Characteristics of the Compassionate Use Program in Japan: An Analysis of Expanded Access Clinical Trials from 2016 to 2021.

Compassionate use is a system that provides patients with exceptional access to investigational new drugs to treat life-threatening diseases that have no effective conventional treatments. The purpose of this study was to characterize and assess the current status of the compassionate use program's application in Japan by evaluating expanded access clinical trials (EACTs) conducted between 2016 and 2021. In this study, a data set containing all EACTs, and pivotal clinical trials (PCTs) conducted in Japan between February 2016 and April 2021 was obtained from the Pharmaceutical and Medical Devices Agency, systemically reviewed, and analyzed. During the 5 years since EACTs began in Japan, out of 2,031 PCTs, 31 EACTs were conducted in Japan. Twenty-four trials (77.4%) of the 31 EACTs used anticancer drugs and 5 of those trials (16.1%) were conducted in children. Furthermore, we conducted an EACT survey for drugs with a high degree of social and patient demands as recommended in the EACT notification. Among the 2,031 PCTs, we found 152 trials with high degree of social and patient demands. Of these, EACT was implemented in 17 trials (11.2%). Days from the start of the EACT to the submission of new drug applications and the approval were 9.0 (67.0-56.5) and 208.0 (172.8-308.8) days, respectively. Of the 31 EACTs conducted, 24 (77.4%) drugs have been approved as of August 2021. This first comprehensive study on EACTs clarified the current status and issues of Japan's compassionate use system and the 5 years since the program initiated.

Assessment of Drugs Approved by Public Knowledge-Based Applications (Kouchi-shinsei) During the Last Two Decades in Japan.

Public knowledge-based application ("Kouchi-shinsei" in Japanese) is unique to Japan, implemented to eliminate the off-label use of unapproved indications, dosages, and administrations because of drug lag. The guidance for public knowledge-based application was issued in 1999. This study comprehensively investigated the trends of items approved by public knowledge-based application in Japan during the last 2 decades. Prescription drugs approved from January 2000 to December 2019 were surveyed. In Japan, 1,855 drugs were approved within the target survey period. Among them, 219 (11.8%) were approved by public knowledge-based application. Considering the changes in the number of items approved by public knowledge-based application over the years, the number of items approved in 2000 was 7, reaching a maximum of 34 items in 2011, and decreased after that, 8 items were approved in 2019. The regulatory characteristics of drugs approved by public knowledge-based application and those of other drugs were compared. By public knowledge-based application, more anticancer and pediatric drugs were approved (P < 0.001), and only one drug for orphan diseases was approved (P < 0.001). In addition, the review time of public knowledge-based applications was significantly shorter than that of normal applications regardless of time point. The approval system using public knowledge-based application began in 2000, following issuance of the "Guidance for off-label use of prescription drugs." Furthermore, the approved items were mostly drugs for cancer, infectious diseases, and pediatric drugs. We anticipate the promotion of public knowledge-based application to accommodate the approval of drugs for orphan diseases.