Author Correction: 'Stealth' corporate innovation: an emerging threat for therapeutic drug development.

An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.

Inhibition of the C1s Protease and the Classical Complement Pathway by 6-(4-Phenylpiperazin-1-yl)Pyridine-3-Carboximidamide and Chemical Analogs.

The classical pathway (CP) is a potent mechanism for initiating complement activity and is a driver of pathology in many complement-mediated diseases. The CP is initiated via activation of complement component C1, which consists of the pattern recognition molecule C1q bound to a tetrameric assembly of proteases C1r and C1s. Enzymatically active C1s provides the catalytic basis for cleavage of the downstream CP components, C4 and C2, and is therefore an attractive target for therapeutic intervention in CP-driven diseases. Although an anti-C1s mAb has been Food and Drug Administration approved, identifying small-molecule C1s inhibitors remains a priority. In this study, we describe 6-(4-phenylpiperazin-1-yl)pyridine-3-carboximidamide (A1) as a selective, competitive inhibitor of C1s. A1 was identified through a virtual screen for small molecules that interact with the C1s substrate recognition site. Subsequent functional studies revealed that A1 dose-dependently inhibits CP activation by heparin-induced immune complexes, CP-driven lysis of Ab-sensitized sheep erythrocytes, CP activation in a pathway-specific ELISA, and cleavage of C2 by C1s. Biochemical experiments demonstrated that A1 binds directly to C1s with a Kd of ∼9.8 µM and competitively inhibits its activity with an inhibition constant (Ki) of ∼5.8 µM. A 1.8-Å-resolution crystal structure revealed the physical basis for C1s inhibition by A1 and provided information on the structure-activity relationship of the A1 scaffold, which was supported by evaluating a panel of A1 analogs. Taken together, our work identifies A1 as a new class of small-molecule C1s inhibitor and lays the foundation for development of increasingly potent and selective A1 analogs for both research and therapeutic purposes.

Complement component C3: A structural perspective and potential therapeutic implications.

As the most abundant component of the complement system, C3 and its proteolytic derivatives serve essential roles in the function of all three complement pathways. Central to this is a network of protein-protein interactions made possible by the sequential proteolysis and far-reaching structural changes that accompany C3 activation. Beginning with the crystal structures of C3, C3b, and C3c nearly twenty years ago, the physical transformations underlying C3 function that had long been suspected were finally revealed. In the years that followed, a compendium of crystallographic information on C3 derivatives bound to various enzymes, regulators, receptors, and inhibitors generated new levels of insight into the structure and function of the C3 molecule. This Review provides a concise classification, summary, and interpretation of the more than 50 unique crystal structure determinations for human C3. It also highlights other salient features of C3 structure that were made possible through solution-based methods, including Hydrogen/Deuterium Exchange and Small Angle X-ray Scattering. At this pivotal time when the first C3-targeted therapeutics begin to see use in the clinic, some perspectives are also offered on how this continually growing body of structural information might be leveraged for future development of next-generation C3 inhibitors.

S. aureus Eap is a polyvalent inhibitor of neutrophil serine proteases.

Staphylococcus aureus expresses three high-affinity neutrophil serine protease (NSP) inhibitors known as the extracellular adherence protein domain (EAPs) proteins. Whereas EapH1 and EapH2 are comprised of a single EAP domain, the modular extracellular adherence protein (Eap) from S. aureus strain Mu50 consists of four EAP domains. We recently reported that EapH2 can simultaneously bind and inhibit cathepsin-G (CG) and neutrophil elastase (NE), which are the two most abundant NSPs. This unusual property of EapH2 arises from independent CG and NE-binding sites that lie on opposing faces of its EAP domain. Here we used X-ray crystallography and enzyme assays to show that all four individual domains of Eap (i.e. Eap1, Eap2, Eap3, and Eap4) exhibit an EapH2-like ability to form ternary complexes with CG and NE that inhibit both enzymes simultaneously. We found that Eap1, Eap2, and Eap3 have similar functional profiles insofar as NSP inhibition is concerned but that Eap4 displays an unexpected ability to inhibit two NE enzymes simultaneously. Using X-ray crystallography, we determined that this second NE-binding site in Eap4 arises through the same region of its EAP domain that also comprises its CG-binding site. Interestingly, small angle X-ray scattering data showed that stable tail-to-tail dimers of the NE/Eap4/NE ternary complex exist in solution. This arrangement is compatible with NSP-binding at all available sites in a two-domain fragment of Eap. Together, our work implies that Eap is a polyvalent inhibitor of NSPs. It also raises the possibility that higher-order structures of NSP-bound Eap may have unique functional properties.

