Identifying Levels of Competency in Aesthetic Medicine: A Questionnaire-Based Study.

BACKGROUND: In 2022, the US experienced a significant increase in demand for minimally invasive aesthetic procedures, underscoring its rising acceptance amidst an unregulated educational environment for practitioners. The absence of standardized educational pathways and quality control in aesthetic medicine, primarily provided by non-academic institutions, highlights a critical need for establishing educational standards to ensure practitioner competence and patient safety. OBJECTIVES: To identify levels of competency for the aesthetic practitioner and for necessary achievement milestones during the educational path from novice to expert injector. METHODS: A total of n = 386 international study participants responded to an online questionnaire regarding their experience in aesthetic medicine practice. The questionnaire comprised 58 questions focusing on professional data, the perceived difficulty of injection and risk for the occurrence of adverse events for specific facial regions in soft tissue filler and toxin injections. RESULTS: Regardless of medical specialty and experience level, an average of 3.85 (1.8) years, 786.4 (2,628) filler injections, and 549.9 (1,543) toxin injections was estimated to progress from novice to advanced injector, while an average of 6.10 (3.7) years, 1,842.2 (4,793) filler injections, and 1,308.5 (3,363) injections was estimated to advance from advanced to expert injector. The nose and the perioral region have been ranked as the facial regions most difficult to achieve a perfect aesthetic outcome and with the greatest risk for the occurrence of adverse events for filler and toxin injections, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This study establishes an educational framework in aesthetic medicine by defining the progression from novice to competent and expert injector levels, suggesting 4 years of practice and over 790 filler and 550 neuromodulator injections for competence, and at least 6 years with 1,840 filler and 1,310 neuromodulator injections for expertise. It also identifies critical facial regions for targeted treatments by different expertise levels.

Understanding Platysma Muscle Contraction Pattern and Its Relationship to Platysmal Banding: A Real-Time Ultrasound Study.

BACKGROUND: Addressing neck contouring with surgical and nonsurgical aesthetic procedures includes understanding the origin of platysmal banding. A theory was postulated to explain this phenomenon by isometric vs isotonic muscular contraction patterns. However, no scientific proof had been provided to date for its correctness. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to confirm the correctness of the platysmal banding theory based on isometric vs isotonic muscular contractions. METHODS: Eighty platysma muscles from 40 volunteers (15 males and 25 females) were investigated (mean age 41.8; SD 15.2 years; mean BMI of 22.2; SD 2.3 kg/m2). Real-time ultrasound imaging was utilized to measure the increase in local muscle thickness inside and outside of a platysmal band as well as platysma mobility. RESULTS: Within a platysmal band, the local thickness of the muscle increases during muscular contractions by 0.33 mm (37.9%; P < .001). Outside of a platysmal band the thickness of the platysma muscle decreased by 0.13 mm (20.3%; P < .001). It was identified that within a platysmal band no gliding was detectable, whereas outside of a band an average muscle gliding of 2.76 mm was observed. CONCLUSIONS: The results confirm the correctness of the isometric vs isotonic platysma muscle contraction pattern theory: isotonic muscle contraction (gliding without increase in tension and therefore in muscle thickness) vs isometric muscle contraction (no gliding but increase in tension and therefore in muscle thickness). These 2 types of contraction patterns occur within the platysma simultaneously and are an indicator for zones of adhesion in the neck to guide surgical and nonsurgical aesthetic procedures.

The Suitability of a Large Particle Hyaluronic Acid Filler for the Treatment of Temporal Hollowing.

