Simultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation Method for Evaluation of Target Contouring in Radiosurgery.

ABSTRACT

BACKGROUND/AIM: The problem of lack of standardisation in target delineation and herewith the variability of target contours in Gamma Knife radiosurgery is as severe as in linac-based radiotherapy in general. The first aim of this study was to quantify the contouring variability for a group of five radiosurgery targets and estimate their true-volume based on multiple delineations using the Simultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation (STAPLE) algorithm. The second aim was to assess the robustness of the STAPLE method for the assessment of the true-volume, with respect to the number of contours available as input. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A multicentre analysis of the variability in contouring of five cases was performed. Twelve contours were provided for each case by experienced planners for Gamma Knife. To assess the robustness of the STAPLE method with respect to the number of contours used as input, sets of contours were randomly selected in the analysis. RESULTS: A high similarity was observed between the STAPLE generated true-volume and the 50%-agreement volume when all 12 available contours were used as input (90-100%). Lower similarity was observed with smaller sets of contours (10-70%). CONCLUSION: If a high number of input contours is available, the STAPLE method provides a valuable tool in the estimation of the true volume of a target based on multiple contours as well as the sensitivity and specificity for each input contour relative to the true volume of that structure. The robustness of the STAPLE method for rendering the true target volume depends on the number of contours provided as input and their variability with respect to shape, size and position.