conceptual understanding about the composition-structure-property relationships in these glass systems, which can be applied to attain a significant leap in designing borosilicate based bioactive glasses with controlled dissolution rates tailored for specific patient and disease states.

Structure of semiconducting versus fast-ion conducting glasses in the Ag-Ge-Se system.

The transition from a semiconductor to a fast-ion conductor with increasing silver content along the Ag x (Ge0.25Se0.75)(100-x) tie line (0≤x≤25) was investigated on multiple length scales by employing a combination of electric force microscopy, X-ray diffraction, and neutron diffraction. The microscopy results show separation into silver-rich and silver-poor phases, where the Ag-rich phase percolates at the onset of fast-ion conductivity. The method of neutron diffraction with Ag isotope substitution was applied to the x=5 and x=25 compositions, and the results indicate an evolution in structure of the Ag-rich phase with change of composition. The Ag-Se nearest-neighbours are distributed about a distance of 2.64(1) Å, and the Ag-Se coordination number increases from 2.6(3) at x=5 to 3.3(2) at x=25. For x=25, the measured Ag-Ag partial pair-distribution function gives 1.9(2) Ag-Ag nearest-neighbours at a distance of 3.02(2) Å. The results show breakage of Se-Se homopolar bonds as silver is added to the Ge0.25Se0.75 base glass, and the limit of glass-formation at x≃28 coincides with an elimination of these bonds. A model is proposed for tracking the breakage of Se-Se homopolar bonds as silver is added to the base glass.

Relative contribution of stoichiometry and mean coordination to the fragility of Ge-As-Se glass forming liquids.

The structural relaxation properties of 34 compositions of Ge-As-Se glass forming liquids are investigated by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The fragility index (m) and activation energies for enthalpy relaxation (Ea) exhibit universal trends with respect to stoichiometry and mean coordination (⟨r⟩), respectively. The liquid fragility which defines the full temperature dependence of the relaxation processes shows no well defined trend with respect to ⟨r⟩ but instead is found to be closely determined by the excess or deficiency in selenium with respect to stoichiometry. The mean coordination on the other hand appears to be an accurate predictor of the activation energy near the glass transition where most constraints are still intact. No intermediate phase is observed in either case. These results emphasize that chemical effects rather than topological effects appear to control the wide ranging structural mobility of these glass forming liquids. The consequences of these findings in terms of the thermal stability of the corresponding glasses are discussed. It is similarly found that sub-Tg relaxation is controlled by stoichiometry rather than topology.