Oligomerization-driven avidity correlates with SARS-CoV-2 cellular binding and inhibition.

Cellular processes are controlled by the thermodynamics of the underlying biomolecular interactions. Frequently, structural investigations use one monomeric binding partner, while ensemble measurements of binding affinities generally yield one affinity representative of a 1:1 interaction, despite the majority of the proteome consisting of oligomeric proteins. For example, viral entry and inhibition in SARS-CoV-2 involve a trimeric spike surface protein, a dimeric angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) cell-surface receptor and dimeric antibodies. Here, we reveal that cooperativity correlates with infectivity and inhibition as opposed to 1:1 binding strength. We show that ACE2 oligomerizes spike more strongly for more infectious variants, while exhibiting weaker 1:1 affinity. Furthermore, we find that antibodies use induced oligomerization both as a primary inhibition mechanism and to enhance the effects of receptor-site blocking. Our results suggest that naive affinity measurements are poor predictors of potency, and introduce an antibody-based inhibition mechanism for oligomeric targets. More generally, they point toward a much broader role of induced oligomerization in controlling biomolecular interactions.

Lifting the Concentration Limit of Mass Photometry by PEG Nanopatterning.

Mass photometry (MP) is a rapidly growing optical technique for label-free mass measurement of single biomolecules in solution. The underlying measurement principle provides numerous advantages over ensemble-based methods but has been limited to low analyte concentrations due to the need to uniquely and accurately quantify the binding of individual molecules to the measurement surface, which results in diffraction-limited spots. Here, we combine nanoparticle lithography with surface PEGylation to substantially lower surface binding, resulting in a 2 orders of magnitude improvement in the upper concentration limit associated with mass photometry. We demonstrate the facile tunability of degree of passivation, enabling measurements at increased analyte concentrations. These advances provide access to protein-protein interactions in the high nanomolar to low micromolar range, substantially expanding the application space of mass photometry.

Surface passivation and functionalisation for mass photometry.

Interferometric scattering (iSCAT) microscopy enables the label-free observation of biomolecules. Consequently, single-particle imaging and tracking with the iSCAT-based method known as mass photometry (MP) is a growing area of study. However, establishing reliable cover glass passivation and functionalisation methods is crucial to reduce nonspecific binding and prepare surfaces for in vitro single-molecule binding experiments. Existing protocols for fluorescence microscopy can contain strongly scattering or mobile components, which make them impractical for MP-based microscopy. In this study, we characterise several different surface coatings using MP. We present approaches for cover glass passivation using 3-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (APTES) and polyethylene glycol (PEG, 2k) along with functionalisation via a maleimide-thiol linker. These coatings are compatible with water or salt buffers, and show low background scattering; thus, we are able to measure proteins as small as 60 kDa. In this technical note, we offer a surface preparation suitable for in vitro experiments with MP.

Automated Mass Photometry of Adeno-Associated Virus Vectors from Crude Cell Extracts.

Mass photometry (MP) is a fast and simple analysis method for the determination of the proportions of subpopulations in an AAV sample. It is label-free and requires minimal sample volumes between 5-10 µL, which makes it a promising candidate over orthogonal techniques such as analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC), cryo-transmission electron microscopy (Cryo-TEM) or charge-detection mass spectrometry (CDMS). However, these methods are limited in their application to purified samples only. Here we developed a purification step based on single-domain monospecific antibody fragments immobilised on either a poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) resin or on magnetic beads prior to MP analysis that allows the quantification of empty, partially filled, full and overfull AAV vectors in crude cell extracts. This is aimed at identifying potentially promising harvest conditions that yield large numbers of filled AAV vectors during the early stages of the viral vector development platform, e.g., the type of transfection reagent used. Furthermore, we provide a direct comparison of the automated and manual handling of the mass photometer with respect to the quantities of AAV subspecies, molar mass of the capsid and payload, and highlight the differences between the "buffer-free" sample measurement and the "buffer-dilution" mode. In addition, we provide information on which candidates to use for calibration and demonstrate the limitations of the mass photometer with respect to the estimation of the capsid titer.

