Gene expression in IFN-gamma-activated murine macrophages

Macrophages are critical for natural immunity and play a central role in specific acquired immunity. The IFN-gamma activation of macrophages derived from A/J or BALB/c mice yielded two different patterns of antiviral state in murine hepatitis virus 3 infection, which were related to a down-regulation of the main virus receptor. Using cDNA hybridization to evaluate mRNA accumulation in the cells, we were able to identify several genes that are differently up- or down-regulated by IFN-gamma in A/J (267 and 266 genes, respectively, up- and down-regulated) or BALB/c (297 and 58 genes, respectively, up- and down-regulated) mouse macrophages. Macrophages from mice with different genetic backgrounds behave differently at the molecular level and comparison of the patterns of non-activated and IFN-gamma-activated A/J or BALB/c mouse macrophages revealed, for instance, an up-regulation and a down-regulation of genes coding for biological functions such as enzymatic reactions, nucleic acid synthesis and transport, protein synthesis, transport and metabolism, cytoskeleton arrangement and extracellular matrix, phagocytosis, resistance and susceptibility to infection and tumors, inflammation, and cell differentiation or activation. The present data are reported in order to facilitate future correlation of proteomic/transcriptomic findings as well as of results obtained from a classical approach for the understanding of biological phenomena. The possible implication of the role of some of the gene products relevant to macrophage biology can now be further scrutinized. In this respect, a down-regulation of the main murine hepatitis virus 3 receptor gene was detected only in IFN-gamma-activated macrophages of resistant mice.

Gene expression in IFN-gamma-activated murine macrophages.

Macrophages are critical for natural immunity and play a central role in specific acquired immunity. The IFN-gamma activation of macrophages derived from A/J or BALB/c mice yielded two different patterns of antiviral state in murine hepatitis virus 3 infection, which were related to a down-regulation of the main virus receptor. Using cDNA hybridization to evaluate mRNA accumulation in the cells, we were able to identify several genes that are differently up- or down-regulated by IFN-gamma in A/J (267 and 266 genes, respectively, up- and down-regulated) or BALB/c (297 and 58 genes, respectively, up- and down-regulated) mouse macrophages. Macrophages from mice with different genetic backgrounds behave differently at the molecular level and comparison of the patterns of non-activated and IFN-gamma-activated A/J or BALB/c mouse macrophages revealed, for instance, an up-regulation and a down-regulation of genes coding for biological functions such as enzymatic reactions, nucleic acid synthesis and transport, protein synthesis, transport and metabolism, cytoskeleton arrangement and extracellular matrix, phagocytosis, resistance and susceptibility to infection and tumors, inflammation, and cell differentiation or activation. The present data are reported in order to facilitate future correlation of proteomic/transcriptomic findings as well as of results obtained from a classical approach for the understanding of biological phenomena. The possible implication of the role of some of the gene products relevant to macrophage biology can now be further scrutinized. In this respect, a down-regulation of the main murine hepatitis virus 3 receptor gene was detected only in IFN-gamma-activated macrophages of resistant mice.

Proteomic analysis of rare molecular species of translated polypeptides from a mouse fetal thymus cDNA library.

Proteomic patterns from an ordered cDNA library of mouse fetal thymus origin of an overall complexity of 1536 clones are described. Patterns have been analyzed at 96, 12, or 8 clones in a mixture, or as individual clones. Clones yield in some instances a single spot, in other cases a complex cluster or family of spots is formed. The determination of the clonal address (a six-digit number, indicating the interception of three pooling dimensions) by inspection of pools of 8, 12 or 16 clones is a reliable approach; nevertheless a complete proof consists in retrieving the clone and then submitting to transcription, translation and proteomic analysis. The spot clusters are meaningful clone identifiers; cluster components (families of polypeptides) are characteristic of individual clones and are independent of clones coexisting (and being co-expressed) in a given pool. A 'cluster' originates from a single cloned message and might be due to post-translational modification (offered by the reticuleocyte machinery) or as a result of programmed degradation. Thirteen clones or families of clonal products are shown, and the heterogeneity of the 'appearance' of clones is documented. In about half, the assignment of a clonal polypeptide product to a storage well position has failed; this might be due to a variety of considerations elaborated herein. The arguments are presented, that analysis of abundant proteins of a cell (activated lymphocyte) comprises 'classical proteomics', but for the analysis of the rare molecular species of proteins, Poissonian approaches of replicable material have to be used.

