Adenoviral Vector DNA- and SARS-CoV-2 mRNA-Based Covid-19 Vaccines: Possible Integration into the Human Genome - Are Adenoviral Genes Expressed in Vector-based Vaccines?

Vigorous vaccination programs against SARS-CoV-2-causing Covid-19 are the major chance to fight this dreadful pandemic. The currently administered vaccines depend on adenovirus DNA vectors or on SARS-CoV-2 mRNA that might become reverse transcribed into DNA, however infrequently. In some societies, people have become sensitized against the potential short- or long-term side effects of foreign DNA being injected into humans. In my laboratory, the fate of foreign DNA in mammalian (human) cells and organisms has been investigated for many years. In this review, a summary of the results obtained will be presented. This synopsis has been put in the evolutionary context of retrotransposon insertions into pre-human genomes millions of years ago. In addition, studies on adenovirus vector-based DNA, on the fate of food-ingested DNA as well as the long-term persistence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA/DNA will be described. Actual integration of viral DNA molecules and of adenovirus vector DNA will likely be chance events whose frequency and epigenetic consequences cannot with certainty be assessed. The review also addresses problems of remaining adenoviral gene expression in adenoviral-based vectors and their role in side effects of vaccines. Eventually, it will come down to weighing the possible risks of genomic insertions of vaccine-associated foreign DNA and unknown levels of vector-carried adenoviral gene expression versus protection against the dangers of Covid-19. A decision in favor of vaccination against life-threatening disease appears prudent. Informing the public about the complexities of biology will be a reliable guide when having to reach personal decisions about vaccinations.

Inheritable epigenetic response towards foreign DNA entry by mammalian host cells: a guardian of genomic stability.

Apart from its well-documented role in long-term promoter silencing, the genome-wide distribution patterns of ~ 28 million methylated or unmethylated CpG dinucleotides, e. g. in the human genome, is in search of genetic functions. We have set out to study changes in the cellular CpG methylation profile upon introducing foreign DNA into mammalian cells. As stress factors served the genomic integration of foreign (viral or bacterial plasmid) DNA, virus infections or the immortalization of cells with Epstein Barr Virus (EBV). In all instances investigated, alterations in cellular CpG methylation and transcription profiles were observed to different degrees. In the case of adenovirus DNA integration in adenovirus type 12 (Ad12)-transformed hamster cells, the extensive changes in cellular CpG methylation persisted even after the complete loss of all transgenomic Ad12 DNA. Hence, stress-induced alterations in CpG methylation can be inherited independent of the continued presence of the transgenome. Upon virus infections, changes in cellular CpG methylation appear early after infection. In EBV immortalized as compared to control cells, CpG hypermethylation in the far-upstream region of the human FMR1 promoter decreased four-fold. We conclude that in the wake of cellular stress due to foreign DNA entry, preexisting CpG methylation patterns were altered, possibly at specific CpG dinucleotides. Frequently, transcription patterns were also affected. As a working concept, we view CpG methylation profiles in mammalian genomes as a guarding sensor for genomic stability under epigenetic control. As a caveat towards manipulations of cells with foreign DNA, such cells can no longer be considered identical to their un-manipulated counterparts.

Intracellular African swine fever virus DNA remains unmethylated in infected Vero cells.

AIM: Sequence-specific CpG methylation of eukaryotic promoters is an important epigenetic signal for long-term gene silencing. We have now studied the methylation status of African swine fever virus (ASFV) DNA at various times after infection of Vero cells in culture. METHODS & RESULTS: ASFV DNA was detectable throughout the infection cycle and was found unmethylated in productively infected Vero cells as documented by bisulfite sequencing of 13 viral DNA segments. CONCLUSION: ASFV DNA does not become de novo methylated in the course of infection in selected segments spread across the entire genome. Thus DNA methylation does not interfere with ASFV genome transcription. Lack of de novo methylation has previously been observed for free intracellular viral DNA in cells permissively infected with human adenoviruses, with human papillomaviruses and others.

DNA methylation and transcription in HERV (K, W, E) and LINE sequences remain unchanged upon foreign DNA insertions.

