The tumorigenicity of mutagenic contact-sensitizing chemicals.

The electrophilic nature of some contact sensitizers, that is, chemicals that cause allergic contact dermatitis (ACD), is also characteristic of genotoxic tumorigens. Electrophiles can adduct protein, which is the basis for ACD, as well as DNA, which is the basis for mutagenicity and carcinogenicity. This suggests that some electrophilic contact sensitizers may be genotoxic tumorigens. To further investigate this matter, we evaluated 146 chemicals that had been bioassayed for tumorigenicity and mutagenicity in the National Toxicology Program, with an analysis of structure-activity relationships for contact sensitization. Using the data from this analysis and from other sources, the proportion of the contact sensitizers that were both mutagenic and tumorigenic was found to range from 20% to 28%. This finding suggests that there may be in the order of 90 genotoxic tumorigens for rodents among the approximately 384 chemicals that have been validated as contact sensitizers for humans.

Allergic contact sensitizing chemicals as environmental carcinogens.

Chemicals that were bioassayed by the National Toxicology Program (NTP) and that also produce allergic dermatitis (ACD) in humans were evaluated for their tumorigenic characteristics. The impetus for the study was that most contact sensitizers, i.e., those that produce ACD, and genotoxic carcinogens are chemically similar in that they are electrophilic, thereby producing adducts on macromolecules including protein and DNA. This similarity in chemical behavior suggests that many contact sensitizers might be environmental carcinogens. All of the published NTP bioassays by early 1996 that had both genotoxicity and carcinogenicity studies were included in this analysis. The NTP chemicals had been chosen for bioassay without regard to their ability to produce ACD. Of the 209 chemicals that were bioassayed, there were 36 (17%) that were known to be human contact sensitizers; about half of these were positive on tumor bioassays. The contact sensitizers differed from the NTP sample as a whole by having a proportionately larger number of nongenotoxic chemicals by the Ames Salmonella assay, presumably because more of them were selected on the basis of widespread usage rather than structural resemblance to known carcinogens. Compared to the nongenotoxic chemicals, the genotoxics were stronger carcinogens in that they had a higher incidence of positive tumor bioassays, with twice the number of organs in which tumors were induced. The nongenotoxic chemicals had a preference for tumor induction in parenchymal tissues in contrast to epithelial tissues. The contact sensitizers showed essentially the same characteristics as the whole NTP sample when stratified according to genotoxicity. Judging by the chemicals that were chosen primarily for their widespread use rather than for their structural resemblance to carcinogens, the addition of a test for contact sensitization to the Ames test as a screening tool would increase the tumorigenic detection efficiency by about 40% because of the nongenotoxic tumorigens. A ballpark estimate suggests that there could be several thousand contact sensitizers for humans in commercial use that are rodent tumorigens.

Colcemid alters S phase and other parameters in skin during chronic exposure to benzo(a)pyrene.

The administration of Colcemid for collecting mitotic figures in a carcinogenesis study, using benzo(a)pyrene (BaP), diminished the experimental differences between exposed and control mice. A dose-related increase in noncollected mitotic index (n-mitotic index) was seen in keratinocytes in the dorsal epidermis of mice which received four weekly treatments of BaP at 16, 32 and 64 micrograms in 50 microliters of acetone. In contrast, the number of mitotic figures collected for 4 hr by Colcemid block (c-mitotic index) was depressed at 16 micrograms, unchanged at 32 micrograms, and elevated at 64 micrograms of BaP. Weekly treatments with 4,8 or 16 micrograms BaP for 3-8 months induced an elevation in both n-mitotic and c-mitotic indices. The differences in results produced by the two methods of determining mitotic index depended upon dose and duration of treatment with BaP. The administration of Colcemid to acetone-treated mice increased the labeling index (number of labeled cells) and reduced the rate of DNA synthesis (low grain count per keratinocyte nucleus). After chronic application of BaP, Colcemid abrogated the increase in labeling index, but produced no additional effect on the number of grains per labeled keratinocyte. The modifying effect of Colcemid was greatest when administered during the peak of the tissue response to BaP. A number of significant changes in morphology of the skin associated with chronic exposure to BaP were attenuated by the use of Colcemid.

Cell proliferation and nuclear abnormalities are increased and apoptosis is decreased in the epidermis of the p53 null mouse after topical application of benzo[a]pyrene.

