Conserved folding landscape of monomeric initiator caspases.

The apoptotic caspase subfamily evolved into two subfamilies-monomeric initiators and dimeric effectors; both subfamilies share a conserved caspase-hemoglobinase fold with a protease domain containing a large subunit and a small subunit. Sequence variations in the conserved caspase-hemoglobinase fold resulted in changes in oligomerization, enzyme specificity, and regulation, making caspases an excellent model for examining the mechanisms of molecular evolution in fine-tuning structure, function, and allosteric regulation. We examined the urea-induced equilibrium folding/unfolding of two initiator caspases, monomeric caspase-8 and cFLIPL, over a broad pH range. Both proteins unfold by a three-state equilibrium mechanism that includes a partially folded intermediate. In addition, both proteins undergo a conserved pH-dependent conformational change that is controlled by an evolutionarily conserved mechanism. We show that the conformational free energy landscape of the caspase monomer is conserved in the monomeric and dimeric subfamilies. Molecular dynamics simulations in the presence or the absence of urea, coupled with limited trypsin proteolysis and mass spectrometry, show that the small subunit is unstable in the protomer and unfolds prior to the large subunit. In addition, the unfolding of helix 2 in the large subunit results in disruption of a conserved allosteric site. Because the small subunit forms the interface for dimerization, our results highlight an important driving force for the evolution of the dimeric caspase subfamily through stabilizing the small subunit.

Sequential Unfolding Mechanisms of Monomeric Caspases.

Caspases are evolutionarily conserved cysteinyl proteases that are integral in cell development and apoptosis. All apoptotic caspases evolved from a common ancestor into two distinct subfamilies with either monomeric (initiators) or dimeric (effectors) oligomeric states. The regulation of apoptosis is influenced by the activation mechanism of the two subfamilies, but the evolution of the well-conserved caspase-hemoglobinase fold into the two subfamilies is not well understood. We examined the folding landscape of monomeric caspases from two coral species over a broad pH range of 3-10.5. On an evolutionary timescale, the two coral caspases diverged from each other approximately 300 million years ago, and they diverged from human caspases about 600 million years ago. Our results indicate that both proteins have overall high stability, ∼15 kcal mol-1, near the physiological pH range (pH 6-8) and unfold via two partially folded intermediates, I1 and I2*, that are in equilibrium with the native and the unfolded state. Like the dimeric caspases, the monomeric coral caspases undergo a pH-dependent conformational change resulting from the titration of an evolutionarily conserved site. Data from molecular dynamics simulations paired with limited proteolysis and MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry show that the small subunit of the monomeric caspases is unstable and unfolds prior to the large subunit. Overall, the data suggest that all caspases share a conserved folding landscape, that a conserved allosteric site can be fine-tuned for species-specific regulation, and that the subfamily of stable dimers may have evolved to stabilize the small subunit.

Resurrection of an ancient inflammatory locus reveals switch to caspase-1 specificity on a caspase-4 scaffold.

Pyroptosis is a mechanism of inflammatory cell death mediated by the activation of the prolytic protein gasdermin D by caspase-1, caspase-4, and caspase-5 in human, and caspase-1 and caspase-11 in mouse. In addition, caspase-1 amplifies inflammation by proteolytic activation of cytokine interleukin-1ß (IL-1ß). Modern mammals of the order Carnivora lack the caspase-1 catalytic domain but express an unusual version of caspase-4 that can activate both gasdermin D and IL-1ß. Seeking to understand the evolutionary origin of this caspase, we utilized the large amount of data available in public databases to perform ancestral sequence reconstruction of an inflammatory caspase of a Carnivora ancestor. We expressed the catalytic domain of this putative ancestor in Escherichia coli, purified it, and compared its substrate specificity on synthetic and protein substrates to extant caspases. We demonstrated that it activates gasdermin D but has reduced ability to activate IL-1ß. Our reconstruction suggests that caspase-1 was lost in a Carnivora ancestor, perhaps upon a selective pressure for which the generation of biologically active IL-1ß by caspase-1 was detrimental. We speculate that later, a Carnivora encountered selective pressures that required the production of IL-1ß, and caspase-4 subsequently gained this activity. This hypothesis would explain why extant Carnivora possess an inflammatory caspase with caspase-1 catalytic function placed on a caspase-4 scaffold.

