Regulator T cells: specific for antigen and/or antigen receptors?

Adaptive immune responses are regulated by many different molecular and cellular effectors. Regulator T cells are coming to their rights again, and these T cells seem to have ordinary alpha/beta T-cell receptors (TCRs) and to develop in the thymus. Autoimmune responses are tightly regulated by such regulatory T cells, a phenomenon which is beneficial to the host in autoimmune situations. However, the regulation of autoimmune responses to tumour cells is harmful to the host, as this regulation delays the defence against the outgrowth of neoplastic cells. In the present review, we discuss whether regulatory T cells are specific for antigen and/or for antigen receptors. Our interest in these phenomena comes from the findings that T cells produce many more TCR-alpha and TCR-beta chains than are necessary for surface membrane expression of TCR-alphabeta heterodimers with CD3 complexes. Excess TCR chains are degraded by the proteasomes, and TCR peptides thus become available to the assembly pathway of major histocompatibility complex class I molecules. Consequently, do T cells express two different identification markers on the cell membrane, the TCR-alphabeta clonotype for recognition by B-cell receptors and clonotypic TCR-alphabeta peptides for recognition by T cells?

Relative resistance to nasally induced tolerance in non-obese diabetic mice but not other I-A(g7)-expressing mouse strains.

I-A(g7) is a unique class II MHC molecule that is clearly associated with autoimmune diabetes in non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice. To determine if I-A(g7) is defective in its ability to deliver tolerogenic signals in vivo, H-2(g7) mice were nasally pretreated with antigen, prior to immunization, to induce antigen-specific regulation. Nasally pretreated NOR (H-2(g7)) and (NON).NOD (H-2(g7)) congenic mice showed responses similar to those of NON (H-2(nb1)), BALB/c (H-2(d)) and B10.PL (H-2(u)) mice-a reduced recall response and a deviated T(h) cytokine profile. However, we found that NOD (H-2(g7)) mice are comparatively resistant to immunological tolerance induced by nasal pretreatment, such that at the usually effective dose no significant reduction was seen in the proliferative recall responses to nominal antigen after immunization. (NOD x BALB/c)F(1) (H-2(g7/d)) and (NOD x NOR)F(1) (H-2(g7)) mice were similarly resistant to nasal-induced tolerance, although significantly higher nasal doses of antigen were able to overcome the resistance in NOD and F(1) mice. Interestingly, activated NOD T cells were resistant to cell death induced by re-stimulation with plate-bound anti-CD3. These results demonstrate that activated T cells in NOD mice are defective in their ability to respond to regulatory signals delivered in vivo or in vitro. Furthermore, NOD T cells have an increased resistance to tolerance induced by I-A(g7)-dependent (antigen) or I-A(g7)-independent (anti-CD3) mechanisms. Thus, while I-A(g7) may contribute to insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus by selecting a particular repertoire of self-reactive T cell clones, additional defects in the peripheral T cells themselves are required to allow the expansion of diabetogenic clones and the development of autoimmune disease.

MHC class I-restricted determinants on the glutamic acid decarboxylase 65 molecule induce spontaneous CTL activity.

CD4(+) T cell responses to glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65) spontaneously arise in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice before the onset of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) and may be critical to the pathogenic process. However, since both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells are involved in autoimmune diabetes, we sought to determine whether GAD65-specific CD8(+) T cells were also present in prediabetic NOD mice and contribute to IDDM. To refine the analysis, putative K(d)-binding determinants that were proximal to previously described dominant Th determinants (206-220 and 524-543) were examined for their ability to elicit cytolytic activity in young NOD mice. Naive NOD spleen cells stimulated with GAD65 peptides 206-214 (p206) and 546-554 (p546) produced IFN-gamma and showed Ag-specific CTL responses against targets pulsed with homologous peptide. Conversely, several GAD peptides distal to the Th determinants, and control K(d)-binding peptides did not induce similar responses. Spontaneous CTL responses to p206 and p546 were mediated by CD8(+) T cells that are capable of lysing GAD65-expressing target cells, and p546-specific T cells transferred insulitis to NOD.scid mice. Young NOD mice pretreated with p206 and p546 showed reduced CTL responses to homologous peptides and a delay in the onset of IDDM. Thus, MHC class I-restricted responses to GAD65 may provide an inflammatory focus for the generation of islet-specific pathogenesis and beta cell destruction. This report reveals a potential therapeutic role for MHC class I-restricted peptides in treating autoimmune disease and revisits the notion that the CD4- and CD8-inducing determinants on some molecules may benefit from a proximal relationship.

