Prolonged exposure to the candidate microbicide C31G differentially reduces cellular sensitivity to agent re-exposure.

Comparative assays of in vitro cytotoxicity using nonoxynol-9 (N-9) and the candidate microbicides C31G and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) demonstrated that these agents, which are, respectively, characterized as nonionic, amphoteric, and anionic surfactants, differed in their concentration-dependent effects on cell viability, especially after prolonged exposure. We hypothesized that differences in cellular sensitivity may have been due, in part, to cellular changes induced by long-term exposure to each agent. To examine this possibility, HeLa cells were exposed to N-9, C31G, or SDS for extended periods of time and subsequently reassessed for sensitivity to each of these agents. Following 10 continuous days of C31G exposure, HeLa cells were less sensitive to a subsequent C31G exposure compared to cells that had not undergone long-term C31G treatment. Interestingly, long-term C31G exposure also changed subsequent sensitivity to N-9 but not SDS. In contrast, prolonged exposure to either N-9 or SDS did not reduce sensitivity to re-exposure. The effect of long-term C31G exposure was both concentration-dependent and transient, as treated cells reverted to pre-exposure sensitivity in a time-dependent manner following the cessation of C31G exposure. Lipid analyses of cells exposed to C31G for extended durations revealed altered phospholipid profiles relative to C31G-naïve cells. Experiments examining the individual components of C31G demonstrated the involvement of the amine oxide moiety in reductions in cellular sensitivity. These studies, which provide new information concerning the cytotoxicity of surfactant microbicides, suggest that cervicovaginal epithelial cells may have greater in vivo tolerance for products containing C31G through unique interactions between C31G and components of the cellular membranes.

Toxicity, inflammation, and anti-human immunodeficiency virus type 1 activity following exposure to chemical moieties of C31G.

C31G, which has potent activity against the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and an established record of safety in animal studies and human trials, is a microbicidal agent comprised of a buffered equimolar mixture of two amphoteric, surface-active agents: an alkyl amine oxide (C14AO) and an alkyl betaine (C16B). Studies of long-term in vitro exposure to C31G and its constituents have suggested that the components of C31G may contribute differentially to its toxicity and efficacy. In the present studies, in vitro assays of cytotoxicity and anti-HIV-1 activity demonstrated that C16B was slightly less cytotoxic compared to either C31G or C14AO, whereas the anti-HIV-1 activities of C31G and its individual constituents were similar. In the murine model of cervicovaginal microbicide toxicity, in vivo exposure to C14AO resulted in severe cervical inflammation followed by a delayed disruption of the columnar epithelium. In contrast, exposure to C16B caused severe cervical epithelial disruption and a secondary, less intense inflammatory response. These results demonstrate that (i) there are both mechanistic and temporal differences in toxicity associated with the components of C31G not necessarily predicted by in vitro assessments of cytotoxicity and (ii) contributions of each component to the anti-HIV-1 activity of C31G appear to be equal. In addition, these findings indicate that direct and indirect mechanisms of in vivo toxicity can be observed as separate but interrelated events. These results provide further insight into the activity of C31G, as well as mechanisms potentially associated with microbicide toxicity.

Comparative safety evaluation of the candidate vaginal microbicide C31G.

C31G is currently the focus of clinical trials designed to evaluate this agent as a microbicidal and spermicidal agent. In the following studies, the in vivo safety of C31G was assessed with a Swiss Webster mouse model of cervicovaginal toxicity and correlated with results from in vitro cytotoxicity experiments and published clinical observations. A single exposure of unformulated 1% C31G resulted in mild-to-moderate epithelial disruption and inflammation at 2 and 4 h postapplication. The columnar epithelium of the cervix was the primary site of damage, while no perturbation of the vaginal mucosa was observed. In contrast, application of unformulated 1.7% C31G resulted in greater levels of inflammation in the cervical epithelium at 2 h postapplication and severe epithelial disruption that persisted to 8 h postapplication. Application of a nonionic aqueous gel formulation containing 1% C31G resulted in no apparent cervicovaginal toxicity at any time point evaluated. However, formulation of 1.7% C31G did not substantially reduce the toxicity associated with unformulated C31G at that concentration. These observations correlate with findings gathered during a recent clinical trial, in which once-daily applications resulted in no adverse events in women receiving the formulation containing 1% C31G, compared to moderate-to-severe adverse events in 30% of women receiving the 1.7% C31G formulation. The Swiss Webster mouse model was able to effectively discriminate between concentrations and formulations of C31G that produced distinct clinical effects in human trials. The Swiss Webster animal model may be a highly valuable tool for preclinical evaluation of candidate vaginal microbicides.

Comparative in vitro sensitivities of human immune cell lines, vaginal and cervical epithelial cell lines, and primary cells to candidate microbicides nonoxynol 9, C31G, and sodium dodecyl sulfate.

In experiments to assess the in vitro impact of the candidate microbicides nonoxynol 9 (N-9), C31G, and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) on human immune and epithelial cell viability, cell lines and primary cell populations of lymphocytic and monocytic origin were generally shown to be equally sensitive to exposures ranging from 10 min to 48 h. However, U-937 cells were more sensitive to N-9 and C31G after 48 h than were primary monocyte-derived macrophages. Cytokine activation of monocytes and lymphocytes had no effect on cell viability following exposure to these microbicidal compounds. Primary and passaged vaginal epithelial cultures and cell lines differed in sensitivity to N-9 and C31G but not SDS. These studies provide a foundation for in vitro experiments in which cell lines of human immune and epithelial origin can be used as suitable surrogates for primary cells to further investigate the effects of microbicides on cell metabolism, membrane composition, and integrity and the effects of cell type, proliferation, and differentiation on microbicide sensitivity.