Attenuation of Response to Repeated Drug Administration: A Proposal for Differentiating Tachyphylaxis and Tolerance.

Attenuation of drug response with repeated administration is referred to as tachyphylaxis or tolerance, though the distinction between these two is obscured through both their usage in the literature and imprecise definitions in common pharmacology texts. In this perspective, I propose that these terms be distinguished by the mechanisms underlying the attenuation of drug response. Specifically, tachyphylaxis should be reserved for attenuation that occurs in response to cellular depletion, whereas tolerance should be used to describe attenuation that arises from cellular adaptations. A framework for understanding behavioral tolerance, physiologic tolerance, and dispositional tolerance as distinct phenomena is also discussed. Using this framework, a classification of drugs exhibiting attenuation of drug response with repeated administration is presented. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Distinction between tachyphylaxis and tolerance is unclear in the literature. Nonetheless, a mechanistic basis for distinguishing these important terms has practical implications for managing or preventing attenuation of drug response with repeated administration.

CBD for the treatment of pain: What is the evidence?

Cannabidiol (CBD) has become widely available owing to recent changes in federal and state regulations. Although it is marketed for many health conditions, a recent survey found that the most common reason for taking CBD was for the treatment of pain. The endocannabinoid system (ECS) is present at essentially all levels of the anterolateral system, which is responsible for the perception and modulation of pain. In addition to its effects on the ECS, CBD interacts with other important signaling systems involved in the regulation of pain. Thus, there is a physiological basis to investigate CBD for the treatment of pain. Although CBD has been found to reduce pain in several animal models of inflammatory and neuropathic pain, studies to date lack sufficient rigor to provide more than modest evidence for the analgesic activity of CBD. To date, only 1 controlled clinical study has been published evaluating the effect of CBD in the treatment of pain. This study was fraught with numerous deficiencies in design, such that the results are uninformative. Because studies to date have found a high level of variability in the content of CBD products, product quality is a major concern. Although limited preclinical studies suggest that CBD may alter the metabolism of drugs metabolized by cytochromes P450, the lack of clinical studies makes it impossible to assess the clinical significance of these observations. At present, there is insufficient evidence to recommend CBD for the treatment of pain. The safety of the compound in patients with chronic illness remains untested, and pharmacists should caution patients about its use in the absence of clinical supervision.

Opioid-induced hyperalgesia: is it a clinically relevant phenomenon?

The potential for the development of opioid-induced hyperalgesia (OIH) provokes debate about whether long-term treatment with opioids is advisable and effective. If OIH develops during acute administration, will continuation of opioids actually make the pain worse? Hence, it is not surprising that OIH is part of the rationale used to promote deprescribing opioids in patients with chronic pain. But is there evidence that OIH is a clinically relevant phenomenon? This Commentary examines the evidence for OIH in randomized clinical trials in both the acute and chronic settings. Of critical importance in such an assessment is a trial design capable of differentiating OIH, tolerance, withdrawal-mediated pain sensitivity and worsening of the disease. However, studies published to date that purport to give evidence of OIH via experimentally induced pain all lack the rigour needed to differentiate these phenomena. Patient-reported measures of pain and analgesic consumption in these trials are not consistent with the presence of clinically significant OIH. At present, there is insufficient evidence from well-designed clinical trials that OIH is a clinically relevant phenomenon. Hence, while there are other reasons to avoid long-term use of opioids, the potential for the development of hyperalgesia during chronic opioid treatment is not a sound rationale for deprescribing these drugs in patients with chronic pain.

Biotransformation of drugs in human skin.

Although it is the largest organ of the human body, skin is often not considered in discussions of drug metabolism. However, there is growing evidence that most common drug-metabolizing enzymes are expressed in the skin. Evidence for expression of cytochromes P450, flavin monooxygenases, glutathione-S-transferases, N-acetyltransferases, and sulfotransferases in human skin and skin cells are presented. Additional discussion is focused on the evidence of actual metabolism of drugs. Finally, the potential clinical implications of metabolism within the skin are discussed briefly.

Effect of arylhydroxylamine metabolites of sulfamethoxazole and dapsone on stress signal expression in human keratinocytes.