AIM: DNA methylation and transcriptional profiles were determined in the regulatory sequences of the human endogenous retroviral (HERV-K, -W, -E) and LINE-1.2 elements and were compared between non-transgenomic and plasmid-transgenomic cells. METHODS: DNA methylation profiles in the HERV (K, W, E) and LINE sequences were determined by bisulfite genomic sequencing. The transcription of these genome segments was assessed by quantitative real-time PCR. RESULTS: In HERV-K, HERV-W and LINE-1.2 the levels of DNA methylation ranged between 75 and 98%, while in HERV-E they were around 60%. Nevertheless, the HERV and LINE-1.2 sequences were actively transcribed. No differences were found in comparisons of HERV and LINE-1.2 CpG methylation and transcription patterns between non-transgenomic and plasmid-transgenomic HCT116 cells. CONCLUSION: The insertion of a 5.6 kbp plasmid into the HCT116 genome had no effect on the HERV and LINE-1.2 methylation and transcription profiles, although other parts of the HCT116 genome had shown marked changes. These repetitive sequences are transcribed, probably because the large number of HERV and LINE-1.2 elements harbor copies with non- or hypo-methylated long terminal repeat sequences.

Epigenetic analysis of HIV-1 proviral genomes from infected individuals: predominance of unmethylated CpG's.

Efforts to cure HIV-1 infections aim at eliminating proviral DNA. Integrated DNA from various viruses often becomes methylated de novo and transcriptionally inactivated. We therefore investigated CpG methylation profiles of 55 of 94 CpG's (58.5%) in HIV-1 proviral genomes including ten CpG's in each LTR and additional CpG's in portions of gag, env, nef, rev, and tat genes. We analyzed 33 DNA samples from PBMC's of 23 subjects representing a broad spectrum of HIV-1 disease. In 22 of 23 HIV-1-infected individuals, there were only unmethylated CpG's regardless of infection status. In one long term nonprogressor, however, methylation of proviral DNA varied between 0 and 75% over an 11-year period although the CD4+ counts remained stable. Hence levels of proviral DNA methylation can fluctuate. The preponderance of unmethylated CpG's suggests that proviral methylation is not a major factor in regulating HIV-1 proviral activity in PBMC's. Unmethylated CpG's may play a role in HIV-1 immunopathogenesis.

Impact of foreign DNA integration on tumor biology and on evolution via epigenetic alterations.

The insertion of foreign DNA into mammalian genomes can alter their methylation and transcription patterns at remote sites from the locus of foreign DNA integration. The mechanisms leading to these fundamental changes and their frequencies are unknown. Sites and extent of changes in the recipient cells might depend on the location of foreign DNA integration. In the second part of this review, it will be hypothesized that the insertion event itself, for example, of tumor viral DNA via its epigenetic genome-wide consequences, plays an important role in oncogenesis. During evolution, the impact of ancient retrotransposon or retroviral genomes and the ensuing epigenetic alterations in the recipient genomes might have generated cells with completely different transcriptional profiles. Due to the continued presence of the transgenomes these alterations were genetically stable and were selected for or against by the environmental conditions prevalent at the time. These evolutionary effects are very different from those postulated for insertional mutagenesis, added genetic information or regulatory elements placed into the vicinity of cellular functions.

Epigenetic consequences of foreign DNA insertions: de novo methylation and global alterations of methylation patterns in recipient genomes.

The insertion of foreign DNA into mammalian or plant genomes is a frequent event in biology. My laboratory has pursued a long-standing interest in the structure of integrated adenovirus genomes and in the mechanism of foreign DNA insertions in mammalian cells. The long-term consequences of the integration of alien DNA are only partly known, and even less well understood are the mechanisms that bring them about. Evidence from viral systems has contributed to the realization that foreign DNA insertions entail a complex of sequelae that have also become apparent in non-viral systems: (i) The de novo methylation of integrated foreign DNA sequences has frequently been observed. (ii) Alterations of DNA methylation patterns in the recipient genome at and remote from the site of foreign DNA insertion have been demonstrated but it remains to be investigated how generally this phenomenon occurs. Many viral genomes find and have found entry into the genomes of present-day organisms. A major portion of mammalian genomes represents incomplete retroviral genomes that frequently have become permanently silenced by DNA methylation. It is still unknown how and to what extent the insertion of retroviral or retrotransposon sequences into established genomes has altered and shaped the methylation and transcription profiles of present day genomes. An additional reason for concern about the effects of foreign DNA integration is the fact that in all fields of molecular biology and medicine, the generation of transgenic or transgenomic cells and organisms has become a ubiquitously applied experimental technique.

