Changes and associations between synovial fluid and magnetic resonance imaging markers of osteoarthritis after high tibial osteotomy.

BACKGROUND: Mechanobiological mechanisms of osteoarthritis (OA) are unclear. Our objectives were to explore: 1) changes in knee joint physiology using a large panel of synovial fluid biomarkers from before to one year after high tibial osteotomy (HTO) surgery, and 2) the association of changes in the synovial fluid biomarkers with the changes in MRI measures of knee effusion-synovitis and articular cartilage composition. METHODS: Twenty-six patients with symptomatic knee OA and varus alignment underwent synovial fluid aspirations and 3 T MRI before and one year after medial opening wedge HTO. Cytokine and growth factor levels in synovial fluid were measured with multiplex assays. Ontology and pathway enrichment was assessed using data protein sets with gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA), and analyzed using linear mixed effects models. MRIs were analyzed for effusion-synovitis and T2 cartilage relaxation time using manual segmentations. Changes in biomarker concentrations were correlated to changes in MRI effusion-synovitis volume and articular cartilage T2 relaxation times. RESULTS: Decreased enrichment in Toll-like receptor and TNF-α signalling was detected one year after HTO. The leading contributors to this reduction included IL-6, TNF-α and IL-1ß, whereas the highest contributors to positive enrichment were EGF, PDGF-BB and FGF-2. Effusion-synovitis volume decreased (mean [95%CI]) one year after HTO (-2811.58 [-5094.40, -528.76mm3]). Effusion-synovitis volume was moderately correlated (r [95% CI]) with decreased MMP-1 (0.44 [0.05; 0.71]), IL-7 (0.41 [0.00; 0.69]) and IL-1ß (0.59 [0.25; 0.80]) and increased MIP-1ß (0.47 [0.10; 0.73]). Medial tibiofemoral articular cartilage T2 relaxation time decreased (mean [95% CI]) one year after HTO (-0.33 [-2.69; 2.05]ms). Decreased T2 relaxation time was moderately correlated to decreased Flt-3L (0.61 [0.28; 0.81]), IL-10 (0.47 [0.09; 0.73]), IP-10 (0.42; 0.03-0.70) and increased MMP-9 (-0.41 [-0.7; -0.03]) and IL-18 (-0.48 [-0.73; -0.10]). CONCLUSIONS: Decreased aberrant knee mechanical loading in patients with OA is associated with decreased biological and imaging measures of inflammation (measured in synovial fluid and on MRI) and increased anabolic processes. These exploratory findings suggest that improvement in knee loading can produce long-term (one year) improvement in joint physiology.

Association between synovial tissue damage and pain in late-stage knee osteoarthritis: A cross-sectional study.

OBJECTIVE: To identify the presence and distribution of histopathological features of synovial inflammation and tissue damage, and to test their associations with ultrasound (US) imaging measures of synovitis and patient-reported measures of pain in knee osteoarthritis (OA). DESIGN: In the cross-sectional study of 122 patients undergoing surgery for painful late-stage (Kellgren-Lawrence Grade 3 or 4) knee OA, we compared US measures of synovitis (n = 118) and pain (Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score) to histopathological measures of inflammation vs. synovial tissue damage in synovial tissue biopsies. Associations of histopathological features with US measures of inflammation or pain were assessed using linear or logistic regression while controlling for covariates. RESULTS: Histopathological features of inflammation were associated with higher odds of moderate/severe US synovitis (odds ratio [OR] = 1.34 [95%CI 1.04, 1.74), whereas features of synovial tissue damage were associated with lower odds of moderate/severe US synovitis (OR = 0.77 [95%CI 0.57, 1.03]). Worse histopathological scores for synovial tissue damage were associated with more pain (-1.47 [95%CI -2.88, -0.05]), even while adjusting for synovial inflammation (-1.61 [95%CI -3.12, -0.10]). CONCLUSIONS: Synovial tissue damage is associated with pain in late-stage knee OA, independent from inflammation and radiographic damage. These novel findings suggest that preventing synovial tissue damage may be an important goal of disease-modifying OA therapy.

Targeting STAT6-mediated synovial macrophage activation improves pain in experimental knee osteoarthritis.

