Resensitizing daclatasvir-resistant hepatitis C variants by allosteric modulation of NS5A.

It is estimated that more than 170 million people are infected with hepatitis C virus (HCV) worldwide. Clinical trials have demonstrated that, for the first time in human history, the potential exists to eradicate a chronic viral disease using combination therapies that contain only direct-acting antiviral agents. HCV non-structural protein 5A (NS5A) is a multifunctional protein required for several stages of the virus replication cycle. NS5A replication complex inhibitors, exemplified by daclatasvir (DCV; also known as BMS-790052 and Daklinza), belong to the most potent class of direct-acting anti-HCV agents described so far, with in vitro activity in the picomolar (pM) to low nanomolar (nM) range. The potency observed in vitro has translated into clinical efficacy, with HCV RNA declining by ~3-4 log10 in infected patients after administration of single oral doses of DCV. Understanding the exceptional potency of DCV was a key objective of this study. Here we show that although DCV and an NS5A inhibitor analogue (Syn-395) are inactive against certain NS5A resistance variants, combinations of the pair enhance DCV potency by >1,000-fold, restoring activity to the pM range. This synergistic effect was validated in vivo using an HCV-infected chimaeric mouse model. The cooperative interaction of a pair of compounds suggests that NS5A protein molecules communicate with each other: one inhibitor binds to resistant NS5A, causing a conformational change that is transmitted to adjacent NS5As, resensitizing resistant NS5A so that the second inhibitor can act to restore inhibition. This unprecedented synergistic anti-HCV activity also enhances the resistance barrier of DCV, providing additional options for HCV combination therapy and new insight into the role of NS5A in the HCV replication cycle.

Chemical genetics strategy identifies an HCV NS5A inhibitor with a potent clinical effect.

The worldwide prevalence of chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is estimated to be approaching 200 million people. Current therapy relies upon a combination of pegylated interferon-alpha and ribavirin, a poorly tolerated regimen typically associated with less than 50% sustained virological response rate in those infected with genotype 1 virus. The development of direct-acting antiviral agents to treat HCV has focused predominantly on inhibitors of the viral enzymes NS3 protease and the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase NS5B. Here we describe the profile of BMS-790052, a small molecule inhibitor of the HCV NS5A protein that exhibits picomolar half-maximum effective concentrations (EC(50)) towards replicons expressing a broad range of HCV genotypes and the JFH-1 genotype 2a infectious virus in cell culture. In a phase I clinical trial in patients chronically infected with HCV, administration of a single 100-mg dose of BMS-790052 was associated with a 3.3 log(10) reduction in mean viral load measured 24 h post-dose that was sustained for an additional 120 h in two patients infected with genotype 1b virus. Genotypic analysis of samples taken at baseline, 24 and 144 h post-dose revealed that the major HCV variants observed had substitutions at amino-acid positions identified using the in vitro replicon system. These results provide the first clinical validation of an inhibitor of HCV NS5A, a protein with no known enzymatic function, as an approach to the suppression of virus replication that offers potential as part of a therapeutic regimen based on combinations of HCV inhibitors.

Synergistic Activity of Combined NS5A Inhibitors.

