New evidence of consistency between phylogeny and morphology for two taxa in ciliated protists, the subclasses Oligotrichia and Choreotrichia (Protista, Ciliophora).

Marine planktonic ciliates are largely oligotrichs and choreotrichs, which are two subclasses of the class Spirotrichea. The current phylogenetic assignments of oligotrichs and choreotrichs are inconsistent with previous results based on morphological features, probably hindered by the limited information from a single gene locus. Here we provide 53 new sequences from small subunit ribosomal RNA (SSU rDNA), ITS1-5.8S rDNA-ITS2, and large subunit ribosomal RNA (LSU rDNA) gene loci in 25 oligotrich and choreotrich species. We also predict RNA secondary structures for the ITS2 regions in 55 species, 48 species of which are reported for the first time. Based on these novel data, we make a more comprehensive phylogenetic reconstruction, revealing consistency between morphological taxonomy and an updated phylogenetic system for oligotrichs and choreotrichs. With the addition of data from ciliature patterns and genes, the phylogenetic analysis of the subclass Oligotrichia suggests three evolutionary trajectories, among which: 1) Novistrombidium asserts an ancestral ciliary pattern in Oligotrichia; 2) the subgenera division of Novistrombidium and Parallelostrombidium are fully supported; 3) the three families (Tontoniidae, Pelagostrombidiidae and Cyrtostrombidiidae) all evolved from the most diverse family Strombidiidae, which explains why strombidiids consistently form polyphyletic clades. In the subclass Choreotrichia, Strombidinopsis likely possesses an ancestral position to other choreotrichs, and both phylogenetic analysis and RNA secondary structure prediction support the hypothesis that tintinnids may have evolved from Strombidinopsis. The results presented here offer an updated hypothesis for the evolutionary history of oligotrichs and choreotrichs based on new evidence obtained by expanding sampling of molecular information across multiple gene loci.