Alzheimer special care units compared with traditional nursing home for dementia care: are there differences at admission and in clinical outcomes?

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND: Studies comparing Alzheimer Special Care Units (ASCUs) with traditional nursing homes (NHs) have reported conflicting results. OBJECTIVES: To compare the characteristics and the effects on mortality, hospitalization, use of physical restraints, falls, and antipsychotics among patients admitted to ASCUs or to NHs. METHODS: A sequential cohort of patients with dementia was recruited and followed for 18 months in a sample of randomly selected ASCUs and NHs. Data on socio-demographic, cognitive, functional, behavioral, and clinical characteristics, and drug exposure were collected at baseline and at 6-month intervals up to 18 months. RESULTS: A total of 349 patients were enrolled in 35 ASCUs and 81 in 9 NHs. Patients admitted to ASCUs were younger, cognitively and functionally less impaired, but had more behavioral disturbances than those in NH. During follow-up, ASCU patients had a lower risk of hospitalization (odds ratio 0.67; 95% confidence interval 0.46-0.99; P=0.04), and use of physical restraints (odds ratio 0.66; 95% confidence interval 0.51-0.86; P=0.003), and showed a higher rate of withdrawal of antipsychotics (P=0.003). No difference was found in mortality and falls. Propensity score analysis gives similar results. CONCLUSIONS: This study found that patients with dementia in ASCUs had different baseline clinical and functional characteristics from those in NHs. They had a lower rate of hospitalization and use of physical restraints at 6-month follow-up, and a higher probability of having antipsychotic agents withdrawn.