Evolution of the folding landscape of effector caspases.

Caspases are a family of cysteinyl proteases that control programmed cell death and maintain homeostasis in multicellular organisms. The caspase family is an excellent model to study protein evolution because all caspases are produced as zymogens (procaspases [PCPs]) that must be activated to gain full activity; the protein structures are conserved through hundreds of millions of years of evolution; and some allosteric features arose with the early ancestor, whereas others are more recent evolutionary events. The apoptotic caspases evolved from a common ancestor (CA) into two distinct subfamilies: monomers (initiator caspases) or dimers (effector caspases). Differences in activation mechanisms of the two subfamilies, and their oligomeric forms, play a central role in the regulation of apoptosis. Here, we examine changes in the folding landscape by characterizing human effector caspases and their CA. The results show that the effector caspases unfold by a minimum three-state equilibrium model at pH 7.5, where the native dimer is in equilibrium with a partially folded monomeric (PCP-7, CA) or dimeric (PCP-6) intermediate. In comparison, the unfolding pathway of PCP-3 contains both oligomeric forms of the intermediate. Overall, the data show that the folding landscape was first established with the CA and was retained for >650 million years. Partially folded monomeric or dimeric intermediates in the ancestral ensemble provide mechanisms for evolutionary changes that affect stability of extant caspases. The conserved folding landscape allows for the fine-tuning of enzyme stability in a species-dependent manner while retaining the overall caspase-hemoglobinase fold.

Caspases from scleractinian coral show unique regulatory features.

Coral reefs are experiencing precipitous declines around the globe with coral diseases and temperature-induced bleaching being primary drivers of these declines. Regulation of apoptotic cell death is an important component in the coral stress response. Although cnidaria are known to contain complex apoptotic signaling pathways, similar to those in vertebrates, the mechanisms leading to cell death are largely unexplored. We identified and characterized two caspases each from Orbicella faveolata, a disease-sensitive reef-building coral, and Porites astreoides, a disease-resistant reef-building coral. The caspases are predicted homologs of the human executioner caspases-3 and -7, but OfCasp3a (Orbicella faveolata caspase-3a) and PaCasp7a (Porites astreoides caspase-7a), which we show to be DXXDases, contain an N-terminal caspase activation/recruitment domain (CARD) similar to human initiator/inflammatory caspases. OfCasp3b (Orbicella faveolata caspase-3b) and PaCasp3 (Porites astreoides caspase-3), which we show to be VXXDases, have short pro-domains, like human executioner caspases. Our biochemical analyses suggest a mechanism in coral which differs from that of humans, where the CARD-containing DXXDase is activated on death platforms but the protease does not directly activate the VXXDase. The first X-ray crystal structure of a coral caspase, of PaCasp7a determined at 1.57 Å resolution, reveals a conserved fold and an N-terminal peptide bound near the active site that may serve as a regulatory exosite. The binding pocket has been observed in initiator caspases of other species. These results suggest mechanisms for the evolution of substrate selection while maintaining common activation mechanisms of CARD-mediated dimerization.

Resurrection of ancestral effector caspases identifies novel networks for evolution of substrate specificity.

Apoptotic caspases evolved with metazoans more than 950 million years ago (MYA), and a series of gene duplications resulted in two subfamilies consisting of initiator and effector caspases. The effector caspase genes (caspases-3, -6, and -7) were subsequently fixed into the Chordata phylum more than 650 MYA when the gene for a common ancestor (CA) duplicated, and the three effector caspases have persisted throughout mammalian evolution. All caspases prefer an aspartate residue at the P1 position of substrates, so each caspase evolved discrete cellular roles through changes in substrate recognition at the P4 position combined with allosteric regulation. We examined the evolution of substrate specificity in caspase-6, which prefers valine at the P4 residue, compared with caspases-3 and -7, which prefer aspartate, by reconstructing the CA of effector caspases (AncCP-Ef1) and the CA of caspase-6 (AncCP-6An). We show that AncCP-Ef1 is a promiscuous enzyme with little distinction between Asp, Val, or Leu at P4. The specificity of caspase-6 was defined early in its evolution, where AncCP-6An demonstrates a preference for Val over Asp at P4. Structures of AncCP-Ef1 and of AncCP-6An show a network of charged amino acids near the S4 pocket that, when combined with repositioning a flexible active site loop, resulted in a more hydrophobic binding pocket in AncCP-6An. The ancestral protein reconstructions show that the caspase-hemoglobinase fold has been conserved for over 650 million years and that only three substitutions in the scaffold are necessary to shift substrate selection toward Val over Asp.

