Endoscopic classification system of pars tensa retractions.

BACKGROUND: Previous classification systems of pars tensa retractions have not consistently incorporated ossicular erosion or the presence of cholesteatoma. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to illustrate our classification of pars tensa retractions, which is more precise than previous systems, with aided use of the endoscope. METHODS: A retrospective study was carried out on 200 ears of 170 patients whose pars tensa retractions had been documented at a tertiary otological referral centre. RESULTS: A classification system was developed. Pars tensa retractions were divided into the following subcategories: grade 0, grade 1, grade 2a, grade 2b, grade 3a, grade 3b, grade 3c, grade 4a, grade 4b, grade 4c, grade 5a, grade 5b and grade 5c. CONCLUSION: This classification system was able to accommodate all pars tensa retractions. The distribution of grades of pars tensa retractions was based on ossicular status and the presence or absence of cholesteatoma. It is therefore a more applicable, and functionally based system than previous alternatives.

Management of attic retraction pockets.

OBJECTIVE: Attic retraction pockets, classified by degree of invasion and erosion, are reconstructed here as outlined by attic retraction pocket grade. METHOD: Attic retraction pocket grade, surgical management, subsequent conditions of tympanic membrane and middle ear, and improvement of air-bone gap pure tone average were recorded. RESULTS: Our management strategy, based on attic retraction pocket grade, was applied to 200 ears: 44 grade I ears had non-surgical management and 156 grade II-V ears had surgical management. All 200 ears were followed up for 36-240 months, showing only 1 attic retraction pocket reformation and 1 adhesive otitis media (complication rate of 1 per cent), and improved air-bone gaps (p < 0.05). An earlier series of 50 grade IV attic retraction pockets used atticotomy with epitympanic reconstruction. These showed attic retraction pocket recurrence or cholesteatoma onset in 34 ears (68 per cent). When these ears were revised per protocol, there was no evidence of cholesteatoma thereafter. CONCLUSION: Reconstruction of the ossicles and scutal defect according to attic retraction pocket grade shows long-term stability of the tympanic membrane, middle ear and hearing.

A Unified Classification of Middle Ear and Petrous Bone Congenital Cholesteatomas.

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to classify congenital cholesteatoma along an entire spectrum of involvement ranging from the middle ear to petrous apex. METHODS: A total of 131 patients (85 adults and 46 children) underwent operations for congenital cholesteatoma over the duration of 27 years. RESULTS: For most cases, middle ear mucosa was normal, the first ossicle eroded by the mass was the stapes, and the mastoid air cell system was well-pneumatized on intraoperative and radiographic views. Totally 34% of patients presented with facial nerve weakness and 45% of these cholesteatomas arose from the supralabyrinthine area (32.8%) and from the petrous apex (12.2%). CONCLUSION: In this unified classification system, the otologist sees congenital cholesteatoma as a continuum, with facial nerve involvement and anacusis as part of the picture. This system of congenital cholesteatoma accommodates the supralabyrinthine and petrous bone locations of the disease.

The Thickness of the facial Nerve Sheath Consistently Varies by Region in Its Intra-Tympanic Course on Cadaveric Study.

OBJECTIVES: Iatrogenic removal of intra-temporal disease processes, such as cholesteatoma and keratosis obturans, can be challenging when the facial nerve (FN) is involved. Despite this concern about possible FN injury during these procedures, our clinical observation has been that the diseased growth can be cleaned quite easily from the vertical FN epineurium. Therefore, we designed a cadaveric protocol to measure thickness of the FN sheath (epineurium) in horizontal, second genu and vertical FN segments and to correlate these measurements with surgical management of FN disorders. METHODS: Fifty non-fixated (wet) cadaveric temporal bones were dissected over 1 year's time. The intra-temporal FN sheath epineurium was harvested from the mid-horizontal, second genu, and mid-vertical segments. Using a digital micrometric technique, the thickness of each sample was measured. Data analysis was performed using student's two-tailed, dependent t-test. RESULTS: Epineurial nerve sheath thickness was the least in the horizontal segment (mean 0.9 mm, range 0.040-0.140 mm), greater at the second genu (mean 0.19 mm, range 0.010-0.280 mm), and greatest in the vertical segment (mean 0.29 mm, range 0.170-0.570 mm). These differences were statistically significant. CONCLUSION: In cases of cholesteatoma and keratosis obturans involving the vertical FN, the disease process can be separated from the FN sheath because of the sheath thickness in this region. Disease in the horizontal segment involves a thinner sheath and separating the disease process from the nerve is more difficult in this area.