Native Proteomics by Capillary Zone Electrophoresis-Mass Spectrometry.

Native proteomics measures endogenous proteoforms and protein complexes under a near physiological condition using native mass spectrometry (nMS) coupled with liquid-phase separations. Native proteomics should provide the most accurate bird's-eye view of proteome dynamics within cells, which is fundamental for understanding almost all biological processes. nMS has been widely employed to characterize well-purified protein complexes. However, there are only very few trials of utilizing nMS to measure proteoforms and protein complexes in a complex sample (i.e., a whole cell lysate). Here, we pioneer the native proteomics measurement of large proteoforms or protein complexes up to 400 kDa from a complex proteome via online coupling of native capillary zone electrophoresis (nCZE) to an ultra-high mass range (UHMR) Orbitrap mass spectrometer. The nCZE-MS technique enabled the measurement of a 115-kDa standard protein complex while consuming only about 0.1 ng of protein material. nCZE-MS analysis of an E.coli cell lysate detected 72 proteoforms or protein complexes in a mass range of 30-400 kDa in a single run while consuming only 50-ng protein material. The mass distribution of detected proteoforms or protein complexes agreed well with that from mass photometry measurement. This work represents a technical breakthrough in native proteomics for measuring complex proteomes.

Anomalous Oligomerization Behavior of E. coli Aquaporin Z in Detergent and in Nanodiscs.

Aquaporins are tetrameric integral membrane proteins that act as water channels, and can also permeabilize membranes to other solutes. The monomer appears to be the functional form despite all aquaporins being organized as tetramers, which therefore must provide a clear functional advantage. In addition to this quaternary organization, some aquaporins can act as adhesion molecules in membrane junctions, when tetramers located in opposing membranes interact via their extracellular domains. These stacked forms have been observed in a range of aquaporins, whether using lipidic membrane environments, in electron crystallography, or using detergent micelles, in single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). In the latter technique, structural studies can be performed when the aquaporin is reconstituted into nanodiscs of lipids that are surrounded by a protein scaffold. During attempts to study E. coli Aquaporin Z (AqpZ), we have found that in some conditions these nanodiscs tend to form filaments that appear to be either thicker head-to-tail or thinner side-to-side stacks of nanodiscs. Nanodisc oligomerization was observed using orthogonal analytical techniques analytical ultra-centrifugation and mass photometry, although the nature of the oligomers (head-to-tail or side-to-side) could not be determined. Using the latter technique, the AqpZ tetramer itself formed oligomers of increasing size when solubilized only in detergent, which is consistent with multiple stacking of AqpZ tetramers. We observed images consistent with both of these filaments in negative staining EM conditions, but only thicker filaments in cryo-EM conditions. We hypothesize that the apparent nanodisc side-to-side arrangement that can only be visualized in negative staining conditions is related to artifacts due to the sample preparation. Filaments of any kind were not observed in EM when nanodiscs did not contain AqpZ, or after addition of detergent into the nanodisc cryo-EM preparation, at concentrations that did not disrupt nanodisc formation. To our knowledge, these filaments have not been observed in nanodiscs preparations of other membrane proteins. AqpZ, like other aquaporins has a charge asymmetry between the cytoplasmic (more positive) and the extracellular sides, which may explain the likely head-to-tail stacking observed, both in nanodisc preparations and also in detergent micelles.

Quantification of Empty, Partially Filled and Full Adeno-Associated Virus Vectors Using Mass Photometry.