Modifications to a common phosphorylation network provide individualized control in caspases.

Caspase-3 activation and function have been well-defined during programmed cell death, but caspase activity, at low levels, is also required for developmental processes such as lymphoid proliferation and erythroid differentiation. Post-translational modification of caspase-3 is one method used by cells to fine-tune activity below the threshold required for apoptosis, but the allosteric mechanism that reduces activity is unknown. Phosphorylation of caspase-3 at a conserved allosteric site by p38-MAPK (mitogen-activated protein kinase) promotes survival in human neutrophils, and the modification of the loop is thought to be a key regulator in many developmental processes. We utilized phylogenetic, structural, and biophysical studies to define the interaction networks that facilitate the allosteric mechanism in caspase-3. We show that, within the modified loop, Ser150 evolved with the apoptotic caspases, whereas Thr152 is a more recent evolutionary event in mammalian caspase-3. Substitutions at Ser150 result in a pH-dependent decrease in dimer stability, and localized changes in the modified loop propagate to the active site of the same protomer through a connecting surface helix. Likewise, a cluster of hydrophobic amino acids connects the conserved loop to the active site of the second protomer. The presence of Thr152 in the conserved loop introduces a "kill switch" in mammalian caspase-3, whereas the more ancient Ser150 reduces without abolishing enzyme activity. These data reveal how evolutionary changes in a conserved allosteric site result in a common pathway for lowering activity during development or a more recent cluster-specific switch to abolish activity.

Tunable allosteric library of caspase-3 identifies coupling between conserved water molecules and conformational selection.

The native ensemble of caspases is described globally by a complex energy landscape where the binding of substrate selects for the active conformation, whereas targeting an allosteric site in the dimer interface selects an inactive conformation that contains disordered active-site loops. Mutations and posttranslational modifications stabilize high-energy inactive conformations, with mostly formed, but distorted, active sites. To examine the interconversion of active and inactive states in the ensemble, we used detection of related solvent positions to analyze 4,995 waters in 15 high-resolution (<2.0 Å) structures of wild-type caspase-3, resulting in 450 clusters with the most highly conserved set containing 145 water molecules. The data show that regions of the protein that contact the conserved waters also correspond to sites of posttranslational modifications, suggesting that the conserved waters are an integral part of allosteric mechanisms. To test this hypothesis, we created a library of 19 caspase-3 variants through saturation mutagenesis in a single position of the allosteric site of the dimer interface, and we show that the enzyme activity varies by more than four orders of magnitude. Altogether, our database consists of 37 high-resolution structures of caspase-3 variants, and we demonstrate that the decrease in activity correlates with a loss of conserved water molecules. The data show that the activity of caspase-3 can be fine-tuned through globally desolvating the active conformation within the native ensemble, providing a mechanism for cells to repartition the ensemble and thus fine-tune activity through conformational selection.

Caspase Allostery and Conformational Selection.

The role of caspase proteases in regulated processes such as apoptosis and inflammation has been studied for more than two decades, and the activation cascades are known in detail. Apoptotic caspases also are utilized in critical developmental processes, although it is not known how cells maintain the exquisite control over caspase activity in order to retain subthreshold levels required for a particular adaptive response while preventing entry into apoptosis. In addition to active site-directed inhibitors, caspase activity is modulated by post-translational modifications or metal binding to allosteric sites on the enzyme, which stabilize inactive states in the conformational ensemble. This review provides a comprehensive global view of the complex conformational landscape of caspases and mechanisms used to select states in the ensemble. The caspase structural database provides considerable detail on the active and inactive conformations in the ensemble, which provide the cell multiple opportunities to fine tune caspase activity. In contrast, the current database on caspase modifications is largely incomplete and thus provides only a low-resolution picture of global allosteric communications and their effects on the conformational landscape. In recent years, allosteric control has been utilized in the design of small drug compounds or other allosteric effectors to modulate caspase activity.