Epigenetic mechanisms in human adenovirus type 12 oncogenesis.

For the past 30 years, my laboratory has concentrated its work on demonstrating that the epigenetic consequences of foreign DNA insertion into established mammalian genomes -de novo DNA methylation of the integrate and alterations of methylation patterns across the recipient genome - are essential elements in setting the stage towards oncogenic transformation. We have primarily studied human adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) which induces undifferentiated tumors in Syrian hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus) either at the site of subcutaneous Ad12 injection or intraperitoneally upon intramuscular injection. Up to 90% of the hamsters injected with Ad12 develop tumors within 3-6 weeks. Integration of foreign DNA, its de novo methylation, and the consequences of insertion on the cellular methylation and transcription profiles have been studied in detail. While viral infections are a frequent source of foreign genomes entering mammalian and other hosts and often their genomes, we have also pursued the fate of food-ingested foreign DNA in the mouse organism. The persistence of this DNA in the animals is transient and there is no evidence for the expression or germ line fixation of foreign DNA. Nevertheless, the occasional cell that carries integrated genomes from that foreign source deserves the oncologist's sustained interest.

In pursuit of the first recognized epigenetic signal--DNA methylation: a 1976 to 2008 synopsis.

A synopsis will be presented of work on DNA methylation, the first epigenetic signal to be recognized. In the author's laboratory, the following problems dealing with DNA methylation have been addressed over the past 32 years: (1) The de novo methylation of foreign DNA integrated into mammalian genomes. (2) Inverse correlations between promoter methylation and activity. (3) The long-term inactivating effect of site-specific promoter methylation. (4) Adenovirus E1 functions in trans and a strong enhancer in cis cancel the silencing effect of promoter methylation. (5) Frog virus 3, an iridovirus with a completely CpG-methylated genome. (6) Mechanisms of de novo methylation. (7) Different segments of the genome possess topical methylation memories. (8) Consequences of foreign DNA insertion into mammalian genomes: alterations of DNA methylation in cis and trans. (9) The epigenetic status of an adenovirus transgenome in Ad12-transformed hamster cells. (10) Cell type-specific patterns of DNA methylation: interindividual concordance in the human genome.

Human CAR gene expression in nonpermissive hamster cells boosts entry of type 12 adenovirions and nuclear import of viral DNA.

Adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) propagation in hamster BHK21 cells is blocked prior to viral DNA replication. The amounts of Ad12 DNA in the nuclei or cytoplasm of hamster cells are about 2 orders of magnitude (2 h postinfection [p.i.]) and 4 to 5 orders of magnitude (48 h p.i.) lower than in permissive human cells. Cell line BHK21-hCAR is transgenic for and expresses the human coxsackie- and adenovirus receptor (hCAR) gene. Nuclear uptake of Ad12 DNA in BHK21-hCAR cells is markedly increased compared to that in naïve BHK21 cells. Ad12 elicits a cytopathic effect in BHK21-hCAR cells but not in BHK21 cells. Quantitative PCR or [(3)H]thymidine labeling followed by zone velocity sedimentation fails to detect Ad12 DNA replication in BHK21 or BHK21-hCAR cells. Newly assembled Ad12 virions cannot be detected. Thus, the block in Ad12 DNA replication in hamster cells is not released by enhanced nuclear import of Ad12 DNA.

Human adenovirus type 12: crossing species barriers to immortalize the viral genome.