Characterization of two distinct neutrophil serine protease-binding modes within a Staphylococcus aureus innate immune evasion protein family.

Extracellular adherence protein domain (EAPs) proteins are a class of innate immune evasion proteins secreted by the human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus. EAPs are potent and selective inhibitors of cathepsin-G (CG) and neutrophil elastase (NE), which are the two most abundant neutrophil serine proteases (NSPs). Previous work from our group has shown that the prototypical EAP, EapH1, relies on plasticity within a single inhibitory site to block the activities of CG and NE. However, whether other EAPs follow similar structure-function relationships is unclear. To address this question, we studied the inhibitory properties of the first (Eap1) and second (Eap2) domains of the modular extracellular adherence protein of S. aureus and determined their structures when bound to CG and NE, respectively. We observed that both Eap1 and Eap2 displayed time-dependent inhibition of CG (on the order of 10-9 M) and of NE (on the order of 10-10 M). We also found that whereas the structures of Eap1 and Eap2 bound to CG showed an overall inhibitory mode like that seen previously for EapH1, the structures of Eap1 and Eap2 bound to NE revealed a new inhibitory mode involving a distal region of the EAP domain. Using site-directed mutagenesis of Eap1 and Eap2, along with enzyme assays, we confirmed the roles of interfacial residues in NSP inhibition. Taken together, our work demonstrates that EAPs can form structurally divergent complexes with two closely related serine proteases and further suggests that certain EAPs may be capable of inhibiting two NSPs simultaneously.

Simultaneous inhibition of two neutrophil serine proteases by the S. aureus innate immune evasion protein EapH2.

Extracellular adherence protein domain (EAP) proteins are high-affinity, selective inhibitors of neutrophil serine proteases (NSP), including cathepsin-G (CG) and neutrophil elastase (NE). Most Staphylococcus aureus isolates encode for two EAPs, EapH1 and EapH2, that contain a single functional domain and share 43% identity with one another. Although structure/function investigations from our group have shown that EapH1 uses a globally similar binding mode to inhibit CG and NE, NSP inhibition by EapH2 is incompletely understood due to a lack of NSP/EapH2 cocrystal structures. To address this limitation, we further studied NSP inhibition by EapH2 in comparison with EapH1. Like its effects on NE, we found that EapH2 is a reversible, time-dependent, and low nanomolar affinity inhibitor of CG. We characterized an EapH2 mutant which suggested that the CG binding mode of EapH2 is comparable to EapH1. To test this directly, we used NMR chemical shift perturbation to study EapH1 and EapH2 binding to CG and NE in solution. Although we found that overlapping regions of EapH1 and EapH2 were involved in CG binding, we found that altogether distinct regions of EapH1 and EapH2 experienced changes upon binding to NE. An important implication of this observation is that EapH2 might be capable of binding and inhibiting CG and NE simultaneously. We confirmed this unexpected feature by solving crystal structures of the CG/EapH2/NE complex and demonstrating their functional relevance through enzyme inhibition assays. Together, our work defines a new mechanism of simultaneous inhibition of two serine proteases by a single EAP protein.

Staphylococcal peroxidase inhibitor (SPIN): Investigation of the inhibitory N-terminal domain via a stabilizing disulfide insertion.

