The impact of HLA unidirectional mismatches on the outcome of myeloablative hematopoietic stem cell transplantation with unrelated donors.

The impact of HLA homozygosity at mismatched (MM) loci on the outcome of 2687 myeloablative unrelated donor hematopoietic cell transplantations performed for malignant disease was evaluated among 4 groups: 7/8 bidirectional MM transplants (donor and recipient heterozygous MM, n = 1393), 7/8 host-versus-graft (HVG) vector MM (recipient homozygous, n = 112), 7/8 graft-versus-host (GVH) vector MM (donor homozygous, n = 119), and 8/8 matches (n = 1063). Multivariate analyses found 7/8 GVH (P = .001) and bidirectional MM groups (P < .0001) had significantly worse transplant-related mortality and overall and disease-free survival than the 8/8 match group, a difference not observed with the 7/8 HVG MM group (P > .01). The 3 7/8 groups differed only for grades III-IV acute GVH disease (GVHD), where HVG MM had less GVHD than the 7/8 bidirectional MM (hazard ratio [HR] 0.52, P = .0016) and GVH MM (HR 0.43, P = .0009) groups but not the 8/8 group (HR 0.83, P = .39). There were no differences between the 7/8 groups for relapse, chronic GVHD, neutrophil engraftment, or graft failure. GVH MM have the same risk as 7/8 bidirectional MM. 7/8 HVG MM confer a reduced risk of acute GVHD without an increased risk of disease relapse or graft failure compared with a 7/8 bidirectional MM.

Allelic variation in KIR2DL3 generates a KIR2DL2-like receptor with increased binding to its HLA-C ligand.

Although extensive homology exists between their extracellular domains, NK cell inhibitory receptors killer Ig-like receptor (KIR) 2DL2*001 and KIR2DL3*001 have previously been shown to differ substantially in their HLA-C binding avidity. To explore the largely uncharacterized impact of allelic diversity, the most common KIR2DL2/3 allelic products in European American and African American populations were evaluated for surface expression and binding affinity to their HLA-C group 1 and 2 ligands. Although no significant differences in the degree of cell membrane localization were detected in a transfected human NKL cell line by flow cytometry, surface plasmon resonance and KIR binding to a panel of HLA allotypes demonstrated that KIR2DL3*005 differed significantly from other KIR2DL3 allelic products in its ability to bind HLA-C. The increased affinity and avidity of KIR2DL3*005 for its ligand was also demonstrated to have a larger impact on the inhibition of IFN-γ production by the human KHYG-1 NK cell line compared with KIR2DL3*001, a low-affinity allelic product. Site-directed mutagenesis established that the combination of arginine at residue 11 and glutamic acid at residue 35 in KIR2DL3*005 were critical to the observed phenotype. Although these residues are distal to the KIR/HLA-C interface, molecular modeling suggests that alteration in the interdomain hinge angle of KIR2DL3*005 toward that found in KIR2DL2*001, another strong receptor of the KIR2DL2/3 family, may be the cause of this increased affinity. The regain of inhibitory capacity by KIR2DL3*005 suggests that the rapidly evolving KIR locus may be responding to relatively recent selective pressures placed upon certain human populations.

Definitions of histocompatibility typing terms.

Histocompatibility testing for stem cell and solid organ transplantation has become increasingly complex as newly discovered HLA alleles are described. HLA typing assignments reported by laboratories are used by physicians and donor registries for matching donors and recipients. To communicate effectively, a common language for histocompatibility terms should be established. In early 2010, representatives from Clinical, Registry, and Histocompatibility organizations joined together as the Harmonization of Histocompatibility Typing Terms Working Group to define a consensual language for laboratories, physicians, and registries to communicate histocompatibility typing information. The Working Group defined terms for HLA typing resolution, HLA matching, and a format for reporting HLA assignments. In addition, definitions of verification typing and extended typing were addressed. The original draft of the Definitions of Histocompatibility Typing Terms was disseminated to colleagues from each organization to gain feedback and create a collaborative document. Commentary gathered during this 90-day review period were discussed and implemented for preparation of this report. Histocompatibility testing continues to evolve; thus, the definitions agreed on today probably will require refinement and perhaps additional terminology in the future.

The characteristics of allelic polymorphism in killer-immunoglobulin-like receptor framework genes in African Americans.