Cell proliferation and cell death in mouse epidermis are altered by topical application of benzo[a]pyrene (BaP), a procarcinogen, which yields metabolites that can form DNA adducts. The mitotic rate, nuclear abnormalities, labelling index, grain density, necrosis and apoptosis were compared in the epidermis of TSG-p53 null (p53-/-) and C57BL wild-type (wt) mice after weekly treatments with BaP to determine whether the absence of the p53 gene altered cytokinetic responses to DNA damaging agents in vivo. Acetone alone or 64 micrograms BaP in 50 microliters acetone was applied to the clipped dorsum of mice once, or in four consecutive weekly treatments. Indices of cell proliferation and cell death were the same in both wt and p53-/- mice treated only with acetone. One application of BaP depressed mitosis and slowed the rate of DNA synthesis in both genotypes. After four applications of BaP the number of keratinocytes in S phase increased substantially, while there was no further slowing in the rate of S phase in the wt and p53-/- mice. Cell proliferation rates and numbers of cells with nuclear abnormalities were higher and there were fewer apoptotic cells and apoptotic bodies in the p53-/- mice than in the wt mice. Numbers of 'sunburn' cells were similar in both types.

Mechanism of skin tumorigenesis by contact sensitizers: the effect of the corticosteroid fluocinolone acetonide on inflammation and tumor induction by 2,4 dinitro-1-fluorobenzene in the skin of the TG.AC (v-Ha-ras) mouse.

The effect of the corticosteroid fluocinolone acetonide (FA) on skin tumor induction and inflammation by the contact sensitizer dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB) was examined. This study broadly relates to the question of whether contact sensitizers, as electrophilic chemicals that produce protein adduction, may constitute an environmental cancer hazard. The specific aim of this study was to evaluate the extent to which the immunogenic inflammatory response to DNFB, in contrast to DNFB cytotoxicity, might be responsible for tumor induction. Experiments were conducted on a transgenic (TG.AC) mouse, incorporating a mutated ras oncogene (v-Ha-ras) that responds rapidly and profusely with skin papillomas to tumor promoters as if it were genetically initiated. Various doses and patterns of DNFB and FA were applied to the skin in a 2-week period; DNFB was given four times and FA was given either with the DNFB or daily. The tumor response to DNFB was completed by 8 weeks from the first dose and was consistent with a dose-squared relationship. FA was not tumorigenic alone; when given with DNFB, it caused only a small reduction in inflammation and tumor yield. When given daily, FA increased ulcerative skin damage, inflammation, and the yield tumors. The results suggest that tumorigenesis by DNFB, in the high-dose short-term regimen used here, is mainly due to its cytotoxicity and not contact sensitization.

Epidermal cytokinetics, DNA adducts, and dermal inflammation in the mouse skin in response to repeated benzo[a]pyrene exposures.

Few studies have investigated the chronic cytokinetic effects of carcinogen exposure in the mouse skin. We report two experiments involving the repeated application of benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) to the dorsal skin of female Ha/ICR mice. In the first experiment, the cytokinetic, inflammatory, and DNA adduct responses were studied daily over a 9-day period encompassing the fourth and fifth weekly applications of BaP at doses of 16, 32, and 64 micrograms. The second experiment involved the same cytokinetic measurements at 1, 3, 5, and 8 months, and the weekly BaP doses were 4, 8, and 16 micrograms. The first study showed that after each application of 32 or 64 micrograms BaP, there was a wave of slow DNA synthesis in the epidermis which peaked at 24 hr, in coincidence with a wave of BaP-DNA adducts, followed by the appearance of dead and damaged keratinocytes. For the first few days after BaP application there was a depression in the mitotic rate which recovered several days before the next BaP application. There was a predominantly monocytic dermal inflammation throughout the observation period. In the second experiment, at the lower BaP doses, there was proliferative depression at 1 month, without dermal inflammation. With continued exposure, the proliferative depression changed to a dose-dependent increase in the rate of proliferation and dermal inflammation. The level of BaP-DNA adducts was followed in the 4 micrograms/week dose group, which showed a threefold increase after 4 months with the appearance of inflammation and heightened cell proliferation. These results suggest that the delayed inflammatory reaction, possibly based on a cell-mediated immune reaction to BaP, might have been responsible for the late cytokinetic responses and the associated increase in the level of BaP-DNA adducts.

Evaluation of a possible association of urban air toxics and asthma.

