Escherichia coli monothiol glutaredoxin GrxD replenishes Fe-S clusters to the essential ErpA A-type carrier under low iron stress.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are required for essential biological pathways, including respiration and isoprenoid biosynthesis. Complex Fe-S cluster biogenesis systems have evolved to maintain an adequate supply of this critical protein cofactor. In Escherichia coli, two Fe-S biosynthetic systems, the "housekeeping" Isc and "stress responsive" Suf pathways, interface with a network of cluster trafficking proteins, such as ErpA, IscA, SufA, and NfuA. GrxD, a Fe-S cluster-binding monothiol glutaredoxin, also participates in Fe-S protein biogenesis in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Previous studies in E. coli showed that the ΔgrxD mutation causes sensitivity to iron depletion, spotlighting a critical role for GrxD under conditions that disrupt Fe-S homeostasis. Here, we utilized a global chemoproteomic mass spectrometry approach to analyze the contribution of GrxD to the Fe-S proteome. Our results demonstrate that (1) GrxD is required for biogenesis of a specific subset of Fe-S proteins under iron-depleted conditions, (2) GrxD is required for cluster delivery to ErpA under iron limitation, (3) GrxD is functionally distinct from other Fe-S trafficking proteins, and (4) GrxD Fe-S cluster binding is responsive to iron limitation. All these results lead to the proposal that GrxD is required to maintain Fe-S cluster delivery to the essential trafficking protein ErpA during iron limitation conditions.

Fe-S cluster biogenesis by the bacterial Suf pathway.

Biogenesis of iron-sulfur (FeS) clusters in an essential process in living organisms due to the critical role of FeS cluster proteins in myriad cell functions. During biogenesis of FeS clusters, multi-protein complexes are used to drive the mobilization and protection of reactive sulfur and iron intermediates, regulate assembly of various FeS clusters on an ATPase-dependent, multi-protein scaffold, and target nascent clusters to their downstream protein targets. The evolutionarily ancient sulfur formation (Suf) pathway for FeS cluster assembly is found in bacteria and archaea. In Escherichia coli, the Suf pathway functions as an emergency pathway under conditions of iron limitation or oxidative stress. In other pathogenic bacteria, such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Enterococcus faecalis, the Suf pathway is the sole source for FeS clusters and therefore is a potential target for the development of novel antibacterial compounds. Here we summarize the considerable progress that has been made in characterizing the first step of mobilization and protection of reactive sulfur carried out by the SufS-SufE or SufS-SufU complex, FeS cluster assembly on SufBC2D scaffold complexes, and the downstream trafficking of nascent FeS clusters to A-type carrier (ATC) proteins. Cell Biology of Metals III edited by Roland Lill and Mick Petris.

Direct observation of intermediates in the SufS cysteine desulfurase reaction reveals functional roles of conserved active-site residues.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are necessary for the proper functioning of numerous metalloproteins. Fe-S cluster (Isc) and sulfur utilization factor (Suf) pathways are the key biosynthetic routes responsible for generating these Fe-S cluster prosthetic groups in Escherichia coli Although Isc dominates under normal conditions, Suf takes over during periods of iron depletion and oxidative stress. Sulfur acquisition via these systems relies on the ability to remove sulfur from free cysteine using a cysteine desulfurase mechanism. In the Suf pathway, the dimeric SufS protein uses the cofactor pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) to abstract sulfur from free cysteine, resulting in the production of alanine and persulfide. Despite much progress, the stepwise mechanism by which this PLP-dependent enzyme operates remains unclear. Here, using rapid-mixing kinetics in conjunction with X-ray crystallography, we analyzed the pre-steady-state kinetics of this process while assigning early intermediates of the mechanism. We employed H123A and C364A SufS variants to trap Cys-aldimine and Cys-ketimine intermediates of the cysteine desulfurase reaction, enabling direct observations of these intermediates and associated conformational changes of the SufS active site. Of note, we propose that Cys-364 is essential for positioning the Cys-aldimine for Cα deprotonation, His-123 acts to protonate the Ala-enamine intermediate, and Arg-56 facilitates catalysis by hydrogen bonding with the sulfhydryl of Cys-aldimine. Our results, along with previous SufS structural findings, suggest a detailed model of the SufS-catalyzed reaction from Cys binding to C-S bond cleavage and indicate that Arg-56, His-123, and Cys-364 are critical SufS residues in this C-S bond cleavage pathway.