Adeno-associated viruses (AAV) are one of the most commonly used vehicles in gene therapies for the treatment of rare diseases. During the AAV manufacturing process, particles with little or no genetic material are co-produced alongside the desired AAV capsid containing the transgene of interest. Because of the potential adverse health effects of these byproducts, they are considered impurities and need to be monitored carefully. To date, analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and charge-detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) are used to quantify these subspecies. However, they are associated with long turnaround times, low sample throughput and complex data analysis. Mass photometry (MP) is a fast and label-free orthogonal technique which is applicable to multiple serotypes without the adaption of method parameters. Furthermore, it can be operated with capsid titers as low as 8 × 1010 cp mL-1 with a CV < 5% using just 10 µL total sample volume. Here we demonstrate that mass photometry can be used as an orthogonal method to AUC to accurately quantify the proportions of empty, partially filled, full and overfull particles in AAV samples, especially in cases where ion-exchange chromatography yields no separation of the populations. In addition, it can be used to confirm the molar mass of the packaged genomic material in filled AAV particles.

Discovery of a novel lactate dehydrogenase tetramerization domain using epitope mapping and peptides.

Despite being initially regarded as a metabolic waste product, lactate is now considered to serve as a primary fuel for the tricarboxylic acid cycle in cancer cells. At the core of lactate metabolism, lactate dehydrogenases (LDHs) catalyze the interconversion of lactate to pyruvate and as such represent promising targets in cancer therapy. However, direct inhibition of the LDH active site is challenging from physicochemical and selectivity standpoints. However, LDHs are obligate tetramers. Thus, targeting the LDH tetrameric interface has emerged as an appealing strategy. In this work, we examine a dimeric construct of truncated human LDH to search for new druggable sites. We report the identification and characterization of a new cluster of interactions in the LDH tetrameric interface. Using nanoscale differential scanning fluorimetry, chemical denaturation, and mass photometry, we identified several residues (E62, D65, L71, and F72) essential for LDH tetrameric stability. Moreover, we report a family of peptide ligands based on this cluster of interactions. We next demonstrated these ligands to destabilize tetrameric LDHs through binding to this new tetrameric interface using nanoscale differential scanning fluorimetry, NMR water-ligand observed via gradient spectroscopy, and microscale thermophoresis. Altogether, this work provides new insights on the LDH tetrameric interface as well as valuable pharmacological tools for the development of LDH tetramer disruptors.

Single-molecule fluorescence-based approach reveals novel mechanistic insights into human small heat shock protein chaperone function.

Small heat shock proteins (sHsps) are a family of ubiquitous intracellular molecular chaperones; some sHsp family members are upregulated under stress conditions and play a vital role in protein homeostasis (proteostasis). It is commonly accepted that these chaperones work by trapping misfolded proteins to prevent their aggregation; however, fundamental questions regarding the molecular mechanism by which sHsps interact with misfolded proteins remain unanswered. The dynamic and polydisperse nature of sHsp oligomers has made studying them challenging using traditional biochemical approaches. Therefore, we have utilized a single-molecule fluorescence-based approach to observe the chaperone action of human alphaB-crystallin (αBc, HSPB5). Using this approach we have, for the first time, determined the stoichiometries of complexes formed between αBc and a model client protein, chloride intracellular channel 1. By examining the dispersity and stoichiometries of these complexes over time, and in response to different concentrations of αBc, we have uncovered unique and important insights into a two-step mechanism by which αBc interacts with misfolded client proteins to prevent their aggregation.

Standard protocol for mass photometry experiments.

Mass photometry (MP) is a relatively new experimental technique with a quickly expanding list of applications. Using optical detection, MP measures the mass of individual molecules to obtain molecular mass distributions of proteins and other biomolecules in solution. The combination of speed, sensitivity, and very low sample consumption with label- and immobilization-free detection sets MP apart from other analytical methods. An increasing number of laboratories incorporates mass photometry as a routine sample analysis technique. However, MP measurements can sometimes be challenging, especially for users without previous experience with single-molecule techniques. Here, we present a protocol for the determination of protein molecular mass distributions by MP. It describes the sample and materials preparation as well as data collection and analysis. The advantages and limitations of this technique and the potential sources of artifacts are also given. This protocol can be used by new MP users and serve as a checklist for laboratories routinely performing MP experiments to guide consistent data collection and documentation.

