Quantitative analysis of breast cancer tissue microarrays shows that both high and normal levels of HER2 expression are associated with poor outcome.

ABSTRACT

Using a tissue microarray cohort of 300 breast cancers and 84 samples of normal breast epithelium, we analyzed HER2/neu expression and compared traditional clinical (manual) scoring with a recently developed system for the quantitative measurement of immunohistochemical stains (AQUA). As expected, both methods identified a population (10-15%) of high-HER2-expressing tumors with poor 30-year disease-related survival. Using AQUA analysis, we found that normal epithelium expresses a low but detectable level of HER2 and that 17.5% of tumors exhibit similar low-level HER2 expression. This low group was not definable by manual scoring. Surprisingly, HER2-normal tumors were as aggressive as HER2-overexpressing tumors. Our studies suggest that in situ quantitative measurement of HER2 stratifies breast tumors into three expression levels normal, intermediate, and high, where both normal and high levels are associated with a worse outcome.