Structural Evidence for Dimer-Interface-Driven Regulation of the Type II Cysteine Desulfurase, SufS.

SufS is a type II cysteine desulfurase and acts as the initial step in the Suf Fe-S cluster assembly pathway. In Escherichia coli, this pathway is utilized under conditions of oxidative stress and is resistant to reactive oxygen species. Mechanistically, this means SufS must shift between protecting a covalent persulfide intermediate and making it available for transfer to the next protein partner in the pathway, SufE. Here, we report five X-ray crystal structures of SufS including a new structure of SufS containing an inward-facing persulfide intermediate on C364. Additional structures of SufS variants with substitutions at the dimer interface show changes in dimer geometry and suggest a conserved ß-hairpin structure plays a role in mediating interactions with SufE. These new structures, along with previous HDX-MS and biochemical data, identify an interaction network capable of communication between active-sites of the SufS dimer coordinating the shift between desulfurase and transpersulfurase activities.

Nickel exposure reduces enterobactin production in Escherichia coli.

Escherichia coli is a well-studied bacterium that can be found in many niches, such as industrial wastewater, where the concentration of nickel can rise to low-millimolar levels. Recent studies show that nickel exposure can repress pyochelin or induce pyoverdine siderophore production in Pseudomonas aueroginosa. Understanding the molecular cross-talk between siderophore production, metal homeostasis, and metal toxicity in microorganisms is critical for designing bioremediation strategies for metal-contaminated sites. Here, we show that high-nickel exposure prolongs lag phase duration as a result of low-intracellular iron levels in E. coli. Although E. coli cells respond to low-intracellular iron during nickel stress by maintaining high expression of iron uptake systems such as fepA, the demand for iron is not met due to a lack of siderophores in the extracellular medium during nickel stress. Taken together, these results indicate that nickel inhibits iron accumulation in E. coli by reducing the presence of enterobactin in the extracellular medium.

Conserved cysteine residues are necessary for nickel-induced allosteric regulation of the metalloregulatory protein YqjI (NfeR) in E. coli.

Transition metal homeostasis is necessary to sustain life. First row transition metals act as cofactors within the cell, performing vital functions ranging from DNA repair to respiration. However, intracellular metal concentrations exceeding physiological requirements may be toxic. In E. coli, the YqjH flavoprotein is thought to play a role in iron homeostasis. YqjH is transcriptionally regulated by the ferric uptake regulator and a newly discovered regulator encoded by yqjI. The apo-form of YqjI is a transcriptional repressor of both the yqjH and yqjI genes. YqjI repressor function is disrupted upon binding of nickel. The YqjI N-terminus is homologous to nickel-binding proteins, implicating this region as a nickel-binding domain. Based on function, yqjI and yqjH should be renamed Ni-responsive Fe-uptake regulator (nfeR) and Ni-responsive Fe-uptake flavoprotein (nfeF), respectively. X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy was employed to characterize the nickel binding site(s) within YqjI. Putative nickel binding ligands were targeted by site-directed mutagenesis and resulting variants were analyzed in vivo for repressor function. Isothermal titration calorimetry and competitive binding assays were used to further quantify nickel interactions with wild-type YqjI and its mutant derivatives. Results indicate plasticity in the nickel binding domain of YqjI. Residues C42 and C43 were found to be required for in vivo response of YqjI to nickel stress, though these residues are not required for in vitro nickel binding. We propose that YqjI may contain a vicinal disulfide bond between C42 and C43 that is important for nickel-responsive allosteric interactions between YqjI domains.

Changes in Protein Dynamics in Escherichia coli SufS Reveal a Possible Conserved Regulatory Mechanism in Type II Cysteine Desulfurase Systems.