The initiation of an immune response to small molecules is believed to require the release of stress/danger signals that activate resident dendritic cells, presumably secondary to the formation of reactive metabolites. We hypothesized that exposure to arylhydroxylamine metabolites of dapsone and sulfamethoxazole lead to the expression/release of numerous stress signals in the skin. To test this hypothesis, we examined the effect of these metabolites on the expression of selected heat shock proteins, uric acid, cytokines, adhesion molecules, and costimulatory molecules in normal human epidermal keratinocytes (NHEKs). NHEKs showed a time-dependent up-regulation of heat shock protein 70 and translocation of heat shock protein 27 when exposed to the arylhydroxylamine metabolites. In addition, the secretion of several proinflammatory cytokines was increased upon incubation of these cells with metabolite. In contrast, the uric acid concentration was not altered. Moreover, intercellular adhesion molecule-1, CD80, and CD86 expressions did not change when NHEKs were exposed to these reactive metabolites. Our data suggest that NHEKs selectively up-regulate certain danger signals when exposed to arylhydroxylamine metabolites. These signals may subsequently activate dendritic cells and initiate an immune response within skin.

Effect of pro-inflammatory cytokines on the toxicity of the arylhydroxylamine metabolites of sulphamethoxazole and dapsone in normal human keratinocytes.

Sulphonamides, such as sulphamethoxazole (SMX) and the related sulphone dapsone (DDS), show a higher incidence of cutaneous drug reactions (CDRs) in patients with the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) compared with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) negative patients. During HIV infection, pro-inflammatory cytokines such as interleukin-1 beta (IL-1 beta) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) are increased. We hypothesized that this increase in pro-inflammatory cytokines may increase the toxicity of the arylhydroxylamine metabolites of SMX (S-NOH) and DDS (D-NOH) in keratinocytes through a reduction in glutathione (GSH) content. We evaluated the effect of TNF-alpha on GSH levels in normal human epidermal keratinocytes (NHEK) and found a significant decrease in GSH after 24h. Pre-treatment with TNF-alpha also resulted in an increase in the recovery of D-NOH, but failed to alter drug-protein covalent adduct formation in NHEK. We also evaluated the effect of TNF-alpha, IL-1 beta, interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and conditioned media (obtained from monocytes stimulated with LPS) on the cytotoxicity of pre-formed arylhydroxylamine metabolites in NHEK. Priming cells with cytokines did not significantly alter the cytotoxicity of the metabolites. The effect of pre-treatment with TNF-alpha on reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation in NHEK was also determined. While ROS formation in NHEK was increased in the presence of D-NOH, TNF-alpha did not alter the level of ROS generation. Our data suggest that the level of GSH reduction induced by pro-inflammatory cytokines does not predispose NHEK to cellular toxicity from either S-NOH or D-NOH.

Immune response to xenobiotics in the skin: from contact sensitivity to drug allergy.

Skin is the most frequent target of adverse drug reactions. These cutaneous drug reactions (CDRs) show varied clinical manifestations ranging from mildly discomforting rashes to life-threatening Stevens-Johnson syndrome or toxic epidermal necrolysis. Most CDRs appear to be immune mediated, although the mechanism by which they are initiated remains unclear. In this review, current knowledge of the mechanisms by which xenobiotics provoke immune responses in the skin after epicutaneous administration and how similar reactions may occur after systemic routes are summarised. This review also discusses a variety of genetic or environmental factors that may determine the susceptibility of individuals towards immune responses in skin following drug exposure.

Reactive oxygen species generation and its role in the differential cytotoxicity of the arylhydroxylamine metabolites of sulfamethoxazole and dapsone in normal human epidermal keratinocytes.

Cutaneous drug reactions (CDR) are responsible for numerous minor to life-threatening complications. Though the exact mechanism for CDR is not completely understood, evidence suggests that bioactivation of drugs to reactive oxygen or nitrogen species is an important factor in the initiation of these reactions. Several CDR-inducing drugs having an arylamine functional group, such as sulfamethoxazole (SMX) and dapsone (DDS), undergo bioactivation to reactive arylhydroxylamine metabolites. These metabolites can generate cellular oxidative stress by forming reactive oxygen species (ROS). Several studies have demonstrated a higher cytotoxicity with DDS hydroxylamine (DDS-NOH) compared to SMX hydroxylamine (SMX-NOH). To investigate the role of differential ROS generation in the higher cytotoxicity of DDS-NOH, hydroxylamine metabolites of SMX and DDS were synthesized and ROS formation by these metabolites determined. DDS-NOH and its analogues/metabolites consistently resulted in higher ROS formation as compared to SMX-NOH. However, comparison of the ROS generation and cytotoxicity of a series of arylhydroxylamine analogues of DDS did not support a simple correlation between ROS generation and cell death. Numerous ROS scavengers were found to reduce metabolite-induced ROS formation, with differences in the potency between the agents. The decrease in DDS-NOH-induced ROS generation in NHEK with ascorbic acid, N-acetylcysteine, Trolox, and melatonin was 87, 86, 44, and 16%, respectively. Similarly, the cytotoxicity and adduct formation of DDS-NOH in NHEK was reduced in the presence of ascorbic acid. In summary, these studies show that arylhydroxylamine metabolites of SMX/DDS induce ROS generation in NHEK, though such generation is not directly related to cytotoxicity.

