Phase II screening trial of lithium carbonate in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: examining a more efficient trial design.

OBJECTIVE: To use a historical placebo control design to determine whether lithium carbonate slows progression of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). METHODS: A phase II trial was conducted at 10 sites in the Western ALS Study Group using similar dosages (300-450 mg/day), target blood levels (0.3-0.8 mEq/L), outcome measures, and trial duration (13 months) as the positive trial. However, taking riluzole was not a requirement for study entry. Placebo outcomes in patients matched for baseline features from a large database of recent clinical trials, showing stable rates of decline over the past 9 years, were used as historical controls. RESULTS: The mean rate of decline of the ALS Functional Rating Scale-Revised was greater in 107 patients taking lithium carbonate (-1.20/month, 95% confidence interval [CI] -1.41 to -0.98) than that in 249 control patients (-1.01/month, 95% CI -1.11 to -0.92, p = 0.04). There were no differences in secondary outcome measures (forced vital capacity, time to failure, and quality of life), but there were more adverse events in the treated group. CONCLUSIONS: The lack of therapeutic benefit and safety concerns, taken together with similar results from 2 other recent trials, weighs against the use of lithium carbonate in patients with ALS. The absence of drift over time and the availability of a large database of patients for selecting a matched historical control group suggest that use of historical controls may result in more efficient phase II trials for screening putative ALS therapeutic agents. CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE: This study provided Class IV evidence that lithium carbonate does not slow the rate of decline of function in patients with ALS over 13 months.

Pilot trial of etanercept in the treatment of inclusion-body myositis.

Inclusion-body myositis (IBM) is an inflammatory muscle disease that has proven resistant to treatment. Tumor necrosis factor molecules have been detected in muscle biopsies from patients with IBM. Etanercept is a TNFalpha receptor fusion protein that binds and inactivates tumor necrosis factor. Nine patients were treated with etanercept at a dose of 25 mg, two times a week for an average of 17 +/- 6.1 months. Each patient was evaluated using quantitative strength testing. Their data were compared to two different control groups. The first control group consisted of patients who participated in trials of beta-interferon-1A and had received placebo. There was no significant difference. The second control group was a natural history cohort of IBM patients. There was no statistically significant difference between the treated group and the natural history group at 6 and 12 months when looking at elbow flexors, or 6 months when looking at hand grip. In the treated patients there was a small but significant improvement (p = 0.002) in handgrip at 12 months.

Prolonged paralysis due to nondepolarizing neuromuscular blocking agents and corticosteroids.

The long-term use of nondepolarizing neuromuscular blocking agents (ND-NMBA) has recently been implicated as a cause of prolonged muscle weakness, although the site of the lesion and the predisposing factors have been unclear. We report 3 patients (age 37-52 years) with acute respiratory insufficiency who developed prolonged weakness following the discontinuation of ND-NMBAs. Two patients also received intravenous corticosteroids. Renal function was normal but hepatic function was impaired in all patients, and all had acidosis. Electrophysiologic studies revealed low amplitude compound motor action potentials, normal sensory studies, and fibrillations. Repetitive stimulation at 2 Hz showed a decremental response in 2 patients. The serum vecuronium level measured in 1 patient 14 days after the drug had been discontinued was 172 ng/mL. A muscle biopsy in this patient showed loss of thick, myosin filaments. The weakness in these patients is due to pathology at both the neuromuscular junction (most likely due to ND-NMBA) and muscle (most likely due to corticosteroids). Hepatic dysfunction and acidosis are contributing risk factors.

Adult acid maltase deficiency.

A 30-year-old man was referred for neurologic evaluation because of elevated creatine kinase. He had noted symptoms of proximal arm and distal leg weakness for several years, and, on examination, he had weakness in a scapuloperoneal distribution. An electromyogram showed myotonic discharges in the paraspinous muscles, and a muscle biopsy revealed severe vacuolar myopathy. Biochemical analysis of muscle showed acid maltase deficiency. The patient's only brother had childhood-onset acid maltase deficiency and died of respiratory failure at age 27. Acid maltase deficiency may have heterogeneous presentations within a family, and adult AMD can present as a scapuloperoneal neuromuscular syndrome.