In the Suf Fe-S cluster assembly pathway, the activity of the cysteine desulfurase, SufS, is regulated by interactions with the accessory sulfotransferase protein, SufE. SufE has been shown to stimulate SufS activity, likely by inducing conformational changes in the SufS active site that promote the desulfurase step and by acting as an efficient persulfide acceptor in the transpersulfuration step. Previous results point toward an additional level of regulation through a "half-sites" mechanism that affects the stoichiometry and affinity for SufE as the dimeric SufS shifts between desulfurase and transpersulfuration activities. Investigation of the covalent persulfide intermediate of SufS by backbone amide hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry identified two active site peptides (residues 225-236 and 356-366) and two peptides at the dimer interface of SufS (residues 88-100 and 243-255) that exhibit changes in deuterium uptake upon formation of the intermediate. Residues in these peptides are organized to form a conduit between the two active sites upon persulfide formation and include key cross-monomer interactions, suggesting they may play a role in the half-sites regulation. Three evolutionarily conserved residues at the dimer interface (R92, E96, and E250) were investigated by alanine scanning mutagenesis. Two of the substituted enzymes (E96A and E250A SufS) resulted in 6-fold increases in the value of KSufE, confirming a functional role. Re-examination of the dimer interface in reported crystal structures of SufS and the SufS homologue CsdA identified previously unnoticed residue mobility at the dimer interface. The identification of conformational changes at the dimer interface by hydrogen-deuterium exchange confirmed by mutagenesis and structural reports provides a physical mechanism for active site communication in the half-sites regulation of SufS activity. Given the conservation of the interface interactions, this mechanism may be broadly applicable to type II cysteine desulfurase systems.

Functional Dynamics Revealed by the Structure of the SufBCD Complex, a Novel ATP-binding Cassette (ABC) Protein That Serves as a Scaffold for Iron-Sulfur Cluster Biogenesis.

ATP-binding cassette (ABC)-type ATPases are chemomechanical engines involved in diverse biological pathways. Recent genomic information reveals that ABC ATPase domains/subunits act not only in ABC transporters and structural maintenance of chromosome proteins, but also in iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster biogenesis. A novel type of ABC protein, the SufBCD complex, functions in the biosynthesis of nascent Fe-S clusters in almost all Eubacteria and Archaea, as well as eukaryotic chloroplasts. In this study, we determined the first crystal structure of the Escherichia coli SufBCD complex, which exhibits the common architecture of ABC proteins: two ABC ATPase components (SufC) with function-specific components (SufB-SufD protomers). Biochemical and physiological analyses based on this structure provided critical insights into Fe-S cluster assembly and revealed a dynamic conformational change driven by ABC ATPase activity. We propose a molecular mechanism for the biogenesis of the Fe-S cluster in the SufBCD complex.

SufE D74R Substitution Alters Active Site Loop Dynamics To Further Enhance SufE Interaction with the SufS Cysteine Desulfurase.

Many essential metalloproteins require iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster cofactors for their function. In vivo persulfide formation from l-cysteine is a key step in the biogenesis of Fe-S clusters in most organisms. In Escherichia coli, the SufS cysteine desulfurase mobilizes persulfide from l-cysteine via a PLP-dependent ping-pong reaction. SufS requires the SufE partner protein to transfer the persulfide to the SufB Fe-S cluster scaffold. Without SufE, the SufS enzyme fails to efficiently turn over and remains locked in the persulfide-bound state. Coordinated protein-protein interactions mediate sulfur transfer from SufS to SufE. Multiple studies have suggested that SufE must undergo a conformational change to extend its active site Cys loop during sulfur transfer from SufS. To test this putative model, we mutated SufE Asp74 to Arg (D74R) to increase the dynamics of the SufE Cys51 loop. Amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) analysis of SufE D74R revealed an increase in solvent accessibility and dynamics in the loop containing the active site Cys51 used to accept persulfide from SufS. Our results indicate that the mutant protein has a stronger binding affinity for SufS than that of wild-type SufE. In addition, SufE D74R can still enhance SufS desulfurase activity and did not show saturation at higher SufE D74R concentrations, unlike wild-type SufE. These results show that dynamic changes may shift SufE to a sulfur-acceptor state that interacts more strongly with SufS.