Diagnostic Protocol for Detecting Otosclerosis on High-Resolution Temporal Bone CT.

OBJECTIVES: To present a systematic checklist to improve diagnosing otosclerosis (OS) on high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) of the temporal bones and review this protocol's efficacy in diagnosing OS on HRCT. METHODS: A retrospective case series was performed at a University Referral Hospital in urban Chicago, Illinois. High-resolution computed tomographies of the temporal bone were reviewed including 17 ears in the test group with surgically confirmed OS and 21 ears in the control group surgically confirmed to not have OS. Preoperative HRCTs were evaluated by a single neuroradiologist using a systematic protocol created to assist in diagnosing OS. This looked for radiolucency at the fissula ante fenestram and pericochlear region, and new bone formation around the oval and round windows. RESULTS: The radiologist accurately diagnosed OS in all 17 test group ears and ruled out OS in all 21 control group ears using the protocol. All 17 test ears were read to have lucency at the fissula ante fenestram, 9 (53.0%) to have new bone formation, and 8 (47.1%) to have cochlear lucency. The radiologist was more confident in diagnosing OS when cochlear lucency was present with the fissula ante fenestram lucency. CONCLUSIONS: This HRCT checklist is a highly accurate tool for evaluating the presence of OS when images are reviewed in the systematic fashion described. Imaging prior to surgery aids in counseling patients, preparing surgically, and excluding other pathologies.

Stapedectomy Is Rewarding: But How to Prove It?

OBJECTIVE: To demonstrate that neurotologists enjoy performing stapedectomies. SUBJECTS: A group of survey recipients consisting of 174 neurotologists who perform stapedectomy, a nonoverlapping control group of 145 head/neck oncologists who perform parotidectomy, and a second nonoverlapping control group of 365 pediatric otolaryngologists who perform tonsillectomy. OUTCOME MEASURES: Responses to surveys distributed by electronic mail to the 3 nonoverlapping recipient groups during nonoverlapping 4-week periods. RESULTS: During the 4-week survey periods, 84 of 174 neurotologists (48%) responded, while 33 of 145 oncologists (23%) and 87 of 365 pediatric otolaryngologists (24%) responded. Most neurotologists performed stapedectomy (80/84; 95% of survey responders), while 33 of 33 (100% of survey responders) oncologists performed parotidectomy and 87 of 87 (100% of survey responders) pediatric otolaryngologists performed tonsillectomy. Seventy-six of the 80 neurotologists who performed stapedectomies (95%) enjoyed performing it, slightly more than the 30 of the 33 oncologists who performed parotidectomies (91%) and appreciably more than the 67 of 87 pediatric otolaryngologists who performed tonsillectomies (77%). Twenty-three neurotologists (30%) would sacrifice vacation time to perform additional stapedectomies, slightly more than 8 oncologists (27%) for additional parotidectomies and more than the 7 pediatric otolaryngologists (10%) for additional tonsillectomies. Ten (13%) of the neurotologists, 3 (9%) of the oncologists, and 1 (2%) of the pediatric otolaryngologists would sacrifice 5 or more vacation days to perform more of the procedures. CONCLUSIONS: Our data suggest that neurotologists enjoy performing stapedectomy.

Effective Inexpensive Management of Necrotizing Otitis Externa Is Possible in Resource-Poor Settings.