BACKGROUND: Hyaluronic acid (HA) fillers may be manufactured to have distinctive physical properties that optimize their use for specific indications. Fillers manufactured with large gel calibration (particle size; HA-V) may be particularly suitable for volumizing large surface areas such as the temporal hollows. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the safety and effectiveness of HA-V for the treatment of temporal hollows. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A prospective, open-label, single-cohort, clinical trial was conducted. Twenty-six women who presented with bilateral temporal hollows at baseline were recruited. All subjects received treatment with HA-V and were observed at 4 to 5 in-person visits over 16 weeks. Subjective and objective measures of safety and efficacy parameters were collected through 2- and 3-dimensional imagery, questionnaires/scales (i.e., subject satisfaction, global aesthetic improvement, temporal hollowing severity), and adverse event diaries. RESULTS: To achieve optimal correction, the investigator used an average of 1.70 syringes per subject, per side. All treatments were performed using a bolus injection technique to place the product on the periosteum (bone) of the temporal region. Following optimal correction, all subjects (100%) displayed improvement in their global aesthetic appearance, and 25 of 26 subjects (96.15%) displayed ≥1 grade improvement on the temporal volume scale. Subject satisfaction was high, with 91.3% of subjects being satisfied with the appearance of their temporal regions following optimal correction. CONCLUSION: In this pivotal trial, HA-V was evidenced to have an excellent safety profile and proven efficacy up to 16 weeks, making it a suitable HA filler for volumization of the temporal region.

Novel Treatment Protocol for Combined Tear Trough Ligament Stretching and Injection.

BACKGROUND: Complex anatomical changes have been the main challenges for optimal treatment results of tear trough deformities through hyaluronic acid (HA) injections. The authors present a novel technique consisting of a preinjection tear trough ligament stretching (TTLS-I) leading to its release, and compared its efficacy, safety, and patient satisfaction to tear trough deformity injection (TTDI). METHODS: This was a 4-year, retrospective, single-center cohort study of 83 TTLS-I patients, with a follow-up period of 1 year. One hundred thirty-five TTDI patients served as a comparison group. Outcome analyses included the analysis of possible risk factors for adverse outcome and comparative statistics between the complication and satisfaction rates of the two groups. RESULTS: TTLS-I patients received significantly less HA (0.3 cc; range, 0.2 to 0.3 cc) than TTDI patients did (0.6 cc; range, 0.6 to 0.8 cc; P < 0.001). The injected HA amount was a significant predictive factor for complications ( P < 0.05). Complication rates assessed during the follow-up visit for hematomas, edema, and the need for corrective hyaluronidase injection were low in both groups, with no significant differences between the groups. TTDI patients had significantly higher rates (5.1%) of lump surface irregularities during follow-up, compared with 0% in the TTLS-I group ( P < 0.05). After 1 year of follow-up, 98.8% of TTLS-I patients were satisfied, whereas 95.6% of TTDI patients were satisfied, with no significant difference between groups. CONCLUSIONS: TTLS-I is a novel, safe, and effective treatment method, necessitating significantly less HA compared with TTDI. Moreover, it leads to very high satisfaction rates and very low complication rates. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, III.

A Computed Tomographic Investigation of the Ophthalmic Artery Volume and Its Relevance to Soft Tissue Filler Injections.

BACKGROUND: The measured intraarterial volume of cadaveric ophthalmic arteries was utilized for safety recommendations during facial soft tissue filler injections. However, its clinical practicability and model applicability have become questionable. OBJECTIVES: To measure the volume of the ophthalmic artery in living individuals by utilizing computed tomography (CT) imaging technology. METHODS: A total of 40 Chinese patients (23 males, 17 females) were included in this study with a mean age of 61.0 (14.2) years and a mean body mass index of 23.7 (3.3) kg/m2. Patients were investigated with CT imaging technology to evaluate the length, diameter, and volume of the bilateral ophthalmic arteries as well as the length of the bony orbits, resulting in a total of 80 investigated ophthalmic arteries and orbits. RESULTS: Independent of gender, the average length of the ophthalmic artery was 80.6 (18.7) mm, the calculated volume of the ophthalmic artery was 0.16 (0.05) mL and the minimal and maximal internal diameter of the ophthalmic artery were 0.50 (0.05) mm and 1.06 (0.1) mm, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Based on the results obtained from the investigation of 80 ophthalmic arteries it must be concluded that current safety recommendations should be reevaluated. The volume of the ophthalmic artery appears to be 0.2 mL rather than 0.1 mL as previously reported. In addition, it appears impractical to limit the volume of soft tissue filler bolus injections to 0.1 mL due to the aesthetic requirements of each individual patient and treatment plan.

Tips and Tricks for Facial Toxin Injections with Illustrated Anatomy.