Daclatasvir (DCV) is a first-in-class hepatitis C virus (HCV) nonstructural 5A replication complex inhibitor (NS5A RCI) that is clinically effective in interferon-free combinations with direct-acting antivirals (DAAs) targeting alternate HCV proteins. Recently, we reported NS5A RCI combinations that enhance HCV inhibitory potential in vitro, defining a new class of HCV inhibitors termed NS5A synergists (J. Sun, D. R. O'Boyle II, R. A. Fridell, D. R. Langley, C. Wang, S. Roberts, P. Nower, B. M. Johnson F. Moulin, M. J. Nophsker, Y. Wang, M. Liu, K. Rigat, Y. Tu, P. Hewawasam, J. Kadow, N. A. Meanwell, M. Cockett, J. A. Lemm, M. Kramer, M. Belema, and M. Gao, Nature 527:245-248, 2015, doi:10.1038/nature15711). To extend the characterization of NS5A synergists, we tested new combinations of DCV and NS5A synergists against genotype (gt) 1 to 6 replicons and gt 1a, 2a, and 3a viruses. The kinetics of inhibition in HCV-infected cells treated with DCV, an NS5A synergist (NS5A-Syn), or a combination of DCV and NS5A-Syn were distinctive. Similar to activity observed clinically, DCV caused a multilog drop in HCV, followed by rebound due to the emergence of resistance. DCV-NS5A-Syn combinations were highly efficient at clearing cells of viruses, in line with the trend seen in replicon studies. The retreatment of resistant viruses that emerged using DCV monotherapy with DCV-NS5A-Syn resulted in a multilog drop and rebound in HCV similar to the initial decline and rebound observed with DCV alone on wild-type (WT) virus. A triple combination of DCV, NS5A-Syn, and a DAA targeting the NS3 or NS5B protein cleared the cells of viruses that are highly resistant to DCV. Our data support the observation that the cooperative interaction of DCV and NS5A-Syn potentiates both the genotype coverage and resistance barrier of DCV, offering an additional DAA option for combination therapy and tools for explorations of NS5A function.

Comparison of daclatasvir resistance barriers on NS5A from hepatitis C virus genotypes 1 to 6: implications for cross-genotype activity.

A comparison of the daclatasvir (DCV [BMS-790052]) resistance barrier on authentic or hybrid replicons containing NS5A from hepatitis C virus (HCV) genotypes 1 to 6 (GT-1 to -6) was completed using a replicon elimination assay. The data indicated that genotype 1b (GT-1b) has the highest relative resistance barrier and genotype 2a (GT-2a M31) has the lowest. The rank order of resistance barriers to DCV was 1b>4a≥5a>6a≅1a>2a JFH>3a>2a M31. Importantly, DCV in combination with a protease inhibitor (PI) eliminated GT-2a M31 replicon RNA at a clinically relevant concentration. Previously, we reported the antiviral activity and resistance profiles of DCV on HCV genotypes 1 to 4 evaluated in the replicon system. Here, we report the antiviral activity and resistance profiles of DCV against hybrid replicons with NS5A sequences derived from HCV GT-5a and GT-6a clinical isolates. DCV was effective against both GT-5a and -6a hybrid replicon cell lines (50% effective concentrations [EC50s] ranging from 3 to 7 pM for GT-5a, and 74 pM for GT-6a). Resistance selection identified amino acid substitutions in the N-terminal domain of NS5A. For GT-5a, L31F and L31V, alone or in combination with K56R, were the major resistance variants (EC50s ranging from 2 to 40 nM). In GT-6a, Q24H, L31M, P32L/S, and T58A/S were identified as resistance variants (EC50s ranging from 2 to 250 nM). The in vitro data suggest that DCV has the potential to be an effective agent for HCV genotypes 1 to 6 when used in combination therapy.

Persistence of resistant variants in hepatitis C virus-infected patients treated with the NS5A replication complex inhibitor daclatasvir.

Daclatasvir (DCV; BMS-790052) is a hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS5A replication complex inhibitor (RCI) with picomolar to low nanomolar potency and broad genotypic coverage in vitro. Viral RNA declines have been observed in the clinic for both alpha interferon-ribavirin (IFN-α-RBV) and IFN-RBV-free regimens that include DCV. Follow-up specimens (up to 6 months) from selected subjects treated with DCV in 14-day monotherapy studies were analyzed for genotype and phenotype. Variants were detected by clonal sequencing in specimens from baseline and were readily detected by population sequencing following viral RNA breakthrough and posttreatment. The major amino acid substitutions generating resistance in vivo were at residues M28, Q30, L31, and Y93 for genotype 1a (GT-1a) and L31 and Y93 for GT-1b, similar to the resistance substitutions observed with the in vitro replicon system. The primary difference in the resistance patterns observed in vitro and in vivo was the increased complexity of linked variant combinations observed in clinical specimens. Changes in the percentage of individual variants were observed during follow-up; however, the overall percentage of variants in the total population persisted up to 6 months. Our results suggest that during the 14-day monotherapy, most wild-type virus was eradicated by DCV. After the end of DCV treatment, viral fitness, rather than DCV resistance, probably determines which viral variants emerge as dominant in populations.