Regulatory and effector CD4 T cells in nonobese diabetic mice recognize overlapping determinants on glutamic acid decarboxylase and use distinct V beta genes.

The 524--543 region of glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65), GAD65(524--543), is one of the first fragments of this islet Ag to induce proliferative T cell responses in the nonobese diabetic (NOD) mouse model of spontaneous autoimmune diabetes. Furthermore, NOD mice given tolerogenic doses of GAD65(524--543) are protected from spontaneous and cyclophosphamide-induced diabetes. In this study, we report that there are at least two I-A(g7)-restricted determinants present in the GAD65(524--543) sequence, each capable of recruiting unique T cell repertoires characterized by distinct TCR V beta gene use. CD4(+) T cells arise spontaneously in young NOD mice to an apparently dominant determinant found within the GAD65 peptide 530--543 (p530); however, T cells to the overlapping determinant 524-538 (p524) dominate the response only after immunization with GAD65(524--543). All p530-responsive T cells used the V beta 4 gene, whereas the V beta 12 gene is preferentially used to encode the TCR of p524-responsive T cell populations. T cell clones and hybridomas from both of these T cell groups were responsive to APC pulsed with GAD65(524--543) or whole rGAD65. p524-reactive cells appeared to be regulatory upon adoptive transfer into young NOD mice and could inhibit insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus development, although they were unable to produce IL-4, IL-10, or TGF beta upon antigenic challenge. Furthermore, we found that i.p. injection with p524/IFA was very effective in providing protection from cyclophosphamide-induced insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. These data demonstrate that the regulatory T cells elicited by immunizing with GAD65(524--543) are unique and distinct from those that arise from spontaneous endogenous priming, and that T cells to this limited region of GAD65 may be either regulatory or pathogenic.

Molecular characterization of the T cell repertoire using immunoscope analysis and its possible implementation in clinical practice.

T lymphocytes play a central role in the pathogenesis of a large number of human conditions including autoimmunity and graft rejection. Although T cells are key players in mounting immune responses, the assessment of T cell repertoires has yet to find an important role in clinical decision making. In this review, we discuss the "immunoscope" technique and its potential diagnostic role in a variety of clinical scenarios. This is an RT-PCR based approach that subdivides a bulk T cell population (i. e. from blood, lymph, spleen, or tissue) into approximately 2800 groups based upon rearranged variable beta (Vbeta)/joining beta (Jbeta) gene segments and the resulting length of the T cell receptor's (TCR's) third complementarity determining region (CDR-3). This extensive subdivision, or focusing, allows clonal expansions to be directly observed. Such a fine-tuned analysis has revealed previously unappreciated aspects of the T cell repertoire. For instance, an antigen-specific immune response can be divided into both public and non-public components. The non-public repertoire contains the majority of the expanding T cells which are unique to the individual (private), or shared by only some (semi-private), while "public" T cells can be found responding to the antigenic determinant in every individual. Although they are often a minority of the response, the public T cell repertoire seems to play a more important role in defining, as well as driving, the overall immune phenotype in the animal. Immunoscope analysis has identified public and non-public responses in human pathologies, such as multiple sclerosis. The ability to characterize the driver T cells dictating the state of immunity/autoimmunity in individual patients will be an important step towards understanding autoimmunity and designing effective treatment for a variety of conditions including rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis. We review the current literature involving public and non-public repertoires and discuss the prospect that immunoscope analysis may play a central role in the study and perhaps the management of human autoimmune diseases, and cancer.

