Simultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation Method for Evaluation of Target Contouring in Radiosurgery.

BACKGROUND/AIM: The problem of lack of standardisation in target delineation and herewith the variability of target contours in Gamma Knife radiosurgery is as severe as in linac-based radiotherapy in general. The first aim of this study was to quantify the contouring variability for a group of five radiosurgery targets and estimate their true-volume based on multiple delineations using the Simultaneous Truth and Performance Level Estimation (STAPLE) algorithm. The second aim was to assess the robustness of the STAPLE method for the assessment of the true-volume, with respect to the number of contours available as input. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A multicentre analysis of the variability in contouring of five cases was performed. Twelve contours were provided for each case by experienced planners for Gamma Knife. To assess the robustness of the STAPLE method with respect to the number of contours used as input, sets of contours were randomly selected in the analysis. RESULTS: A high similarity was observed between the STAPLE generated true-volume and the 50%-agreement volume when all 12 available contours were used as input (90-100%). Lower similarity was observed with smaller sets of contours (10-70%). CONCLUSION: If a high number of input contours is available, the STAPLE method provides a valuable tool in the estimation of the true volume of a target based on multiple contours as well as the sensitivity and specificity for each input contour relative to the true volume of that structure. The robustness of the STAPLE method for rendering the true target volume depends on the number of contours provided as input and their variability with respect to shape, size and position.

Impact of Tumour Cell Infiltration on Treatment Outcome in Gamma Knife Radiosurgery: A Modelling Study.

BACKGROUND: High-grade gliomas with a widespread infiltration beyond the lesion detectable on diagnostic images are increasingly treated with Gamma Knife™ Radiosurgery (GKRS). The aim of this study was to assess the cell infiltration impact on the GKRS outcome for invasive gliomas. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Tumor cell distribution was predicted using a novel algorithm whose computations are iterated until they reach an agreement with histopathology results. Treatment plans with different combinations of dose prescription (20 Gy at 50%-20% isodose) and targets [Gross Tumour Volume (GTV), zone 1 with 100%-60% of the GTV cell density and zone 2 with 60%-0% of the GTV cell density] were evaluated using standard conformity indexes (CI) and radiobiological parameters. RESULTS: Considerable differences in terms of tumor control probability were found between plans having similar CI but different targets. CONCLUSION: To account for tumor cell infiltration outside the target is of key importance in GKRS and a radiobiological evaluation should accompany well-established CI.

Multi-institutional study of the variability in target delineation for six targets commonly treated with radiosurgery.

BACKGROUND: Although accurate delineation of the target is a key factor of success in radiosurgery there are no consensus guidelines for target contouring. AIM: The aim of the present study was therefore to quantify the variability in target delineation and discuss the potential clinical implications, for six targets regarded as common in stereotactic radiosurgery. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Twelve Gamma Knife centers participated in the study by contouring the targets and organs at risks and performing the treatment plans. Analysis of target delineation variability was based on metrics defined based on agreement volumes derived from overlapping structures following a previously developed method. The 50% agreement volume (AV50), the common and the encompassing volumes as well as the Agreement Volume Index (AVI) were determined. RESULTS: Results showed that the lowest AVI (0.16) was found for one of the analyzed metastases (range of delineated volumes 1.27-3.33 cm3). AVI for the other two metastases was 0.62 and 0.37, respectively. Corresponding AVIs for the cavernous sinus meningioma, pituitary adenoma and vestibular schwannoma were 0.22, 0.37 and 0.50. CONCLUSIONS: This study showed that the variability in the contouring was much higher than expected and therefore further work in standardizing the contouring practice in radiosurgery is warranted.

Assessment of organs-at-risk contouring practices in radiosurgery institutions around the world - The first initiative of the OAR Standardization Working Group.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: This study was an initiative of the Organs-at-Risk Standardization Working Group for evaluating the current degree of variability in the clinical practice of contouring organs-at-risk (OAR) for radiosurgery planning. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Imaging datasets for typical lesions (cavernous sinus meningioma, vestibular schwannoma, pituitary adenoma) treated with Leksell Gamma Knife Perfexion were circulated to 12 centers. Observers were asked to contour the target and OARs as per their standard clinical practice. The analyzed parameters were the intersection (AV100), union volumes (AV100/N) and the 50% agreement volume (AV50). The ratio of AV100 and AV100/N (the Agreement Volume Index, AVI) was used as a measure of agreement level together with a generalized conformity index (CIgen) and a pairwise averaged conformity index (CIpairs). The maximum doses were also determined. RESULTS: Results showed a wide variability in terminology, choice of structures contoured and in the size and shape of the contoured structures. The highest variability was observed for the left and right optic tract for cavernous sinus meningioma where the AV100 was zero. The highest consistency was observed for the right optic nerve in the cavernous sinus case followed by the cochlea for the vestibular schwannoma case for which the AVI was still only 0.13 and 0.054, respectively. Corresponding results for the CIgen and CIpairs also showed the highest variability for the right optic tract and the highest consistency in contours for the right optic nerve, both in the cavernous sinus meningioma case. CONCLUSION: The results quantify the large variability in OAR contouring in clinical practice across Gamma Knife radiosurgery centers with respect to the choice of OARs to be contoured, nomenclature and size and shape of OARs. This motivates future effort to standardize practices to enable more effective collaboration.