HCV NS5A replication complex inhibitors. Part 5: discovery of potent and pan-genotypic glycinamide cap derivatives.

The isoquinolinamide series of HCV NS5A inhibitors exemplified by compounds 2b and 2c provided the first dual genotype-1a/1b (GT-1a/1b) inhibitor class that demonstrated a significant improvement in potency toward GT-1a replicons compared to that of the initial program lead, stilbene 2a. Structure-activity relationship (SAR) studies that uncovered an alternate phenylglycine-based cap series that exhibit further improvements in virology profile, along with some insights into the pharmacophoric elements associated with the GT-1a potency, are described.

HCV NS5A replication complex inhibitors. Part 3: discovery of potent analogs with distinct core topologies.

In a recent disclosure, we described the discovery of dimeric, prolinamide-based NS5A replication complex inhibitors exhibiting excellent potency towards an HCV genotype 1b replicon. That disclosure dealt with the SAR exploration of the peripheral region of our lead chemotype, and herein is described the SAR uncovered from a complementary effort that focused on the central core region. From this effort, the contribution of the core region to the overall topology of the pharmacophore, primarily vector orientation and planarity, was determined, with a set of analogs exhibiting <10 nM EC(50) in a genotype 1b replicon assay.

Hepatitis C virus RNA elimination and development of resistance in replicon cells treated with BMS-790052.

BMS-790052, a first-in-class hepatitis C virus (HCV) replication complex inhibitor, targeting nonstructural protein 5A (NS5A), displays picomolar to nanomolar potency against genotypes 1 to 5. This exceptional potency translated into robust anti-HCV activity in clinical studies with HCV genotype 1-infected subjects. To date, all BMS-790052-associated resistance mutations have mapped to the N-terminal region of NS5A. To further characterize the antiviral activity of BMS-790052, HCV replicon elimination and colony formation assays were performed. Replicon was cleared from genotype 1a and 1b replicon cells in a time- and dose-dependent manner. Elimination of the genotype 1a replicon required longer treatment durations and higher concentrations of BMS-790052 than those for the genotype1b replicon. Single amino acid substitutions that conferred relatively low levels of resistance were observed at early time points and at low doses. Higher doses and longer treatment durations yielded mutations that conferred greater levels of resistance, including linked amino acid substitutions. Replicon cells that survived inhibitor treatment remained fully sensitivity to pegylated alpha interferon (pegIFN-α) and other HCV inhibitors. Moreover, genotype 1a replicon elimination was markedly enhanced when pegIFN-α and BMS-790052 were combined. Resistant variants observed in this study were very similar to those observed in a multiple ascending dose (MAD) monotherapy trial of BMS-790052, validating replicon elimination studies as a model to predict clinical resistance. Insights gained from the in vitro anti-HCV activity and resistance profiles of BMS-790052 will be used to help guide the clinical development of this novel HCV inhibitor.

In vitro activity of BMS-790052 on hepatitis C virus genotype 4 NS5A.

The antiviral profile of BMS-790052, a potent hepatitis C virus (HCV) replication complex inhibitor targeting nonstructural protein NS5A, is well characterized for HCV genotype-1. Here, we report that BMS-790052 inhibits hybrid replicons containing HCV genotype-4 NS5A genes with 50% effective concentrations (EC(50)s) ranging from 7 to 13 pM. NS5A residue 30 was an important site for BMS-790052-selected resistance in the hybrid replicons. Our results support the potential of BMS-790052 as a valuable component of combination therapy for HCV genotype-4 chronic infection.

Genotypic and phenotypic analysis of variants resistant to hepatitis C virus nonstructural protein 5A replication complex inhibitor BMS-790052 in humans: in vitro and in vivo correlations.

