Accessibility and satisfaction's analysis of simulation-based training in surgery for residents and surgical fellows in France.

BACKGROUND: In surgery, simulated-based training improves the knowledge and interpersonal skills needed for surgeons to improve their performance and meet the "never the first time on a patient" imperative. The objective is to evaluate the effects of a 2017 reform on surgeon's accessibility to simulation-based training, five years after the implementation of the program, and to gauge surgeon satisfaction. METHODS: A 27-item national online survey was sent to all surgical residents and fellows in the 13 surgical specialties. RESULTS: Among 523 responses, 405 (77.4%) were residents and 118 (22.6%) were surgical fellows. Two hundred forty-seven (47.2%) of surgical residents and fellows stated they did not have a simulation structure or simulation program in the town of their university hospital center. Two hundred thirty-five (44.9%) reported having simulation training programs and 41 (7.8%) reported having easy and free access to their simulation structure. Regarding simulation-based training, 44.6% of surgical residents and fellows had never received training in technical skills on simulators, 82.2% had never received training in teamwork or interprofessional skills and 76.1% had never received training in behavioral or relational skills. There was a significant difference between the degree of satisfaction of residents at the beginning and at the end of the study (P=0.02). CONCLUSION: Simulation is a well-established educational tool, but there are still strong inequalities between universities. Despite the national deployment of simulation-based teaching programs and institutional efforts, surgical simulation is insufficiently developed in France, and learner satisfaction is poor.

Robotic-assisted thoracic surgery training in France: a nation-wide survey from young surgeons.

OBJECTIVES: Evaluate theoretical and practical training of thoracic surgeons-in-training in robotic-assisted thoracic surgery (RATS) in France. METHODS: A survey was distributed to thoracic surgeons-in-training in France from November 2022 to February 2023. RESULTS: We recruited 101 thoracic surgeons-in-training (77% response rate). Over half had access to a surgical robotics system at their current institution. Most (74%) considered robotic surgery training essential, 90% had attended a robotic procedure. Only 18% had performed a complete thoracic robotic procedure as the main operator. A complete RATS procedure was performed by 42% of fellows and 6% of residents. Of the remaining surgeons, 23% had performed part of a robotic procedure. Theoretical courses and simulation are well developed; 72% of residents and 91% of fellows had undergone simulation training in the operating room, at training facilities, or during congress amounting to <10 h (for 73% of the fellows and residents), 10-20 h (17%), 20-30 h (8%) or >30 h (3%). Access to RATS was ≥1 day/week in 71% of thoracic departments with robotic access. Fellows spent a median of 2 (IQR 1-3) semesters in departments performing robotic surgery. Compared with low-volume centres, trainees at high-volume centres performed significantly more complete robotic procedures (47% vs 13%; P = 0.001), as did fellows compared with residents. CONCLUSIONS: Few young surgeons perform complete thoracic robotic procedures during practical training, and access remains centre dependent. Opportunities increase with seniority and exposure; however, increasing availability of robotic devices, theoretical formation, and simulation courses will increase opportunities.

Attractiveness and gender dynamics in surgical specialties: a comparative analysis of French medical graduates (2017-2022).

BACKGROUND: French medical graduates undertake a national examination at the end of their studies with a subsequent national ranking. Specialty is then chosen by each candidate according to their ranking. This study aims to describe the attractiveness of surgical specialties and the evolution of the male-female distribution among French medical graduates (FMG) from 2017 to 2022. METHODS: Our database included the candidates' ranking, sex and choice of specialty from 2017 to 2022. It included all French medical graduates from 2017 to 2022 and all French medical schools. A linear regression was performed to predict future trends. Dependent variables were mean rankings and the percentage of women. The independent variable was year of application. A Pearson correlation was performed to examine any relationship with mean workweek. RESULTS: A total number of 5270 residents chose a surgical programme between 2017 and 2022. The number of residents who were assigned their desired surgical programme held stable at 878 surgical residents per year. Plastic and reconstructive surgery remained the most frequently chosen surgical programme. Thoracic and cardiovascular surgery was the least frequently chosen surgical programme between 2017 and 2022. The mean ranking for a candidate choosing a surgical programme rose significantly by 9% from 2017 to 2022 (p < 0.01). Neurosurgery exhibited the greatest fall as a surgical specialty as its rankings decreased by 163.6% (p < 0.01). Maxillo-facial surgery was the only specialty with a statistically significant increase in its rankings by 35.9% (p < 0.05). The overall proportion of women was 51.1%. Obstetrics-and-gynecology was the highest represented specialty among female candidates, with a mean of 83.9% of women. Orthopedic surgery was the lowest represented, being composed of a mean of 28.6% of women. The number of female surgical residents increased significantly over the six-year period, by 7.6% (p < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: More and more medical school graduates decide not to choose surgery for their residency programme. Some specialties continue to be attractive while many are losing their appeal. While there does appear to be progress towards gender equity, further investigation is necessary to assess its actual implementation.

Thoracic surgery in France.

Until recently, thoracic surgery in France was associated with vascular or cardiac surgery. It is now increasingly performed as a specific activity. Training of a thoracic surgeon has a common part with cardiovascular surgery during a 6-year curriculum including theory and practical practice acquired both by simulation and clinical fellowship. There are 343 board-certified surgeons performing thoracic surgery in 147 authorized centers. To be authorized to perform thoracic surgery, these centers must have at least 2 qualified surgeons and perform a minimum of 40 procedures per year for thoracic cancer. The discussion of the cases in a multidisciplinary tumor board (MDTB), validated by a written conclusion, is also mandatory and is a prerequisite for operating on patient for any cancer. All thoracic surgery procedures are recorded in a national database, Epithor. This database gives a precise idea not only of the activity but also of operative data, morbidity, mortality and follow-up. In 2023, participation to Epithor database will be a prerequisite for the certification of thoracic surgeons. Major changes in diagnostic and therapeutic options, development and innovations in video-assisted and robotically-assisted surgery, forthcoming transbronchial approaches will more likely lead to reorganize thoracic surgery with specialized and expert multidisciplinary boards as well as a concentration in high volume centers.