Reproducibility of inverse gas chromatography under infinite dilution: Results and interpretations of an interlaboratory study.

Over the last years, inverse gas chromatography (IGC) proved to be a versatile and sensitive analytical technique for physicochemical properties. However, the comparability of results obtained by different users and devices remains a topic for debate. This is the first time, an interlaboratory study using different types of IGC instruments is reported. Eight organizations with different IGC devices defined a common lab measurement protocol to analyse two standard materials, silica and lactose. All data was collected in a standard result form and has been treated identically with the objective to identify experimentally observed differences and not potentially different data treatments. The calculated values of the dispersive surface energy vary quite significantly (silica: 22 mJ/m2 - 34 mJ/m2, lactose 37 mJ/m2 - 51 mJ/m2) and so do the ISP values and retention volumes for both materials. This points towards significant and seemingly undiscovered differences in the operation of the instruments and the obtained underlying primary data, even under the premise of standard conditions. Variations are independent of the instrument type and uncertainties in flow rates or the injected quantities of probe molecules may be potential factors for the differences. This interlaboratory study demonstrates that the IGC is a very sensitive analytical tool, which detects minor changes, but it also shows that for a proper comparison, the measurement conditions have to be checked with great care. A publicly available standard protocol and material, for which this study can be seen as a starting point, is still needed to judge on the measurements and the resulting parameters more objectively.

Characterization of polar surface groups on siliceous materials by inverse gas chromatography and the enthalpy-entropy compensation effect.

Surface-modified porous silica is a well-established composite material. To improve its embedding and application behavior, adsorption studies of various probe molecules have been performed using the technique of inverse gas chromatography (IGC). For this purpose, IGC experiments were carried out in the infinite dilution mode on macro-porous micro glass spheres before and after surface modification with (3-mercaptopropyl)trimethoxysilane. To provide information about the polar interactions between probe molecules and the silica surface, in particular, eleven polar molecules have been injected. In summary, the free surface energy for pristine silica ( γ S t o t a l = 229 mJ/m2) and for (3-mercaptopropyl)trimethoxysilane-modified silica ( γ S t o t a l = 135 mJ/m2) indicates a reduced wettability after surface modification. This is due to the reduction of the polar component of the free surface energy ( γ S S P ) from 191 mJ/m2 to 105 mJ/m2. Simultaneously, with the reduction of surface silanol groups caused by surface modification of silica and, therefore, the decrease in polar interactions, a substantial loss of Lewis acidity was observed by various IGC approaches. Experiments with all silica materials have been conducted at temperatures in the range from 90°C to 120°C to determine the thermodynamic parameters, such as adsorption enthalpy ( Δ H a d s ) and adsorption entropy ( Δ S a d s ), using the Arrhenius regression procedure evaluating the IGC data. With the help of the enthalpy-entropy compensation, two types of adsorption complexes are assumed between polar probe molecules and the silica surface because of different isokinetic temperatures. Identical adsorption complexes with an isokinetic temperature of 370°C have been assigned to alkanes and weakly interacting polar probes such as benzene, toluene, dichloromethane, and chloroform. Polar probe molecules with typical functional groups such as OH, CO, and CN, having the ability to form hydrogen bonds to the silica surface, exhibit a lower isokinetic temperature of 60°C. Quantum chemical calculations of the probe molecules on a non-hydroxylated and hydroxylated silica cluster supported the formation of hydrogen bonds in the case of a strong polar adsorption complex with a bonding distance of 1.7 nm-1.9 nm to the silica surface.

Functionalization of porous siliceous materials, Part 2: Surface characterization by inverse gas chromatography.

Surface modification of porous glass beads by ethanol-based 3-mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane (MPTMS) grafting solutions is directly evidenced by nitrogen adsorption, elemental analysis, thermogravimetry, infrared and 29Si CP MAS NMR spectroscopy. Furthermore, the energetic characterization of the surface is essential to understand comprehensively the physico-chemical interactions between the pristine and MPTMS-modified surface and its gas/liquid-phase environment. In this study, inverse gas chromatography (IGC) is used to characterize the surface properties of porous glass (PG). By means of IGC at infinite dilution (IGC-ID), the dispersive component of the surface energy (γsd), the enthalpy and entropy of adsorption of C6-C10 hydrocarbon probes were determined at temperatures between 30 and 120 °C. The specific component of the surface energy (γssp) at the temperature of 120 °C has been obtained via the Van Oss theory and a least-squares procedure evaluating the IGC data of 8 polar probe molecules collectively. After surface silylation, the total surface energy (γst) decreased from 402 to 255 mJ/m² indicating both a reduced wettability and an increased hydrophobicity of the MPTMS-modified PG. Moreover, the acidity/basicity parameters according to the Van Oss and the Gutmann approach indicated that the acidity of the PG surface decreases by MPTMS grafting. Using n-octane and isopropanol probes, IGC at finite concentration (IGC-FC) was applied to obtain their adsorption isotherms and subsequently the BET specific surface areas. In addition, the surface heterogeneity of the studied PGs was also computed. The energy distribution functions of adsorption sites were monomodal (peak maximum at about 22 kJ/mol) for the n-octane probe, while isopropanol revealed a bimodal distribution function (maxima at about 18 and 25 kJ/mol) on both pristine and MPTMS-modified PG. Furthermore, the proportion of high energy sites (apparently assigned to SiOH groups) has been reduced by surface modification from 65% to only 35% despite a high surface coverage of ˜10 MPTMS species/nm2. These findings are in agreement with the results of 29Si CP MAS NMR measurements and are supported by DFT calculations on the adsorption of isopropanol and n-octane on the surface of a silica cluster model.

Comparative Gas Sorption and Cryoporometry Study of Mesoporous Glass Structure: Application of the Serially Connected Pore Model.

Nitrogen sorption and melting and freezing of water in a small pore size mesoporous glass with irregular pore structure is studied. The analysis of the experimentally obtained data is performed using the recently developed serially connected pore model (SCPM). The model intrinsically incorporates structural disorder by introducing coupling between nucleation and phase growth mechanisms in geometrically disordered mesopore spaces. It is shown that, in contrast to the independent pore models prevailing in the literature, SCPM self-consistently describes not only boundary transitions, but also the entire family of the scanning transitions. The scanning behavior is shown to be very sensitive to microscopic details of the fluid phase distribution within the porous materials, hence can be used to check the validity of the thermodynamic models and to improve the structural analysis. We show excellent quantitative agreement between the structural information evaluated from the cryoporometry and gas sorption data using SCPM.