UNLABELLED: The NS5A replication complex inhibitor, BMS-790052, inhibits hepatitis C virus (HCV) replication with picomolar potency in preclinical assays. This potency translated in vivo to a substantial antiviral effect in a single-ascending dose study and a 14-day multiple-ascending dose (MAD) monotherapy study. However, HCV RNA remained detectable in genotype 1a-infected patients at the end of the MAD study. In contrast, viral breakthrough was observed less often in patients infected with genotype 1b, and, in several patients, HCV RNA declined and remained below the level of quantitation (<25 IU/mL) through the duration of treatment. Here, we report on the results of the genotypic and phenotypic analyses of resistant variants in 24 genotype 1-infected patients who received BMS-790052 (1, 10, 30, 60, and 100 mg, once-daily or 30 mg twice-daily) in the 14-day MAD study. Sequence analysis was performed on viral complementary DNA isolated from serum specimens collected at baseline and days 1 (4, 8, and 12 hours), 2, 4, 7, and 14 postdosing. Analyses of the sequence variants (1) established a correlation between resistant variants emerging in vivo with BMS-790052 treatment and those observed in the in vitro replicon system (major substitutions at residues 28, 30, 31, and 93 for genotype 1a and residues 31 and 93 for genotype 1b); (2) determined the prevalence of variants at baseline and the emergence of resistance at different times during dosing; and (3) revealed the resistance profile and replicative ability (i.e., fitness) of the variants. CONCLUSION: Although resistance emerged during monotherapy with BMS-790052, the substantial anti-HCV effect of this compound makes it an excellent candidate for effective combination therapy.

Discovery of potent hepatitis C virus NS5A inhibitors with dimeric structures.

The exceptional in vitro potency of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS5A inhibitor BMS-790052 has translated into an in vivo effect in proof-of-concept clinical trials. Although the 50% effective concentration (EC(50)) of the initial lead, the thiazolidinone BMS-824, was ~10 nM in the replicon assay, it underwent transformation to other inhibitory species after incubation in cell culture medium. The biological profile of BMS-824, including the EC(50), the drug concentration required to reduce cell growth by 50% (CC(50)), and the resistance profile, however, remained unchanged, triggering an investigation to identify the biologically active species. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) biogram fractionation of a sample of BMS-824 incubated in medium revealed that the most active fractions could readily be separated from the parental compound and retained the biological profile of BMS-824. From mass spectral and nuclear magnetic resonance data, the active species was determined to be a dimer of BMS-824 derived from an intermolecular radical-mediated reaction of the parent compound. Based upon an analysis of the structural elements of the dimer deemed necessary for anti-HCV activity, the stilbene derivative BMS-346 was synthesized. This compound exhibited excellent anti-HCV activity and showed a resistance profile similar to that of BMS-824, with changes in compound sensitivity mapped to the N terminus of NS5A. The N terminus of NS5A has been crystallized as a dimer, complementing the symmetry of BMS-346 and allowing a potential mode of inhibition of NS5A to be discussed. Identification of the stable, active pharmacophore associated with these NS5A inhibitors provided the foundation for the design of more potent inhibitors with broad genotype inhibition. This culminated in the identification of BMS-790052, a compound that preserves the symmetry discovered with BMS-346.

The effects of NS5A inhibitors on NS5A phosphorylation, polyprotein processing and localization.

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) non-structural protein 5A (NS5A) is a multi-functional protein that is expressed in basally phosphorylated (p56) and in hyperphosphorylated (p58) forms. NS5A phosphorylation has been implicated in regulating multiple aspects of HCV replication. We recently reported the identification of a class of compounds that potently inhibit HCV RNA replication by targeting NS5A. Although the precise mechanism of inhibition of these compounds is not well understood, one activity that has been described is their ability to block expression of the hyperphosphorylated form of NS5A. Here, we report that an NS5A inhibitor impaired hyperphosphorylation without affecting basal phosphorylation at the C-terminal region of NS5A. This inhibitor activity did not require NS5A domains II and III and was distinct from that of a cellular kinase inhibitor that also blocked NS5A hyperphosphorylation, results that are consistent with an inhibitor-binding site within the N-terminal region of NS5A. In addition, we observed that an NS5A inhibitor promoted the accumulation of an HCV polyprotein intermediate, suggesting that inhibitor binding to NS5A may occur prior to the completion of polyprotein processing. Finally, we observed that NS5A p56 and p58 separated into different membrane fractions during discontinuous sucrose gradient centrifugation, consistent with these NS5A phosphoforms performing distinct replication functions. The p58 localization pattern was disrupted by an NS5A inhibitor. Collectively, our results suggest that NS5A inhibitors probably impact several aspects of HCV expression and regulation. These findings may help to explain the exceptional potency of this class of HCV replication complex inhibitors.

