Safety and efficacy of a cytomegalovirus glycoprotein B (gB) vaccine in adolescent girls: A randomized clinical trial.

BACKGROUND: Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is a leading cause of congenital infection and an important target for vaccine development. METHODS: CMV seronegative girls between 12 and 17 years of age received CMV glycoprotein B (gB) vaccine with MF59 or saline placebo at 0, 1 and 6 months. Blood and urine were collected throughout the study for evidence of CMV infection based on PCR and/or seroconversion to non-vaccine CMV antigens. RESULTS: 402 CMV seronegative subjects were vaccinated (195 vaccine, 207 placebo). The vaccine was generally well tolerated, although local and systemic adverse events were significantly more common in the vaccine group. The vaccine induced gB antibody in all vaccine recipients with a gB geometric mean titer of 13,400 EU; 95%CI 11,436, 15,700, after 3 doses. Overall, 48 CMV infections were detected (21 vaccine, 27 placebo). In the per protocol population (124 vaccine, 125 placebo) vaccine efficacy was 43%; 95%CI: -36; 76, p=0.20. The most significant difference was after 2 doses, administered as per protocol; vaccine efficacy 45%, 95%CI: -9; 72, p=0.08. CONCLUSION: The vaccine was safe and immunogenic. Although the efficacy did not reach conventional levels of significance, the results are consistent with a previous study in adult women (Pass et al. N Engl J Med 2009;360:1191) using the same formulation.

Acceptability of optical coherence tomography and abstinence requirements among women participating in microbicide safety trials.

BACKGROUND: Developing effective and safe microbicides requires study procedures (e.g., technology used, abstinence requirements, and product use) that are acceptable to participants. METHODS: Thirty women completed 4 study visits including pelvic examination, colposcopy, optical coherence tomography (OCT), and semistructured, qualitative interviews. Additional requirements included abstinence (for approximately 16 days) and twice daily vaginal product use (for 5.5 days). Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using framework analysis. Themes addressing OCT experiences, acceptability of abstinence, and vaginal product use were examined. RESULTS: OCT was viewed favorably as an imaging technology. Some women reported feeling the fiber-optic probe "poking" them and more than one-third spontaneously reported feeling pressure or pinching upon rotation of the speculum in connection with the OCT evaluation. Compliance with vaginal gel use was high, but for many women assigned to use a product containing nonoxynol-9 (vs. placebo), the postproduct use examination was more uncomfortable, relative to the initial examination or 1 week following product discontinuation. Nearly all women experienced product leakage; acceptability of leakage varied. Two women were not abstinent and several more found abstinence challenging. Some women involved their partner in decision making regarding trial enrollment. Strategies to remain abstinent included participating when the partner was away, avoiding early intimacy, and engaging in alternative sexual activities. CONCLUSIONS: Qualitative interviews in early-phase studies provide insights and capture information that would be missed by behavioral inference alone. Understanding participant's experiences is important in order to provide anticipatory guidance and plan future microbicide studies that facilitate adherence with trial requirements.

Optical coherence tomography compared with colposcopy for assessment of vaginal epithelial damage: a randomized controlled trial.

OBJECTIVE: Colposcopy has been used to detect epithelial damage with vaginal microbicides. In animal models, optical coherence tomography provided increased sensitivity over colposcopy in detecting epithelial injury. This randomized, double-blinded, clinical study compared optical coherence tomography to colposcopy for the evaluation of epithelial injury in women using placebo or nonoxynol-9. METHODS: Thirty women aged 18-45 were randomized to use hydroxyethyl cellulose placebo or nonoxynol-9 vaginal gel twice daily for 5.5 days. Imaging with colposcopy and optical coherence tomography was performed before product use, after the last dose, and 1 week later. Colposcopy was graded using standard criteria. Optical coherence tomography images were scored for epithelial integrity based on a published scoring system and were measured for epithelial thickness. RESULTS: Colposcopy findings, optical coherence tomography scores, and epithelial thicknesses were similar between treatment groups at baseline. After treatment, there were significant differences between the nonoxynol-9 (1.37) and control group (1.15) optical coherence tomography scores (P<.001), indicating epithelial injury, and there was epithelial thinning in the nonoxynol-9 group (237 micrometers) compared with the control group (292 micrometers; P=.008). There were no significant posttreatment colposcopic differences in epithelial disruption between treatment groups, with only increased erythema noted after nonoxynol-9 use (P=.02). CONCLUSION: Optical coherence tomography detected epithelial disruption and thinning not identified by colposcopy. Vaginal epithelial thickness, a measure previously available only through biopsy, decreased after nonoxynol-9 use, a finding that may contribute to increased susceptibility to human immunodeficiency virus after frequent use. Optical coherence tomography shows promise for the noninvasive clinical assessment of vaginal epithelial damage. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: UMIN Clinical Trials Registry, www.umin.ac.jp/ctr/index.htm, R000006186. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: I.