Immunogenicity of self antigens is unrelated to MHC-binding affinity: T-cell determinant structure of Golli-MBP in the BALB/c mouse.

The 'classical' myelin basic protein (MBP) exons belong to a much larger unit, termed the 'Golli-MBP' gene. Here we have examined the T-cell determinant structure of the Golli protein region in the BALB/c mouse. Golli p10-24, which was shown to have the strongest affinity for I-A(d), could not induce T-cell activation. Paradoxically, the poorer binding, overlapping p5-19 was effective at inducing T-cell proliferation. Thus, immunogenicity is not necessarily related to the MHC-binding affinity of self-peptides. In addition, MBP: p151-168-specific T cell clones responded only poorly to J37, a Golli-MBP protein, while MBP: 59-76-specific clones responded well to J37.

Processing and reactivity of T cell epitopes containing two cysteine residues from hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL74-90).

The Ag processing and structural requirements involved in the generation of a major T cell epitope from the hen egg-white lysozyme protein (HEL74-88), containing two cysteine residues at positions 76 and 80, were investigated. Several T cell hybridomas derived from both low responder (I-Ab) and high responder (I-Ak) mice recognize this region. These hybridomas are strongly responsive to native HEL, but unresponsive to the reduced and carboxymethylated protein. Air-oxidized HEL74-88 peptide was unable to bind I-Ak molecules and failed to stimulate T cells in the absence of intracellular Ag processing. Further functional competition assays showed that alkylation of cysteine residues with bulky methyl groups interferes with the contacts for the MHC class II molecules (I-Ak) of high responder mice and the I-Ab-restricted TCR of low responder mice. Serine substitutions of the cysteine residues of HEL74-88 either enhanced or abrogated T cell stimulation by the peptides without significant alterations in the class II binding. These results suggest that the cysteine residues of peptides must be free from disulfide bonding for efficient stimulation of T cells and yet frequently used modifications of cysteine residues may not be suitable for peptide-based vaccine development.

The self-directed T cell repertoire: its creation and activation.

The considerable breadth of the self-directed T cell repertoire has only fully been appreciated during this past decade. It is a potential repertoire which can be tapped in various ways, most evidently in the study of autoimmune diseases, when because of a variety of factors, there is enhanced processing and presentation of determinants on self antigens. In this review, we have focused on the engagement of this self-reactive repertoire and some of the rules involved, which are not always so obvious. The total "residual" self-reactive repertoire directed against a single antigen (that remains after negative selection) will be a heterogeneous assemblage of T cells - (a) high affinity T cells directed against determinants whose presentation during tolerance induction was prevented, eg. through competitive binding by neighboring determinants; (b) lower affinity T cells directed against well-presented (dominant), as well as poorly-presented (cryptic) determinants; and (c) high affinity T cells directed against poorly-presented determinants, which are only presented during inflammation. Under conditions that favor upregulation of previously cryptic self determinants, one or more of the above subsets of the 'protected' T cell repertoires can be stimulated by these self determinants, leading to induction of autoreactivity. The latter could eventually result in autoimmunity under permissive conditions governed by MHC and non-MHC genes. Interestingly, the very same repertoires that appear to be recruited into pathogenic autoimmune destruction may be alternatively manipulated as a source of anti-cancer treatment. It is now evident that many tumor antigens are unmutated self antigens, and cryptic determinants within such tumor antigens could be used to recruit the anticryptic T cell repertoire for induction of anti-tumor immunity.

A single intramuscular injection with an adenovirus-expressing IL-12 protects BALB/c mice against Leishmania major infection, while treatment with an IL-4-expressing vector increases disease susceptibility in B10.D2 mice.