Interplay between oxygen and Fe-S cluster biogenesis: insights from the Suf pathway.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster metalloproteins conduct essential functions in nearly all contemporary forms of life. The nearly ubiquitous presence of Fe-S clusters and the fundamental requirement for Fe-S clusters in both aerobic and anaerobic Archaea, Bacteria, and Eukarya suggest that these clusters were likely integrated into central metabolic pathways early in the evolution of life prior to the widespread oxidation of Earth's atmosphere. Intriguingly, Fe-S cluster-dependent metabolism is sensitive to disruption by oxygen because of the decreased bioavailability of ferric iron as well as direct oxidation of sulfur trafficking intermediates and Fe-S clusters by reactive oxygen species. This fact, coupled with the ubiquity of Fe-S clusters in aerobic organisms, suggests that organisms evolved with mechanisms that facilitate the biogenesis and use of these essential cofactors in the presence of oxygen, which gradually began to accumulate around 2.5 billion years ago as oxygenic photosynthesis proliferated and reduced minerals that buffered against oxidation were depleted. This review highlights the most ancient of the Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathways, the Suf system, which likely was present in early anaerobic forms of life. Herein, we use the evolution of the Suf pathway to assess the relationships between the biochemical functions and physiological roles of Suf proteins, with an emphasis on the selective pressure of oxygen toxicity. Our analysis suggests that diversification into oxygen-containing environments disrupted iron and sulfur metabolism and was a main driving force in the acquisition of accessory Suf proteins (such as SufD, SufE, and SufS) by the core SufB-SufC scaffold complex. This analysis provides a new framework for the study of Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathways and Fe-S cluster-containing metalloenzymes and their complicated patterns of divergence in response to oxygen.

Escherichia coli SufE sulfur transfer protein modulates the SufS cysteine desulfurase through allosteric conformational dynamics.

Fe-S clusters are critical metallocofactors required for cell function. Fe-S cluster biogenesis is carried out by assembly machinery consisting of multiple proteins. Fe-S cluster biogenesis proteins work together to mobilize sulfide and iron, form the nascent cluster, traffic the cluster to target metalloproteins, and regulate the assembly machinery in response to cellular Fe-S cluster demand. A complex series of protein-protein interactions is required for the assembly machinery to function properly. Despite considerable progress in obtaining static three-dimensional structures of the assembly proteins, little is known about transient protein-protein interactions during cluster assembly or the role of protein dynamics in the cluster assembly process. The Escherichia coli cysteine desulfurase SufS (EC 2.8.1.7) and its accessory protein SufE work together to mobilize persulfide from L-cysteine, which is then donated to the SufB Fe-S cluster scaffold. Here we use amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to characterize SufS-SufE interactions and protein dynamics in solution. HDX-MS analysis shows that SufE binds near the SufS active site to accept persulfide from Cys-364. Furthermore, SufE binding initiates allosteric changes in other parts of the SufS structure that likely affect SufS catalysis and alter SufS monomer-monomer interactions. SufE enhances the initial l-cysteine substrate binding to SufS and formation of the external aldimine with pyridoxal phosphate required for early steps in SufS catalysis. Together, these results provide a new picture of the SufS-SufE sulfur transferase pathway and suggest a more active role for SufE in promoting the SufS cysteine desulfurase reaction for Fe-S cluster assembly.

The E. coli SufS-SufE sulfur transfer system is more resistant to oxidative stress than IscS-IscU.

During oxidative stress in Escherichiacoli, the SufABCDSE stress response pathway mediates iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster biogenesis rather than the Isc pathway. To determine why the Suf pathway is favored under stress conditions, the stress response SufS-SufE sulfur transfer pathway and the basal housekeeping IscS-IscU pathway were directly compared. We found that SufS-SufE cysteine desulfurase activity is significantly higher than IscS-IscU at physiological cysteine concentrations and after exposure to H(2)O(2). Mass spectrometry analysis demonstrated that IscS-IscU is more susceptible than SufS-SufE to oxidative modification by H(2)O(2). These important results provide biochemical insight into the stress resistance of the Suf pathway.

Separate FeS scaffold and carrier functions for SufB2C2 and SufA during in vitro maturation of [2Fe2S] Fdx.

