Barriers to the quality delivery of seasonal malaria chemoprevention in Chad and Burkina Faso: a qualitative exploration of caregivers and community distributors' perspectives.

BACKGROUND: Recommended since 2012 by the World Health Organization (WHO), seasonal malaria chemoprevention (SMC) is a community-based intervention to prevent malaria in children in African regions where malaria transmission follows a seasonal pattern. Following the publication of consolidated WHO guidelines for malaria, SMC is expected to reach more children in new geographies in future years. Though SMC has been shown to reduce malaria-related morbidity and mortality, there is potential for quality improvement of the intervention implementation. Assisted by ten quality standards from a framework developed by Malaria Consortium, this paper aims to better understand the quality of SMC implementation and identify potential barriers to quality delivery of SMC. METHODS: A qualitative thematic analysis on data collected after the annual SMC rounds implemented in Burkina Faso and Chad in 2019 was conducted. Sixteen focus group discussions conducted with caregivers and community distributors were analysed. Three selected quality standards for SMC delivery; planning and enumeration; community engagement; and administration of SMC medicines provided overarching quality themes under which subthemes were identified. RESULTS: Eight subthemes relating to the three quality standards were identified. Although SMC was well accepted by communities in both settings, common barriers to the quality delivery of SMC were identified including difficulty ensuring adherence to the SMC administration protocol; difficulties reaching mobile populations; concerns around adverse drug reactions; rumours, and concerns about SMC safety; and community distributors' working conditions. Context-specific barriers included: the suboptimal timeliness of the SMC round in Burkina Faso, and the lack of involvement of female caregivers in mobilization activities in Chad. CONCLUSION: In the context of increased adoption of SMC, this paper provides relevant insights and recommendations for the improved implementation of SMC programmes. These include the integration of strategies addressing communities' concerns around adverse drug reactions, gender-specific mobilization strategies, and attention to community distributors' working conditions. It also highlights the importance and utility of further, robust research on the quality of SMC delivery.

RéSUMé EN FRANçAIS: BACKGROUND: Recommandée depuis 2012 par l'Organisation mondiale de la santé (OMS), la chimioprévention du paludisme saisonnier (CPS) est une intervention communautaire visant à prévenir le paludisme chez les enfants dans les régions d'Afrique où la transmission du paludisme suit un schéma saisonnier. Suite à la publication des lignes directrices consolidées de l'OMS sur le paludisme, la CPS devrait toucher davantage d'enfants dans de nouvelles zones géographiques dans les années à venir. Bien qu'il ait été démontré que la CPS réduisait la morbidité et la mortalité liées au paludisme, il y a du potentiel pour améliorer la qualité de l'implémentation l'intervention. En s'appuyant sur un cadre de normes de qualité de la CPS développé par le Malaria Consortium, cette publication vise à mieux comprendre la qualité de la mise en œuvre de la CPS et à identifier les obstacles potentiels à la qualité de la mise en œuvre de la CPS. METHODS: Une étude qualitative basée sur l'analyse secondaire des données collectées après les tournées annuelles du SMC mises en œuvre au Burkina Faso et au Tchad en 2019 a été menée. Une analyse thématique de 16 discussions de groupe menées avec des parents/tuteurs et des distributeurs communautaires a été faite. Trois des éléments clés du cadre des normes de qualité pour le déploiement de la CPS ont fourni les thèmes de qualité principaux sous lesquels les sous-thèmes identifiés ont été placés. RéSULTATS: Huit sous-thèmes relatifs aux normes de qualité ; la planification, la sensibilisation et l'engagement des communautés ainsi que l'administration des médicaments de la CPS ont été identifiés. Bien que la CPS ait été bien acceptée par les communautés dans les deux contextes, des obstacles communs à la qualité du déploiement de la CPS ont été identifiés, notamment : la difficulté d'assurer le respect du protocole d'administration de la CPS; atteindre les populations mobiles ; les préoccupations concernant les effets indésirables des médicaments ; les rumeurs et les préoccupations concernant le SMC; et les conditions de travail des distributeurs communautaires. D'autres barrières spécifiques au contexte de déploiement ont été identifiées, telles que le choix sous-optimal de la période de déploiement au Burkina Faso ou le manque d'implication des mères/tutrices dans les activités de mobilisation au Tchad. CONCLUSION: Dans le contexte de l'adoption croissante de la CPS, cette publication fournit des informations et des recommandations pertinentes pour l'amélioration de la mise en œuvre des programmes de CMS, telles que l'intégration de stratégies répondant aux préoccupations des communautés concernant les effets indésirables des médicaments, les stratégies de mobilisation spécifiques au genre, et/ou l'attention portée aux conditions de travail des distributeurs communautaires. Cette publication souligne également l'importance et l'utilité des recherches en cours sur la qualité du déploiement de la CPS.