Staphylococcus aureus secretes an array of small proteins that inhibit key enzyme-catalyzed reactions necessary for proper function of the human innate immune system. Among these, the Staphylococcal Peroxidase Inhibitor, SPIN, blocks the activity of myeloperoxidase (MPO) and thereby disrupts the HOCl-generating system of neutrophils. Previous studies on S. aureus SPIN have shown that it relies on a C-terminal α-helical bundle domain to mediate initial binding to MPO, but requires a disordered N-terminal region to fold into a ß-hairpin conformation to inhibit MPO activity. To further investigate the structure/function relationship of SPIN, we introduced two cysteine residues into its N-terminal region to trap SPIN in its MPO-bound conformation and characterized the modified protein, which we refer to here as SPIN-CYS. Although control experiments confirmed the presence of the disulfide bond in SPIN-CYS, solution structure determination revealed that the N-terminal region of SPIN-CYS adopted a physically constrained series of lariat-like structures rather than a well-defined ß-hairpin. Nevertheless, SPIN-CYS exhibited a gain in inhibitory potency against human MPO when compared to wild-type SPIN. This gain of function persisted even in the presence of deleterious mutations within the C-terminal α-helical bundle domain. Surface plasmon resonance studies showed that the gain in potency arose through an increase in apparent affinity of SPIN-CYS for MPO, which was driven primarily by an increased association rate with MPO when compared to wild-type SPIN. Together, this work provides new information on the coupled binding and folding events required to manifest biological activity of this unusual MPO inhibitor.

Staphylococcal peroxidase inhibitor (SPIN): Residue-level investigation of the helical bundle domain.

Myeloperoxidase is a critical component of the antibacterial arsenal of neutrophils, whereby it consumes H2O2 as an oxidant to convert halogen and pseudohalogen anions into cytotoxic hypohalous acids. Following phagocytosis by neutrophils, the human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus secretes a potent myeloperoxidase inhibitory protein, called SPIN, as part of its immune evasion repertoire. The matured S. aureus SPIN polypeptide consists of only 73 residues yet contains two functional domains: whereas the 60 residue C-terminal helical bundle domain is responsible for MPO binding, the 13 residue N-terminal domain is required to inhibit MPO. Previous studies have informed understanding of the SPIN N-terminal domain, but comparatively little is known about the helical domain insofar as the contribution of individual residues is concerned. To address this limitation, we carried out a residue-level structure/function investigation on the helical bundle domain of S. aureus SPIN. Using sequence conservation and existing structures of SPIN bound to human MPO as a guide, we selected residues L49, E50, H51, E52, Y55, and Y75 for interrogation by site-directed mutagenesis. We found that loss of L49 or E52 reduced SPIN activity by roughly an order of magnitude, but that loss of Y55 or H51 caused progressively greater loss of inhibitory potency. Direct binding studies by SPR showed that loss of inhibitory potency in these SPIN mutants resulted from a diminished initial interaction between the inhibitor and MPO. Together, our studies provide new insights into the structure/function relationships of SPIN and identify positions Y55 and H51 as critical determinants of SPIN function.

Group B Streptococcus Surface Protein ß: Structural Characterization of a Complement Factor H-Binding Motif and Its Contribution to Immune Evasion.

The ß protein from group B Streptococcus (GBS) is a ∼132-kDa, cell-surface exposed molecule that binds to multiple host-derived ligands, including complement factor H (FH). Many details regarding this interaction and its significance to immune evasion by GBS remain unclear. In this study, we identified a three-helix bundle domain within the C-terminal half of the B75KN region of ß as the major FH-binding determinant and determined its crystal structure at 2.5 Å resolution. Analysis of this structure suggested a role in FH binding for a loop region connecting helices α1 and α2, which we confirmed by mutagenesis and direct binding studies. Using a combination of protein cross-linking and mass spectrometry, we observed that B75KN bound to complement control protein (CCP)3 and CCP4 domains of FH. Although this binding site lies within a complement regulatory region of FH, we determined that FH bound by ß retained its decay acceleration and cofactor activities. Heterologous expression of ß by Lactococcus lactis resulted in recruitment of FH to the bacterial surface and a significant reduction of C3b deposition following exposure to human serum. Surprisingly, we found that FH binding by ß was not required for bacterial resistance to phagocytosis by neutrophils or killing of bacteria by whole human blood. However, loss of the B75KN region significantly diminished bacterial survival in both assays. Although our results show that FH recruited to the bacterial surface through a high-affinity interaction maintains key complement-regulatory functions, they raise questions about the importance of FH binding to immune evasion by GBS as a whole.