Global analysis of gene expression in cells of the immune system I. Analytical limitations in obtaining sequence information on polypeptides in two-dimensional gel spots.

We have outlined various aspects and limitations of the collective analysis of protein species of a cell (lymphocyte). We have indicated research directions that, in to our opinion, deserve more attention. We have evaluated mainly the approach used in our laboratory and we recognize that a bulk of important research on the interface of proteomics and genomics remains to be dealt with. It is of great value that we can proceed in our quest by trial and error. But as much as the human genome initiative was not implemented by trial and error, but by formulating new technological approaches, we hope that our approach can be incorporated in the mainstream of proteomics. We need several integrating research directions, some of which are outlined in this communication, namely the use of ordered cDNA libraries, cell-free expression systems, high density filter hybridization, identification of two-dimensional (2-D) gel spots in terms of their amino acid composition through biosynthetic labeling and identification of restriction sites in the corresponding coding sequences. In the accompanying paper the cDNA ordered library approach will be described in some detail.

Increased protein synthesis after T cell activation in presence of cyclosporin A.

BACKGROUND: The immunosuppressive drug, cyclosporin A (CsA), blocks immune responses by inhibiting the calcineurin-dependent dephosphorylation of the nuclear factor of activated T cells (NFAT). We have previously reported that T cells activated in presence of CsA exhibit particular properties. In our study, we have tested the hypothesis that T cells activated in presence of CsA display a differential pattern of gene expression. METHODS: T lymphocytes were activated in vitro by Concanavalin A with or without CsA. The cells were: (1) pulsed with 35S-methionine to label the newly synthesized proteins that in turn were revealed by 2D-gel electrophoresis; (2) analyzed by flow cytometry for activation markers expression; and (3) examined by gel electrophoresis for early tyrosine phosphorylation events. RESULTS: The proteomic patterns of T lymphocytes activated by Concanavalin A, with or without CsA, were compared. In keeping with the well-known effect of the immunosuppressor, many polypeptides were not found in its presence. Remarkably, several newly synthesized polypeptides were detected only when activation was carried out in presence of CsA. In addition, immunologically relevant proteins, such as CD44 and CD69, escape CsA-inhibitory action. Furthermore, CsA did not modify the early protein tyrosine phosphorylation events resulting from T cell triggering. CONCLUSIONS: The present data show that the effect of CsA on protein synthesis is more complex than anticipated. Signaling provided by T cell activation and the blockade of the calcineurin-dependent pathway by CsA results in an altered program of gene expression.

Proteomic analysis of T cell activation in the presence of cyclosporin A: immunosuppressor and activator removal induces de novo protein synthesis.

Cyclosporin A (CsA), a fungal metabolite used in organ transplantation, blocks the immune responses by interfering with early activation signals preventing the induction of the IL2 gene. We have previously reported that the removal of the immunosuppressor provokes the transcription of the IL2 encoding gene. We have now investigated whether the transcription and translation of other genes accompanies this process. Withdrawal of CsA and Concanavalin A (ConA) from cultures of murine T cells activated by ConA in the presence of CsA leads to substantial changes in the pattern of radio-labelled proteins. A large number of polypeptides were synthesised de novo. In addition, a set of polypeptides detected prior to immunosuppressor elimination was not anymore synthesised. Finally, besides these qualitative changes, quantitative differences in terms of increased or decreased polypeptide abundance were also observed. The results demonstrate that activation in the presence of CsA has programmed the T cells to transcribe and translate a large number of genes, without further reactivation, once the immunosuppressor and the activator were removed.