Benzalkonium chloride causes colposcopic changes and increased susceptibility to genital herpes infection in mice.

BACKGROUND: Colposcopy is widely used in clinical microbicide safety testing but not in preclinical small animal studies. Endoscopic colposcopy could be employed in small animals allowing colposcopy to be used as one component in a multifactorial safety testing paradigm. STUDY DESIGN: We conducted dose-response studies in mice using 2%, 0.2%, or 0.02% benzalkonium chloride (BZK) as the test compound, and using multiple safety end points that included endoscopic colposcopy, susceptibility to vaginal HSV-2 infection, histology, and entry of inflammatory cells into the vagina. RESULTS: Animals treated with 0.2% or higher BZK experienced vaginal toxicities detectable by all tests used including colposcopy. In contrast, 0.02% BZK produced no significant changes except by histology in which a significant thinning of the vaginal epithelium was seen. CONCLUSION: Endoscopic colposcopy detected microbicide-elicited changes in the mouse vagina with similar sensitivity to the other endpoints used in these studies and would appear to be useful as part of a multifactorial microbicide safety testing paradigm in mice.

High resolution imaging of epithelial injury in the sheep cervicovaginal tract: a promising model for testing safety of candidate microbicides.

BACKGROUND: Access to readily available large animal models and sensitive noninvasive techniques that can be used for the evaluation of microbicide-induced changes in tissue could significantly facilitate preclinical evaluations of microbicide safety. The sheep cervicovaginal tract, with stratified squamous epithelium similar to humans, holds promise as a large animal model used before nonhuman primates. In addition, optical coherence tomography (OCT) could enable high resolution visualization of tissue morphology and noninvasive assessment of microbicide-induced epithelial injury. METHODS: We evaluated the dose response of sheep cervicovaginal tract to benzalkonium chloride (BZK). Twenty sheep received treatment with phosphate-buffered saline or BZK solution (2%, 0.2%, or 0.02%). Pre- and posttreatment colposcopy and OCT images were collected and graded based on World Health Organization criteria and a previously reported scoring system, respectively. Biopsies were collected and the degree of epithelial injury and its thickness was assessed based on histology and OCT. RESULTS: The sheep cervicovagina exhibited anatomic and microscopic features similar to the human. Extensive loss of the epithelium was noted on colposcopy and OCT after application of 2% BZK. Colposcopy detected findings in half of sheep and OCT in all sheep treated with 0.2% BZK. OCT detected differences in the 0.02% BZK-treated group compared with controls, whereas colposcopy failed to detect any changes. CONCLUSIONS: The sheep cervicovagina is similar to humans, and exhibits dose dependent epithelial changes after BZK treatment. These findings suggest that the sheep model and OCT may become valuable tools for the safety evaluation of candidate microbicides, and warrant continued development.

Application of optical coherence tomography for monitoring changes in cervicovaginal epithelial morphology in macaques: potential for assessment of microbicide safety.