INTRODUCTION: Necrotizing otitis externa resolves best with antimicrobial treatment. How to care for these patients and monitor their resolution remains a problem. Our protocol in Bangalore can manage these patients inexpensively and well. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patients who were referred to our patients became the subjects for this paper. They were managed through our protocol, which consists of IV ciprofloxacin and meropenem, weekly labs, weekly examinations, and photodocumention. RESULTS: Fifty-one people presented with necrotizing otitis externa (NOE) between October 2015 and November 2017 and completed our entire protocol. Forty-six had complete resolution of their disease, while 5 had to undergo surgical removal of necrotic bone. Six of 8 patients with facial weakness had improvement in their House-Brackmann scores. Reduction of self-reported nocturnal pain, dissolution of ear canal granulations, and normalization of the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) proved to be the most accurate indicators of disease regression. CONCLUSION: Patients are monitored closely with review of their otalgia, examination of their canal, repeated ESRs, effective control of their diabetes, and radiological imaging. All this can be done in a resource-poor country, which in turn serves as a model for the wealthier nations.

High-Density Otologic Camps in Regions of Sparse Expertise.

Aims/Purpose: When 2 models of otologic surgery instruction in Ethiopia are compared, high-density otologic surgery campaigns are more effective for accelerated skills transfer in areas of sparse expertise than the standard outpatient clinic/OR model. METHODS: A continuously operating otolaryngology/head and neck surgery department in a large public hospital is compared with a nonprofit specialty hospital where outpatients are selected for weeklong surgical campaigns. The number and variety of otologic visits and operations in each setting, presence of expert supervision, and resident-trainees' surgical progress were tallied. RESULTS: The public hospital saw 84 otologic operations in 1 full year. Meanwhile, the ear specialty surgical campaign site saw 185 otologic operations in 6 surgical campaign weeks. All operations at both sites were performed primarily by trainees. Experienced otologists supervised 40% of operations at the public hospital and 100% at the surgical campaign site. At the end of the year, none of the 10 resident-trainees in the public hospital were able to perform a simple underlay tympanoplasty, compared to 6 of 12 resident-trainees in the campaign setting. CONCLUSIONS: Where otologic expertise is sparse, otologic surgical campaigns allow the most effective use of resources-patient pathology, medical facilities, trainee attendance, and imported instructors.

Ossicular Chain Reconstruction in a Developing Country.

OBJECTIVES: In Ethiopia, 2-stage operations with middle ear prostheses are economically unfavorable. We hypothesized that single-stage autologous ossiculoplasty results in acceptable tympanic membrane (TM) and hearing improvements in a setting of limited resources. METHODS: One hundred eighty-eight patients (197 ears) who underwent 1-stage autologous ossiculoplasty for ossicular dysfunction are presented. All but 14 of these ears also had perforations of the TM. Conditions of the middle ear were granulation tissue, ossicular disruption only, tympanosclerosis, and cholesteatoma. Reconstructions of the ossicular chain were performed with autologous ossicles only. RESULTS: The closure rate of TM perforations was 95%. Preoperative air bone gaps were 27 to 60 dB (mean [SD] = 44 [7] dB); postoperative air bone gaps were 0 to 50 dB (average [SD] = 23 [10] dB), for an average improvement of 21 dB across all reconstruction types ( P < .001). The largest favorable changes in air bone gaps were with incus and malleus columellas from the footplate to the TM (33 and 23 dB, respectively) ( P < .001). No patient had worsening of sensorineural hearing levels or extrusion of the reconstructed ossicles. CONCLUSION: Autologous ossiculoplasty performed well in this setting. Acceptable TM closure rates and improvement of air bone gaps were seen in 1-stage operations without the use of prostheses.

HIV Positivity per se Does Not Affect Tympanoplasty Outcomes.