Expressed immunoglobulin repertoire of LPS-stimulated splenocytes of unimmunized mice as studied by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis.

The repertoire of isolated immunoglobulin polypeptide chains synthesized by LPS-stimulated splenic B cells from unimmunized 6 weeks old mice was studied by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. These B cells formed mainly mu heavy chains, while only a small amount of gamma chains was detected on two-dimensional electrophoregrams. The number and character of spots corresponding to each class and type of H and L chains were analyzed. Most of the detected 52 spots, which corresponded to L chains, were well resolved with clearly defined round boundaries. Six of them belonged to two isotypes of lambda chains and the rest to the kappa chain. About 25 clusters corresponded to mu chains. They had different appearance from those of L chains and their characteristic elliptic form with prolonged vertical axes indicated the presence of several H chain variants of slightly different length (due probably to the length variations of CDR3 and carbohydrate heterogeneity) in each cluster. The limited number of spots both of H and L chains is explained as being due to restrictions in the expressed repertoire of preimmune splenic B cells, which have no somatic mutations in the immunoglobulin genes. The concept of macrorepertoire (referring to the relatively small number of detected molecular species) and microrepertoire (describing the mutationally altered molecules) is introduced.

Analysis of a randomly assorted cDNA library from BW 5147 lymphoid cells. Frequency estimates based on computer aided concatenation matching of 2D gel polypeptide products.

A cDNA library was divided into 291 sectors of low complexity, 800-1000 recombinant phage plaques per sector. Aliquots of DNA from sectors prepared from high titer phage were subjected to in vitro transcription using T7 polymerase and thereafter RNA was translated in a cell-free rabbit reticulocyte system in the presence of [35S] methionine. The resulting polypeptides were separated by 2D gel electrophoresis. Radiofluorographs of the gels prepared from 10 sectors were subjected to scanning and image analysis. A multilevel spot matching procedure was employed allowing us to recognise spot occurrence in the 10 sectors. The number of detected polypeptide spots per sector varied between 147 and 325. Overall, 1082 different spots were counted totalling 1983 spots considering multiple entries. The distribution of the spots and the frequency distribution of the RNA population among the 10 sectors are shown. The highest detected frequency is 10(-2), while one half of the RNA molecular species are present at a frequency of 10(-3) or lower.

Isolation and characterization of the mycobacterial phagosome: segregation from the endosomal/lysosomal pathway.

Mycobacteria have the ability to persist within host phagocytes, and their success as intracellular pathogens is thought to be related to the ability to modify their intracellular environment. After entry into phagocytes, mycobacteria-containing phagosomes acquire markers for the endosomal pathway, but do not fuse with lysosomes. The molecular machinery that is involved in the entry and survival of mycobacteria in host cells is poorly characterized. Here we describe the use of organelle electrophoresis to study the uptake of Mycobacterium bovis bacille Calmette Guerin (BCG) into murine macrophages. We demonstrate that live, but not dead, mycobacteria occupy a phagosome that can be physically separated from endosomal/lysosomal compartments. Biochemical analysis of purified mycobacterial phagosomes revealed the absence of endosomal/lysosomal markers LAMP-1 and beta-hexosaminidase. Combining subcellular fractionation with two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, we found that a set of host proteins was present in phagosomes that were absent from endosomal/lysosomal compartments. The residence of mycobacteria in compartments outside the endosomal/lysosomal system may explain their persistence inside host cells and their sequestration from immune recognition. Furthermore, the approach described here may contribute to an improved understanding of the molecular mechanisms that determine the intracellular fate of mycobacteria during infection.

Neutrophils as a source of putative restriction proteases: degradation of mammalian and yeast proteins monitored by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis.