LEARNING OBJECTIVES: After studying this article, the participant should be able to: 1. Recognize facial muscle contraction direction and muscle morphology based on skin surface movements and facial rhytides. 2. Classify different muscle contraction patterns and target respectively with the recommended dosage and injection technique. 3. Apply the presented injection techniques to the patients' individual anatomy with greater precision and without affecting adjacent muscles or causing other adverse events. SUMMARY: Facial muscular anatomy has recently gained increased attention, with new investigative methodologies and new injection techniques arising on the market. These recent advancements have increased our understanding about the functional anatomy of facial muscles and have changed the way health care professionals see and understand their interplay during various facial expressions and in determining facial shape. This new anatomical understanding of facial muscles and their interaction has resulted in superior neuromodulator treatment outcomes with fewer side effects and with increased precision. The latter is of greatest importance, as all facial muscles act as a unit and connect with each other. It is therefore paramount to target during neuromodulator treatments only the muscle responsible for the aesthetic effect desired and not other adjacent muscles, which can have different or even antagonistic effects. Conventional anatomy was previously limited to two-dimensional explanations of muscle locations without incorporating their detailed action or their three-dimensional location of extent. The "new" anatomy incorporates those novel concepts and, once understood, will help health care providers to understand better and to "read" the underlying muscular anatomy based on the wrinkle status and based on the change in skin surface landmarks based on the actions of the underlying musculature. The following article summarizes tips and tricks, pearls and pitfalls, and dos and don'ts during facial neuromodulator injections along with a guide toward adverse event management and patient outcome assessment with special focus on the underlying anatomy.

A Randomized, Crossover-Controlled Evaluator-Blinded Trial Evaluating Cannula- vs Needle-Assisted Hyaluronic Acid Injections for Infraorbital Deformities.

BACKGROUND: Periorbital deformities can be corrected utilizing hyaluronic acid injections. However, previous studies have not evaluated the effect of utilizing different injection techniques (eg, a needle vs cannula) on efficacy and safety. OBJECTIVES: The authors sought to investigate the efficacy and safety of HA for the correction of periorbital deformities when utilizing either needle or cannula-assisted injections. METHODS: This was a prospective, randomized-controlled (with crossover), evaluator-blinded study. Forty-two patients with a mean age of 44.82 ± 11.62 years were recruited. Patients underwent 2 treatment sessions, spaced 2 weeks apart, and attended 1 follow-up visit at Week 4, following the last treatment. Patients were randomized in a 3:3:1 ratio, whereby 18 patients received injections by needle, 18 received injections by cannula, and 6 were randomized to act as their own control at baseline. Those in the control group were randomized (n = 3) to needle or cannula injections at Week 4 and proceeded with the same visit schedule as those treated at baseline. At Weeks 2 and 4 posttreatment, patient satisfaction was evaluated and information on adverse effects was collected. A blinded reviewer assessed patient imagery utilizing standardized efficacy scales. RESULTS: Chi-square tests did not reveal any associations between treatment group and efficacy, safety, or patient satisfaction scores (P ≥ 0.05). Adverse effects reported in patient diaries were mild to moderate in nature and expected. CONCLUSIONS: For the treatment of infraorbital deformities, hyaluronic acid injections performed utilizing either a cannula or needle result in similarly high efficacy and safety ratios.

Change in Rheologic Properties of Facial Soft-Tissue Fillers across the Physiologic Angular Frequency Spectrum.

BACKGROUND: The number of soft-tissue filler injections performed in the United States is constantly increasing and reflects the high demand for enhanced facial and body attractiveness. The objective of the present study was to measure the viscoelastic properties of soft-tissue fillers when subjected to different testing frequencies. The range of tested frequencies represents clinically different facial areas with more [lips (high frequency)] or less [zygomatic arch (low frequency)] soft-tissue movement. METHODS: A total of 35 randomly selected hyaluronic acid-based dermal filler products were tested in an independent laboratory for their values of G', G″, tan δ, and G* at angular frequencies between 0.1 and 100 radian/second. RESULTS: The results of the objective analyses revealed that the viscoelastic properties of all tested products changed between 0.1 and 100 radian/second angular frequency. Changes in G' ranged from 48.5 to 3116 percent, representing an increase in their initial elastic modulus, whereas changes in G″ ranged from -53.3 percent (i.e., decrease in G″) to 7741 percent (i.e., increase in G″), indicating both an increase and a decrease in their fluidity, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The increase in G' would indicate the transition from a "softer" to a "harder" filler, and the observed decrease in G″ would indicate an increase in the filler's "fluidity." Changes in the frequency of applied shear forces such as those occurring in the medial versus the lateral face will influence the aesthetic outcome of soft-tissue filler injections.

