RESUMEN
Purpose: Quantification of integral radiation dose delivered during treatment for prostate cancer is lacking. We performed a comparative quantification of dose to nontarget body tissues delivered via 4 common radiation techniques: conventional volumetric modulated arc therapy, stereotactic body radiation therapy, pencil-beam scanning proton therapy, and high-dose-rate brachytherapy. Methods and Materials: Plans for each radiation technique were generated for 10 patients with typical anatomy. For brachytherapy plans, virtual needles were placed to achieve standard dosimetry. Standard planning target volume margins or robustness margins were applied as appropriate. A "normal tissue" structure (entire computed tomography simulation volume minus planning target volume) was generated for integral dose computation. Dose-volume histogram parameters for targets and normal structures were tabulated. Normal tissue integral dose was calculated by multiplying normal tissue volume by mean dose. Results: Normal tissue integral dose was lowest for brachytherapy. Pencil-beam scanning protons, stereotactic body radiation therapy, and brachytherapy resulted in 17%, 57%, and 91% absolute reductions compared with standard volumetric modulated arc therapy, respectively. Mean nontarget tissues receiving 25%, 50%, and 75% of the prescription dose were reduced by 85%, 76%, and 83% for brachytherapy relative to volumetric modulated arc therapy, by 79%, 64%, and 74% relative to stereotactic body radiation therapy, and 73%, 60%, and 81% relative to proton therapy. All reductions observed using brachytherapy were statistically significant. Conclusions: High-dose-rate brachytherapy is an effective technique for reducing dose to nontarget body tissues relative to volumetric modulated arc therapy, stereotactic body radiation therapy, and pencil-beam scanning proton therapy.
RESUMEN
PURPOSE: We present 4-year results from a Phase I/II trial using balloon-based brachytherapy to deliver accelerated partial breast irradiation in 2 days. MATERIALS/METHODS: Forty-five patients received breast-conserving surgery followed by adjuvant radiation therapy using a balloon-based brachytherapy applicator delivering 2800 cGy in four fractions over 2 days. Outcomes analyzed include toxicities scored using the NCI Common Toxicity Criteria v3.0 scale, ipsilateral breast tumor recurrence, regional nodal failure, distant metastasis, disease-free survival, cause-specific survival, and overall survival. RESULTS: Median age was 66 years (range, 48-83 years) and median tumor size was 0.6 cm (range, 0.2-2.3 cm). Five percent of patients were node positive (n=2), whereas 73% was estrogen receptor positive (n=33). Median followup was 3.7 years (2.4-7.0 years) with greater than 2 years of followup for all patients. Only Grades 1 and 2 chronic toxicities were noted with fat necrosis (18%) and asymptomatic seromas (42%) being the most common toxicities. Seven percent of patients developed ipsilateral rib fractures (n=3), although this was not statistically associated with maximum rib dose (p=0.31). Ninety-eight percent of patients had a good or excellent radiation-related cosmetic outcome at the time of last followup. There were no ipsilateral breast tumor recurrences or regional nodal failures; however, 2 patients developed distant metastases. Four-year actuarial disease-free survival, cause-specific survival, and overall survival were 96%, 100%, and 93%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of early-stage breast cancer patients with breast-conserving therapy using a 2-day radiation dose schedule resulted in acceptable chronic toxicity and similar clinical outcomes as standard 5-day fractionation.