Acetylator phenotype and genotype in HIV-infected patients with and without sulfonamide hypersensitivity.

Adverse reactions to sulfonamides occur at a higher frequency in patients infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) than noninfected patients. Some studies have suggested that patients with the slow acetylator phenotype are predisposed to these reactions, whereas other studies suggest that the slow acetylator genotype is not a predisposing factor. To rationalize these seemingly contradictory observations, the authors determined the N-acetyltransferase 2 (NAT2) genotype and phenotype in patients with and without a history of hypersensitivity reactions to sulfonamides. HIV-infected patients with a history of a delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction to trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole were enrolled, along with a group of AIDS patients with no history of hypersensitivity (delayed or immediate). NAT2 phenotype was determined in both groups using dapsone, while the genotype was determined using a polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism assay. Ten of 14 patients (71%) with a history of hypersensitivity exhibited the slow acetylator phenotype, while 8 of 14 patients (57%) without such a history exhibited this same phenotype (odds ratio [OR] = 1.9, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.4-9.0; p = 0.69, Fisher's Exact Test). While 9 of 14 patients (64%) with a history of hypersensitivity exhibited a slow acetylator genotype, only 4 of 14 patients (29%) without such a history exhibited this genotype (ns). There were more instances of discordance between deduced and actual phenotype in the nonhypersensitive patients (n = 4) than in the hypersensitive patients (n = 1). The reported higher frequency of the slow acetylator phenotype among patients with a history of hypersensitivity to sulfonamides does not appear to be explained by metabolic changes that would cause discordance between acetylator genotype and phenotype.

Pharmacogenomics of acetaminophen in pediatric populations: a moving target.

Acetaminophen (APAP) is widely used as an over-the-counter fever reducer and pain reliever. However, the current therapeutic use of APAP is not optimal. The inter-patient variability in both efficacy and toxicity limits the use of this drug. This is particularly an issue in pediatric populations, where tools for predicting drug efficacy and developmental toxicity are not well established. Variability in toxicity between age groups may be accounted for by differences in metabolism, transport, and the genetics behind those differences. While pharmacogenomics has been revolutionizing the paradigm of pharmacotherapy for many drugs, its application in pediatric populations faces significant challenges given the dynamic ontogenic changes in cellular and systems physiology. In this review we focused on the ontogenesis of the regulatory pathways involved in the disposition of APAP and on the variability between pediatric, adolescent, and adult patients. We also summarize important polymorphisms of the pharmacogenes associated with APAP metabolism. Pharmacogenetic studies in pediatric APAP treatment are also reviewed. We conclude that while a consensus in pharmacogenetic management of APAP in pediatric populations has not been achieved, a systems biology based strategy for comprehensively understanding the ontogenic regulatory pathway as well as the interaction between age and genetic variations are particularly necessary in order to address this question.

Advancing pharmacist scholarship and research within academic pharmacy.

An appropriate balance between teaching, scholarship, and service is important for a faculty member to have a satisfying and successful career. The relative emphasis on each area normally changes during the course of a career. Although some level of scholarly output is an ongoing and fundamental expectation of all faculty members, this activity is too often given low priority, particularly among faculty members in practice areas who may have a minimal background in research and large demands on their time for teaching and clinical service. Addressing this issue requires establishing a shared commitment between administrators and faculty members, as well as identifying or developing education programs that will ensure research competence for practice faculty members. This paper provides insights into the role that scholarship and research should have for all pharmacy faculty members and provides suggestions for how to better advance this critical component within academic pharmacy.