HCV NS5A replication complex inhibitors.

The development of anti-HCV drugs is one of the most successful stories of antiviral therapy. In fact, for the first time in human history we have the potential to eradicate a chronic viral infection using only orally administered direct antiviral agents (DAAs). HCV NS5A replication complex inhibitors, exemplified by Daclatasvir (DCV, BMS-790052, Daklinza®), are a new class of DAA. The astonishing in vitro potency of DCV (pM to low nM range) translated to remarkable efficacy in clinical trials, and 2nd generation NS5A inhibitors have become essential components of HCV combination therapies. The current cure rate of effective combination therapies exceeds 90% in most clinical trials. The extraordinary potency of NS5A inhibitors promoted significant efforts to understand their mechanism(s) of inhibition.

Discovery and development of hepatitis C virus NS5A replication complex inhibitors.

Lead inhibitors that target the function of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) nonstructural 5A (NS5A) protein have been identified by phenotypic screening campaigns using HCV subgenomic replicons. The demonstration of antiviral activity in HCV-infected subjects by the HCV NS5A replication complex inhibitor (RCI) daclatasvir (1) spawned considerable interest in this mechanistic approach. In this Perspective, we summarize the medicinal chemistry studies that led to the discovery of 1 and other chemotypes for which resistance maps to the NS5A protein and provide synopses of the profiles of many of the compounds currently in clinical trials. We also summarize what is currently known about the NS5A protein and the studies using NS5A RCIs and labeled analogues that are helping to illuminate aspects of both protein function and inhibitor interaction. We conclude with a synopsis of the results of notable clinical trials with HCV NS5A RCIs.

HCV NS5A replication complex inhibitors. Part 4. Optimization for genotype 1a replicon inhibitory activity.

A series of symmetrical E-stilbene prolinamides that originated from the library-synthesized lead 3 was studied with respect to HCV genotype 1a (G-1a) and genotype 1b (G-1b) replicon inhibition and selectivity against BVDV and cytotoxicity. SAR emerging from an examination of the prolinamide cap region revealed 11 to be a selective HCV NS5A inhibitor exhibiting submicromolar potency against both G-1a and G-1b replicons. Additional structural refinements resulted in the identification of 30 as a potent, dual G-1a/1b HCV NS5A inhibitor.

Hepatitis C virus NS5A replication complex inhibitors. Part 6: Discovery of a novel and highly potent biarylimidazole chemotype with inhibitory activity toward genotypes 1a and 1b replicons.

A medicinal chemistry campaign that was conducted to address a potential genotoxic liability associated with an aniline-derived scaffold in a series of HCV NS5A inhibitors with dual GT-1a/-1b inhibitory activity is described. Anilides 3b and 3c were used as vehicles to explore structural modifications that retained antiviral potency while removing the potential for metabolism-based unmasking of the embedded aniline. This effort resulted in the discovery of a highly potent biarylimidazole chemotype that established a potency benchmark in replicon assays, particularly toward HCV GT-1a, a strain with significant clinical importance. Securing potent GT-1a activity in a chemotype class lacking overt structural liabilities was a critical milestone in the effort to realize the full clinical potential of targeting the HCV NS5A protein.

Hepatitis C virus NS5A replication complex inhibitors: the discovery of daclatasvir.

The biphenyl derivatives 2 and 3 are prototypes of a novel class of NS5A replication complex inhibitors that demonstrate high inhibitory potency toward a panel of clinically relevant HCV strains encompassing genotypes 1-6. However, these compounds exhibit poor systemic exposure in rat pharmacokinetic studies after oral dosing. The structure-activity relationship investigations that improved the exposure properties of the parent bis-phenylimidazole chemotype, culminating in the identification of the highly potent NS5A replication complex inhibitor daclatasvir (33) are described. An element critical to success was the realization that the arylglycine cap of 2 could be replaced with an alkylglycine derivative and still maintain the high inhibitory potency of the series if accompanied with a stereoinversion, a finding that enabled a rapid optimization of exposure properties. Compound 33 had EC50 values of 50 and 9 pM toward genotype-1a and -1b replicons, respectively, and oral bioavailabilities of 38-108% in preclinical species. Compound 33 provided clinical proof-of-concept for the NS5A replication complex inhibitor class, and regulatory approval to market it with the NS3/4A protease inhibitor asunaprevir for the treatment of HCV genotype-1b infection has recently been sought in Japan.