The frequencies of alleles of killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptor genes, KIR3DL3 and KIR3DL2, and the carrier frequency of KIR2DL4 alleles have been determined from a population of African Americans (n = 100) by DNA sequencing of the coding regions. Fifty alleles of KIR3DL3 were observed with the most frequent, KIR3DL3*00901 (13%). KIR3DL2 was also diverse; 32 alleles with KIR3DL2*00103 the most frequent (17%). For KIR2DL4, of the 18 alleles observed, one allele, KIR2DL4*00103, was found in 64 of the 100 individuals. Thirty-six novel alleles encoding a total of 28 unique receptors are described. Pairwise comparisons among all of the alleles at each locus suggest a predominance of synonymous substitutions. The variation at all three framework loci fits a neutral model of evolution.

Naming HLA diversity: A review of HLA nomenclature.

The development of a standardized HLA nomenclature has been critical in our understanding of the HLA system and in facilitating the clinical applications of HLA. The Nomenclature Committee for Factors of the HLA System, established in 1968, has overseen the development and usage of nomenclature based on serologic specificities, cellular responses, and DNA sequences. Their decisions have been guided by community consensus reached through 17 international workshops beginning in 1964 and continuing today. Two websites provide a curated database of the sequences of over 26,000 HLA alleles and a reference site for the current nomenclature. This review covers the major steps in the development of the HLA nomenclature as well as the efforts of other groups to extend its usefulness for research and clinical applications.

Thirty allele-level haplotypes centered around KIR2DL5 define the diversity in an African American population.

KIR2DL5 alleles were physically linked to alleles at adjacent KIR loci to define this region of KIR haplotypes in 55 gene-positive random African Americans. The majority carried KIR2DL5B. Three KIR2DL5A and six KIR2DL5B alleles that have been previously described and 11 novel KIR2DL5 alleles were identified by DNA sequencing. Novel alleles included variation that may impact promoter activity; two alleles carried nonsynonymous coding region variation. Based on linkage with KIR2DS1, KIR2DS3, KIR2DS5, KIR2DL2, KIR2DL3, and KIR3DS1 alleles, seven haplotypes of KIR2DL5A and 23 haplotypes of KIR2DL5B were observed. The phylogenetic relationships among the KIR2DL5 alleles predicted their association with either KIR2DS3 (six alleles) or KIR2DS5 (seven alleles). All of the KIR2DL5A alleles were linked either to KIR3DS1*01301 or KIR3DS1*049N. The majority of the KIR2DL5B alleles were linked to seven KIR2DL2 alleles; two were linked to a novel allele of KIR2DL3. These findings underscore the diversity of KIR haplotypes present in this population.

HLA-A disparities illustrate challenges for ranking the impact of HLA mismatches on bone marrow transplant outcomes in the United States.

HLA disparity between hematopoietic stem cell donors and recipients is one of the most important factors influencing transplant outcomes, but there are no well-accepted guidelines to aid in selecting the optimal donor among several HLA mismatched donors. In this report, HLA-A is used as a model to illustrate factors that are barriers to delineating the relationship between specific HLA mismatches and transplant outcomes in the United States. Patients in this investigation received transplants for hematologic malignancies that were facilitated by the National Marrow Donor Program (NMDP) between 1990 and 2002 (n = 4226). High-resolution HLA typing was performed for HLA-A, -B, -C, -DRB1, -DQA1, -DQB1, -DPA1, and -DPB1. HLA-A mismatches were observed in 745 donor-recipient pairs and 62% of these pairs also had disparities at HLA-B, -C, and/or -DRB1. The HLA-A mismatches involved 190 different combinations of HLA-A alleles and 51% of these were observed in only 1 pair. Addition of a single HLA-A disparity when HLA-B, -C, and -DRB1 were matched (n = 282) was associated with increased mortality (odds ratio [OR] = 1.32, confidence interval [CI] 1.07-1.63). When HLA-B, -C, and -DRB1 were matched, the most frequent HLA-A mismatches were HLA-A*0201:0205 (n = 28), HLA-A *0301:0302 (n = 15), HLA-A *0201:0206 (n = 15), HLA-A *0201:6801 (n = 12), HLA-A*0101:1101 (n = 11), and HLA-A*0101:0201 (n = 10). There were no statistically significant relationships between any of these disparities and transplant outcomes (engraftment, acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease [aGVHD, cGVHD] relapse, treatment-related mortality [TRM], or overall survival [OS]) when adjustments for multiple comparisons were considered. Achieving 80% power to detect an effect of any 1 of these 6 HLA-A disparities on survival is estimated to require a total transplant population of 11,000 to more than 1 million U.S. donor-recipient pairs depending upon the HLA disparity. Thus, alternative approaches are required to develop a clinically relevant ranking system for specific HLA disparities in the United States.