Differences in Temporal Volume between Males and Females and the Influence of Age and BMI: A Cross-Sectional CT-Imaging Study.

BACKGROUND: The temple has been identified as one of the most compelling facial regions in which to seek aesthetic improvement-both locally and in the entire face-when injecting soft tissue fillers. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study is to identify influences of age, gender, and body mass index (BMI) on temporal parameters to better understand clinical observations and to identify optimal treatment strategies for treating temporal hollowing. METHODS: The sample consisted of 28 male and 30 female individuals with a median age of 53 (34) years and a median BMI of 27.00 (6.94) kg/m2. The surface area of temporal skin, the surface area of temporal bones, and the temporal soft tissue volume were measured utilizing postprocessed computed tomography (CT) images via the Hausdorff minimal distance algorithm. Differences between the investigated participants related to age, BMI, and gender were calculated. RESULTS: Median skin surface area was greater in males compared with females 5,100.5 (708) mm2 versus 4,208.5 (893) mm2 (p < 0.001) as was the median bone surface area 5,329 (690) mm2 versus 4,477 (888) mm2 (p < 0.001). Males had on average 11.04 mL greater temporal soft tissue volume compared with age and BMI-matched females with p < 0.001. Comparing the volume between premenopausal versus postmenopausal females, the median temporal soft tissue volume was 46.63 mL (11.94) versus 40.32 mL (5.69) (p = 0.014). CONCLUSION: The results of this cross-sectional CT imaging study confirmed previous clinical and anatomical observations and added numerical evidence to those observations for a better clinical integration of the data.

An Objective, Quantitative Assessment of Flexible Hyaluronic Acid Fillers in Lip and Perioral Enhancement.

BACKGROUND: HARK is an FDA-approved flexible filler designed for lips. OBJECTIVE: To quantitatively evaluate subject outcomes by measuring the change in lip texture, color (redness), lip fullness, and lip and perioral surface stretch (dynamic strain) after treatment. METHODS AND MATERIALS: In this 8-week open-label, Phase IV multicenter study, subjects were treated with HARK in the lips and HARR and/or HARD in perioral wrinkles and folds as add-on treatment. Assessments included 2D photographic analyses of lip texture and color, and 3D photographic assessments of lip enhancement and dynamic strain. RESULTS: HARK significantly improved lip texture (p ≤ .002), lip redness (p < .001), and added fullness to the lips (lip enhancement measurements; p < .001), at Week 8 after treatment. In addition, lower lip wrinkles were significantly reduced (p = .007) and there was a reduction in upper lip wrinkles (not statistically significant). Surface stretch (dynamic strain) in the lip and perioral region was significantly increased after treatment (p < .001). CONCLUSION: This analysis provides an objective measure of the beneficial effects of flexible hyaluronic acid fillers in lip augmentation and perioral enhancement and demonstrates a significantly improved lip texture, red color, and fullness. A significant increase in surface stretch (dynamic strain) is indicative of tissue expansion and improvement in lip smoothness.

A Multicenter Evaluation of Paradoxical Adipose Hyperplasia Following Cryolipolysis for Fat Reduction and Body Contouring: A Review of 8658 Cycles in 2114 Patients.

BACKGROUND: Paradoxical adipose hyperplasia (PAH) is a rare, moderate-to-severe adverse event associated with cryolipolysis (CoolSculpting, CS). OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to describe the incidence, diagnosis, and treatment of PAH occurring after CS for nonsurgical fat reduction. METHODS: A multicenter evaluation of all patients who underwent CS treatment between January 2015 and December 2019 at 8 Canadian medical centers was conducted. Data abstracted included symptoms, management strategy, outcome, operator characteristics, device characteristics, patient characteristics, body region, and CS treatment details. Incidence of PAH was calculated based on the number of treatment cycles. RESULTS: Our findings revealed incidence rates between 0.05% and 0.39%, which are slightly higher than the manufacturer's quoted rate of 0.025% (1 per 4000 cycles). Incidence rates at all sites were dramatically reduced by over 75% with the implementation of newer models of CS units. Of patients who developed PAH, 55% were male and 77.8% were of European ethnic origin. The majority of cases (76.9%) were associated with older models of CS units. CONCLUSIONS: Development of PAH may be related to a combination of factors, including older models of CS units and applicators, as well as individual characteristics that predispose certain patients.