Iron-sulfur (FeS) clusters are inorganic cofactors required for a variety of biological processes. In vivo biogenesis of FeS clusters proceeds via complex pathways involving multiple protein complexes. In the Suf FeS cluster biogenesis system, SufB may be a scaffold for nascent FeS cluster assembly whereas SufA is proposed to act as either a scaffold or an FeS cluster carrier from the scaffold to target apo-proteins. However, SufB can form multiple stable complexes with other Suf proteins, such as SufB(2)C(2) and SufBC(2)D and the specific functions of these complexes in FeS cluster assembly are not clear. Here we compare the ability of the SufB(2)C(2) and SufBC(2)D complexes as well as SufA to promote in vitro maturation of the [2Fe2S] ferredoxin (Fdx). We found that SufB(2)C(2) was most proficient as a scaffold for de novo assembly of holo-Fdx using sulfide and iron as freely available building blocks while SufA was best at direct transfer of a pre-formed FeS cluster to Fdx. Furthermore, cluster transfer from [4Fe4S] SufB(2)C(2) or SufBC(2)D to Fdx will proceed through a SufA intermediate to Fdx if SufA is present. Finally, addition of ATP repressed cluster transfer from [4Fe4S] SufB(2)C(2) to Fdx and from SufBC(2)D to [2Fe2S] SufA or Fdx. These studies indicate that SufB(2)C(2) can serve as a terminal scaffold to load the SufA FeS cluster carrier for in vitro maturation of [2Fe2S] enzymes like Fdx. This work is the first to systematically compare the cluster transfer rates of a scaffold (SufB) to the transfer rates of a carrier (SufA) under the same conditions to the same target enzyme and is also the first to reconstitute the full transfer pathway (from scaffold to carrier to target enzyme) in a single reaction.

SufD and SufC ATPase activity are required for iron acquisition during in vivo Fe-S cluster formation on SufB.

In vivo biogenesis of Fe-S cluster cofactors requires complex biosynthetic machinery to limit release of iron and sulfide, to protect the Fe-S cluster from oxidation, and to target the Fe-S cluster to the correct apoenzyme. The SufABCDSE pathway for Fe-S cluster assembly in Escherichia coli accomplishes these tasks under iron starvation and oxidative stress conditions that disrupt Fe-S cluster metabolism. Although SufB, SufC, and SufD are all required for in vivo Suf function, their exact roles are unclear. Here we show that SufB, SufC, and SufD, coexpressed with the SufS-SufE sulfur transfer pair, purify as two distinct complexes (SufBC(2)D and SufB(2)C(2)) that contain Fe-S clusters and FADH(2). These studies also show that SufC and SufD are required for in vivo Fe-S cluster formation on SufB. Furthermore, while SufD is dispensable for in vivo sulfur transfer, it is absolutely required for in vivo iron acquisition. Finally, we demonstrate for the first time that the ATPase activity of SufC is necessary for in vivo iron acquisition during Fe-S cluster assembly.

Molecular dynamism of Fe-S cluster biosynthesis implicated by the structure of the SufC(2)-SufD(2) complex.

Maturation of iron-sulfur (Fe-S) proteins is achieved by the SUF machinery in a wide number of eubacteria and archaea, as well as eukaryotic chloroplasts. This machinery is encoded in Escherichia coli by the sufABCDSE operon, where three Suf components, SufB, SufC, and SufD, form a complex and appear to provide an intermediary site for the Fe-S cluster assembly. Here, we report the quaternary structure of the SufC(2)-SufD(2) complex in which SufC is bound to the C-terminal domain of SufD. Comparison with the monomeric structure of SufC revealed conformational change of the active-site residues: SufC becomes competent for ATP binding and hydrolysis upon association with SufD. The two SufC subunits were spatially separated in the SufC(2)-SufD(2) complex, whereas cross-linking experiments in solution have indicated that two SufC molecules associate with each other in the presence of Mg(2+) and ATP. Such dimer formation of SufC may lead to a gross structural change of the SufC(2)-SufD(2) complex. Furthermore, genetic analysis of SufD revealed an essential histidine residue buried inside the dimer interface, suggesting that conformational change may expose this crucial residue. These findings, together with biochemical characterization of the SufB-SufC-SufD complex, have led us to propose a model for the Fe-S cluster biosynthesis in the complex.

IscR controls iron-dependent biofilm formation in Escherichia coli by regulating type I fimbria expression.