A 96-well based analysis of replicon elimination with the HCV NS5A replication complex inhibitor daclatasvir.

A 96-well based replicon elimination and colony formation assay is presented for comparing the resistance barrier of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS5A replication complex inhibitor daclatasvir (DCV, BMS-790052) on three HCV genotypes (gts) in a proof of concept experimental protocol. The 96-well assay format provides both individual colony as well as population characterization and is readily applicable to other HCV direct-acting antiviral agents (DAAs). The assay provides an assessment of HCV replication levels over a 5log10 range by measuring a luciferase reporter resident in the HCV replicons. Individual colony status can be measured with a separate and compatible resazurin assay to assess relative host cell fitness following inhibitor treatments. The methods employed are non-toxic and leave intact isolatable colonies that can be used for phenotyping and genotyping. The utility of the assay is demonstrated by the identification and isolation of resistant variants as well as in the ranking of the relative resistance barrier for the replication complex inhibitor DCV for gts 1a, 1b and 2a. The format provides a quantitative ranking based upon luciferase activity and has the ability to monitor DAA resistance development over time for large numbers of compounds.

Inhibitors of HCV NS5A: From Iminothiazolidinones to Symmetrical Stilbenes.

The iminothiazolidinone BMS-858 (2) was identified as a specific inhibitor of HCV replication in a genotype 1b replicon assay via a high-throughput screening campaign. A more potent analogue, BMS-824 (18), was used in resistance mapping studies, which revealed that inhibitory activity was related to disrupting the function of the HCV nonstructural protein 5A. Despite the development of coherent and interpretable SAR, it was subsequently discovered that in DMSO 18 underwent an oxidation and structural rearrangement to afford the thiohydantoin 47, a compound with reduced HCV inhibitory activity. However, HPLC bioassay fractionation studies performed after incubation of 18 in assay media led to the identification of fractions containing a dimeric species 48 that exhibited potent antiviral activity. Excision of the key elements hypothesized to be responsible for antiviral activity based on SAR observations reduced 48 to a simplified, symmetrical, pharmacophore realized most effectively with the stilbene 55, a compound that demonstrated potent inhibition of HCV in a genotype 1b replicon with an EC50 = 86 pM.

Development of a cell-based high-throughput specificity screen using a hepatitis C virus-bovine viral diarrhea virus dual replicon assay.

The hepatitis C virus (HCV) replicon is a unique system for the development of a high-throughput screen (HTS), since the analysis of inhibitors requires the quantification of a decrease in a steady-state level of HCV RNA. HCV replicon replication is dependent on host cell factors, and any toxic effects may have a significant impact on HCV replicon replication. Therefore, determining the antiviral specificity of compounds presents a challenge for the identification of specific HCV inhibitors. Here we report the development of an HCV/bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) dual replicon assay suitable for HTS to address these issues. The HCV reporter enzyme is the endogenous NS3 protease contained within the HCV genome, while the BVDV reporter enzyme is a luciferase enzyme engineered into the BVDV genome. The HTS uses a mixture of HCV and BVDV replicon cell lines placed in the same well of a 96-well plate and isolated in the same cell backgrounds (Huh-7). The format consists of three separate but compatible assays: the first quantitates the amount of cytotoxicity based upon the conversion of Alamar blue dye via cellular enzymes, while the second indirectly quantitates HCV replicon replication through measurement of the amount of NS3 protease activity present. The final assay measures the amount of luciferase activity present from the BVDV replicon cells, as an indicator of the specificity of the test compounds. This HCV/BVDV dual replicon assay provides a reliable format to determine the potency and specificity of HCV replicon inhibitors.