Experimental infection of the susceptible BALB/c (H-2d) mouse with the intracellular parasite Leishmania major induces a predominant Th2-type T cell response that eventually leads to death. In contrast, the resistant B10.D2 (H-2d) strain develops Th1 cells that control parasite replication and disease. In this study, we tested the ability of a recombinant adenovirus vector-expressing IL-12 to skew the immune response in a Th1 direction and prevent leishmaniasis in susceptible mice. We report that BALB/c mice treated with the Ad5IL-12 vector on the same day as parasitic challenge are significantly protected against leishmaniasis and acquired long-lasting immunity, because upon rechallenge with L. major parasites they were resistant to disease. The vector-derived IL-12 expression was transient and highly localized to the tissue after i.m. injection; it caused an increase in the number of Ag-specific IFN-gamma-secreting lymphocytes and enhanced NK cell activity in the draining popliteal node. In contrast, resistant B10.D2 mice given i.m. injections with a recombinant adenovirus-expressing IL-4 displayed greater susceptibility to disease, and severe lesions were produced in some of the infected animals. These results suggest the potential use of recombinant adenoviruses expressing cytokines as potent immunomodulatory agents for the generation of protective immune responses against intracellular pathogens.

Heterogeneity of the T cell response to immunodominant determinants within hen eggwhite lysozyme of individual syngeneic hybrid F1 mice: implications for autoimmunity and infection.

Hybrid F1 mice derived from inbred parental mouse strains are extensively used as animal models of human autoimmune diseases and transplantation. It is generally believed that with regard to immunologic studies, hybrid F1 mice behave in a consistent manner, equivalent to any other inbred mouse strain. In this study, we report that in comparison to inbred parental strains, individual hybrid F1 mice revealed a broad heterogeneity of proliferative response to the immunodominant determinants within hen eggwhite lysozyme (HEL). Of five parental strains tested, individual mice of three strains responding to only a few dominant HEL determinants (B6, BALB/c, and B10.PL) showed quite homogeneous patterns of response, whereas two mouse strains responsive to several determinants of HEL revealed either relative homogeneity (CBA/J mice) or heterogeneity (SJL mice) of response. However, in SJL mice, responses to major, dominant determinants of HEL were quite consistent. On the contrary, regardless of the consistency of response of parental strains, all three of F1 mice [[B6 x BALB/c]F1, [B6 x CBA/J]F1, and [SJL x B10.PL]F1] revealed significantly greater heterogeneity of response, which even involved the major, dominant determinants of HEL. We attribute the above heterogeneity of response to the competitive as well as aleatory nature of the interaction between various factors, including the coexistence of different MHC (parental as well as hybrid MHC) molecules, determinant capture, and the T cell repertoire. These results have important implications for studies on autoimmunity, infection, and vaccine design in human populations, where heterozygosity is the norm rather than the exception.

Recognition of prostate-specific antigenic peptide determinants by human CD4 and CD8 T cells.

It is now becoming accepted that one is not tolerant to all the determinants of self proteins: the T cell repertoire directed to some sequences in self proteins is intact and can be activated. When a self protein is exclusively expressed by tumour cells, the T cell repertoire directed to the particular self antigen can potentially be activated to attack the tumour: this would amount to induction of a beneficial autoimmune response. Prostate cancer offers a unique opportunity for activation of a tumour-specific immune response owing to the exclusive synthesis of prostate-specific antigen (PSA) and prostate-specific membrane antigen (PSM) by prostatic tissue and prostate tumour cells. In this study we examine the CD4 and CD8 T cell repertoires specific for peptides of PSA and PSM in normal human male individuals, using short-term, peptide antigen-driven CD4 and CD8 T cell lines. We show that short-term, CD4 T cell lines derived from six HLA-DR4 individuals showed strong proliferative responses to six of 10 tested peptides of PSA, selected as to contain a DR4 binding motif. Short-term, CD8 T cell lines from three HLA-A1 individuals showed specific cytolytic activity for autologous targets loaded with five of five tested peptides of PSA and PSM, selected to possess an HLA-A1 binding motif. One of the peptides chosen is termed a 'dual-motif' peptide, as it encodes determinants for both CD4 and CD8 T cells. These results, indicating the existence of CD4 and CD8 T cells against determinants of the self proteins, PSA and PSM, in healthy male individuals reveal the potential of the T cell repertoire from the typical prostate cancer patient to eradicate prostate tumours upon being appropriately activated.