BACKGROUND: Pain from osteoarthritis (OA) is one of the top causes of disability worldwide, but effective treatment is lacking. Nociceptive factors are released by activated synovial macrophages in OA, but depletion of synovial macrophages paradoxically worsens inflammation and tissue damage in previous studies. Rather than depleting macrophages, we hypothesized that inhibiting macrophage activation may improve pain without increasing tissue damage. We aimed to identify key mechanisms mediating synovial macrophage activation and test the role of STAT signaling in macrophages on pain outcomes in experimental knee OA. METHODS: We induced experimental knee OA in rats via knee destabilization surgery, and performed RNA sequencing analysis on sorted synovial tissue macrophages to identify macrophage activation mechanisms. Liposomes laden with STAT1 or STAT6 inhibitors, vehicle (control), or clodronate (depletion control) were delivered selectively to synovial macrophages via serial intra-articular injections up to 12 weeks after OA induction. Treatment effects on knee and hindpaw mechanical pain sensitivity were measured during OA development, along with synovitis, cartilage damage, and synovial macrophage infiltration using histopathology and immunofluorescence. Lastly, crosstalk between drug-treated synovial tissue and articular chondrocytes was assessed in co-culture. RESULTS: The majority of pathways identified by transcriptomic analyses in OA synovial macrophages involve STAT signaling. As expected, macrophage depletion reduced pain, but increased synovial tissue fibrosis and vascularization. In contrast, STAT6 inhibition in macrophages led to marked, sustained improvements in mechanical pain sensitivity and synovial inflammation without worsening synovial or cartilage pathology. During co-culture, STAT6 inhibitor-treated synovial tissue had minimal effects on healthy chondrocyte gene expression, whereas STAT1 inhibitor-treated synovium induced changes in numerous cartilage turnover-related genes. CONCLUSION: These results suggest that STAT signaling is a major mediator of synovial macrophage activation in experimental knee OA. STAT6 may be a key mechanism mediating the release of nociceptive factors from macrophages and the development of mechanical pain sensitivity. Whereas therapeutic depletion of macrophages paradoxically increases inflammation and fibrosis, blocking STAT6-mediated synovial macrophage activation may be a novel strategy for OA-pain management without accelerating tissue damage.

Impaired Efferocytosis by Synovial Macrophages in Patients With Knee Osteoarthritis.

OBJECTIVE: Osteoarthritis (OA) exposes all joint tissues to physiologic stresses, increasing the need to clear apoptotic cells from tissues, including the synovium. We undertook this study to assess the burden of apoptotic cells in synovial tissue in patients with late-stage knee OA and to investigate whether OA impairs the macrophage-mediated clearance of apoptotic cells via efferocytosis. METHODS: Synovial tissue was collected from individuals with healthy knees and patients with late-stage knee OA during arthroplasty. Synovial apoptotic cell burden was assessed by immunofluorescence for cleaved caspase 3. Efferocytosis of apoptotic Jurkat cells by CD14+ synovial tissue macrophages and peripheral blood-derived macrophages was quantified using immunofluorescence microscopy. Effects of OA on macrophage-mediated efferocytosis were modeled by stimulating blood-derived macrophages with synovial fluid collected from individuals with healthy knees and patients with early- or late-stage knee OA. RESULTS: Patients with late-stage knee OA had more apoptotic synovial cells compared to healthy individuals. There was a marked reduction in the fraction of synovial tissue macrophages engaging in efferocytosis and the quantity of material efferocytosed by individual macrophages in OA patients. Blood-derived macrophages exposed to synovial fluid from patients with knee OA recapitulated the defective efferocytosis, with the greatest effect from patients with early-stage knee OA and higher disease activity (pain and inflammation). CONCLUSION: Apoptotic cells accumulate in the synovium of patients with late-stage knee OA. Our results suggest that OA impairs critical homeostatic functions of synovial macrophages, leading to accumulation of apoptotic cells.

Sex-Differences and Associations Between Complement Activation and Synovial Vascularization in Patients with Late-Stage Knee Osteoarthritis.

Purpose: Synovial inflammation in knee osteoarthritis (OA) causes disorganized synovial angiogenesis and complement activation in synovial fluid, but links between complement and synovial microvascular pathology have not been established. Since complement causes vascular pathology in other diseases and since sex-differences exist in complement activation and in OA, we investigated sex differences in synovial fluid complement factors, synovial tissue vascular pathology, and associations between complement and synovial vascular pathology in patients with late-stage knee OA. Methods: Patients with symptomatic, late-stage radiographic knee OA undergoing total knee arthroplasty or high tibial osteotomy provided matched synovial fluid and tissue biopsies during surgery. Complement factors (C2, C5, adipsin, MBL, and CFI) and terminal complement complex (sC5b-C9) were measured in synovial fluid by multiplex or enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, respectively. Features of synovial vascular pathology (vascularization, perivascular edema, and vasculopathy) were assessed by histopathology. Multivariate linear regression models were used to assess associations between synovial fluid complement factors and histopathological features of vascular pathology, with adjustment for age, sex, body mass index, and sex interaction. Sex-disaggregated comparisons were completed. Results: Synovial fluid biomarker and histopathology data were included from 97 patients. Most synovial fluid complement factors and synovial tissue histopathological features were similar between sexes. Synovial fluid C5 trended to lower levels in males (-20.93 ng/mL [95%CI -42.08, 0.23] p=0.05). Median vasculopathy scores (0.42 [95%CI 0.07, 0.77] p=0.02) were higher in males. In the full cohort, C5 concentration was associated with lower vascularization scores (-0.005 [95%CI -0.010, -0.0001] p=0.04) while accounting for sex*C5 interaction. In sex-disaggregated analyses, increased C5 concentration was associated with lower vascularization scores (-0.005 [95%CI -0.009, -0.0001] p=0.04) in male patients, but not in female patients. Males had higher sC5b-C9 compared to females. Additionally, males with high C5 had a higher synovial fluid concentration of sC5b-C9 compared to males with low C5. No differences were found in females. Conclusion: Higher synovial fluid C5 levels were associated with increased complement activation and decreased synovial vascularization in males but not in females with OA. Future studies should test whether synovial fluid complement activation suppresses synovial angiogenesis and identify mechanisms accounting for C5-related sex-differences in synovial fluid complement activation in patients with knee OA.