We have compared the ability of intact neutrophils to degrade a complex substrate of proteins from mammalian and yeast origin. The substrate was obtained by biosynthetic labeling, and subsequent lysis of K562 cells (leukemic cell line) and of yeast culture. The mammalian substrate consisted of 619 and the yeast substrate of 185 different polypeptides, as visualized and represented on two-dimensional gel patterns. Upon incubation of the mammalian substrate with neutrophils, the bulk of spots disappeared so rapidly that after 240 min of incubation only 21 spots were detectable. Just one spot remained unaltered in its intensity throughout the whole period of incubation. About 440 spots reveal a t1/2 shorter than 8 min. Yeast substrate is represented by a smaller number of the starting polypeptides (185) from which 55 spots "survive" the neutrophil treatment. About 30 spots have a t1/2 shorter than 8 min. We conclude that neutrophils are equipped with a potent proteolytic apparatus, and this is capable of eliminating various proteins in a highly efficient manner. The system is much less effective in eliminating proteins from distant species, like yeast. Although the cells governing and regulating the immune system are clearly of lymphoid origin, it might well be that the preimmune task of eliminating self antigens in a manner as predicted in the restriction protease hypothesis is performed by neutrophils.

Restriction sites as identification tags for lymphocyte cDNAs.

A cDNA library was prepared from BW 5147 murine lymphoma cells in lambda ecc III phage and randomly partitioned into 291 sectors, each with 800-1000 recombinant phage plaques. One sector was chosen for further characterization in terms of sensitivity to restriction endonuclease cutting. Aliquots of DNA preparations from this sector were treated with XhoI, SmaI, NcoI, PvuII, PstI, HindIII, EcoRI, BamHI, and ApaLI before being used as templates in a cell-free expression system. The polypeptide products were separated by two-dimensional (2-D) gel electrophoresis and radiofluorographs of the gels were submitted to computer-aided image analysis. The matched patterns were inspected for the presence or absence of spots upon individual endonuclease treatments. Thereafter the results were integrated in a data matrix which served as a basis to construct "restriction tags" for all spots. These (restriction) tags are binary numbers termed "cut numbers" and are a representation of the set of recognition sequences which are (or are not) part of the coding sequence. From 493 sequences (visualized as 2-D gel spots), 12 were not cut by any of the nine enzymes, while 45 were cut by all of them. The percentages of sequences resistant to enzyme treatment ranged between 17% and 77% for NcoI and XhoI, respectively. The enzyme treatments led to the appearance of a certain portion of "new spots", probably products from truncated sequences. From 512 possible cut numbers, 136 were assigned to the 493 spots. Restriction tags are available to facilitate retrieval of cDNA clones from the (partitioned) cDNA library.

Caffeic acid phenethyl ester profoundly modifies protein synthesis profile in type 5 adenovirus-transformed cloned rat embryo fibroblast cells.

Caffeic acid phenethyl ester (CAPE), an active component of propolis from bee hives, exerts a plethora of biological changes in diverse systems. These include antimitogenic, anticarcinogenic, anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory responses. CAPE directly induces programmed cell death (apoptosis) in type 5 adenovirus (Ad5)-transformed cloned rat embryo fibroblast cells, wt3A. To identify the gene and protein expression changes induced by CAPE in wt3A cells we used a strategy involving in vitro translation of mRNAs followed by high resolution two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis. This approach results in the detection of 745 spots, including 172 displaying differences in expression upon exposure to CAPE. A high proportion of spots show profound changes in spot intensity (42 spots with increased and 27 spots with decreased intensity) following CAPE treatment. These studies provide a basis for comparing these changes to known protein patterns of various cell populations with an ultimate aim of identifying families of polypeptides responsible for the up- and down-regulation of cellular proteins during CAPE-induced apoptosis. Specific newly appearing or completely disappearing spots (52 and 51 molecular species, respectively) will be used to attempt to identify and retrieve their cDNA counterparts from an ordered cDNA library. These approaches represent a novel strategy for cloning genes associated with and potentially mediating apoptosis.

Protein expression during murine thymus differentiation.