The prevalence of asthma, measured either as the frequency of hospital admissions or number of deaths attributed to asthma, has increased over the last 15 to 20 years. Rapid increases in disease prevalence are more likely to be attributable to environmental than genetic factors. Inferring from past associations between air pollution and asthma, it is feasible that changes in the ambient environment could contribute to this increase in morbidity and mortality. Scientific evaluation of the links between air pollution and the exacerbation of asthma is incomplete, however. Currently, criteria pollutants [SOx, NOx, O3, CO, Pb, particulate matter (PM10)] and other risk factors (exposure to environmental tobacco smoke, volatile organic compounds, etc.) are constantly being evaluated as to their possible contributions to this situation. Data from these studies suggest that increases in respiratory disease are associated with exposures to ambient concentrations of particulate and gaseous pollutants. Similarly, exposure to environmental tobacco smoke, also a mixture of particulate and gaseous air toxics, has been associated with an increase in asthma among children. In addition, current associations of adverse health effects with existing pollution measurements are often noted at concentrations below those that produce effects in controlled animal and human exposures to each pollutant alone. These findings imply that adverse responses are augmented when persons are exposed to irritant mixtures of particles and gases and that current measurements of air pollution are, in part, indirect in that the concentrations of criteria pollutants are acting as surrogates of our exposure to a complex mixture. Other irritant air pollutants, including certain urban air toxics, are associated with asthma in occupational settings and may interact with criteria pollutants in ambient air to exacerbate asthma. An evaluation of dose-response information for urban air toxics and biological feasibility as possible contributors to asthma is therefore needed. However, this evaluation is compounded by a lack of information on the concentrations of these compounds in the ambient air and their effects on asthma morbidity and mortality. Through an initial review of the current toxicological literature, we propose a tentative list of 30 compounds that could have the highest impact on asthma and respiratory health. These compounds were selected based on their ability to induce or exacerbate asthma in occupational and nonoccupational settings, their allergic potential and ability to react with biological macromolecules, and lastly, their ability to irritate the respiratory passages. We recommend better documentation of exposure to these compounds through routine air sampling and evaluation of total exposure and further evaluation of biological mechanisms through laboratory and epidemiological studies directed specifically at the role these substances play in the induction and exacerbation of asthma.

Life span and cancer mortality in the beagle dog and humans.

This study compares the age-dependence and rate of cancer mortality in untreated Beagles over a lifetime with that of Japanese and US white men and women. The purpose of the study was to determine the extent to which there is a linkage between life span and cancer mortality in Beagle dogs and humans. The two human populations were chosen to represent contrasting races and environments. Using the age at 10% survival as the measure of life span, about 5.5 years in humans was equivalent to 1 year of life in Beagles. The age dependence and total cancer mortality was the same in men and male Beagles. The age dependence was the same in female Beagles and women, but the total cancer mortality was somewhat greater in female Beagles due to more breast cancer. Cancer in Beagles, other than breast cancer in females, consisted mostly of sarcomas and lymphomas. There was very little cancer in environmentally exposed tissues (lung and intestine). There was also some contrast between Japanese and Americans in the relative rates of cancer at certain sites. The study provides support for the life span linkage of adult cancer mortality in the two species, in spite of the different patterns of cancer types and environments.

Carcinogen risk assessment in the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

This is a narrative account of the origins and development of carcinogen risk assessment in the U.S. EPA, which pioneered the field. It began in an era of high hopes that the regulation of carcinogens in the environment would make a major reduction in the heavy public health burden of cancer. The immediate cause for the development of carcinogen risk assessment was the need to respond to heavy criticism that the EPA was not using science in an unbiased way to defend its regulation of important pesticides as carcinogens. The formulation of the initial assessment guidelines is described as well as the rationale behind the assessment procedures that were developed by the EPA's Carcinogen Assessment Group. The issue of whether the original hopes of reducing cancer has been realized is discussed. Recent developments in molecular carcinogenesis point to the possibility of a revised view of the role of environmental carcinogens at low levels of exposure from that of causing cancer de novo to an acceleration of the development of cancer that results from heritable genetic defects. It is suggested that advances in carcinogen risk assessment will mainly depend on a better understanding of the causes and mechanisms of cancer in humans at the molecular level.

Dose- and time-dependent expression of transforming growth factor-beta 1 mRNA and protein in mouse epidermis and papillomas after repeated topical application of benzo[a]pyrene.