Cannula versus needle in medical rhinoplasty: the nose knows.

The use of hyaluronic acid (HA) fillers has become a popular alternative for nose remodeling, although poor understanding of the nasal anatomy has resulted in adverse events and generated some controversy. Among them, is the question of where and when to use cannulas vs needles. Through multiple cadaver dissections, clinical experience and the review of medical literature the authors conclude the use of needle over cannula is preferred, assuring a correct injection plane lying fully against the bone or cartilage. Although blunt in nature, cannulas may lead to difficulty in determining with precision the exact depth of product placement and contribute to more dissection of adjacent structures. Thorough knowledge of the highly variable nasal anatomy, including vessel depth location is of outmost importance in avoiding adverse events. Good patient selection is critical where most noses for augmentation rhinoplasty and some reduction rhinoplasty candidates where the goal is to camouflage the dorsal hump are amenable to medical rhinoplasty, unless there is reduced skin elasticity of nasal soft tissues or distortion of anatomy from surgery or trauma. Appropriate product selection is important for effective results. The authors suggest fillers with low cohesivity and high lifting capacity. Finally, we suggest a technique referred as Rhinosculpting base in the use the use of three conceptual elements: facial analysis, light reflection, and use of HA gel as a cartilage graft, in combination with the detailed injection technique presented in this article, which ensures a safer and satisfying treatment outcome.

Relationship Between Vertical Glabellar Lines and the Supratrochlear and Supraorbital Arteries.

BACKGROUND: Glabellar soft tissue filler injections have been shown to be associated with a high risk of causing injection-related visual compromise. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to identify the course of the superficial branch of the supratrochlear and of the deep branch of the supraorbital artery in relation to the ipsilateral vertical glabellar line and to test whether an artery is located deep to this line. METHODS: Forty-one healthy volunteers with a mean age of 26.17 [9.6] years and a mean BMI of 23.09 [2.3] kg/m2 were analyzed. Ultrasound imaging was applied to measure the diameters, distance from skin surface, distance between the midline, distance between vertical glabella lines, and the cutaneous projection of the supratrochlear/supraorbital arteries at rest and upon frowning. RESULTS: The mean distance between the superficial branch of the supratrochlear artery and the ipsilateral vertical glabellar line was 10.59 [4.0] mm in males and 8.21 [4.0] mm in females, whereas it was 22.38 [5.5] mm for the supraorbital artery in males and 20.73 [5.6] mm in females. Upon frowning, a medial shift in supratrochlear arterial position of 1.63 mm in males and 1.84 mm in females and of 3.9 mm in supraorbital arterial position for both genders was observed. The mean depth of the supratrochlear artery was 3.34 [0.6] mm at rest, whereas the depth of the supraorbital artery was 3.54 [0.8] mm. CONCLUSIONS: The hypothesis that injecting soft tissue fillers next to the vertical glabellar line is safe because the supratrochlear artery courses deep to the crease should be rejected. Additionally, the glabella and the supraorbital region should be considered as an area of mobile, rather than static, soft tissues.

The Role of Clinical Examination in Midface Volume Correction Using Hyaluronic Acid Fillers: Should Patients Be Stratified by Skin Thickness?