Quantifying Protein-Protein Interactions by Molecular Counting with Mass Photometry.

Interactions between biomolecules control the processes of life in health and their malfunction in disease, making their characterization and quantification essential. Immobilization- and label-free analytical techniques are desirable because of their simplicity and minimal invasiveness, but they struggle with quantifying tight interactions. Here, we show that mass photometry can accurately count, distinguish by molecular mass, and thereby reveal the relative abundances of different unlabelled biomolecules and their complexes in mixtures at the single-molecule level. These measurements determine binding affinities over four orders of magnitude at equilibrium for both simple and complex stoichiometries within minutes, as well as the associated kinetics. These results introduce mass photometry as a rapid, simple and label-free method for studying sub-micromolar binding affinities, with potential for extension towards a universal approach for characterizing complex biomolecular interactions.

Dissecting FOXP2 Oligomerization and DNA Binding.

Protein-protein and protein-substrate interactions are critical to function and often depend on factors that are difficult to disentangle. Herein, a combined biochemical and biophysical approach, based on electrically switchable DNA biochips and single-molecule mass analysis, was used to characterize the DNA binding and protein oligomerization of the transcription factor, forkhead box protein P2 (FOXP2). FOXP2 contains domains commonly involved in nucleic-acid binding and protein oligomerization, such as a C2 H2 -zinc finger (ZF), and a leucine zipper (LZ), whose roles in FOXP2 remain largely unknown. We found that the LZ mediates FOXP2 dimerization via coiled-coil formation but also contributes to DNA binding. The ZF contributes to protein dimerization when the LZ coiled-coil is intact, but it is not involved in DNA binding. The forkhead domain (FHD) is the key driver of DNA binding. Our data contributes to understanding the mechanisms behind the transcriptional activity of FOXP2.

A dynamic compositional equilibrium governs mRNA recognition by eIF3.

Eukaryotic translation initiation factor (eIF) 3 is a multi-subunit protein complex that binds both ribosomes and messenger RNAs (mRNAs) to drive a diverse set of mechanistic steps during translation of an mRNA into the protein it encodes. And yet, a unifying framework explaining how eIF3 performs these numerous activities is lacking. Using single-molecule light scattering microscopy, we demonstrate that Saccharomyces cerevisiae eIF3 is in dynamic exchange between the full complex, subcomplexes, and subunits. By extending our microscopy approach to an in vitro reconstituted eIF3 and complementing it with biochemical assays, we define the subspecies comprising this dynamic compositional equilibrium and show that mRNA binding by eIF3 is not driven by the full complex but instead by the eIF3a subunit within eIF3a-containing subcomplexes. Our findings provide a mechanistic model for the role of eIF3 in mRNA recruitment and establish a mechanistic framework for explaining and investigating the other activities of eIF3.

Orthogonal characterization of rAAV9 reveals unexpected transgene heterogeneity.

Recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) is the most widely used viral vector for in vivo human gene therapy. To ensure safety and efficacy of gene therapy products, a comprehensive analytical profile of the rAAVs is needed, which provides crucial information for therapeutic development and manufacturing. Besides information on rAAV quantities and possible contaminating DNA and protein species, assessing rAAV quality is of utmost importance. In vitro biopotency and methods to determine the full/empty ratio of rAAV capsids are commonly applied, but methods to assess the integrity of the viral genome are still rarely used. Here we describe an orthogonal approach to characterize rAAV quality. Two biologically different rAAV9s from different stages of the bioprocess, generated each with two different transfection reagents, were investigated. In vitro biopotency tests in all cases demonstrated that rAAV9s generated with transfection reagent FectoVIR® possessed a higher biological activity. Mass-based analytical methods, such as sedimentation velocity analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC) and mass photometry, showed a high share of full capsids (>80 %) at late process stages but did not detect any differences in the rAAV9s from the different transfection reagents. Multiplex dPCR and Nanopore long-read sequencing both demonstrated that, also in late-stage process samples, sample heterogeneity was relatively high with a rather small share of full-length transgenes of ∼10-40 %. Intriguingly, both methods detected a higher share of complete transgenes in rAAV9 generated with transfection reagent FectoVIR® instead of Polyethylenimine (PEI), and thereby explain the differences already observed in the biopotency assays. This study therefore emphasizes the necessity to utilize multiple, orthogonal methods to gain a better understanding of recombinantly manufactured AAVs.