Modifying caspase-3 activity by altering allosteric networks.

Caspases have several allosteric sites that bind small molecules or peptides. Allosteric regulators are known to affect caspase enzyme activity, in general, by facilitating large conformational changes that convert the active enzyme to a zymogen-like form in which the substrate-binding pocket is disordered. Mutations in presumed allosteric networks also decrease activity, although large structural changes are not observed. Mutation of the central V266 to histidine in the dimer interface of caspase-3 inactivates the enzyme by introducing steric clashes that may ultimately affect positioning of a helix on the protein surface. The helix is thought to connect several residues in the active site to the allosteric dimer interface. In contrast to the effects of small molecule allosteric regulators, the substrate-binding pocket is intact in the mutant, yet the enzyme is inactive. We have examined the putative allosteric network, in particular the role of helix 3, by mutating several residues in the network. We relieved steric clashes in the context of caspase-3(V266H), and we show that activity is restored, particularly when the restorative mutation is close to H266. We also mimicked the V266H mutant by introducing steric clashes elsewhere in the allosteric network, generating several mutants with reduced activity. Overall, the data show that the caspase-3 native ensemble includes the canonical active state as well as an inactive conformation characterized by an intact substrate-binding pocket, but with an altered helix 3. The enzyme activity reflects the relative population of each species in the native ensemble.

Slow folding and assembly of a procaspase-3 interface variant.

Caspases execute apoptosis and exist in the cell as inactive zymogens (procaspases) prior to activation. Initiator procaspases are monomers that must dimerize for activation, while effector procaspases, such as procaspase-3, are stable dimers that must be processed for activation. The dimer interface regions of the two subfamilies are different, although the role of the interface in oligomerization is not known. Equilibrium and kinetic folding studies were performed on procaspase-3(C163S,V266H), an interface variant, to determine the importance of the dimer interface in the folding of procaspase-3. Equilibrium folding data at pH 5 and 7 display a hysteresis, indicating a kinetically controlled folding reaction. Refolding kinetic studies reveal a complex burst phase, followed by a series of monomeric intermediates. At longer refolding times, the monomer populates a species that becomes kinetically trapped and slowly aggregates. Unfolding kinetic studies reveal a hyperfluorescent native ensemble that unfolds to form highly structured monomeric intermediates that unfold very slowly. Dimerization is very slow, likely because of the inability to correctly orient the histidine residues in the interface, so the initial encounter complex for dimerization is inefficient. As a consequence, the monomer folds into species that aggregate. Introducing a histidine into the interface of procaspase-3 prevents activation by acting as a negative design element, providing evidence that the interface region is a site of regulation of caspase assembly in general by affecting the rate of dimerization.

Lengthening the intersubunit linker of procaspase 3 leads to constitutive activation.

The conformational ensemble of procaspase 3, the primary executioner in apoptosis, contains two major forms, inactive and active, with the inactive state favored in the native ensemble. A region of the protein known as the intersubunit linker (IL) is cleaved during maturation, resulting in movement of the IL out of the dimer interface and subsequent active site formation (activation-by-cleavage mechanism). We examined two models for the role of the IL in maintaining the inactive conformer, an IL-extension model versus a hydrophobic cluster model, and we show that increasing the length of the IL by introducing 3-5 alanines results in constitutively active procaspases. Active site labeling and subsequent analyses by mass spectrometry show that the full-length zymogen is enzymatically active. We also show that minor populations of alternately cleaved procaspase result from processing at D169 when the normal cleavage site, D175, is unavailable. Importantly, the alternately cleaved proteins have little to no activity, but increased flexibility of the linker increases the exposure of D169. The data show that releasing the strain of the short IL, in and of itself, is not sufficient to populate the active conformer of the native ensemble. The IL must also allow for interactions that stabilize the active site, possibly from a combination of optimal length, flexibility in the IL, and specific contacts between the IL and interface. The results provide further evidence that substantial energy is required to shift the protein to the active conformer. As a result, the activation-by-cleavage mechanism dominates in the cell.

Sequential unfolding mechanisms of monomeric caspases.