Antigen processing differences among APC.

The hierarchy of display of determinants on a protein antigen is of critical importance with respect to which T cells will be selected during thymic development, as well as in the induction of mature responses. Activation of T cells will be dependent on unfolding, reduction and chain cleavage of the antigen, and the vagaries of competition with other determinants as well as hindrance in access to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) or subsequently of the MHC/peptide complex to the T cell receptor. We here focus on a description of the parameters that determine the generation and display of determinants on MHC class II molecules by different types of antigen presenting cells in different locations.

Harnessing self-reactivity in cancer immunotherapy.

Recent years have witnessed a significant advance in our understanding of the immune response to cancer through the identification of human tumor antigens at the molecular level. The growing list of normal self proteins recognized on tumors by T cells of cancer patients is consistent with the existence in humans of a self-reactive T-cell repertoire analogous to that described in murine models of autoimmune disease. The presence of these cells in normal individuals reveals the benign self-reactivity which lies dormant in the T-cell repertoire of humans. These autoreactive T cells, although pathogenic when activated in autoimmune disease, could be directed towards a beneficial effect in tumor immunotherapy. Potential targets for such a limited anti-self/anti-tumor immune response include overexpressed proteins, tissue-specific differentiation antigens and developmental proteins expressed aberrantly in tumor cells. Depending on the determinant chosen, recruitment of these self-directed T cells may require overcoming some degree of non-deletional peripheral tolerance. By specifically targeting immune responses to subdominant and cryptic determinants from these proteins, it may be possible to maximize the anti-tumor effect resulting from self-directed immunity while minimizing unwanted damage to normal tissue.

Recognition of multiple peptide cores by a single T cell receptor.

We present evidence that a single T cell clone can recognize at least five different overlapping peptides, each with its distinct core structure, in the context of the same major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule. Distinct core residues are crucial for triggering the T cell receptor (TCR) in each case. These results suggest that the TCR (a) has multiple sets of contact residues for alternative peptide-MHC ligands, the binding to any one of which can trigger the cell; and/or (b) is able to attach to the peptide-MHC complex in more than one orientation. In this sense, the TCR is a multisubsite structure capable of being stimulated by a variety of peptide ligands associated with the same MHC molecules.

T cell determinants from autoantibodies to DNA can upregulate autoimmunity in murine systemic lupus erythematosus.

(NZB x NZW) F1 (BWF1) mice develop spontaneous T cell autoimmunity to VH region determinants of syngeneic anti-DNA before the onset of clinical disease. In this study, we characterized the immunogenicity, MHC binding, and lymphokine secretion patterns induced by T cell determinants from the VH region of one such anti-DNA mAb (A6.1) and examined their role in the regulation of autoimmunity. Determinants were identified by proliferation of syngeneic splenic T cells from young, unprimed BWF1 mice in response to overlapping 12-mer peptides representing the entire VH region sequence. Immunization of young BWF1 mice with any of three determinants (A6H 34-45 [p34], A6H 58-69 [p58], and A6H 84-95 [p84]) elicited proliferative responses upon in vitro recall. Upon immunization with the whole A6.1 molecule, however, proliferative responses could be recalled only to the p58 peptide, defining this as immunodominant. The other two peptides (p34 and p84) elicited minimal or no proliferation and could be termed cryptic. Proliferative responses elicited by the cryptic determinants were restricted by a single class II (I-Ed for p34 and I-Au for p84), whereas the immunodominant p58 determinant was restricted by both I-Ed and I-Eu. The cryptic p34 and p84 bound strongly to I-Ed and I-Au, respectively, whereas the immunodominant p58 peptide bound poorly to I-Ed. A6H p84 elicited T cells that secreted lymphokines in a pattern consistent with a Th1-like phenotype, whereas p58 induced a Th2-like cytokine pattern. Immunization with p34 or p84, or adoptive transfer of a p84-reactive T cell line to young BWF1 mice significantly increased IgG anti-DNA levels, accelerated nephritis, and decreased survival. In conclusion, in BWF1 mice, autoreactive T cells recognizing both cryptic and dominant self-determinants on anti-DNA autoantibodies escape deletion or anergy induction. Furthermore, since these cells are spontaneously activated before the onset of clinical disease, they may be involved in the development of the autoimmune process.