Continue to focus clinical decision-making on the antigen recognition domain for the present.

Next generation DNA sequencing has facilitated the routine characterization of complete HLA gene sequences. These data complement structural and functional studies of HLA elements encoded outside of the exons specifying the antigen recognition domain. This commentary is focused on evaluating whether the interpretation of HLA clinical typing results should expand the region of the HLA gene considered in the assignment from the exon(s) encoding the antigen recognition domain to the full gene sequence. Our recommendation is that, at present, there is insufficient data to support considering variation in the regions outside of the antigen recognition domain in clinical decision-making.

Next generation sequencing characterizes HLA diversity in a registry population from the Netherlands.

Next generation DNA sequencing is used to determine the HLA-A, -B, -C, -DRB1, -DRB3/4/5, and -DQB1 assignments of 1009 unrelated volunteers for the unrelated donor registry in The Netherlands. The analysis characterizes all HLA exons and introns for class I alleles; at least exons 2 to 3 for HLA-DRB1; and exons 2 to 6 for HLA-DQB1. Of the distinct alleles present, there are 229 class I and 71 class II; 36 of these alleles are novel. The majority (approximately 98%) of the cumulative allele frequency at each locus is contributed by alleles that appear three or more times. Alleles encoding protein variation outside of the antigen recognition domains are 0.6% of the class I assignments and 5.3% of the class II assignments.

Limited allelic diversity of stimulatory two-domain killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors.

Genomic sequencing was used to characterize most of the coding regions of the five two-domain stimulatory killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptor (KIR) loci from 80 unrelated, primarily Caucasian, individuals. Specific loci were present in from 26% (KIR2DS3) to 98% (KIR2DS4) of individuals. The number of known alleles present varied from one (KIR2DS1, KIR2DS5) to five (KIR2DS4). The frequencies of loci and alleles were similar to observations made in populations of European and Asian ethnicities. New alleles were found at 2DS1 (*00202, *00302, *005, *006, *007) and 2DS4 (*008) loci.

Characterizing alleles with large deletions using region specific extraction.

Two novel HLA class II alleles, DRB4*03:01N and DQB1*03:276N, containing large deletions were identified during routine typing. Extraction of DNA encompassing the deletions was carried out with a panel of capture oligonucleotides followed by whole genome amplification. Next generation DNA sequencing was then used to characterize the sequences. DRB4*03:01N has a 16 kilobase pair deletion stretching upstream from intron 2 toward centromeric DRB8. DQB1*03:276N has two deletions separated by 844 nucleotides. The first deletion (3.7 kilobase pairs) is upstream of intron 1 and the second deletion removes 3.3 kilobase pairs further upstream towards centromeric DQA2.

Estimation of HLA-A, -B, -DRB1 haplotype frequencies using mixed resolution data from a National Registry with selective retyping of volunteers.

Large registries of volunteer hematopoietic stem cell donors typed for HLA contain potentially valuable data for studying haplotype frequencies in the general population. However the usual assumptions for use of the expectation-maximization (EM) algorithm are typically violated in these registries. To avoid this problem, previous studies using registry data have reduced the HLA typings to low-resolution and/or excluded subjects who were selected for testing on behalf of a specific patient ("patient-directed" typings). These restrictions, added to avoid bias from selection of nonrepresentative volunteers for higher-resolution typing, have limited previous results to haplotypes defined at low resolution. In this article we eliminate the need for such restrictions by formally relaxing the assumptions necessary for the EM algorithm. We show mathematically and through simulation that varying levels of resolution can be incorporated even if the level of typing resolution is chosen based on the HLA type. This allows use of intermediate and high resolution data from patient-directed typings to extend haplotype frequency estimates to the allele level for HLA-DRB1. We demonstrate the feasibility of using this computationally demanding algorithm on large datasets by applying it to more than 3 million volunteers listed in the National Marrow Donor Program Registry.

HLA haplotypes in Singapore: a study of mothers and their cord blood units.