Caspases are evolutionarily conserved cysteinyl proteases that are integral in cell development and apoptosis. All apoptotic caspases evolved from a common ancestor into two distinct subfamilies with either monomeric (initiators) or dimeric (effectors) oligomeric states. The regulation of apoptosis is influenced by the activation mechanism of the two subfamilies, but the evolution of the well-conserved caspase-hemoglobinase fold into the two subfamilies is not well understood. We examined the folding landscape of monomeric caspases from two coral species over a broad pH range of 3 to 10.5. On an evolutionary timescale, the two coral caspases diverged from each other approximately 300 million years ago, and they diverged from human caspases about 600 million years ago. Our results indicate that both proteins have overall high stability, ∻ 15 kcal mol -1 near the physiological pH range (pH 6 to pH 8), and unfold via two partially folded intermediates, I 1 and I 2 , that are in equilibrium with the native and the unfolded state. Like the dimeric caspases, the monomeric coral caspases undergo a pH-dependent conformational change resulting from the titration of an evolutionarily conserved site. Data from molecular dynamics simulations paired with limited proteolysis and MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry show that the small subunit of the monomeric caspases is unstable and unfolds prior to the large subunit. Overall, the data suggest that all caspases share a conserved folding landscape, that a conserved allosteric site can be fine-tuned for species-specific regulation, and that the subfamily of stable dimers may have evolved to stabilize the small subunit.

Death by caspase dimerization.

Controlled cell death, or apoptosis, occurs in response to many different environmental stimuli. The apoptotic cascade that occurs within the cell in response to these cues leads to morphological and biochemical changes that trigger the dismantling and packaging of the cell. Caspases are a family of cysteine-dependent aspartate-directed proteases that play an integral role in the cascade that leads to apoptosis. Caspases are grouped as either initiators or effectors of apoptosis, depending on where they enter the cell death process. Prior to activation, initiator caspases are present as monomers that must dimerize for full activation whereas effector caspases are present as dimeric zymogens that must be processed for full activation. The stability of the dimer may be due predominately to the interactions in the dimer interface as each caspase has unique properties in this region that lend to its specific mode of activation. Moreover, dimerization is responsible for active site formation because both monomers contribute residues that enable the formation of a fully functional active site. Overall, dimerization plays a key role in the ability of caspases to form fully functional proteases.

Comparing the folding landscapes of evolutionarily divergent procaspase-3.

All caspases evolved from a common ancestor and subsequently developed into two general classes, inflammatory or apoptotic caspases. The caspase-hemoglobinase fold has been conserved throughout nearly one billion years of evolution and is utilized for both the monomeric and dimeric subfamilies of apoptotic caspases, called initiator and effector caspases, respectively. We compared the folding and assembly of procaspase-3b from zebrafish to that of human effector procaspases in order to examine the conservation of the folding landscape. Urea-induced equilibrium folding/unfolding of procaspase-3b showed a minimum three-state folding pathway, where the native dimer isomerizes to a partially folded dimeric intermediate, which then unfolds. A partially folded monomeric intermediate observed in the folding landscape of human procaspase-3 is not well-populated in zebrafish procaspase-3b. By comparing effector caspases from different species, we show that the effector procaspase dimer undergoes a pH-dependent conformational change, and that the conformational species in the folding landscape exhibit similar free energies. Together, the data show that the landscape for the caspase-hemoglobinase fold is conserved, yet it provides flexibility for species-specific stabilization or destabilization of folding intermediates resulting in changes in stability. The common pH-dependent conformational change in the native dimer, which yields an enzymatically inactive species, may provide an additional, albeit reversible, mechanism for controlling caspase activity in the cell.

Thermodynamic, enzymatic and structural effects of removing a salt bridge at the base of loop 4 in (pro)caspase-3.

Interactions between loops 2, 2' and 4, known as the loop bundle, stabilize the active site of caspase-3. Loop 4 (L4) is of particular interest due to its location between the active site and the dimer interface. We have disrupted a salt bridge between K242 and E246 at the base of L4 to determine its role in overall conformational stability and in maintaining the active site environment. Stability measurements show that only the K242A single mutant decreases stability of the dimer, whereas both single mutants and the double mutant demonstrate much lower activity compared to wild-type caspase-3. Structural studies of the caspase-3 variants show the involvement of K242 in hydrophobic interactions that stabilize helix 5, near the dimer interface, and the role of E246 appears to be to neutralize the positive charge of K242 within the hydrophobic cluster. Overall, the results suggest E246 and K242 are important in procaspase-3 for their interaction with neighboring residues, not with one another. Conversely, formation of the K242-E246 salt bridge in caspase-3 is needed for an accurate, stable conformation of loop L4 and proper active site formation in the mature enzyme.