Antibody response of murine B1 cells to hen eggwhite lysozyme.

Cell transfer studies were performed to investigate the ability of murine peritoneal B1 cells to produce specific IgG antibody against the T-dependent protein antigen, hen eggwhite lysozyme (HEL). Peritoneal cells (PeC) from normal BALB/c mice were transferred into newborn, allotype-congenic, C.B-17 severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice alone or together with splenic T cells from HEL-primed C.B-17 mice. After immunization with HEL, only those mice that received both PeC and primed T cells produced HEL-specific IgG of the PeC donor allotype. To identify the B cell subset responsible for antibody production, PeC were sorted before transfer into B1 and conventional B (B2) cell populations. It was found that transfer of purified B1 cells plus primed T cells resulted in high levels of IgG1 anti-HEL in approximately half of the SCID recipients, while mice receiving B2 cells produced little detectable antibody. The responses consisted primarily of IgG1 kappa anti-HEL, with no significant IgM or lambda-bearing components. Seventeen HEL-specific hybridomas of BALB/c origin, i.e., derived from the B1 cell donor, were obtained from reconstituted SCID mice after various periods of immunization and analyzed for fine specificity using a panel of avian lysozymes. All but one of the B1 cell-derived mAbs recognized an HEL epitope not present on the closely related bobwhite quail lysozyme (differing from HEL at only 4 of 129 amino acid positions). While IEF analyses demonstrated the presence of extensive clonotypic diversity, the epitope specificity pattern, which is rare among B2-cell-derived antibodies, suggests that the B1 cell recognition repertoire for HEL is severely limited.

Hindrance of binding to class II major histocompatibility complex molecules by a single amino acid residue contiguous to a determinant leads to crypticity of the determinant as well as lack of response to the protein antigen.

The immune system has evolved the potential to respond to a wide variety of antigens, yet unresponsiveness to many foreign determinants is encountered frequently. Here, we report a lack of response to a particular determinant, hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-(46-61)-peptide (p46-61), in C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice, whereas a strong T-cell response to this determinant is obtained in major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-identical C3H.SW mice. However, (C3H.SW x C57BL/6)F1 mice respond well to p46-61, suggesting the absence of a p46-61-specific "hole" in the T-cell repertoire in C57BL/6 mice. We further show that p46-61 cannot bind the I-Ab class II MHC molecule, whereas p46-60 lacking Arg61 exhibits good binding and is immunogenic in both strains. Thus, the presence of the hindering residue, Arg61, renders p46-61, a dominant determinant in C3H.SW, into a silent, cryptic determinant in C57BL/6 mice. Upon i.p. immunization with HEL, no T-cell responses to either HEL or p46-61 could be demonstrated in spleens of HEL-primed C57BL/6 mice, whereas a predominant response to p46-61 and HEL was demonstrated in C3H.SW mice. Evidently, C57BL/6 mice differ from C3H.SW in their ability to process p46-61 into an actual I-Ab binding determinant, indicating a putative enzymatic defect in the C57BL/6 strain. Furthermore, our results suggest that the inability of C57BL/6 mice to respond in the spleen to HEL is based upon its failure to generate a dominant immunogenic determinant from HEL, coupled with its pattern of susceptibility to regulatory effects.