Detection of haptenated proteins in organotypic human skin explant cultures exposed to dapsone.

Bioactivation of parent drug to reactive metabolite(s) followed by protein haptenation has been suggested to be a critical step in the elicitation of cutaneous drug reactions. Although liver is believed to be the primary organ of drug bioactivation quantitatively, other organs including skin may also metabolize drugs. Cultured human epidermal keratinocytes and dermal fibroblasts have been shown to be capable of bioactivating sulfonamides and sulfones, giving rise to haptenated proteins. It is, however, unclear whether metabolic events in these isolated cells reflect bioactivation in vivo. Hence, split-thickness human skin explants were exposed to dapsone (DDS) or its arylhydroxylamine metabolite (dapsone hydroxylamine, D-NOH) and probed for protein haptenation. DDS and D-NOH were applied either epicutaneously or mixed in the medium (to mimic its entry into skin from the systemic circulation). DDS-protein adducts were readily detected in skin explants exposed to either DDS or D-NOH. Adducts were detected mainly in the upper epidermal region in response to epicutaneous application, whereas adducts were formed all over the explants when DDS/D-NOH were mixed in the culture medium. In addition, adducts were visible in HLA-DR+ cells, indicating their presence in the dendritic cell population in the skin. Our results demonstrate the ability of intact human skin to bioactivate DDS leading to protein haptenation.

Formation and uptake of arylhydroxylamine-haptenated proteins in human dendritic cells.

Bioactivation of sulfonamides and the subsequent formation of haptenated proteins is believed to be a critical step in the development of hypersensitivity reactions to these drugs. Numerous lines of evidence suggest that the presence of such adducts in dendritic cells (DCs) migrating to draining lymph nodes is essential for the development of cutaneous reactions to xenobiotics. Our objective was to determine the ability of human DCs to form drug-protein covalent adducts when exposed to sulfamethoxazole (SMX), dapsone (DDS), or their arylhydroxylamine metabolites [sulfamethoxazole hydroxylamine (S-NOH) and dapsone hydroxylamine (D-NOH)] and to take up preformed adduct. Naive and immature CD34+ KG-1 cells were incubated with SMX, DDS, or metabolites. Formation of haptenated proteins was probed using confocal microscopy and ELISA. Cells were also incubated with preformed adduct (drug-bovine serum albumin conjugate), and uptake was determined using confocal microscopy. Both naive and immature KG-1 cells were able to bioactivate DDS, forming drug-protein adducts, whereas cells showed very little protein haptenation when exposed to SMX. Exposure to S-NOH or D-NOH resulted in protein haptenation in both cell types. Both immature and naive KG-1 cells were able to take up preformed haptenated proteins. Thus, DCs may acquire haptenated proteins associated with drugs via intracellular bioactivation, uptake of reactive metabolites, or uptake of adduct formed and released by adjacent cells (e.g., keratinocytes).

Enhanced xenobiotic-induced hepatotoxicity and Kupffer cell activation by restraint-induced stress.

We tested the hypothesis that environmental stress is a predisposing factor for liver injury by examining the effect of acute restraint on liver injury provoked by carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) and allyl alcohol. Mice were immobilized using Plexiglas restraint cages, producing a form of psychogenic stress, whereas other animals were allowed to roam free. Serum alanine aminotransferase levels were elevated significantly in restrained animals after administration of varying doses of CCl4 or allyl alcohol that did not produce liver injury in unrestrained animals. This enhanced liver injury after CCl4 was seen in both male and female mice. The duration of acute restraint was found to be important because a period of 2.5 h of restraint enhanced hepatotoxicity, whereas shorter periods of restraint did not significantly increase liver injury. Serum corticosterone concentrations increased, whereas hepatic glutathione content decreased during and after acute restraint. In addition, delay in administration of CCl4 until 5 h after completion of restraint also produced an elevated level of liver injury compared with that seen in free roaming animals. Immunohistochemical examination of the livers showed significantly enhanced Kupffer cell activation in restrained mice compared with that of free roaming mice. These observations suggest that induction of psychogenic stress may increase the susceptibility to liver injury observed with classic hepatotoxicants and may represent an important predisposing factor to liver injury after xenobiotic exposure. The underlying mechanism seems to be increased macrophage activation in the liver, which may subsequently sensitize hepatocytes to xenobiotics and thus enhance hepatotoxicity.