Probing recombinant AAV capsid integrity and genome release after thermal stress by mass photometry.

Adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) are gaining traction as delivery vehicles for gene therapy although the molecular understanding of AAV-transgene release is still limited. Typically, the process of viral uncoating is investigated (in vitro) through thermal stress, revealing capsid disintegration at elevated temperatures. To assess the (in)stability of different empty and filled AAV preparations, we used the light-scattering-based interferometric microscopy technique of mass photometry that, on a single-particle basis, determines the molecular weight of AAVs. By introducing a heat-stable DNA plasmid as an internal standard, we quantitatively probed the impact of heat on AAVs. Generally, empty AAVs exhibited greater heat resistance than genome-filled particles. Our data also indicate that upon DNA release, the capsids do not transform into empty AAVs, but seem to aggregate or disintegrate. Strikingly, some AAVs exhibited an intermediate state with disrupted capsids but preserved bound genome, a feature that experimentally only emerged following incubation with a nuclease. Our data demonstrate that the thermal uncoating process is highly AAV specific (i.e., can be influenced by serotype, genome, host system). We argue that nuclease treatment in combination with MP can be used as an additional analytical tool for assessing structural integrity of recombinant and/or clinical AAV vectors.

Evaluation of size-exclusion chromatography, multi-angle light scattering detection and mass photometry for the characterization of mRNA.

The recent approval of messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) as vaccine to combat the COVID-19 pandemic has been a scientific turning point. Today, the applicability of mRNA is being demonstrated beyond infectious diseases, for example in cancer immunotherapy, protein replacement therapy and gene editing. mRNA is produced by in vitro transcription (IVT) from a linear DNA template and modified at the 3' and 5' ends to improve translational efficiency and stability. Co-existing impurities such as RNA fragments and double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), amongst others, can drastically impact mRNA quality and efficacy. In this study, size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) is evaluated for the characterization of IVT-mRNA. The effect of mobile phase composition (ionic strength and organic modifier), pH, column temperature and pore size (300 Å, 1000 Å, and 2000 Å) on the separation performance and structural integrity of IVT-mRNA varying in size is described. Non-replicating, self-amplifying (saRNA), temperature degraded, and ribonuclease (RNase) digested mRNA, the latter to characterize the 3' poly(A) tail, were included in the study. Beyond ultraviolet (UV) detection, refractive index (RI) and multi-angle light scattering (MALS) detection were implemented to accurately determine molecular weight (MW) of mRNA. Finally, mass photometry is introduced as a complementary methodology to study mRNA under native conditions.

Electrophoretic Deposition Interferometric Scattering Mass Photometry.

Interferometric scattering microscopy (iSCAT) has rapidly developed as a quantitative tool for the label-free detection of single macromolecules and nanoparticles. In practice, this measurement records the interferometric scattering signal of individual nanoparticles in solution as they land and stick on a coverslip, exhibiting an intensity that varies linearly with particle volume and an adsorption rate that reflects the solution-phase transport kinetics of the system. Together, such measurements provide a multidimensional gauge of the particle size and concentration in solution over time. However, the landing kinetics of particles in solution also manifest a measurement frequency limitation imposed by the slow long-range mobility of particle diffusion to the measurement interface. Here we introduce an effective means to overcome the inherent diffusion-controlled sampling limitation of spontaneous mass photometry. We term this methodology electrophoretic deposition interferometric scattering microscopy (EPD-iSCAT). This approach uses a coverslip supporting a conductive thin film of indium tin oxide (ITO). Charging this ITO film to a potential of around +1 V electrophoretically draws charged nanoparticles from solution and binds them in the focal plane of the microscope. Regulating this potential offers a direct means of controlling particle deposition. Thus, we find for a 0.1 nM solution of 50 nm polystyrene nanoparticles that the application of +1 V to an EPD-iSCAT coverslip assembly drives an electrophoretic deposition rate constant of 1.7 s-1 µm-2 nM-1. Removal of the potential causes deposition to cease. This user control of EPD-iSCAT affords a means to apply single-molecule mass photometry to monitor long-term changes in solution, owing to slow kinetic processes. In contrast with conventional coverslips chemically derivatized with charged thin films, EPD-iSCAT maintains a deposition rate that varies linearly with the bulk concentration.