Driven by our long-standing interest in identifying proteins of the immune system and in characterizing processes involved in lymphocyte differentiation, we studied protein expression in biosynthetically labeled fetal and newborn thymus by 2D gel electrophoresis. Autoradiographs of the gels were scanned with a densitometer and image analysis was performed using the Kepler system. Calibrated polypeptide spot abundances (volumes) were compared to assesses qualitative and quantitative changes of the spot volumes. Among over 300 proteins evaluated at GD (gestation day) 13, 15, and 17, there were sets of proteins that increased and other that decreased in intensity. We could in addition recognize proteins that were completely absent at GD 13 and/or 15 and that appeared thereafter to gradually increase in intensity. Conversely, various polypeptide spots present at early stages (at GD 13 and 15) disappear later (at GD17 or at birth). Among the proteins that increase in intensity prevail molecules with masses less than 35 kD, whereas a considerable portion of those that decrease in intensity are characterized by masses above 60 kD. Spots reported in this communication were not defined beyond tagging them with numbers, which is a prerequisite to follow them up in the proteinpaedia developed in our laboratory. The next step will be to retrieve the coding sequences from the existing partitioned cDNA library (BW 5147) as well as from thymocyte subtraction libraries. We predict that among those polypeptides with varying intensity, important regulatory proteins in thymus development will be found.

Human lymphocyte cDNA ordered library analyzed by 2D gel electrophoresis. 1. Pooling strategy and matching of gel patterns.

We have analyzed an ordered library of 4,608 cDNA clones from the CEM human leukemic cell line. The aim was to facilitate gene retrieval, to enable immediate access to cDNA clones and to provide information on the protein expression of the individual clones in a 2D gel readout. The matrix array of 24 x 16 x 12, each position of which contained lambda jacII phage from one plaque, enabled us to establish pools of clones along the three axes (24 pools of complexity 192 cloned entities, 16 pools of complexity 288 and 12 pools of complexity 384). The total cDNA complexity is here reduced to such a level that spots which in more complex gels served as landmark spots are not present in each pool, and thus cannot serve as landmarks anymore. The image analysis of such gels and especially the matching of spots is not reliable under these circumstances. In order to achieve reliable matching, additional samples were created, such that pools were co-electrophoresed according to a special concatenation scheme; these samples then contained over-lapping elements (e.g., pools 1 + 2 + 3 and 3 + 4 + 5 have at least those spots in common, which originate from pool 3). This approach turned out to be feasible and we have completed the matching of one half of the ordered library. Already from the present stage of analysis we have obtained valuable information on the cDNA library and on the distribution of clones in this library.

Human lymphocyte cDNA ordered library analyzed by 2D gel electrophoresis. 2. Frequency distribution of mRNA populations.

Cell-free transcription and translation products from an ordered library of cDNA clones from the CEM human leukemic cell line were submitted to analysis using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis as a read out system. The matrix array of 24 x 16 x 12 wells contained in each of the positions lambda jacII phages from one plaque. Pools of clones along the three axes (24 x-pools, 16 y-pools and 12 z-pools) were established. Results obtained upon matching of 12 x-pools were scrutinized for estimating the frequency of cDNA molecular species in the library. The results obtained are interpreted in such a way that there are no discrete distributions of mRNA molecular species, but rather there is a continuous distribution of mRNA's covering a wide range of frequencies. The lowest frequency found was about 4.5 x 10(-4) and the highest 1.6 x 10(-2). About half of all clones can be found among these low frequency ones (each occurring 0.45 times among 1,000 clones).

How do B cells differ from T cells in terms of gene expression?

As part of an ongoing program to identify the genes that distinguish B cells from T cells, we have analyzed 910 molecular species of polypeptides detectable in mouse lymphocytes by 2D gel electrophoresis. Of these 910 polypeptides, 488 were present in both B and T cells, 185 in B but not T cells, and 237 in T but not B cells. The detected set of polypeptides accounts for more than 95% of the protein mass of lymphocytes. There are about 2000 other polypeptides that are below the threshold of detection. We have started to identify and to retrieve cDNA clones belonging to the B and T cell subset.