During 2005, a total of 174 cord blood units with their paired maternal samples from the Singapore Cord Blood Bank were typed for HLA-A, -B, -C at intermediate resolution and DRB1 at allelic resolution. Analysis of allele segregation in mother and child assigned 185 different four locus (HLA-A, -B, -C, -DRB1) haplotypes in Chinese, 66 in Malays, and 34 in Asian Indians. Very few four locus haplotypes were shared among population groups. To evaluate the frequencies of four locus haplotypes, the Expectation Maximization algorithm was used with HLA assignments from 536 unrelated Chinese volunteers from the Singapore Bone Marrow Donor Program registry. The paired maternal and cord blood study identified 75 different B-C associations in Chinese, 52 in Malays, and 24 in Asian Indians. Common B-C associations may be shared among population groups; for example, B*4001g-Cw*0702g was common in Chinese and Malays, whereas B*1502g-Cw*0801g and B*3501g-Cw*0401g were found in all three groups. The high diversity of four locus haplotypes originates from multiple combinations of both HLA-A and -DRB1 alleles with each B-C haplotype.

A high degree of HLA disparity arises from limited allelic diversity: analysis of 1775 unrelated bone marrow transplant donor-recipient pairs.

The allelic diversity and associated human leukocyte antigen (HLA) disparity of 1775 bone marrow recipients and their unrelated donors, matched for six of six (1361/1775,77%), five of six (397/1775, 22%), or four of six (17/1775, 1%) HLA-A, -B, -DR antigens, were retrospectively evaluated. The comprehensive HLA analysis included the class I (A, B, C) and II (DRB1, DQA1, DQB1, DPA1, DPB1) loci. Most (>66%) of the predominantly Caucasian study population carried one or two of five to seven common alleles at each HLA locus. In spite of this limited diversity, 29% of the six of six antigen-matched transplants carried allele mismatches at HLA-A, -B, and/or -DRB1, and 92% carried at least one allele mismatch at one of the eight HLA loci tested. Of the 968 HLA-A,-B,-DRB1 allele-matched pairs, 89% carried mismatches at other HLA loci, predominantly at DP loci. The substantially greater than expected HLA allelic disparity between donor and recipient suggests extensive haplotypic diversity and underscores the importance of enhancing approaches to mitigate the deleterious effect of HLA mismatches.

Combining one-step Sanger sequencing with phasing probe hybridization for HLA class I typing yields rapid, G-group resolution predicting 99% of unique full length protein sequences.

BACKGROUND: Sanger-based DNA sequencing of exons 2+3 of HLA class I alleles from a heterozygote frequently results in two or more alternative genotypes. This study was undertaken to reduce the time and effort required to produce a single high resolution HLA genotype. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Samples were typed in parallel by Sanger sequencing and oligonucleotide probe hybridization. This workflow, together with optimization of analysis software, was tested and refined during the typing of over 42,000 volunteers for an unrelated hematopoietic progenitor cell donor registry. Next generation DNA sequencing (NGS) was applied to over 1000 of these samples to identify the alleles present within the G group designations. RESULTS: Single genotypes at G level resolution were obtained for over 95% of the loci without additional assays. The vast majority of alleles identified (>99%) were the primary allele giving the G groups their name. Only 0.7% of the alleles identified encoded protein variants that were not detected by a focus on the antigen recognition domain (ARD)-encoding exons. CONCLUSION: Our combined method routinely provides biologically relevant typing resolution at the level of the ARD. It can be applied to both single samples or to large volume typing supporting either bone marrow or solid organ transplantation using technologies currently available in many HLA laboratories.

KIR3DL1/HLA-B Subtypes Govern Acute Myelogenous Leukemia Relapse After Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation.

Purpose Disease relapse remains a major challenge to successful outcomes in patients who undergo allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). Donor natural killer (NK) cell alloreactivity in HCT can control leukemic relapse, but capturing alloreactivity in HLA-matched HCT has been elusive. HLA expression on leukemia cells-upregulated in the post-HCT environment-signals for NK cell inhibition via inhibitory killer immunoglobulin-like (KIR) receptors and interrupts their antitumor activity. We hypothesized that varied strengths of inhibition among subtypes of the ubiquitous KIR3DL1 and its cognate ligand, HLA-B, would titrate NK reactivity against acute myelogenous leukemia (AML). Patients and Methods By using an algorithm that was based on polymorphism-driven expression levels and specificities, we predicted and tested inhibitory and cytotoxic NK potential on the basis of KIR3DL1/HLA-B subtype combinations in vitro and evaluated their impact in 1,328 patients with AML who underwent HCT from 9/10 or 10/10 HLA-matched unrelated donors. Results Segregated by KIR3DL1 subtype, NK cells demonstrated reproducible patterns of strong, weak, or noninhibition by target cells with defined HLA-B subtypes, which translated into discrete cytotoxic hierarchies against AML. In patients, KIR3DL1 and HLA-B subtype combinations that were predictive of weak inhibition or noninhibition were associated with significantly lower relapse (hazard ratio [HR], 0.72; P = .004) and overall mortality (HR, 0.84; P = .030) compared with strong inhibition combinations. The greatest effects were evident in the high-risk group of patients with all KIR ligands (relapse: HR, 0.54; P < .001; and mortality: HR, 0.74; P < .008). Beneficial effects of weak and noninhibiting KIR3DL1 and HLA-B subtype combinations were separate from and additive to the benefit of donor activating KIR2DS1. Conclusion Consideration of KIR3DL1-mediated inhibition in donor selection for HLA-matched HCT may achieve superior graft versus leukemia effects, lower risk for relapse, and an increase in survival among patients with AML.