OBJECTIVES: Safety is a primary concern in the development of topical microbicides. Optical coherence tomography (OCT), a high-resolution, in-depth cross-sectional imaging modality, was utilized in conjunction with colposcopy to assess induced cervicovaginal epithelial changes that may predict product safety. STUDY DESIGN: OCT and colposcopic images of macaque vaginal and cervical tissues were obtained in excised tissue and in vivo under various conditions, including mechanical injury and nonoxynol-9 treatment. RESULTS: A scoring system was developed to categorize and quantify the OCT images based on morphologic features that indicate the presence or absence of an intact epithelial layer and inflammation. Using 3 categories (normal, mild to moderately abnormal, and severely abnormal), differences between healthy and injured tissue were apparent on OCT images. Normal images (category 1) had a bilayered structure representative of the epithelium and submucosa. Mild to moderately abnormal images (category 2) had areas of normal and abnormal epithelium. Severely abnormal images (category 3) had complete loss of the epithelium and/or inflammation, with loss of the bilayered structure on OCT. CONCLUSIONS: OCT is a noninvasive imaging modality complementary to colposcopy. It distinguished between normal and abnormal (or injured) tissue and thus holds promise for safety evaluations of candidate microbicides and other vaginal products.

Randomized controlled trial of an adjuvanted human papillomavirus (HPV) type 6 L2E7 vaccine: infection of external anogenital warts with multiple HPV types and failure of therapeutic vaccination.

BACKGROUND: Cellular immunity is involved in spontaneous clearance of anogenital warts caused, most typically, by human papillomavirus (HPV) type 6 or 11, supporting the concept of therapeutic vaccination. A therapeutic vaccine composed of HPV-6 L2E7 fusion protein and AS02A adjuvant was evaluated in conjunction with conventional therapies in subjects with anogenital warts. METHODS: A total of 457 subjects with anogenital warts were screened, of which 320 with HPV-6 and/or HPV-11 infection were enrolled into 2 double-blind, placebo-controlled substudies. Three doses of vaccine or placebo were administered along with either ablative therapy or podophyllotoxin. RESULTS: Although a positive trend toward clearance was seen in patients infected with only HPV-6, in neither substudy did the vaccine significantly increase the efficacy of conventional therapies, despite induction of adequate immune responses. Extensive HPV typing by polymerase chain reaction demonstrated that a majority of screened subjects (73.7%) were infected with HPV-6 and/or HPV-11 and that a large proportion (40.1%) were infected with multiple HPV types. HPV types that put subjects at high risk of development of cervical cancer were detected in 39.8% of subjects. CONCLUSIONS: Infection with multiple HPV types, including high-risk types, is common in anogenital wart disease. Therapeutic vaccination failed to increase the efficacy of conventional therapies.

Impact of immunization with glycoprotein D2/AS04 on herpes simplex virus type 2 shedding into the genital tract in guinea pigs that become infected.

In recent clinical trials, a vaccine that contained herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) glycoprotein D (gD2) and the adjuvant AS04 afforded HSV-seronegative women significant protection against HSV-2 genital disease and limited protection against infection. Similarly, in guinea pigs, immunization with the vaccine provided significant protection against genital HSV-2 disease but did not prevent mucosal infection. We explored the impact of immunization on the magnitude of latent virus infection and on the frequency and magnitude of virus reactivation as measured by both recurrent disease and viral shedding into the genital tract. Guinea pigs immunized with gD2/AS04 were shown by quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) analysis to have significantly less latent viral DNA in the ganglia than did naive control guinea pigs and to have a reduced incidence and frequency of recurrent disease. By contrast, all immunized guinea pigs shed virus into the genital tract with a frequency comparable to that seen in control guinea pigs. However, the amount of virus shed was significantly reduced, as measured by qPCR. These data suggest that immunization could affect transmission by altering viral shedding patterns.

Vaccines for sexually transmitted infections.

STIs are responsible for significant human suffering and carry significant economic costs. Strategies to control STIs, such as screening programs and condoms, have had limited success. Vaccines offer an additional method that is not coitally related and does not depend on consistent use. The HPV vaccine confers protection against the most common types causing cervical dysplasia. Mathematical modeling suggests that the HSV vaccine, given universally to all young women, should reduce genital and neonatal herpes in the population at large. Much work remains on vaccines for chlamydia and gonorrhea, but they offer the hope of preventing pelvic inflammatory disease and its sequelae. As these vaccines become licensed, their successful implementation will require the support of professional organizations, families, and providers.