When viruses cross species barriers, they often change their biological and pathogenetic properties. In the author's laboratory the nonproductive interaction of Syrian hamster cells with human adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) has been studied. Ad12 induces undifferentiated tumors in newborn hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus) at high frequency. Ad12 inefficiently enters hamster (BHK21) cells, and only small amounts of viral DNA reach the nucleus. Viral DNA replication and late transcription are blocked. In Ad12-induced tumor cells, multiple copies of viral DNA are chromosomally integrated. The integrated viral DNA becomes de novo methylated. Cellular DNA methylation and transcription patterns in Ad12-transformed cells and in Ad12-induced tumor cells are altered. These changes may be related to the oncogenic potential of Ad12 in hamsters. In this chapter, concepts and techniques for the study of the Ad12-hamster cell system are summarized.

Epigenetic status of an adenovirus type 12 transgenome upon long-term cultivation in hamster cells.

The epigenetic status of integrated adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) DNA in hamster cells cultivated for about 4 decades has been investigated. Cell line TR12, a fibroblastic revertant of the Ad12-transformed epitheloid hamster cell line T637 with 15 copies of integrated Ad12 DNA, carries one Ad12 DNA copy plus a 3.9-kbp fragment from a second copy. The cellular insertion site for the Ad12 integrate, identical in both cell lines, is a >5.2-kbp inverted DNA repeat. The Ad12 transgenome is packaged around nucleosomes. The cellular junction is more sensitive to micrococcal nuclease at Ad12-occupied sites than at unoccupied sites. Bisulfite sequencing reveals complete de novo methylation in most of the 1,634 CpGs of the integrated viral DNA, except for its termini. Isolated unmethylated CpGs extend over the entire Ad12 integrate. The fully methylated transgenome segments are characterized by promoter silencing and histone H3 and H4 hypoacetylation. Nevertheless, there is minimal transcriptional activity of the late viral genes controlled by the fully methylated major late promoter of Ad12 DNA.

Identification of specific cellular genes up-regulated late in adenovirus type 12 infection.

The infection of human cells by adenoviruses leads to a gradual reduction in the activity of host cell functions while viral gene expression progresses in a regulated way. We used the DNA microarray technique to determine the transcriptional activity profiles of cellular genes upon infection with adenovirus type 12 (Ad12). The microarray data were validated by quantitative real-time PCR for genes which showed significant alterations after Ad12 infection. At 12 h postinfection, there is a striking up-regulation between 10- and 30-fold in the expression of the G1P2, IFIT1, and IFIT2 cellular immune response genes compared to mock-infected cells. At later stages of infection, when the majority of regulated cellular genes has been turned down, a limited number of cellular genes exhibit increased activities by factors of 3 or less. These genes belong to the signal transduction or transcriptional regulator classes or are active in protein degradation, like ANPEP, an aminopeptidase. The SCD and CYP2S1 genes function in lipid metabolism. The eucaryotic translation initiation factor 4 is up-regulated, and one of the major histocompatibility complex genes is diminished in activity. For two of the genes, one up-regulated (CTSF gene) and one down-regulated (CYR61 gene), alterations in gene activity were confirmed at the protein level by Western blotting experiments. Increased genetic activity of cellular genes late in adenovirus infection has not been reported previously and demonstrates that Ad12 has a sustained control of host cell gene expression well into the late phase of infection.

High specificity of quantitative excision repair cross-complementing 1 messenger RNA expression for prediction of minor histopathological response to neoadjuvant radiochemotherapy in esophageal cancer.