RESUMO EM PORTUGUêS: INTRODUçãO: Recomendada desde 2012 pela Organização Mundial de Saúde (OMS), a quimioprevenção sazonal do paludismo (SMC) é uma intervenção de base comunitária para prevenir o paludismo em crianças em zonas da África onde a transmissão do paludismo segue um padrão sazonal. Após a publicação das diretrizes consolidadas da OMS sobre o paludismo, espera-se que a SMC chegue a mais crianças em novas zonas geográficas nos próximos anos. Embora se tenha demonstrado que a SMC reduz a morbilidade e a mortalidade causadas pelo paludismo, há potencial para melhorar a qualidade da implementação da intervenção. Com ajuda dum quadro de padrões de qualidade para a SMC desenvolvido pelo Malaria Consortium, a presente publicação visa compreender melhor a qualidade da implementação da SMC e identificar potenciais barreiras à qualidade da implementação da SMC. MéTODOS: Foi realizado um estudo qualitativo baseado na análise secundária dos dados recolhidos após as rondas anuais da SMC implementadas no Burkina Faso e no Chade em 2019. Foi efectuado uma análise temática de 16 discussões de grupos focais realizadas com cuidadores e distribuidores comunitários. Tres padrões do quadro de normas de qualidade para a implementação da SMC forneceu os principais temas de qualidade sob os quais os subtemas identificados foram colocados. RESULTADOS: Foram identificados oito sub-temas relacionados com padrões de qualidade; planeamento; sensibilização e envolvimento da comunidade; e administração de drogas da SMC. Embora a SMC tenha sido bem aceita pelas comunidades em ambos os contextos, foram identificadas barreiras comuns à implementação duma SMC de qualidade, incluindo: a dificuldade de assegurar o cumprimento do protocolo de administração da SMC; atingir populações móveis; preocupações com reacções adversas aos medicamentos; rumores e preocupações com a SMC; e as condições de trabalho dos distribuidores comunitários. Foram identificados outros obstáculos específicos ao contexto de implantação, tais como a escolha subaproveitada do período de implantação no Burkina Faso ou a falta de envolvimento das cuidadoras femininas nas actividades de mobilização no Chade. CONCLUSãO: No contexto do aumento da adopção da SMC, esta publicação fornece informações e recomendações relevantes para melhorar a implementação de programas de SMC, tais como estratégias integradoras que abordam as preocupações da comunidade sobre reacções adversas aos medicamentos, estratégias de mobilização específicas de género, e/ou atenção às condições de trabalho dos distribuidores comunitários. Salienta igualmente a importância e a utilidade das investigaçãos em curso sobre a qualidade da implementação da SMC.

Contribution and performance of female Community-Directed Distributors in the treatment of onchocerciasis with Ivermectin in Sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review.

The African Program for Onchocerciasis Control (APOC) was launched in 1995 with the main goal being to boost the fight against onchocerciasis in Africa. In 2011, over 80 million people benefited from this intervention thanks to the contribution of 268.718 Community-Directed Distributors (CDD). These significant results obscure the role of women CDD in this fight. Indeed, the insufficient involvement of female CDD has been identified as a concern by the APOC partners early in the program. The present study aims to assess the contribution and performance of women involved in a strategy to control onchocerciasis by community-directed treatment with ivermectin in sub Saharan Africa. We searched the following electronic databases from January 1995 to July 2013: Medline, Embase (Excerpta Medica Database), CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature), LILAS (Latin American and Caribbean Literature on Health Sciences), International Bibliography of Social Sciences, Social Services Abstracts, and Sociological Abstracts. Two research team members independently conducted data extraction from the final sample of articles by using a pre-established data extraction sheet. The primary outcome was the contribution of female CDD in the control of onchocerciasis by community-directed treatment with Ivermectin. Of 25 hits, 7 papers met the inclusion criteria. For the management of onchocerciasis, female CDDs are elected by the health committee from the communities they will serve. The significant proportion of those treated (about 61%) were women, although only 24% of CDDs were women. Many community members reported that women were more committed, persuasive and more patient than men in the distribution of ivermectin. Some studies have identified underutilization of female CDD as one reason for the limited effectiveness or, in some cases, pure failure related to the distribution of Ivermectin interventions in the fight against onchocerciasis in sub-Saharan Africa. Evidence from this review suggests that female CDD contribute to the treatment of onchocerciasis with Ivermectin in sub-Saharan Africa. Large-scale rigorous studies including Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are needed to compare Community-Directed intervention involving men and women CDDs.