Neonatal herpes should be a reportable disease.

Neonatal herpes is a devastating disease, the most serious complication of genital herpes, one of the most common serious congenital or perinatal infections, and the most frequent complication of sexually transmitted infections among children. Nevertheless, neonatal herpes is not reportable to health authorities in most states. The potential for prevention has been enhanced by recent diagnostic and therapeutic advances, and the disease meets widely accepted criteria for reporting, including incidence rates that exceed those of comparable conditions, epidemiologic instability, disease severity, direct and indirect socioeconomic costs, concern by persons at risk, the potential for prevention by public health interventions, and the prospect that the resulting data would influence public health policy. The absence of national surveillance contributes to beliefs by healthcare providers and the public health community that genital and neonatal herpes are uncommon conditions that affect small segments of society, beliefs that directly interfere with prevention. Neonatal herpes should be a reportable condition.

Effects of candidate vaginally-applied microbicide compounds on innate immune cells.

Ideally, a vaginally-applied microbicide would be effective against a broad range of pathogens but would have minimal effects on the female genital tract. The aim of this study was to determine if representative candidate detergent-type and sulfated/sulfonated polymer-type microbicides altered the composition or function of innate immune cells normally found in the vaginal mucosa. The effect of microbicide on the composition of vaginal leukocytes was tested using a flow cytometric approach. Application of the detergent cholic acid, but not the sulfated polysaccharide lambda carrageenan, resulted in a significant increase in macrophages at the vaginal epithelial surface compared to control treatment (19.3% macrophages compared to 2.8%; p<0.0004). Phagocytosis of fluorochrome-labeled bacteria by macrophages was inhibited greater than 50% in the presence of 1.0mg/ml of the sulfonated polymer PRO 2000 but was not inhibited by the same concentration of lambda carrageenan. PRO 2000-pulsed macrophages regained phagocytic function after being washed free of the compound. Culture of macrophages with PRO 2000 also resulted in diminished detection of the surface proteins CD11b and CD18. After treated cells were washed free of PRO 2000, these proteins were detected at levels similar to control treated cells. In conclusion, application of a detergent-type microbicide, but not a sulfated polymer, resulted in the infiltration of inflammatory cells at the vaginal epithelial surface. Phagocytic function of macrophages was lost in the presence of 1mg/ml PRO 2000 which may have reflected masking of important cell surface proteins by the microbicide; however, there was no evidence of permanent loss of function upon removal of the compound.

Progress in vaccines for sexually transmitted diseases.

The development pipeline for vaccines to control sexually transmitted infections holds greater promise than ever before. Preclinical studies are encouraging in the development of chlamydia and gonococcal vaccines, and for the first time, recent clinical trials have shown the feasibility of creating vaccines to control genital herpes and cervical human papillomavirus infections. Behavioral research suggests that these vaccines will likely find acceptance among health care providers and consumers.

Safety and immunogenicity of glycoprotein D-adjuvant genital herpes vaccine.

BACKGROUND: Two previous trials have suggested that a herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 2 glycoprotein D (gD) vaccine combined with the adjuvants alum and 3'-O-deacylated-monophosphoryl lipid A (MPL) is well tolerated and provides protection against genital herpes disease in women with no preexisting HSV antibody. METHODS: The safety and immunogenicity of this vaccine were evaluated in a large, multicenter, double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial. The effects of sex and preexisting HSV immunity were sought. RESULTS: When solicited symptoms that continued after the initial 4 days of observation were excluded, the incidence of unsolicited symptoms occurring during the 7 months after vaccination (the primary analysis period) was 22.1% in vaccine recipients and 21.9% in placebo recipients. Significant increases in the number of local and systemic symptoms were found in vaccine recipients within 4 days after vaccination. However, most symptoms were mild to moderate in severity and were short lived. Women reported symptoms more frequently than did men, but preexisting immunity had little effect. The vaccine induced higher titers of HSV gD antibody on enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays than did natural infection with HSV. CONCLUSION: The vaccine was generally safe, well tolerated, and immunogenic.