Biofilm formation is a complex developmental process regulated by multiple environmental signals. In addition to other nutrients, the transition metal iron can also regulate biofilm formation. Iron-dependent regulation of biofilm formation varies by bacterial species, and the exact regulatory pathways that control iron-dependent biofilm formation are often unknown or only partially characterized. To address this gap in our knowledge, we examined the role of iron availability in regulating biofilm formation in Escherichia coli. The results indicate that biofilm formation is repressed under low-iron conditions in E. coli. Furthermore, a key iron regulator, IscR, controls biofilm formation in response to changes in cellular Fe-S homeostasis. IscR regulates the FimE recombinase to control expression of type I fimbriae in E. coli. We propose that iron-dependent regulation of FimE via IscR leads to decreased surface attachment and biofilm dispersal under iron-limiting conditions.

Iron-based redox switches in biology.

By virtue of its unique electrochemical properties, iron makes an ideal redox active cofactor for many biologic processes. In addition to its important role in respiration, central metabolism, nitrogen fixation, and photosynthesis, iron also is used as a sensor of cellular redox status. Iron-based sensors incorporate Fe-S clusters, heme, and mononuclear iron sites to act as switches to control protein activity in response to changes in cellular redox balance. Here we provide an overview of iron-based redox sensor proteins, in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, that have been characterized at the biochemical level. Although this review emphasizes redox sensors containing Fe-S clusters, proteins that use heme or novel iron sites also are discussed.

SufE transfers sulfur from SufS to SufB for iron-sulfur cluster assembly.

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are key metal cofactors of metabolic, regulatory, and stress response proteins in most organisms. The unique properties of these clusters make them susceptible to disruption by iron starvation or oxidative stress. Both iron and sulfur can be perturbed under stress conditions, leading to Fe-S cluster defects. Bacteria and higher plants contain a specialized system for Fe-S cluster biosynthesis under stress, namely the Suf pathway. In Escherichia coli the Suf pathway consists of six proteins with functions that are only partially characterized. Here we describe how the SufS and SufE proteins interact with the SufBCD protein complex to facilitate sulfur liberation from cysteine and donation for Fe-S cluster assembly. It was previously shown that the cysteine desulfurase SufS donates sulfur to the sulfur transfer protein SufE. We have found here that SufE in turn interacts with the SufB protein for sulfur transfer to that protein. The interaction occurs only if SufC is present. Furthermore, SufB can act as a site for Fe-S cluster assembly in the Suf system. This provides the first evidence of a novel site for Fe-S cluster assembly in the SufBCD complex.

Repair of oxidized iron-sulfur clusters in Escherichia coli.

The [4Fe-4S]2+ clusters of dehydratases are rapidly damaged by univalent oxidants, including hydrogen peroxide, superoxide, and peroxynitrite. The loss of an electron destabilizes the cluster, causing it to release its catalytic iron atom and converting the cluster initially to an inactive [3Fe-4S]1+ form. Continued exposure to oxidants in vitro leads to further iron release. Experiments have shown that these clusters are repaired in vivo. We sought to determine whether repair is mediated by either the Isc or Suf cluster-assembly systems that have been identified in Escherichia coli. We found that all the proteins encoded by the isc operon were critical for de novo assembly, but most of these were unnecessary for cluster repair. IscS, a cysteine desulfurase, appeared to be an exception: although iscS mutants repaired damaged clusters, they did so substantially more slowly than did wild-type cells. Because sulfur mobilization should be required only if clusters degrade beyond the [3Fe-4S]1+ state, we used whole cell EPR to visualize the fate of oxidized enzymes in vivo. Fumarase A was overproduced. Brief exposure of cells to hydrogen peroxide resulted in the appearance of the characteristic [3Fe-4S]1+ signal of the oxidized enzyme. When hydrogen peroxide was then scavenged, the enzyme activity reappeared within minutes, in concert with the disappearance of the EPR signal. Thus it is unclear why IscS is required for efficient repair. The iscS mutants grew poorly, allowing the possibility that metabolic defects indirectly slow the repair process. Our data did indicate that damaged clusters decompose beyond the [3Fe-4S]1+ state in vivo when stress is prolonged. Under the conditions of our experiments, mutants that lacked other repair candidates--Suf proteins, glutathione, and NADPH: ferredoxin reductase--all repaired clusters at normal rates. We conclude that the mechanism of cluster repair is distinct from that of de novo assembly and that this is true because mild oxidative stress does not degrade clusters in vivo to the point of presenting an apoenzyme to the de novo cluster-assembly systems.