Remodeling hydrogen bond interactions results in relaxed specificity of Caspase-3.

Caspase (or cysteinyl-aspartate specific proteases) enzymes play important roles in apoptosis and inflammation, and the non-identical but overlapping specificity profiles (that is, cleavage recognition sequence) direct cells to different fates. Although all caspases prefer aspartate at the P1 position of the substrate, the caspase-6 subfamily shows preference for valine at the P4 position, while caspase-3 shows preference for aspartate. In comparison with human caspases, caspase-3a from zebrafish has relaxed specificity and demonstrates equal selection for either valine or aspartate at the P4 position. In the context of the caspase-3 conformational landscape, we show that changes in hydrogen bonding near the S3 subsite affect selection of the P4 amino acid. Swapping specificity with caspase-6 requires accessing new conformational space, where each landscape results in optimal binding of DxxD (caspase-3) or VxxD (caspase-6) substrate and simultaneously disfavors binding of the other substrate. Within the context of the caspase-3 conformational landscape, substitutions near the active site result in nearly equal activity against DxxD and VxxD by disrupting a hydrogen bonding network in the substrate binding pocket. The converse substitutions in zebrafish caspase-3a result in increased selection for P4 aspartate over valine. Overall, the data show that the shift in specificity that results in a dual function protease, as in zebrafish caspase-3a, requires fewer amino acid substitutions compared with those required to access new conformational space for swapping substrate specificity, such as between caspases-3 and -6.

A constitutively active and uninhibitable caspase-3 zymogen efficiently induces apoptosis.

The caspase-3 zymogen has essentially zero activity until it is cleaved by initiator caspases during apoptosis. However, a mutation of V266E in the dimer interface activates the protease in the absence of chain cleavage. We show that low concentrations of the pseudo-activated procaspase-3 kill mammalian cells rapidly and, importantly, this protein is not cleaved nor is it inhibited efficiently by the endogenous regulator XIAP (X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis). The 1.63 A (1 A = 0.1 nm) structure of the variant demonstrates that the mutation is accommodated at the dimer interface to generate an enzyme with substantially the same activity and specificity as wild-type caspase-3. Structural modelling predicts that the interface mutation prevents the intersubunit linker from binding in the dimer interface, allowing the active sites to form in the procaspase in the absence of cleavage. The direct activation of procaspase-3 through a conformational switch rather than by chain cleavage may lead to novel therapeutic strategies for inducing cell death.

Rapid folding and unfolding of Apaf-1 CARD.

Caspase recruitment domains (CARDs) are members of the death domain superfamily and contain six antiparallel helices in an alpha-helical Greek key topology. We have examined the equilibrium and kinetic folding of the CARD of Apaf-1 (apoptotic protease activating factor 1), which consists of 97 amino acid residues, at pH 6 and pH 8. The results showed that an apparent two state equilibrium mechanism is not adequate to describe the folding of Apaf-1 CARD at either pH, suggesting the presence of intermediates in equilibrium unfolding. Interestingly, the results showed that the secondary structure is less stable than the tertiary structure, based on the transition mid-points for unfolding. Single mixing and sequential mixing stopped-flow studies showed that Apaf-1 CARD folds and unfolds rapidly and suggest a folding mechanism that contains parallel channels with two unfolded conformations folding to the native conformation. Kinetic simulations show that a slow folding phase is described by a third conformation in the unfolded ensemble that interconverts with one or both unfolded species. Overall, the native ensemble is formed rapidly upon refolding. This is in contrast to other CARDs in which folding appears to be dominated by formation of kinetic traps.

Minimizing frustration by folding in an aqueous environment.

Although life as we know it evolved in an aqueous medium, the properties of water are not completely understood. In this review, we focus on the role of water in guiding protein folding and stability. Specifically, we discuss the mechanisms of protein folding in an aqueous environment, the effects of water on the folding energy landscape as well as the transition state ensemble, and interactions of water with the folded state. We show that water cannot be viewed as a passive solvent, but rather, plays a very active role in the life of a protein.