BACKGROUND: Aesthetic physicians have several hundred injectable products to select from. Due to differences in their manufacturing technology, these products display varying biophysical qualities, such as their cohesivity and lift capacity. Currently, there is no guidance to objectively selecting the best product for a particular patient. Therefore, an algorithmic approach is required to take specific skin characteristics into consideration. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate (1) whether subjects seeking injectable treatments for midfacial volume loss and/or contour deficiency can be stratified based on specific skin characteristics (eg, thickness, fat quantity, bony structure) and (2) whether particular hyaluronic acid fillers perform best when used in such particular strata. METHODS: This was a prospective, Phase IV, open-label, single-center clinical trial. Thirty female patients with midface/cheek volume loss and/or contour deficiency were recruited (mean age, 53.5 years; SD, 12.57; range, 35-75 years). Subjects were treated with either Restylane Lyft (HAL) or Restylane Volyme (HAV) and followed for 4 months post-injection. Treatment allocation was based on the treating physician's clinical evaluation and compared with ultrasound evaluation. Ultrasound images were used to confirm stratification. Safety and efficacy assessments were performed at each study visit: baseline, week 2, week 4, week 8, and week 16. Subgroup analyses evaluated whether particular strata performed best when treated with specific products. RESULTS: The 2 investigative products varied in their efficacy, depending on the characteristics of the subject. CONCLUSIONS: The use of a treatment algorithm may improve outcomes for patients seeking injectable treatments for midfacial volume loss and contour deficiencies.

A Multicenter, Retrospective Evaluation of Tissue Stabilized-Guided Subcision in the Management of Cellulite.

BACKGROUND: The first FDA-cleared, long-lasting, minimally invasive device for improving the appearance of cellulite was recently launched in Canada as a novel, tissue stabilized-guided subcision (TS-GS) system (Cellfina, Merz North America, Inc., Raleigh, NC). Clinicians from 2 of the first Canadian sites offering this procedure were interested in evaluating treatment efficacy and patient satisfaction after its first year on the market. OBJECTIVES: The authors sought to evaluate the efficacy of TS-GS and the level of patient satisfaction associated with the procedure. METHODS: Medical charts of female patients treated with the TS-GS system in 2017 were retrospectively analyzed at 2 Canadian centers. Measurements at baseline and 3 months posttreatment were assessed for patient satisfaction and physician-rated efficacy. Patient satisfaction was assessed using a 5-point Likert-type scale, and efficacy was evaluated through physician review of 2-deminsional and 3-dimensional photography, the Nürnberger-Müller Scale for cellulite, and the Global Assessment of Improvement Scale. RESULTS: We reviewed 25 patient charts. At month 3, 95.6% of patients were satisfied with treatment results and physician evaluations revealed that on average, patients displayed a 1-point improvement in their cellulite grades. Moreover, Global Assessment of Improvement Scale scores indicated that all patients had visible improvement in the global appearance of cellulite. No serious adverse events were observed within 3 months postprocedure. CONCLUSIONS: The physician ratings, patient satisfaction, and photographic evidence support the efficacy of the TS-GS system to manage grades 1 to 3 cellulite in women's thighs and buttocks. These findings indicate the safety of the TS-GS system.Level of Evidence: 4.

Long-Term Health-Related Quality of Life Outcomes in Digital Replantation versus Revision Amputation.

Background Earlier, digit viability judged the success of digital replantation. Now, utility health-related quality of life (HRQOL) measures can better assess the impact of digital replantation. Methods Overall, 264 digital injury patients were sent a regimen of utility measures: Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score, European Quality of Life 5 Dimensions, visual analog scale (VAS), time trade-off (TTO), and standard gamble (SG). Overall, 51 patients responded completely to all of these-36 replantation patients and 15 revision amputation patients. The utility results of these patients were stratified between replantation versus revision amputation; dominant hand replantation versus nondominant hand replantation; and dominant hand revision amputation versus nondominant hand revision amputation. Results The mean VAS score of replant (0.84) and revision amputation (0.75) groups was significantly different (p = 0.05). The mean DASH score of dominant hand replantations (29.72) and nondominant hand replantations (17.97) was significantly different (p = 0.027). The dominant hand revision amputation had higher anxiety levels in comparison to nondominant hand revision amputation (p = 0.027). Patients with two or more digits replanted showed a significant decrease in VAS, TTO, and SG scores in comparison to patients who only had one digit replanted (p = 0.009, 0.001, and 0.001, respectively). Conclusions This study suggests that HRQOL can offer better indices for outcomes of digital replantation. This shows some specific replantation cohorts have a significantly better quality of life when compared with their specific correlating revision amputation cohort. These findings can be employed to further refine indications and contraindications to replantation and help predict the quality of life outcomes.