PURPOSE: The excision repair cross-complementing 1 (ERCC1) gene is coding for a nucleotide excision repair protein involved in the repair of radiation- and chemotherapy-induced DNA damage. We examined the potential of quantitative ERCC1 mRNA expression to predict minor or major histopathological response to neoadjuvant radiochemotherapy (cisplatin, 5-fluorouracil, and 36 Gy of radiation) followed by transthoracic en bloc esophagectomy in patients with locally advanced esophageal cancer (cT(2-4), N(x), M(0)). EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: Tissue samples were collected by endoscopic biopsy before treatment. RNA was isolated from biopsies, and quantitative real-time reverse transcriptase PCR assays were performed to determine ERCC1 mRNA expression. Relative mRNA levels (tumor/normal ratios) were calculated as (ERCC1/beta-actin in tumor)/(ERCC1/beta-actin in paired normal tissue). ERCC1 expression levels were correlated with the objective histopathological response in resected specimens. Histomorphological regression was defined as major response when resected specimens contained <10% of residual vital tumor cells or in case a pathologically complete response was achieved. RESULTS: Twelve of 36 tumors showed a major histopathological response, and 24 of 36 showed a minor histopathological response. Relative expression levels of ERCC1 of >1.09 were not associated with a major histopathological response (sensitivity, 62.5%; specificity, 100%) and 15 of 24 patients with minor histopathological response to the delivered neoadjuvant radiochemotherapy could be unequivocally identified. This association of dichotomized relative ERCC1 mRNA expression and histopathological response was statistically significant (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Relative expression levels of ERCC1 mRNA determined by quantitative real-time reverse transcriptase-PCR appear highly specific to predict minor response to our neoadjuvant radiochemotherapy protocol in patients with locally advanced esophageal cancer and could be applied to prevent expensive, noneffective, and potentially harmful therapies in a substantial number (42%) of patients.

PCR-screening of human esophageal and bronchial cancers reveals absence of adenoviral DNA sequences.

A number of human esophageal (3) and bronchial (10) cancers have been characterized clinically and by their histopathology. These tumors have been investigated for the persistence of human adenoviral DNA sequences. The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and Southern transfer hybridization (SBH) techniques have been applied. All analyses have consistently yielded negative results. These findings are discussed in the light of comparisons to the Ad12 hamster tumor system in which tumor cell or transformed cell revertants can lose the integrated Ad12 DNA sequences, but retain the oncogenic phenotype, when reinjected into hamsters. Ad12-transformed cells and Ad12-induced tumor cells have previously been shown to exhibit altered cellular methylation and transcription patterns. In one of the revertants, which has lost all Ad12 DNA sequences, changes in cellular DNA methylation patterns are also maintained. Since in the hamster tumor system the loss of Ad12 DNA sequences is still compatible with the oncogenic phenotype, the possibility exists that human tumors, though themselves devoid of viral DNA sequences, could have had cells as precursors which originally carried integrated adenoviral DNA sequences.

Influence of in vitro manipulation on the stability of methylation patterns in the Snurf/Snrpn-imprinting region in mouse embryonic stem cells.

Recent work on embryonic stem (ES) cells showed that stem cell-derived tissues and embryos, cloned from ES cell nuclei, often fail to maintain epigenetic states of imprinted genes. This deregulation is frequently associated with in vitro manipulations and culture conditions which might affect the cells potential to develop into normal fetuses. Usually, epigenetic instability is reported in differentially methylated regions of mostly growth-related imprinted genes. However, little is known about the epigenetic stability of genes that function late in organogenesis. Hence, we set out to investigate the epigenetic stability of neuronal genes and analyzed DNA methylation patterns in the Snurf/Snrpn imprinted cluster in several cultured mouse ES cell lines. We also determined the effects of in vitro stress factors such as consecutive passaging, trypsination, mechanical handling, single cell cloning, centrifugation, staurosporine-induced neurogenesis and the insertion of viral (foreign) DNA into the host genome. Intriguingly, none of these in vitro manipulations interfered with the stability of the methylation patterns in the analyzed neuronal genes. These data imply that, in contrast to growth-related genes like Igf2, H19, Igf2r or Grb10, the methylation imprints of the analyzed neuronal genes in the Snurf/Snrpn cluster may be particularly stable in manipulated ES cells.

Intraperitoneal dissemination of Ad12-induced undifferentiated neuroectodermal hamster tumors: de novo methylation and transcription patterns of integrated viral and of cellular genes.

