A Comparison of Quit Outcomes for Men and Women in a Smoking Cessation Program Offering Personalized Nicotine Replacement Therapy and Counseling in Primary Care Clinics.

ABSTRACT

INTRODUCTION: Women may have greater difficulty achieving long-term abstinence following a quit attempt compared to men. We sought to determine whether there were differences in treatment characteristics or outcome between female and male primary care patients enrolled in a smoking cessation program providing personalized nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) with counseling support. AIMS AND METHODS: The sample included 27 601 Ontarians (53% female, 47% male) who enrolled in the Smoking Treatment for Ontario Patients program between 2016 and 2018. Dose, type, and duration of NRT supplied were personalized to need. Thirty-day point prevalence tobacco smoking abstinence was self-reported via online or telephone survey at 6 months after enrollment. RESULTS: Both female and male participants received a median of 8 weeks of NRT. Types of NRT received were similar, with 80% of both female and male participants receiving patch and short-acting NRT. The total cumulative dose was somewhat higher for men (1373 mg vs. 1265 mg, p < .001); but when calculated as dose per day, per cigarette smoked at baseline, the dose was slightly higher among women (1.6 mg vs. 1.5 mg, p < .001). Quit rates at 6 months were lower for women versus men (24% vs. 27%; adjusted OR = 0.84 [95% CI = 0.78 to 0.90], p < .001). There were no significant interactions between gender and dose, type, or duration of NRT supplied. CONCLUSIONS: Women were slightly less likely to quit than men, despite receiving similar treatment. There was no evidence that women benefitted more or less from variations in dose, type, or duration of NRT supplied. IMPLICATIONS Women who received personalized NRT with counseling support in a primary care setting had lower quit success than men. Although the absolute difference in quit outcome was small, the public health impact may be large given the burden of disease associated with continued smoking. NRT supplied was similar for women and men, and there was no evidence upon which to suggest tailoring the dose, duration, or type, based on gender alone. Further research to identify the underlying biological and social factors responsible for reduced quit success will help identify ways to optimize treatment for women.