BACKGROUND: The English language literature finds no clear protocols for otologic surgery for HIV+ patients. OBJECTIVE: To demonstrate that simple tympanoplasty and type III tympanoplasty in HIV+ patients with CD4 >400 cells/cc results in tympanic membrane closures and hearing improvements equivalent to the same procedures in controls. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This retrospective review documents the otologic conditions and operative results of 32 HIV+ patients and 32 controls. The controls were healthy and had no opportunistic infections or other medications. RESULTS: Genders, ages, sizes of tympanic membrane perforations, severity of air bone gaps, and type of operation were equivalent between the HIV+ and the control groups. Thirty of 32 patients in each group had closure of their perforations after 1 operation. Air bone gaps improved significantly for each group ( P = .001): 22 dB (SD = 11 dB) in the HIV+ group and 26 dB (SD = 10 dB) in the control group. And there was no statistically significant difference in change in hearing between the 2 groups. There were no complications of infection, wound dehiscence, worsened sensorineural levels, dizziness, or facial weakness in either group. CONCLUSION: HIV+ patients whose CD4 counts are above 400 cells/cc can undergo simple tympanoplasty or type III tympanoplasty with acceptable outcomes.

Cochlear implant electrode array exposure: A delayed complication.

Exposure of the cochlear implant electrode array as a late complication has been reported rarely in the literature. A retrospective analysis revealed 4 patients presenting with exposure of their cochlear implant electrode arrays from 2 to 17 years after implantation. Data collected from these 4 patients were surgical implantation approach, type of implant, age at implant, interval between implant and complication, surgical correction of the problem, pathology at the time of correction, and length of follow-up after intervention. All 4 patients presented with otitis or mastoiditis. Each had undergone a transmastoid approach with facial recess and cochleostomy and full implant insertion. In 3 cases, the tympanic membrane had retracted to expose the electrode array. In 1 patient, the electrode array had eroded through the external canal, lateral to the facial recess. The exposed arrays were addressed surgically, including explantation/reimplantation for 1 patient. Cochlear implant electrode arrays can become exposed by relative migration of the array and the tympanic membrane. Implant surgeons and audiologists need to be aware of the possibility of this complication. Closure of the ear canal appears to be the most effective surgical intervention.

Streamlined bilateral otologic surgery: how I do it.

Bilateral simultaneous otologic surgery is being performed more commonly among otologists. The benefits of performing bilateral simultaneous cochlear implants in the pediatric population, in particular, have become increasingly recognized as the safety and efficacy of this operation have been recognized in the literature. Here we present a streamlined method of performing bilateral simultaneous otologic surgery that emphasizes midline placement of facial nerve electrodes and a method of sterile preparation and draping that affords direct exposure to both ears at one time, without the need to turn the head or adjust the drapes multiple times throughout the operation. Our approach facilitates frequent and efficient alternation between ears throughout the operation, optimizing efficiency of motion and instrumentation for the surgeon, and reducing overall operative and general anesthesia time for the patient.

Hearing in static unilateral vestibular schwannoma declines more than in the contralateral ear.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the effect of static vestibular schwannomas on hearing. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review of audiometric measures in 15 patients with documented nongrowth of internal auditory canal and cerebellopontine angle enhancing masses. METHODS: Data from patients seen in an ambulatory tertiary care setting between the years of 2002 and 2012 with a diagnosis of acoustic neuroma or vestibular schwannoma were reviewed. Exclusion criteria included preexisting otologic disease, prior therapy for the schwannoma, and tumor growth. Radiology reports were reviewed to ensure nongrowth and were confirmed by taking magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) measurements ourselves. Audiologic measurements included pure tone average, enhanced pure tone average (average of .5, 1, 2, and 4 KHz thresholds), 4 KHz threshold, 8 KHz threshold, and speech discrimination. The data were analyzed using mixed effect model with unstructured variance-covariance structure. RESULTS: Difference in audiometric measures between ears significantly (P<.05) increased for all measures except 8 KHz. CONCLUSION: Spontaneous decline in hearing relative to time is exaggerated in the affected ear despite no vestibular schwannoma growth. This finding can be useful for patient counseling and treatment decision making.

Fungal otitis externa as a cause of tympanic membrane perforation: a case series.