Quantification of full and empty particles of adeno-associated virus vectors via a novel dual fluorescence-linked immunosorbent assay.

The adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector is one of the most advanced platforms for gene therapy because of its low immunogenicity and non-pathogenicity. The concentrations of both AAV vector empty particles, which do not contain DNA and do not show any efficacy, and AAV vector full particles (FPs), which contain DNA, are important quality attributes. In this study, a dual fluorescence-linked immunosorbent assay (dFLISA), which uses two fluorescent dyes to quantify capsid and genome titers in a single analysis, was established. In dFLISA, capture of AAV particles, detection of capsid proteins, and release and detection of the viral genome are performed in the same well. We demonstrated that the capsid and genomic titers determined by dFLISA were comparable with those of analytical ultracentrifugation. The FP ratios determined by dFLISA were in good agreement with the expected values. In addition, we showed that dFLISA can quantify the genomic and capsid titers of crude samples. dFLISA can be easily modified for measuring other AAV vector serotypes and AAV vectors with different genome lengths. These features make dFLISA a valuable tool for the future development of AAV-based gene therapies.

Characterization of high-molecular weight by-products in the production of a trivalent bispecific 2+1 heterodimeric antibody.

The development of increasingly complex antibody formats, such as bispecifics, can lead to the formation of increasingly complex high- and low-molecular-weight by-products. Here, we focus on the characterization of high molecular weight species (HMWs) representing the highest complexity of size variants. Standard methods used for product release, such as size exclusion chromatography (SEC), can separate HMW by-products from the main product, but cannot distinguish smaller changes in mass. Here, for the identification of the diverse and complex HMW variants of a trivalent bispecific CrossMAb antibody, offline fractionation, as well as production of HMW by-products combined with comprehensive analytical testing, was applied. Furthermore, HMW variants were analyzed regarding their chemical binding nature and tested in functional assays regarding changes in potency of the variants. Changes in potency were explained by detailed characterization using mass photometry, SDS-PAGE analysis, native mass spectrometry (MS) coupled to SEC and bottom-up proteomics. We identified a major portion of the HMW by-products to be non-covalently linked, leading to dissociation and changes in activity. We also identified and localized high heterogeneity of a by-product of concern and applied a CD3 affinity column coupled to native MS to annotate unexpected by-products. We present here a multi-method approach for the characterization of complex HMW by-products. A better understanding of these by-products is beneficial to guide analytical method development and proper specification setting for therapeutic bispecific antibodies to ensure constant efficacy and patient safety of the product through the assessment of by-products.

Critical Calibration of Mass Photometry for Higher-Mass Samples Such as Adeno-Associated Virus Vectors.

Mass photometry (MP) is a label-free, single-molecule technique that can determine molecular mass distribution with very low sample consumption in a short time. Because of the established experimental instrument and analytical software, MP measurements may be readily obtained; thus, the application of MP is expanding, especially in the fields of bioscience and biotechnology. However, because the MP data quality is strongly focus-dependent, optical settings must be intrinsically strict. In this study, we report the importance of the critical calibration of the mass photometer, which is required for the accurate estimation of high-molecular mass samples, such as adeno-associated virus vectors. Additionally, a method for optimizing the instrument settings, including the calibration of the stage, is presented.