Comparison of preclinical efficacy of immunotherapies against HPV-induced cancers.

ABSTRACT

INTRODUCTION: Persistent infections with the human papilloma viruses, HPV16 and HPV18, are associated with multiple cancers. Although prophylactic vaccines that induce HPV-neutralizing antibodies are effective against primary infections, they have no effect on HPV-mediated malignancies against which there is no approved immuno-therapy. Active research is ongoing on immunotherapy of these cancers. AREAS COVERED In this review, we compared the preclinical efficacy of vaccine platforms used to treat HPV-induced tumors in the standard model of mice grafted with TC-1 cells, which express the HPV16 E6 and E7 oncoproteins. We searched for the key words, 'HPV,' 'vaccine,' 'therapy,' 'E7,' 'tumor,' 'T cells' and 'mice' for the period from 2005 to 2023 in PubMed and found 330 publications. Among them, we selected the most relevant to extract preclinical antitumor results to enable cross-sectional comparison of their efficacy. EXPERT OPINION SECTION We compared these studies for HPV antigen design, immunization regimen, immunogenicity, and antitumor effect, considering their drawbacks and advantages. Among all strategies used in murine models, certain adjuvanted proteins and viral vectors showed the strongest antitumor effects, with the use of lentiviral vectors being the only approach to result in complete tumor eradication in 100% of experimental individuals while providing the longest-lasting memory.

Persistent infections with the human papilloma virus HPV16 and HPV18 gentoypes can cause multiple cancers.Prophylactic anti-HPV vaccines show no efficacy against persistent HPV infections or already malignant tissues.No immunotherapy against HPV-induced cancers has been thus far approved for use in humans.Active research is ongoing on immunotherapy of HPV-induced malignancies.We compared the efficacy of the immunotherapy strategies developed against HPV-induced cancers in the standard murine TC-1 tumor model since 2005.Certain adjuvanted proteins and viral vectors induce the strongest effects against HPV-induced tumors.Lentiviral vectors, able to induce the longest-lasting T-cell immune memory, give rise to full eradication of large solid tumors in 100% of mice.