Optimizing Defibrillator Deployment with Bus-Mounted Automated External Defibrillator.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVES: Early defibrillation with an automated external defibrillator (AED) can effectively improve the survival rate of patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA). Placing AEDs in public locations can reduce the defibrillation response interval from collapse to defibrillation. Most public AEDs are currently placed in a stationary way (S-AED) with limited coverage area. Bus mounted AED (B-AED) can be delivered directly to the demand point. Although B-AEDs are only available during bus operating hours, they provide greater coverage area. When the number of available AEDs is insufficient, better coverage may be achieved by placing a portion of AEDs as B-AEDs. Our purpose is developing a model to determine the optimal locations of B-AEDs and S-AEDs with a predetermined number of available AEDs. The goal is to maximize the total coverage level of all demand points. METHODS: We proposed a joint location model to place B-AEDs and S-AEDs based on the p-median problem (JPMP). Using data from Chang'an District, Xi'an City, China, we determined the optimal AED deployment. The performance of JPMP was compared with several other models. The coverage results of JPMP are analyzed in details, including the quantity assignment, coverage level, and geographical location of B-AEDs and S-AEDs. The impact of the bus departure intervals on coverage was also discussed. RESULTS: The use of B-AEDs results in an average 98.43% increase in the number of covered demand points, and an average 74.05% increase in total coverage level. In optimal AED deployment, B-AEDs coverage follows an inverted U-shaped curve with increasing number of available AEDs. It begins to decrease when all demand points during the operating hours are covered. With a constant number of available AEDs, the total coverage level increases and then decreases as the bus departure interval increases. The larger the number of available AEDs, the smaller the optimal departure interval. CONCLUSIONS: With a given number of available AEDs, combinational deployment of B-AEDs and S-AEDs significantly improves the coverage level. B-AEDs are recommended when AEDs are insufficient. If more AEDs are available, better coverage can be obtained with reasonable location of S-AEDs and B-AEDs.