Topical weekly application of 64 micrograms of benzo[a]pyrene (BAP) for 4 wk induced transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta 1 mRNA in the epidermis of Swiss (ICR) mice, with a maximum at 6-12 h after the last treatment. The increase in TGF-beta 1 mRNA concentration was accompanied by an increase in immunohistochemically detectable intracellularly localized TGF-beta 1 protein in the suprabasal epidermis and by the appearance of extracellularly localized TGF-beta 1 in the basal layers. A dose rate of 16 micrograms/wk for 4 wk was unable to induce the same response. In contrast, after 20 weekly topical applications of 16 or 64 micrograms of BAP, an increase in TGF-beta 1 mRNA concentration and the appearance of extracellularly localized protein in the epidermis were observed. These changes in TGF-beta 1 expression were paralleled by changes in epidermal morphology. A similar group of animals treated with 4 micrograms of BAP/wk for 20 wk did not respond differently from untreated controls. Papillomas resulting from treatment with 16 or 64 micrograms of BAP/wk for 28 wk stained for intracellularly localized TGF-beta 1 predominantly in the differentiating and nondividing layers. Papillomas stained for extracellularly localized TGF-beta 1 solely in the less differentiated and dividing cells. These results suggest that tumorigenesis by BAP involves the induction of cumulative changes in epidermal TGF-beta 1 mRNA and protein concentrations as well as alterations in skin morphology associated with a tumor-promotion process.

Stimulation of TGF-beta 1 mRNA concentration in mouse skin treated with benzo[a]pyrene.

Topical application of benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) at dose rates of 32 or 64 micrograms/week to the dorsal skin of female Swiss (ICR) mice resulted in a marked and rapid increase in concentration of RNA for transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF-beta 1) in epidermis. Two RNA species 1.9 and 2.5 kb, detected by a mouse TGF-beta 1 cDNA probe, were coordinately expressed. The concentration of these species appeared to be maximal 6-12 h after application, and returned to control levels after 48 h. A second, less intense maximum was observed 72-96 h after treatment. Similar effects were observed in CD-1 and HRS (both hr/hr and hr/+) mice, which are also sensitive to B[a[] tumorigenesis. In comparison with 32 and 64 micrograms/week a dose rate of 16 micrograms/week was essentially without activity in increasing TGF-beta 1 RNA concentration. All three dose rates induced an increase in epidermal RNA for ornithine decarboxylase, however, and with kinetics similar to those observed with the potent tumor-promoting phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate. The results obtained support other findings made in this laboratory, that at high dose rates above 16 micrograms tumorigenesis by B[a]P involves a strong tumor-promoting component. The latter further appears to be mediated by increased TGF-beta 1 expression.

Benzo[a]pyrene-induced skin damage and tumor promotion in the mouse.

Epidermal cell kinetics and DNA adduct levels, and skin morphological changes were measured following weekly topical applications for 29 weeks of high (16, 32 and 64 micrograms) benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) doses to female ICR/Harlan mice, in order to investigate the relationship of these parameters to the timing, incidence and morphology of the elicited tumors. During the tumor latency period, [3H]thymidine labeling index, mitotic index, epidermal cell stacking, incidence of pyknotic and dark basal keratinocytes and labeled mitoses were periodically measured, as were nuclear area and DNA content. DNA adducts in skin epidermis were measured by an ELISA method over a period of 9 weeks of single weekly applications of 64, 32, 16 or 8 micrograms B[a]P. There was an initial linear increase in DNA adducts with dose in the epidermis but the increase was much less steep above 32 micrograms/week. This did not correlate with the sharp rise in tumor response above the 32 micrograms/week dose rate. Cell kinetic changes in response to the 64 micrograms/week dose reached a plateau in the first few weeks of the tumor latent period. There was little epidermal hyperplasia but an associated dose-dependent increase in [3H]thymidine labeling index, mitotic index and incidence of pyknotic and dark cells. This evidence indicated that B[a]P produced extensive cytotoxicity and cell death with regenerative proliferation under these conditions. Giant keratinocytes occurred in all dose groups. Analysis of a labeled mitosis curve indicated that B[a]P produced a G2/M block. There was a marked inflammatory response in the dermis at all B[a]P doses. Mice were observed weekly for tumor formation. Virtually all of the tumors were papillomas on initial appearance and required an average of 8 weeks to convert to carcinomas. The substantial cell killing and regenerative proliferation, and the correspondence between the dose-response patterns for epidermal damage and tumors, together with the initial appearance of tumors in the benign form, a characteristic of the action of promoting agents, provided evidence that the tissue damage associated with the high dose levels of B[a]P used in this study reflected tumor-promoting activity in this mouse epidermal tumorigenesis model. The implication of the results for mathematical models of tumor formation are discussed.