Predictors of herpes simplex virus type 2 antibody positivity among persons with no history of genital herpes.

BACKGROUND: The demographic, historical, and behavioral factors that predict a positive herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) antibody test in persons without a history of genital herpes have not been well-defined. METHODS: Individuals (age 14-30 years) without a history of genital herpes completed a questionnaire and were offered free HSV-2 antibody testing. Factors from the questionnaire were correlated with the HSV-2 antibody result. RESULTS: Univariate analysis showed that female gender was significantly associated with positive test results. In gender-specific, multiple logistic regression models, a positive HSV-2 antibody test among men was associated with older age, non-white race, and a history of sexually transmitted disease (STD). Gender-specific symptom scores from the questionnaire were not predictive in either gender, but the gender-common symptom score was marginally predictive of a positive HSV-2 antibody test in women. Among women, older age, non-white race, and STD history predicted a positive test. CONCLUSIONS: Among young persons with no history of genital herpes who agreed to HSV-2 antibody testing, increasing age, non-white race, and a history of an STD were predictors of a positive test. A history of frequent pain, itching, burning, and rashes in the anogenital region was marginally associated with positive HSV-2 tests in women. These results might help guide selective use of HSV-2 antibody screening.

New biomedical approaches for sexually transmitted infection prevention: vaccines and microbicides.

STIs are a major global health problem. Biomedical strategies are under development that will help prevent these infections. Vaccines against C. trachomatis and N. gonorrhoeae are in early stages of development. Stage-III trials are underway on prophylactic vaccines for HPV and HSV-2. Strategies focused on immunizing only high-risk individuals are unlikely to stem the tide of STIs. Approaches to widespread immunization require acceptance of such vaccines by health care providers, institutions providing funding, parents, and adolescents. Microbicides offer a female-controlled method for protection from STIs. They use many strategies to prevent infection. These products are at various stages of development. It seems that young women and teenagers would be interested in using microbicides. Correct and consistent use of microbicides will require taking women's preferences into account during product development and marketing.

Effect of candidate vaginally-applied microbicide compounds on recognition of antigen by CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes.

Vaginally applied antimicrobial compounds (microbicides) are being developed as an alternative method for preventing the spread of sexually transmitted diseases. In addition to identifying compounds effective against a spectrum of sexually transmitted pathogens, it will be important to ensure that these compounds are safe. Avoiding toxicity, inflammatory responses, or alteration of the function of resident immune cells are important considerations for the development of vaginally applied microbicides. Studies were performed with two classes of candidate microbicide compounds to determine if they would interfere with the recognition of antigen by CD4(+) and CD8(+) T lymphocytes. The presence of nontoxic concentrations of the anionic detergent cholic acid or the sulfated polymer lambda carrageenan did not inhibit recognition of immune peptide by antigen-specific T cells. However, antigen recognition by both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T lymphocytes was inhibited in the presence of the naphthalene sulfonate polymer PRO 2000. Brief (4-h) exposure of antigen-presenting cells or T cells to PRO 2000 did not result in inhibition of antigen uptake and processing by antigen-presenting cells or the ability of specific T cells to respond to antigen stimulation, suggesting that the inhibition was temporary. Binding of antibodies specific for CD18, CD8, and CD3 was impaired in the presence of PRO 2000, suggesting that the mechanism by which this microbicide inhibits T cell recognition of antigenic peptide may involve masking or internalization of surface proteins involved in T cell signaling or stabilizing T cell-antigen-presenting cell interactions. The assays described in this study represent a useful means to screen candidate topical microbicide compounds for inappropriate interactions with immune cells and may be useful for prioritization of candidate microbicide compounds.

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 2 glycoprotein D subunit vaccines and protection against genital HSV-1 or HSV-2 disease in guinea pigs.