Assessment of optimal size and composition of the U.S. National Registry of hematopoietic stem cell donors.

BACKGROUND: The National Marrow Donor Program (NMDP) receives federal funding to operate a registry of over 4 million volunteer donors for patients in need of a hematopoietic stem cell transplant. Because minority patients are less likely to find a suitably matched donor than whites, special efforts have been aimed toward recruitment of minorities. Significant financial resources are required to recruit and tissue type additional volunteer donors. METHODS: Population genetics models have been constructed to project likelihoods of finding a human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-matched donor for patients of various racial/ethnic groups. These projections have been made under a variety of strategies for expansion of the NMDP Registry. Cost-effectiveness calculations incorporated donor unavailability and other barriers to transplantation. RESULTS: At current recruitment rates, the probability of an available HLA-A,B,DRB1 matched donor is projected to increase from 27% to 34%; 45% to 54%; 75% to 79%; and 48% to 55%, for blacks, Asians/Pacific Islanders, whites and Hispanics, respectively, by the year 2007. Substantial increases in minority recruitment would have only modest impacts on these projections. These projections are heavily affected by donor availability rates, which are less than 50% for minority volunteers. CONCLUSIONS: Continued recruitment of additional volunteers can improve the likelihood of finding an HLA-matched donor, but will still leave significant numbers of patients of all racial/ethnic groups without a match. Efforts to improve donor availability (especially among minorities) and to increase the number of patients with access to the NMDP Registry may prove to be more cost-effective means of increasing transplants.

Diversity within the DRB1*08 allele family in four populations from a United States hematopoietic stem cell donor database and characterization of five novel DRB1*08 alleles.

The frequencies of DRB1*08 alleles within four major United States populations found within a hematopoietic stem cell volunteer donor database were determined by DNA sequencing of over 60 DRB1*08 positive individuals from each group. Seven of 30 known DRB1*08 alleles were identified within this study population (080101, 080201, 080302, 080401, 0806, 0807, and 0811). Each ethnic group was characterized by a different highly prevalent allele: DRB1*080101 in Caucasians; DRB1*080401 in African-Americans; DRB1*080302 in Asians; and DRB1*080201 in Hispanics. The alleles DRB1*080101, DRB1*080201, and DRB1*080401 were present in all four populations. This report also describes five novel DRB1*08 alleles uncovered during routine human leukocyte antigen typing.

HLA diversity: detection and impact on unrelated hematopoietic stem cell donor characterization and selection.

Matching of patient and unrelated donor for HLA molecules significantly decreases the probability of graft rejection, graft vs. host disease, and transplant-related mortality in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. A significant challenge in the identification of matched donors is the diversity of the HLA system. Almost 1500 alleles have been identified at 12 HLA loci. Significant progress has been made in the application of DNA-based testing to identify this diversity in patients and unrelated volunteer donors; however, the resolution of registry testing remains limited by the need to test many donors inexpensively. Thus, the transplant center must predict which donor might be a match for their patient using incomplete typing information. Design of a typing strategy based on knowledge of allele and haplotype frequencies is critical to speed donor identification. A further challenge is to compare patient HLA assignments to the over 7.7 million volunteer donors on registries carrying both DNA and serologic assignments. The links between alleles and serologic specificities remain unclear in many cases and complicate the design of computer algorithms used to match patients and donors. Finally, since few patients will find donors who are allele matched for all HLA loci, studies are underway to understand which of the HLA loci are most critical to match and to define rules of permissive mismatching to achieve an acceptable outcome.