We describe a series of 11 patients--8 men and 3 women, aged 18 to 70 years (mean: 46.0)--who had fungal otitis externa that had been complicated by a tympanic membrane perforation. These patients had been referred to us for evaluation of chronic, mostly treatment-refractory otitis externa, which had manifested as otorrhea, otalgia, and/or pruritus. Seven of the 11 patients had no history of ear problems prior to their current condition. Five patients had been referred to us by a primary care physician and 4 by an otolaryngologist; the other 2 patients were self-referred. All patients were treated with a thorough debridement of the ear and one of two antifungal medication regimens. Eight of the 11 patients experienced a complete resolution of signs and symptoms, including closure of the tympanic membrane perforation. The other 3 patients underwent either a tympanoplasty (n = 2) or a fat-graft myringotomy (n = 1) because the perforation did not close within a reasonable amount of time. This series demonstrates that the nonspecific signs and symptoms of fungal otitis externa can make diagnosis difficult for both primary care physicians and general otolaryngologists. This study also demonstrates that most cases of tympanic membrane perforation secondary to fungal otitis externa will resolve with cleaning of the ear and proper medical treatment. Therefore, most patients with this condition will not require surgery.

Bilateral middle cranial fossa encephaloceles presenting as conductive hearing loss.

We report a case involving a patient with bilateral middle cranial fossa encephaloceles extending into the middle ear and causing conductive hearing loss. An obese, 47-year-old woman with a history of a seizure disorder presented with a slow-onset subjective hearing loss. Examination revealed opaque tympanic membranes, and audiometry showed a mixed hearing loss bilaterally. Myringotomy demonstrated soft tissue behind each tympanic membrane. Biopsy, computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, and mastoidectomy confirmed the diagnosis of bilateral middle cranial fossa encephaloceles. Bilateral encephaloceles are uncommon, and the resulting bilateral conductive hearing loss secondary to mechanical obstruction of ossicular vibration is even more rare. This patient's obesity and seizures perhaps contributed to her disease process.

Medicolegal concerns among neurotologists in ordering MRIs for idiopathic sensorineural hearing loss and asymmetric sensorineural hearing loss.

OBJECTIVE: To determine if neurotologists order magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in cases of idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss (sudden deafness) and of asymmetric sensorineural hearing loss (ASNHL) for medicolegal reasons. STUDY DESIGN: Survey of 480 American neurotologists. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: 1) The frequency with which neurotologists/otologists in the United States order MRI in sudden deafness and ASNHL, 2) the frequency of medicolegal issues as motivations for ordering MRIs, 3) the frequency of abnormal MRIs, and 4) the prevalence of auditory brainstem reflex (ABR) and acoustic reflex testing as screening tools before ordering an MRI. RESULTS: Approximately 146 responses (30.4%) were received. Ninety-five percent and 94% ordered MRIs in their patients with ASNHL and sudden deafness respectively. Forty percent of the respondents said medicolegal concerns factored into their decision to order a scan. Seventy-seven percent and 82% reported finding vestibular schwannomas in less than 1% to 4% of MRIs for ASNHL and sudden deafness, respectively. Approximately one-third of the respondents still use ABR and acoustic reflex testing as screening tools. CONCLUSION: MRIs are the gold standard for determining retrocochlear pathology in the setting of sudden deafness and ASNHL but are expensive. Approximately one-third of the respondents still use ABR and acoustic reflex testing as screening tools before ordering MRI. MRI typically have a low yield in finding an abnormality (usually <1%-4%). Neurotologists in our survey seem to recognize this quandary: they usually order an MRI, although they know it will usually be negative, and 40% of them cite medicolegal concerns as one of the motivations for their decision. This suggests that routine use of MRI partially reflects the practice of defensive medicine rather than medicine based on evidence. Perhaps MRIs are rarely indicated as the initial screening tool in ASNHL and sudden deafness, given their high cost and low yield of abnormal findings, and their routine use should and could be reduced to contain medical costs.