Issues in the risk assessment of chromium.

Although hexavalent chromium is well established as a human carcinogen by the inhalation route, there are significant uncertainties in the quantitative estimation of cancer risk. One of the important uncertainties is the assumption that the carcinogenic potency, determined under conditions of occupational exposure where most workers were cigarette smokers, applies to the nonsmoking individual in the general population. There is substantial evidence that carcinogenicity is a function of the rate of cell turnover in the target tissue. The chromate worker would be expected to have a relatively high rate of cell proliferation in the bronchial mucosa due to airborne irritants and smoking. The potency of chromium might therefore be relatively high under conditions of occupational exposure. This problem in quantitative risk assessment applies equally well to another important indoor pollutant, radon.

Regulation of carcinogens in terms of life shortening.

Because of the difficulty in using the results of conventional quantitative risk assessment in the regulation of carcinogens, an approach to setting carcinogen standards is presented based on the reduction of cancer-induced life span shortening to statistically nonsignificant levels. An argument is made that the time of cancer occurrence is more important than the risk of cancer. The rationale is that the objective of carcinogen control is to delay the single-risk time of cancer occurrence. Whether this benefit is associated with a decrease, increase or no change in the risk of dying of cancer depends on concomitant changes in the temporal pattern of other causes of death. For indispensable carcinogens the permissible exposure is the level which shortens the time to background cancer by an amount equal to the uncertainty in the time of background cancer occurrence. This approach is illustrated by the use of the ED01 2-FAA bioassay on mice.

Multiple stages in radiation carcinogenesis of rat skin.

Epithelial cell cancers are induced in rat skin by ionizing radiation in a manner that is consistent with the dual action (i.e., two alterations) hypothesis of radiation effects on DNA. This hypothesis states simply that two initial alterations, presumably in the DNA, are necessary to start a normal cell on the pathway to cancer. The initial radiation-induced alteration in the DNA is repairable as indicated by the reduction in tumor incidence with increasing time between dose fractions; the repair halftime is estimated to be 3.0 +/- 1.0 hr. Theoretical predictions of a specific dependence of tumor incidence on linear energy transfer (LET) have been verified experimentally for two specific LET values. However, the theoretical formulation provides no guidance regarding the observed reduction in the carcinogenic action of radiation with age at the time of exposure. Analysis of the tumor DNA for oncogene activation indicated k-ras and c-myc oncogenes were activated in highly anaplastic rat skin cancers, whereas only one of these oncogenes, usually c-myc, was activated in comparatively benign basal cell carcinomas and in squamous cell carcinomas.

Carcinogen risk assessment.

A molecular biological rationale for the linear nonthreshold dose-response pattern for carcinogenesis is presented based on the mutagenic activation of oncogens as the basis of initiation. The approach assumes that the linear nonthreshold dose pattern at very low doses applies only to tissues that are promoted by intrinsic and extrinsic agents other than the one being modeled, and that risk is characterized on a relative rather than absolute basis in terms of aggregate tumor response.

The carcinogenicity of discontinuous inhaled benzene exposures in CD-1 and C57Bl/6 mice.

Groups of male C57Bl and CD-1 mice were exposed to benzene via inhalation using two different exposure protocols. One protocol consisted of repetitive week-long exposures to 300 ppm benzene (6 h/d x 5 d/wk) interrupted by 2 weeks of non-exposure. The exposure pattern (1 week of exposure followed by 2 weeks of non-exposure) was continued until the death of the last exposed animal. The second protocol consisted of exposures to 1200 ppm benzene (6 h/d x 5 d/wk) for 10 weeks. Exposures were then terminated and the animals allowed to live out their lives. For each protocol, appropriate age-matched control mice received comparable exposures to filtered, conditioned air. The discontinuous exposure patterns mimic the patterns of exposure often encountered in the workplace and, in addition, prolong the survival of exposed animals so as to maximize potential tumorigenic responses. Both exposure protocols were markedly hematotoxic to both mouse strains as measured by peripheral blood counts. Both strains of mice responded to the intermittent 300 ppm benzene exposures with elevated incidences of malignant tumors. Particularly noteworthy was a 35% incidence of zymbal gland tumors in the C57Bl mice. In contrast, only the CD-1 mice responded to the 1200 ppm benzene exposures delivered over 10 weeks with elevated tumor incidences. A 46% incidence of lung adenoma was particularly striking in these mice. Neither of the benzene exposure protocols induced elevated incidences of leukemia/lymphoma in either strain.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)