Intra-patient comparison of parietal pleural biopsies by rigid forceps, flexible forceps and cryoprobe obtained during medical thoracoscopy: a prospective series of 80 cases with pleural effusion.

BACKGROUND: There is only few data available on the use of cryotechnique during medical thoracoscopy. METHODS: Medical thoracoscopy was performed in consecutive patients with pleural effusion. Prospectively, biopsies were taken by rigid forceps, flexible forceps and cryoprobe. Specimen size, depth and diagnostic yield were compared. RESULTS: 80 Patients were included. 408 biopsies were taken (205 rigid biopsies, 104 flexible biopsies, 99 cryobiopsies). Mean surface area of rigid biopsies was 22.6 ± 20.4 mm(2) (flexible biopsies: 7.1 ± 9.3 mm(2), cryobiopsies: 14.4 ± 12.8 mm(2)). Rigid biopsies were significantly larger than cryobiopsies (p < 0.001) and flexible biopsies (p < 0.001), crybiopsies were significantly larger than flexible biopsies (p < 0.01). A deep biopsy containing fatty tissue was harvested in 63 % of rigid biopsies (cryobiopsy: 49.5 % flexible biopsy: 39.5 %). In 79/80 cases (98.7 % 95 % CI cannot be calculated) a diagnosis was obtained by rigid biopsy (cryobiopsy: 73/80 cases (91.3 % 95 % CI 86.0 - 96.5 %), flexible biopsy: 74/80 cases (92.5 % 95 % CI 88.6 - 97.4 %)). Diagnostic yield achieved with cryobiopsies was inferior to the yield of rigid biopsies (Difference: 12.7 %), but non-inferior to flexible biopsies (Difference: 6.5 %). CONCLUSION: Cryobiopsies in medical thoracoscopy are safe with high diagnostic yield, non-inferior to flexible biopsies with increased tissue quantity and quality. Cryotechnique can develop an important role in medical thoracoscopy in the near future when rigid thoracoscopy is not available.

[Diagnostic yield and safety of bronchoscopic cryotechnique in routine diagnostics for suspected lung cancer]. / Diagnostischer Wert und Sicherheit der bronchoskopischen Kryotechnik im Routineeinsatz bei Verdacht auf Lungenkarzinom.

BACKGROUND: Cryoprobes with flexible catheters are an additional important tool for endobronchial interventional therapy and histologic diagnosis. Different studies compared the diagnostic effectiveness and complications to the forceps as a standard. However, routine endoscopic procedures require a combined use of different methods in order to achieve the highest diagnostic yield. We investigated the impact of cryotechnique in comparison with combined diagnostic tools during routine diagnostics of malignant tumors. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A consecutive series of patients undergoing routine diagnostic for lung cancer was included over a 30 months period (n = 469). The use of the cryotechnique, the complication rates and diagnostic value were prospectively documented. Cryotechnique was used on top of conventional technologies. RESULTS: A histologic proof of tumor by cryotechnique in centrally located tumors was delivered more frequently compared to forceps biopsies alone (81.4 versus 59.9% and 66.2 versus 37.7% in peripheral lesions). However, when the other non-cryotechniques were taken into account, the value was reduced in central probes (7.4%; p = 0.02), but remained high for peripheral findings (19.3%; p < 0.002). The frequency of complications seemed unchanged, however severe bleeding occurred. CONCLUSION: The cryotechnique bears high diagnostic potential beside its therapeutic value, also in routine investigations. The changed complication profile of this technology needs to be addressed in the informed consent and secured airway management may be helpful.