In two recent clinical trials, a vaccine containing herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 2 glycoprotein D (gD2) and a novel adjuvant AS04 comprising alum (Al) and 3-deactylated monophosphoryl lipid A (3-dMPL) afforded HSV-seronegative women significant protection against HSV-2 genital disease (vaccine efficacy, 73% in study 1 and 74% in study 2) and limited protection against infection (46% in study 1 and 39% in study 2). In the present report, studies in the guinea pig model investigated the protection afforded by gD2/AS04 against HSV-1 and HSV-2 genital herpes and investigated whether immunization could prevent or reduce recurrent disease in guinea pigs that developed mucosal infection. Immunization with gD2/AS04 conveyed nearly complete protection against primary disease with either virus but did not prevent mucosal infection. Guinea pigs immunized with gD2/AS04 were significantly better protected against recurrent disease than were guinea pigs immunized with a gD2/Al vaccine, which suggests that inclusion of 3-dMPL improved protection against latent infection.

Glycoprotein-D-adjuvant vaccine to prevent genital herpes.

BACKGROUND: An effective prophylactic vaccine would help control the spread of genital herpes. METHODS: We conducted two double-blind, randomized trials of a herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) glycoprotein-D-subunit vaccine with alum and 3-O-deacylated-monophosphoryl lipid A in subjects whose regular sexual partners had a history of genital herpes. In Study 1, subjects were seronegative for herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) and HSV-2; in Study 2, subjects were of any HSV serologic status. At months 0, 1, and 6, subjects received either vaccine or a control injection and were evaluated for 19 months. The primary end point was the occurrence of genital herpes disease in all subjects in Study 1 and in HSV-2-seronegative female subjects in Study 2. RESULTS: A total of 847 subjects who were seronegative for both HSV-1 and HSV-2 (268 of them women, in Study 1) and 1867 subjects who were seronegative for HSV-2 (710 of them women, in Study 2) underwent randomization and received injections. Vaccination was well tolerated and elicited humoral and cellular responses. Overall, the efficacy of the vaccine was 38 percent in Study 1 (95 percent confidence interval, -18 to 68 percent; 15 cases occurred in the vaccine group and 24 in the control group), and efficacy in female subjects was 42 percent in Study 2 (95 percent confidence interval, -31 to 74 percent; 9 cases occurred in the vaccine group and 16 in the control group). In both studies, further analysis showed that the vaccine was efficacious in women who were seronegative for both HSV-1 and HSV-2: efficacy in Study 1 was 73 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 19 to 91 percent; P=0.01), and efficacy in Study 2 was 74 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 9 to 93 percent; P=0.02). It was not efficacious in women who were seropositive for HSV-1 and seronegative for HSV-2 at base line or in men. CONCLUSIONS: These studies suggest that the glycoprotein D vaccine has efficacy against genital herpes in women who are seronegative for both HSV-1 and HSV-2 at base line but not in those who are seropositive for HSV-1 and seronegative for HSV-2. It had no efficacy in men, regardless of their HSV serologic status.

Entry of inflammatory cells into the mouse vagina following application of candidate microbicides: comparison of detergent-based and sulfated polymer-based agents.

BACKGROUND: Because topical microbicides designed to prevent the spread of sexually transmitted diseases may be applied frequently, it is important to ensure product safety as well as efficacy. A murine model was developed to test for induction of inflammatory responses following application of candidate microbicides. GOAL: A comparison was made of the induction of inflammation following vaginal application of detergent-based and sulfated polymer-based microbicides. STUDY DESIGN: Vaginal leukocytes were collected, identified, and quantified following microbicide application to detect the entry of inflammatory leukocytes into the vaginal lumen. RESULTS: Large numbers of neutrophils and macrophages entered the vaginal lumen following a single application of detergent-based microbicides. No significant increase in vaginal leukocytes was detected following a single or repeated application of sulfated polymer-based microbicides. CONCLUSION: Application of sulfated polymer-based microbicides was less likely to result in inflammatory responses than was application of detergent-based compounds. This murine model should prove useful as part of a screening process to prioritize candidate microbicides before clinical trial.