The amino acid composition of 350 lymphocyte proteins.

We determined the amino acid composition of proteins of Sp2 hybridoma cells by a procedure which assembles the information on the polypeptides upon two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, such that biosynthetic labeling with 20 different 3H amino acids provides the data--spot intensities--on the relative representation of the detected polypeptides. The gels were impregnated with 2,5-diphenyloxazol (PPO) and suitably exposed radiofluorographs were selected for analysis. The images originating from the 12 cultures labeled with amino acids R, A, H, I, L, K, M, F, P, S, T and Y were analysed with the Kepler image analysis system. The spot volume data of the 12 analysed patterns were corrected for the unequal labeling efficiencies of the 3H amino acids and for the various exposure times. This correction is performed by applying calibration factors based on the amino acid determination of a hydrolysate of the analysed cells. After the calibration step was applied to the data files we used the amino acid compositions of nine proteins taken from a database to establish for each of these proteins the correlation coefficients with the image analysis derived amino acid compositions of all spots. The correlation coefficients allow us to tentatively identify polypeptide spots on two-dimensional gels, while the amino acid composition of 350 investigated two-dimensional gel spots is usable as an identification tag in the gene retrieval from our cDNA libraries.

From clones of cells to clones of genes.

Three approaches to study the immune system are presented. First is the limiting dilution analysis, second is the analysis of the polypeptide patterns of lymphocytes by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, and the third is the utilization of a partitioned cDNA library for establishing a gene catalog and proteinpaedia. All the approaches were used to study clonal diversity and clonal heterogeneity. The gene catalog which is already established is available to recover genes expressed in various lymphocyte clones.

Lymphocyte Proteinpaedia stage two: T-cell polypeptides from a partitioned cDNA library revealed by the dual decay method.

A complex population of gene products was analyzed by combining the great resolving power of two-dimensional (2D) protein electrophoresis with a detailed dissection of individual protein species afforded by cDNA cloning. A cDNA library from BW5147 was partitioned by random sampling into sectors (of a complexity of 500 phase plaques/sector). From each of the unique sets of cDNA clones present in the sector, 2D gels were prepared. Patterns of spots were analyzed using the Kepler software system, and the compiled data both from the sectors and from the natural lymphocyte populations have been established to serve as a guide for gene retrieval. Use of the dual decay method, which compares two exposures of a 2D gel co-electrophoretic pattern, obtained from samples with (35S)-polypeptides mixed with (3H)-polypeptides, is described and scrutinized. It was determined that of 268 spots (three sectors combined), 118 spots were shared with the natural lymphocyte population, the remaining 150 spots occur only in the sectors (and not detected in the cell population). All cDNA populations are available for retrieval. Information obtained throughout the work was entered into the database.

An attempt to identify gene products related to the induction of an antiviral state in macrophages resistant and sensitive to IFN-gamma.

The activation of bone-marrow-derived macrophages by IFN-gamma (IFN gamma) partially inhibits mouse hepatitis virus 3 (MHV3) replication only in cells from resistant A/J mice, and not in cells originating from susceptible BALB/c mice. The computer image analysis of gels obtained from 2D-SDS-PAGE of extracted proteins of IFN gamma-activated A/J or BALB/c macrophages enabled us to identify and tag several gene products that were synthesized at elevated or diminished levels. Comparisons of the patterns of non-activated and IFN gamma-activated A/J macrophages revealed 3 gene products which increased, 1 which newly appeared, 6 which decreased and 20 which disappeared upon IFN gamma activation. The protein pattern of BALB/c macrophages revealed 13 gene products which increased, 8 which decreased and 8 which disappeared in IFN gamma-activated BALB/c macrophages. Whether these proteins are involved in the induction of an antiviral state against MHV3 growth remains to be investigated. Macrophages from mice with different genetic background (A/J and BALB/c), upon IFN gamma activation, behave differently at a molecular level, and this observation is consistent with their distinct expression of antiviral state against MHV3.