To fractionate or not to fractionate? That is the question for the radiosurgery of hypoxic tumors.

OBJECT: This study aimed to investigate the impact of tumor hypoxia on treatment outcome for metastases commonly treated with radiosurgery using 1 fraction of radiation and the potential gain from reoxygenation if the treatment is delivered in a few radiation fractions. METHODS: In silico metastasis-like radiosurgery targets were modeled with respect to size, density of clonogenic cells, and oxygenation. Treatment plans were produced for the targets using Leksell GammaPlan, delivering clinically relevant doses and evaluating the tumor control probability (TCP) that could be expected in each case. Fractionated schedules with 3, 4, and 5 fractions resulting in similar biological effective doses were also considered for the larger target, and TCP was determined under the assumption that local reoxygenation takes place between fractions. RESULTS: The results showed that well-oxygenated small- and medium-size metastases are well controlled by radiosurgery treatments delivering 20 or 22 Gy at the periphery, with TCPs ranging from 90% to 100%. If they are moderately hypoxic, the TCP could decrease to 60%. For large metastases, the TCPs from single-fraction treatments ranged from 0% to 19%, depending on tumor oxygenation. However, for fractionated treatments, the TCP for hypoxic tumors could significantly increase up to 51%, if reoxygenation occurs between fractions. CONCLUSIONS: This study shows that hypoxia worsens the response to single-fraction radiosurgery, especially for large tumors. However, fractionated therapy for large hypoxic tumors might considerably improve the TCP and might constitute a simple way to improve the outcome of radiosurgery for patients with hypoxic tumors.

Variability in target delineation for cavernous sinus meningioma and anaplastic astrocytoma in stereotactic radiosurgery with Leksell Gamma Knife Perfexion.

BACKGROUND: Radiosurgery clinical practice relays on empirical observations and the experience of the practitioners involved in determining and delineating the target and therefore variability in target delineation might be expected for all the radiosurgery approaches, independent of the technique and the equipment used for delivering the treatment. The main aim of this study was to quantify the variability of target delineation for two radiosurgery targets expected to be difficult to delineate. The secondary aim was to investigate the dosimetric implications with respect to the plan conformity. The primary aim of the study has therefore a very general character, not being bound to one specific radiosurgery technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty radiosurgery centers were asked to delineate one cavernous sinus meningioma and one astrocytoma and to plan the treatments for Leksell Gamma Knife Perfexion. The analysis of the delineated targets was based on the calculated 50 % agreement volume, AV50. The AV50 was compared to each delineated target by the concordance index and discordance index. The differences in location, size, and shape of the delineated targets were also analyzed using the encompassing volume compared to the common volume, i.e., the AV100, of all delineated structures. RESULTS: Target delineation led to major differences between the participating centers and therefore the AV50 was small in comparison to each delineated target volume. For meningioma, the AV50 was 5.90 cm(3), the AV100 was 2.60 cm(3), and the encompassing volume was 13.14 cm(3). For astrocytoma, the AV50 was 2.06 cm(3) while the AV100 was extremely small, only 0.05 cm(3), and the encompassing volume was 43.27 cm(3). These variations translate into corresponding discrepancies in plan conformity. CONCLUSIONS: Significant differences in shape, size, and location between the targets included in this study were identified and therefore the clinical implications of these differences should be further investigated.

Radiobiological framework for the evaluation of stereotactic radiosurgery plans for invasive brain tumours.

This study presents a radiobiological formalism for the evaluation of the treatment plans with respect to the probability of controlling tumours treated with stereotactic radiosurgery accounting for possible infiltrations of malignant cells beyond the margins of the delineated target. Treatments plans devised for three anaplastic astrocytoma cases were assumed for this study representing cases with different difficulties for target coverage. Several scenarios were considered regarding the infiltration patterns. Tumour response was described in terms of tumour control probability (TCP) assuming a Poisson model taking into account the initial number of clonogenic cells and the cell survival. The results showed the strong impact of the pattern of infiltration of tumour clonogens outside the delineated target on the outcome of the treatment. The treatment plan has to take into account the existence of the possible microscopic disease around the visible lesion; otherwise the high gradients around the target effectively prevent the sterilisation of the microscopic spread leading to low probability of control, in spite of the high dose delivered to the target. From this perspective, the proposed framework offers a further criterion for the evaluation of stereotactic radiosurgery plans taking into account the possible infiltration of tumour cells around the visible target.

[Embolization of uterine arteries yields good results in symptomatic myoma]. / Embolisering av uterusartärer ger god effekt vid symtomgivande myom.

This article summarizes the experience gained so far of uterine artery embolization (UAE) for symptomatic fibroids, reviewing publications related to this issue. More than 10 years have past since Ravina et al started to treat uterine fibroids with UAE. To date thousands of women have been embolized with excellent results and few serious complications. UAE is a successful alternative to hysterectomy for women wishing uterine preservation. Several cases of pregnancy and partus have been reported after UAE, and the method may be considered in women desiring future fertility, if the only remaining surgical option is complicated multiple myomectomy or hysterectomy. So far, recurrence after initially successful UAE has not been reported, but long-term results are yet to be determined.