The intramuscular (i.m.) injection of human adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) into newborn Syrian hamsters caused widespread dissemination of up to 15 tumors over the entire peritoneal cavity in 70-90% of the animals within 30-50 days. Subcutaneous (s.c.) injections led to local tumor formation only. Independent of location, tumor histology revealed Homer-Wright rosette-like structures typical for primitive neuroectodermal tumors (PNET). All tumor cells showed markers indicative of neuroectodermal and mesenchymal derivations. Each Ad12-induced tumor cell carried multiple copies of integrated Ad12 genomes at one chromosomal site which was different for each tumor. For Ad12 tumor induction in hamsters, the patterns of Ad12 viral and cellular gene expression were important and were affected by changes in DNA methylation, both in the integrated Ad12 DNA and the cellular genome. By applying the bisulfite protocol, the de novo DNA methylation in the integrated Ad12 genomes was determined. These patterns were complex, characterized by regional initiation and by excluding genome segments in the E1A and E1B promoters. In all tumors, the Ad12 segments E1A, E1B, E2A, parts of E3 and E4 were similarly transcribed, as shown by the RT-PCR and DNA microarray methods. Changes in the transcription of a large number of cellular genes was assessed by using mouse gene microarrays encompassing about 1980 different mouse genes with 87-96% homology to hamster genes. Similarities and differences existed in the transcription of cellular genes of different functional classes among the different Ad12-induced tumors. These alterations in cellular gene transcription may be an important parameter in the oncogenic transformation by Ad12.

Staurosporine is a potent activator of neuronal, glial, and "CNS stem cell-like" neurosphere differentiation in murine embryonic stem cells.

Staurosporine (STS), a broad spectrum protein kinase inhibitor, was previously shown to induce neurite outgrowth in several neuroblastoma cell lines. However, data on the neurotrophic potential of this alkaloid in embryonic stem cell systems were not available. Therefore, three mouse ES cell lines, IB10, RW4, and Bruce 4, were induced to enter neurogenesis in culture at low concentrations of STS. These cells differentiated into epidermal growth factor-responsive neural precursor cells, formed neurospheres, and further developed to neurons and astrocytes. The clonally derived neurospheres consisted of multipotent cells which exhibited some of the classical characteristics of early CNS stem cells and could be propagated in vitro. STS was antagonistic in several ways to retinoic acid (RA), a vitamin A metabolite, which promotes neuritogenesis. Results from RT-PCR experiments and inhibition studies with RA provided evidence that staurosporine exerted its neurotrophic effects through the induction of very late levels of the nerve growth factor and protein kinase C neurogenesis pathways.

Integrative recombination between adenovirus type 12 DNA and mammalian DNA in a cell-free system: joining by short sequence homologies.

A cell-free system was developed to investigate the mechanism of how junctions are formed between viral and cellular DNAs during adenoviral DNA integration into the hamster cell genome. Recombination between the segment of adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) DNA, that comprises sequence coordinates 20885-24053, subsequently termed PstI-D fragment and the hamster preinsertion DNA sequence p7 was studied in a cell-free system. The p7 DNA segment had served as viral DNA integration site in the Ad12-induced tumor CLAC1. Nuclear extracts initially from uninfected BHK21 hamster cells were fractionated by a series of chromatographic steps. DNAs of the in vitro generated recombinants were analyzed in detail. In the course of the recombination reaction, the two linear molecules were joined. The reaction took place between two short homologous sequences one of which was always at or very close to a DNA terminus, the second one could be several kilobase pairs remote from a DNA terminus. Apparently, the nucleotide sequence at the terminus of one recombining molecule determined the point of junction by searching for short homologies in the partner molecule. The recombination reaction was not conservative, the sequences in-between the short sequence homologies and one of the short sequence homologies were deleted in the in vitro recombinants. Two main criteria influenced the choice of interacting short sequence homologies: perfect homologies of 8-9 bp were most frequently found, they were preferred over more extended, but less perfect homologies. Comparing different short sequence homologies with similar stabilities, those combinations seemed to be chosen in the reaction which led to a minimal loss of nucleotides in the recombinants. The in vitro activity was found in nuclear extracts from both hamster and human cells. The activity was, hence, available for Ad12 DNA in productively infected human and abortively infected hamster cells. The specific recombination activity was increased in nuclear extracts of hamster cells abortively infected with Ad12. The junction sites in the recombinants, which were generated by the cell-free system, were very similar to junctions between adenoviral and cellular DNAs cloned from Ad12-induced tumor cells and Ad12-transformed cell lines.